Better Overall Album

[ImpulZe]

i am trying to deciede whihc album to buy and throw into my cd collection, I would buy them all but I only have enough for one, and I dont feel like buying anymore anytime soon. I have personal listened to all of these albums but I want your opinon on which is the best one.

[summer skin]

Thursday - ACBTLD for sure.

[love_american_style]

i went w/ brand new even though most of the other bands on that list i like more than brand new....just previous albums of thursday, the used,senses fail and emery were better than their sophmore releases....even FFTLs dear diary....wasn't that bad.

[the sob]

brand new should not be on this poll. Its not a fair poll.

[ImpulZe]

why isnt it a fair poll?@?!!

[love_american_style]

why isnt it a fair poll?@?!!

because the majority of the people on this site have their heads up br& news ass and have biased opinions on anything that has anything to do w/ br& new.

[a speedo model]

Deja Entendu is one of my favorite Cd's ever...so gotta go with that...

[itmakesyoufeel]

You could never pick Cute is What We Aim For over Deja Entendu. There's no comparison.

[saving jonathan]

of course the popular choice is deja, but i'm more of a your favorite weapon fan without a doubt. so i went with anberlin, who deserves a lot of credit. they have 2 great albums and this one is so catchy and well done.

[IATA4224]

All of you complain so much about Brand New.. Stop complaining because they are better than Thursday

[a speedo model]

You could never pick Cute is What We Aim For over Deja Entendu. There's no comparison.
pretty much

[bring the mosh]

how is this a legitimate poll? you've got a band like CIWWAF up against brand new. terrible poll.

[loganmmm]

Call me crazy, but I voted for CIWWAF.
Even with it's horrible lyrics, I like it more than anything else here.
Haha.

Now, if Your Favorite Weapon was up there instead of Daja Endendu I would have voted for Brand New x5.

[jon.fftl]

Brand New kicks the shit out of all of these.

[a speedo model]

how did Cute Is What We Aim For get 5 votes? what the fuck? every single Cd on the list is better then them...

[FOBPrettyNPunk]

Deja by far, then The Question.

[plain white t's]

brand new should not be on this poll. Its not a fair poll.

yeh i think it was pretty obvious that brand new were going to win, i went with them but anberlin would have come second

[ernestothegreat]

because the majority of the people on this site have their heads up br& news ass and have biased opinions on anything that has anything to do w/ br& new.
Maybe they just make really good music...

[love_american_style]

Maybe they just make really good music...

well they do...but still.

[AEast317]

buy brand new and thursday.

[insertwithere]

brand new, hands down.

[Cue the Sun]

Brand New.. or Anberlin. But I went with Brand New.

[cahrishurr]

thursday

then a distant second is brand new
the rest is awful shit

[Timberwolf]

haha thats so funny not a single person chose FFTL (although not particularly surprising).

[totallysweat]

if you don't already have Deja, you shouldn't get it now. That album's popularity still lives on, but it's a thing of the past now man. I got that shit the day it dropped along with 1985.

[SynesthesiaX]

hmmm.... dont get it.... why do they ALWAYS have to have albums that are just as good as each other so people cant choose?

it blows...

voted for FFTL neways..

[Broken Parachute]

So many votes for Brand New. So ridiculous, not even that good of an album.

[normalgene]

Deja is a great album, but to compare them to everything else on this list is just sad... All the other albums are mediocre at best. (in my opinion)

[PomonaForEmpusa]

i own all of them but the Used & Senses Fail... Deja's overall the best....... i almost voted City By The Light though.

[OvenRake]

i went with Brand New, but i love Thursday's ACBTLD. some of those cds probably shouldnt have been on there:unsure:

[Mikebae]

the only band on here i enjoy is brand new....i cant wait for the new cd...

the emery cds arent bad...but everytime i see them live theyre not tight at all

[notoaststereo]

brand new should not be on this poll. Its not a fair poll.

agreed. everyone is going to choose brand new

[IATA4224]

Ummm....Who cares if every body is going to pick Brand New.. Isnt the idea of a poll to see who is better.. Granted if From First to Last were up and Brand New wasn't i would have picked them, but Brand New is absoutely the best band up there..

Maybe we should have put Good Charlotte there instead...Would that have been better

[boysdontcry17]

because the majority of the people on this site have their heads up br& news ass and have biased opinions on anything that has anything to do w/ br& new.

truth

[octoberskies]

Thursday and Brand New are both very good. I can't choose. :|

[leary0315]

All of you complain so much about Brand New.. Stop complaining because they are better than Thursday


That statement is false IMO. Although Deja is better than ACBTLD, i don't think its better than War All The Time or Full Collapse. But then again Thursday is my favorite band..

