View Full Version : What is your favorite Coheed And Cambria Album?
xtheaudition
05/16/10, 12:30 AM
5 albums..
1 vote.
go!
Rustash
05/16/10, 06:19 AM
I won't be surprised in the least if SSTB takes this
kbi the crowing
05/16/10, 08:56 AM
In Keeping Secrets by far.
musicaddicttt
05/16/10, 10:10 AM
there really is no contest for this. In Keeping Secrets is an amazing record and certainly the best.
Yontsey
05/16/10, 10:16 AM
It was a tough call between IKSOSE:3 and SSTB but I went with Secrets. I like some of the songs on SSTB more but front to back, Secrets I think is a better album.
IKSOSE:3 is my favorite record of all time.
xtheaudition
05/17/10, 08:27 AM
the new one got a vote lol
InsaneJester17
05/17/10, 09:14 AM
I tend to bounce betweent he first three albums, but In Keeping has to be the favorite. I think YOTBR was seriously lacking. couple good tracks, but nothing outstanding.
drawndead
05/17/10, 10:13 AM
Second Stage was when I started listening to them but In Keeping Secrets is so solid
notoaststereo
05/17/10, 01:24 PM
Iksose:3
Sstb
Gaibs4
Nwft
Yotbr
xtheaudition
05/17/10, 01:29 PM
how is the new one even? didn't hear much about it.
kbi the crowing
05/17/10, 02:25 PM
how is the new one even? didn't hear much about it.
It has some awesome songs (Here We Are Juggernaut, Guns of Summer), but as a whole it's kinda repetitive and uninteresting.
Almost every songs is verse->chorus->verse->chorus->bridge->chorus as well.
xtheaudition
05/17/10, 02:30 PM
It has some awesome songs (Here We Are Juggernaut, Guns of Summer), but as a whole it's kinda repetitive and uninteresting.
Almost every songs is verse->chorus->verse->chorus->bridge->chorus as well.
bummer dood, i own all their albums, is it even worth buying? i mean i kinda grew out of them with no world for tomorrow, i barely listened to theat album, but their first 3 cds are fucking awesome!
kbi the crowing
05/17/10, 02:40 PM
bummer dood, i own all their albums, is it even worth buying? i mean i kinda grew out of them with no world for tomorrow, i barely listened to theat album, but their first 3 cds are fucking awesome!
I'd download it to see if you like it, then buy it or not based off that. I think it's better than NWFT. It has more electronic influence as well.
I'd really like to see another PFI album or Mic's solo stuff soon.
xtheaudition
05/17/10, 02:45 PM
I'd download it to see if you like it, then buy it or not based off that. I think it's better than NWFT. It has more electronic influence as well.
I'd really like to see another PFI album or Mic's solo stuff soon.
oh yah damn i remember PFI i never got that cd. heard good stuff though. and yah good idea, maybe i will download it one of these days. i hate when bands new stuff sucks and makes you wanna listen to their older stuff, it always happens for me atleast.
kbi the crowing
05/17/10, 02:46 PM
oh yah damn i remember PFI i never got that cd. heard good stuff though. and yah good idea, maybe i will download it one of these days. i hate when bands new stuff sucks and makes you wanna listen to their older stuff, it always happens for me atleast.
I wouldn't say it sucks, but I would say it doesn't have as much impact as earlier albums. Could have been a time in place thing, though.
xtheaudition
05/17/10, 02:48 PM
I wouldn't say it sucks, but I would say it doesn't have as much impact as earlier albums. Could have been a time in place thing, though.
yah i just lost intrest in threm along time ago. last time i saw them live they were touring for good apollo 4, i bought NWFT when it came out, but i never listened to it, its not a bad cd, just didn't get into as much as i did their previous album. i was watching the feathers music video last night, and it was such a weird video, great song through!
drewinseries
05/17/10, 09:40 PM
Wicked tough call between Second Stage and Good Apollo 1, went with Good Apollo. Saw them tonight in Boston, they put on a fantastic show.
InsaneJester17
05/18/10, 07:09 AM
Wicked tough call between Second Stage and Good Apollo 1, went with Good Apollo. Saw them tonight in Boston, they put on a fantastic show.
