PDA

View Full Version : The Beatles Vs. Led Zeppelin

heyjoshua
06/12/10, 09:45 AM
...
bobsheiskawy
06/12/10, 09:58 AM
the beatles. no contest.
tonyC4L
06/12/10, 10:08 AM
I like Zeppelin so much more.
E. Clectic
06/12/10, 10:19 AM
How do you only have 160+ posts?

You've had at least that many stupid fucking (and usually rehashed) polls.
ThePartialGlow
06/12/10, 06:28 PM
The Beatles...and it's not even close.
Me and Babar
06/12/10, 09:24 PM
how does zeppelin have almost double the votes? has to be trolls
MattDennis
06/12/10, 09:31 PM
The results of this are pretty shocking to me thus far. Two fantastic groups, but I'll take The Beatles up against anyone ten times out of ten.
yetconfused
06/12/10, 10:51 PM
beatles.

http://i792.photobucket.com/albums/yy206/PepparPaul/wetwilly.gif

c'mon now.
ChelseaRiane
06/13/10, 08:11 AM
http://www.mangaclub.ch/urd/funPics/stfu/srsly-stfu.jpg
Theseventhson
06/13/10, 12:47 PM
The Beatles, Zep always felt one-dimensional to me.
SuNDaYSTaR
06/13/10, 04:20 PM
Why is Zeppelin winning, people?
xapplexpiex
06/13/10, 04:30 PM
The Beatles. I'm surprised they're losing!
fightinirish217
06/13/10, 04:49 PM
The Beatles.
didwhat77times
06/13/10, 07:49 PM
I grew up with George, John, Paul and Ringo as a constant presence in my house.
MattDennis
06/13/10, 10:19 PM
The Beatles, Zep always felt one-dimensional to me.

I like your final decision, but if you think Led Zep was one dimensional I don't think you've heard enough of their discography.
Theseventhson
06/14/10, 06:31 AM
I like your final decision, but if you think Led Zep was one dimensional I don't think you've heard enough of their discography.

I own/have listened to all of it. Idk, maybe it's just because Robert Plant's voice and Jimmy Page's playing are so distinctive that a lot of their stuff blends together in my head.
IceAge/HeatWave
06/14/10, 08:22 AM
I own/have listened to all of it. Idk, maybe it's just because Robert Plant's voice and Jimmy Page's playing are so distinctive that a lot of their stuff blends together in my head.

make no mistake about it, led zeppelin has maybe the most diverse catalogue in music history. the only band that may have experimented with their sound more would be... well, the beatles.

two of the three best bands of all time. i couldn't choose. i'm leaning towards zeppelin, but i'm holding out for now.
Kiguel182
06/14/10, 02:33 PM
love both bands but the beatles is the obvious choice here
ayerock
06/14/10, 04:06 PM
I listen to Zep a lot more
MattDennis
06/14/10, 04:24 PM
I own/have listened to all of it. Idk, maybe it's just because Robert Plant's voice and Jimmy Page's playing are so distinctive that a lot of their stuff blends together in my head.

I understand where you are coming from. Zep is quite good at blending multiple genres, making it more difficult to see individual styles over the whole unique sound they created as their own. Their sound pretty much runs the gamut though...rock (many styles of it), blues, folk, psych, funk...they experimented frequently.

make no mistake about it, led zeppelin has maybe the most diverse catalogue's in music history. the only band that may have experimented with their sound more would be... well, the beatles.

Nailed it. Their usage and experimentation with studio recording was far and above greater than Zep's.
honkyg88
06/15/10, 11:45 AM
I always felt that Zeppelin were superior musicians and I enjoy their music more so I went with them.
Tristan Needler
06/15/10, 05:50 PM
The Beatles.
OhNoVandetos
06/16/10, 02:55 AM
i respect what the beatles did for music but i just enjoy zeplin more, whatever
lilRIPsta
06/16/10, 07:42 AM
I love both bands, but I dont think its debatable that the Beatles are the best band of all time
drawndead
06/16/10, 10:33 AM
I like both but right now I'm on a Led Zeppelin kick
thechetearly
06/16/10, 01:49 PM
the beatles. no contest.

totally agree. idk how anyone can hold a candle to them.
Deadbolt23
06/16/10, 01:51 PM
What a boring poll.