[fearthesloths]

theres no point in arguing about this poll.
people have favourite bands, for whatever reason and they are obviously going to pick their favourite cd out of the list.

if most people's favourite cd happens to be deja, then so be it... its the most popular, you can't tell people not to pick deja and they can't tell you not to pick whatever you picked, its a poll... god damn


i picked deja

[IATA4224]

theres no point in arguing about this poll.
people have favourite bands, for whatever reason and they are obviously going to pick their favourite cd out of the list.

if most people's favourite cd happens to be deja, then so be it... its the most popular, you can't tell people not to pick deja and they can't tell you not to pick whatever you picked, its a poll... god damn


i picked deja

your totally right, but I do have a problem when people bash Brand New and their fans.. It's like these people who say it's unfair that Brand New is on the poll because everyone is going to vote for them... Isn't that the purpose of the poll..

In my opinion Brand New is better than Thursday, but that doesn't mean Thursday is a terrible band.. Sure Brand New may be hyped up a bit, but Thursday was hyped up for 3 or 4 years being claimed as the next best thing...

These polls aren't facts, they are opinions, but its just really funny that people get ripped on for liking certain bands

[hubbabubbal3ts]

the only other respectable cd on the list besides deja entendu is ACBTLD

[odelay]

WTF? Who are the 17 people that voted for CIWWAF?

[mark cruce]

That latest Used cd totally sucked. Such a waste, do not get it.

[whiteboypain]

Thursday - ACBTLD for sure.

Yeah, NO!

[whiteboypain]

Brand New. That one was easy for me. The new Thursday album sucks. I still like them, but it's not their best work. blah blah blah....new Used album sucks too. Senses Fail - hhahahahhaa

[meliisssaaaa]

this was a hard decision besides cute is what we aim for. i voted senses fail though..

[Alex DiVincenzo]

Deja Entendu. Some solid stuff on the poll though.

[PunkENG]

Lawrence Arms - Oh! Calcutta!

[headclub]

wow i love brand new, but i think anberlin NTFP was a way more concrete album...some songs on deja i can live without, while every song on NTFP i can listen to over and over again

[heytheredelilah]

you guys don't seem to get it, that when you put anything to do with brand new in a poll , they will always, always win.

[KielxDeath]

I think the thing about Deja is it's lasting power. You'll listen to it in 5, maybe ten years... but the rest of these CDs will be forgotten

[Troy will Fall]

wow, deja is one of my favorites of all time. I mean A city by the light is great....but no comparison.

[naphtha74]

You would have to say Deja Entendu, but its a shame that A City by the Light Divided, Never Take Friendship Personal, In Love & Death and The Question was there because they are fantastic albums.
I stand by my choiceB-)

[domesticyeti]

Deja.

[lesto17]

Deja, but barely over ACBTLD. Other Thursday albums are better than Deja, and the more I think about it the more I could argue ACBTLD is as well.

[crit]

ahah. Deja Entendu - 63.07%

[thearmada]

what the fuck is with everybody on this website listening to brand new? fuck that band. they're terrible.

[thescoremag]

i hate to say this...but Brand New sucks...they makle good music but they have let the popularity get to their heads...

[ArmorForZzZzZ]

because the majority of the people on this site have their heads up br& news ass and have biased opinions on anything that has anything to do w/ br& new.

That's basically the theory behind this type of poll: opinion.

[IATA4224]

what the fuck is with everybody on this website listening to brand new? fuck that band. they're terrible.


For a band that sucks, 500 people voted for them, so that must mean the other bands must suck even harder... Don't say a band sucks because you don't like them, because in the end its only your opinion.. But then again you offend people like me because I am a Brand New Fan and have been since day one... And im sure you'd piss off the rest of the bands that are on this poll because they would happen to think that Brand New is indeed a GOOD band...

[omgjames]

haha did someone really need to do this poll to see that brand new would own. not taht any of the other albums were good, but different ones may have fared better.

[NameTaken69]

buy anberlin and brand new

[TheWeakest]

in my oppinion..emery the question>deja

[TheWeakest]

what the fuck is with everybody on this website listening to brand new? fuck that band. they're terrible.


oh by the way..your cool..real cool

[werealldudes19]

i picked the question... i like deja a lot but the question caught on to me right away, deja took a while

[IATA4224]

I just wanted to reiterate to the people who say that Brand New sucks... They now have 561 votes... Thats right 561.. So the people who voted for them must have absolutely no taste in music, or wait, could it be that Deja Entendu is just the best album up there?>

[TellYourFriends]

Brand New all the way.

[sasalukac]

So many votes for Brand New. So ridiculous, not even that good of an album.

agreed. i chose The Used... i obviously like that album more than most people :) after that it would be anberlin, then FFTL, then senses fail, then brand new and emery are a tie, and the other two i havn't listened to enough...

[youcomebeforeyo]

Thursday's new album is by far the best album on that list, failing that go with the popular view because Deja Entedu is pretty good.

[Groogz]

Not a big surprise that the majority of people went with Deja Entendu. A great album and all, but my favorite has to be 'The Question' by Emery.

[Groogz]

Btw, I find it hard to believe that anyone could vote for Cute is What We Aim For against such competition like the bands in this poll. Oh well, whatever.

[Ruggiero2oo8]

bn

[MotionIsntMeaning]

you probably could have predicted the results by putting deja on there. but I went with Anberlin, its a solid album.

[codex avellum31]

wow. deja entendu very suprising. who ever picked heroine should consider walking into on coming traffic.