Jealous. Tickets sold out for that show before I could get them. And I missed out on seeing Claudio perform acoustic at Newbery Comics because I had the A Day to Remember conecert that night. But my friend did get me a signed CD! :-D
drewinseries
05/18/10, 07:55 AM
Jealous. Tickets sold out for that show before I could get them. And I missed out on seeing Claudio perform acoustic at Newbery Comics because I had the A Day to Remember conecert that night. But my friend did get me a signed CD! :-D
Yeah, I missed the Newbury Comics one as well. Thats the second acoustic instore of theirs that ive missed.
gcreams
05/18/10, 08:06 PM
Went with IKSSE:3, favorite album of all time. Second Stage and the first Good Apollo are not far behind though.
NateFoundGlory
05/18/10, 08:31 PM
It was close between Good Apollo and SSTB for me, but went with Apollo. Fuckin love these guys.
Tristan Needler
05/18/10, 08:36 PM
Second Stage, obviously. In Keeping Secrets is the only other one that comes close.
barkingincision
05/18/10, 10:02 PM
second stage is the most unique / nostalgic record for me, with in keeping secrets close behind. good apollo 1 is great too but the ones after that suckkkkkkkk
xtheaudition
05/19/10, 02:31 AM
second stage is the most unique / nostalgic record for me, with in keeping secrets close behind. good apollo 1 is great too but the ones after that suckkkkkkkk
this x 1048012
in keeping secrets. this was tough for me though
zeropunk16
05/19/10, 09:43 AM
IKSOSE:3 is just so fucking good.
No World For Tomorrow. I'm obviously in the minority here. That's cool though.
xapplexpiex
05/19/10, 06:02 PM
IKSSE: 3
But I haven't heard the new one yet, so...
Good Apollo
NWFT
IKSOSE3
SSTB
YOTBR (Not a good album....)
No World For Tomorrow. I'm obviously in the minority here. That's cool though.
I LOVE No World. It's a straight toss up for me between GA and NW, but I'm with you.
Neo Cassady
05/19/10, 06:13 PM
IKSOSE:3 is so money.
tonyC4L
05/19/10, 06:34 PM
I always have such a tough time choosing between SSTB and IKSSE:3; Coheed is my favorite band and those albums are two of my all-time favorites (of any band). I'll vote Second Stage since I never skip tracks on that album but occasionally I'll pass over Three Evils or Faint of Hearts, but I'm really not entirely confident in that decision.
The rest are easy though: Good Apollo Vol. 1, followed closely by YOTBR, followed not-so-closely by NWFT.
I LOVE No World. It's a straight toss up for me between GA and NW, but I'm with you.
and the number shall continue rising...
kbi the crowing
05/20/10, 05:11 AM
These are pretty much the results I was expecting to see, except for maybe a few less on IKS and a few more on SSTB.
I'm gonna have to take a trip to Coheed land soon.
this x 1048012
What makes NWFT such a bad album?
xtheaudition
05/20/10, 01:19 PM
What makes NWFT such a bad album?
by time it came out i lost interest in them, and i like the songs better on their previous albums. its not bad, i just didn't get into it as much.
by time it came out i lost interest in them, and i like the songs better on their previous albums. its not bad, i just didn't get into it as much.
Alright I can dig that. I just feel that album gets a negative response for no reason it's really not as bad as every makes it out to be. I mean No Word For Tomorrow is a sick track and Mother Superior is just awe inspiring.
xtheaudition
05/20/10, 02:13 PM
Alright I can dig that. I just feel that album gets a negative response for no reason it's really not as bad as every makes it out to be. I mean No Word For Tomorrow is a sick track and Mother Superior is just awe inspiring.
yeah my fav is gunslingers, it's definitely not a bad record, just i don't go back to listen to it as much as i do second stage ya know?
nicoteen
05/20/10, 02:55 PM
In Keeping Secrets by far.
This. Top 5 album for me.
yeah my fav is gunslingers, it's definitely not a bad record, just i don't go back to listen to it as much as i do second stage ya know?
Yeah I understand. I'm glad you aren't opinionated on the records as most people are. It tends to get annoying.
xtheaudition
05/20/10, 05:26 PM
Yeah I understand. I'm glad you aren't opinionated on the records as most people are. It tends to get annoying.
understandable.
VIVALAMATT
05/20/10, 07:21 PM
I won't be surprised in the least if SSTB takes this
I would be. It's simply not their best. lol
danielakabigd
05/20/10, 09:46 PM
SSTB is so solid, after all it was my first Coheed exposure.
Toothache
05/21/10, 10:29 AM
in keeping secrets > second stage > good apollo > black rainbow > nwft
Protested Hero
05/21/10, 02:23 PM
IKSOSE:3 is my favorite record of all time.
No, it's mine.
vivatoto56
05/21/10, 06:35 PM
Good Apollo solely for Wake Up
James Ford
05/21/10, 09:03 PM
Second Stage evokes the best memories personally. Which is kind of a shady way of answering which album is best, but that's what music's all about I guess. The connection.
hurricaneoflion
05/21/10, 10:31 PM
III for the WIN!!!
xtheaudition
05/22/10, 12:07 PM
last two are tied at 5 haha
tonighttonight0
05/23/10, 10:48 AM
In Keeping Secrets all the way.
kbi the crowing
05/23/10, 12:38 PM
in keeping secrets > second stage > good apollo > black rainbow > nwft
Almost exactly the same for me, except put an equals sign between SSTB and GA1.
xGangstax
05/23/10, 01:53 PM
Iksose:3
Sstb
Gaibs4
Nwft
Yotbr
This!
HometownHero
05/23/10, 05:54 PM
What everyone else said
Mandee, darling
05/23/10, 06:27 PM
I went with Good Apollo, given that I have the most favorite tracks off of that album... I honestly couldn't decide on this one.
speakhandsforme
05/23/10, 10:25 PM
Good Apollo throttles their other work.
Charles777
05/24/10, 02:01 PM
GOOD EYEEEEEEEEEEEE SNIPERRRRRRRRRRR
x
xtheaudition
05/24/10, 02:12 PM
GOOD EYEEEEEEEEEEEE SNIPERRRRRRRRRRR
x
vevo looks so ghoooood
pRWjLLpwnOM
kbi the crowing
05/24/10, 02:19 PM
vevo looks so ghoooood
pRWjLLpwnOM
I really dislike this music video. I actually dislike pretty much all their music videos.
Although, Blood Red Summer is awesome, and both Devil in Jersey City videos aren't too shabby.
xtheaudition
05/24/10, 02:21 PM
I really dislike this music video. I actually dislike pretty much all their music videos.
Although, Blood Red Summer is awesome, and both Devil in Jersey City videos aren't too shabby.
BRS was my favorite!
SuNDaYSTaR
05/24/10, 07:49 PM
In Keeping Secrets, but really closely followed but Volume I. I dig every single track on that record.
CoheedForever
05/25/10, 03:10 PM
Year of the Black Rainbow is my favorite right now, but favorite of all time would be In Keeping
xtheaudition
05/25/10, 03:13 PM
Year of the Black Rainbow is my favorite right now, but favorite of all time would be In Keeping
nice username & avatar.
CoheedForever
05/25/10, 03:15 PM
nice username & avatar.
sarcasm??
xtheaudition
05/25/10, 03:18 PM
sarcasm??
negative, i like coheed! i did make this poll...
CoheedForever
05/25/10, 03:22 PM
negative, i like coheed! i did make this poll...
ahhh alright.
Tom_is_awesome
05/29/10, 05:04 AM
I really love No World for Tomorrow, but Year Of The Black Rainbow seems really good just haven't listened to it as much.
M.C COB
05/29/10, 11:05 AM
SSTB first followed by In Keeping Secrets
In Keeping Secrets > Good Apollo 1 > Year of the Black Rainbow > No World for Tomorrow > Second Stage Turbine Blade
SSTB has some great songs (Everything Evil, Delirium Trigger, Time Consumer), but the rest of it doesn't do much for me and won't grow on me, as much as I try.
CoheedForever
06/06/10, 10:44 PM
year of the black rainbow seems to be getting better and better!!
vBulletin v3.6.0, Copyright ©2000-2012, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.