The Beatles.
suppyguppy
06/17/10, 07:34 AM
..seriously?
Me and Babar
06/17/10, 04:01 PM
i dont get how zeppelin is winning but im not seeing any responses from people that must have voted for them, or at least arguments of why
TheClockSounds
06/17/10, 06:48 PM
Beatles, I do love me some zeppelin but I just love the beatles so much more
BornUnderPunches
06/17/10, 06:49 PM
i dont get how zeppelin is winning but im not seeing any responses from people that must have voted for them, or at least arguments of why
then I guess they're the Brand New of this argument
jjjkman
06/19/10, 09:22 AM
The Beatles by far...I don't see how they are losing.
Joeypeapot777
06/19/10, 03:09 PM
I actually borderline hate led zeppizzle. but SO much love for the beatles
spansen
06/19/10, 11:49 PM
really!? the beatles are losing?!
secretsociety92
06/20/10, 03:31 AM
Led Zeppelin, I would take them anyday over The Beatles (to be honest I would listen to most bands rather than them).
Me and Babar
06/20/10, 03:16 PM
Led Zeppelin, I would take them anyday over The Beatles (to be honest I would listen to most bands rather than them).

why is that?
secretsociety92
06/20/10, 04:10 PM
why is that?
I just don't feel like I am having a connection with the majority of their music.
SicTransitIbiza
06/21/10, 07:31 AM
wow i went with LZ and was so surprised, yet glad, to see them winning this. they are fucking incredible.
heyjoshua
06/21/10, 07:44 AM
I'm glad Led Zeppelin are winning, they're incredible. I never was into the Beatles...
VeryWittyName
06/21/10, 08:46 AM
I voted Led Zeppelin...The Beatles are obviously the more important band, historically and culturally, but I just enjoy listening to Led Zeppelin more. Love them both though.
Me and Babar
06/21/10, 04:32 PM
I just don't feel like I am having a connection with the majority of their music.

i feel you, yeah thats fair.
Broden Terry
06/22/10, 01:14 AM
As much as I appreciate Zeppelin, the Beatles by the longest margin,
wall e
06/23/10, 10:44 AM
Lol.
samchops697
06/23/10, 05:05 PM
the beatles. no contest.

agreed.
Say Nothing
06/23/10, 05:33 PM
I prefer Zep..
Steeeve Perry
06/24/10, 06:48 PM
If you say Led Zep you lose at life
Parabola23
06/25/10, 01:46 PM
The Beatles, no question
the fact that people even question this just tells you how very little people understand music history
IceAge/HeatWave
06/25/10, 03:30 PM
people need to chill. the beatles might deserve to win this, but zeppelin is definitely in the top two bands of all time.
Ryan Rumsey
06/25/10, 07:51 PM
Led Zep without question for me.
yellowhouse
06/25/10, 08:21 PM
Id prefer to listen to Led Zeppelin over The Beatles at almost any time.
polock
06/25/10, 10:33 PM
led zepplin, jimmy paige and robert plant are pretty much rock gods
phillycheese37
06/25/10, 10:46 PM
the beatles. no contest.

I cannot say this better myself.
TangledUp
06/26/10, 03:40 AM
In terms of what? Either way, went with Zeppelin.
Me and Babar
06/27/10, 05:47 PM
it still shouldnt even be close
BornUnderPunches
06/27/10, 05:50 PM
I'm losing faith in this website
snowboarderkid
07/01/10, 07:01 PM
The Beatles for sure.

Edit: I am surprised that Led Zeppelin is winning right now.
ppt4895
07/07/10, 02:39 PM
The Beatles
awwgereee
08/16/10, 05:27 PM
make no mistake about it, led zeppelin has maybe the most diverse catalogue in music history. the only band that may have experimented with their sound more would be... well, the beatles.

two of the three best bands of all time. i couldn't choose. i'm leaning towards zeppelin, but i'm holding out for now.

they're both in my top five. just curious as to who you think the other is...
IceAge/HeatWave
08/16/10, 09:20 PM
they're both in my top five. just curious as to who you think the other is...

radiohead. thats the one that people generally find issue with. you got any alternates?
Cristuna
08/16/10, 09:30 PM
I like Zeppelin better. Doesn't mean the Beatles weren't the most influential band ever. Sue me?
awwgereee
08/16/10, 11:56 PM
radiohead. thats the one that people generally find issue with. you got any alternates?

i should've thought that first haha. mine are more of my favorite ones, not necessarily the five "best" so to say. but radiohead isn't in my five if you were wondering lol
IceAge/HeatWave
08/17/10, 10:13 AM
i should've thought that first haha. mine are more of my favorite ones, not necessarily the five "best" so to say. but radiohead isn't in my five if you were wondering lol

yeah. those are my three "best" bands. the only one i still listen to of those are radiohead. but whats on your list?
awwgereee
08/17/10, 01:01 PM
yeah. those are my three "best" bands. the only one i still listen to of those are radiohead. but whats on your list?

well those two, plus pink floyd and brand new. the last one out of the five usually changes though haha
IceAge/HeatWave
08/17/10, 04:51 PM
well those two, plus pink floyd and brand new. the last one out of the five usually changes though haha

those are good bands.

my favorites always go radiohead, because i feel like they're the best group i listen to, then foo fighters, because they got me into music, and then its usually the band i've listened to most at the time. these days thats mewithoutYou.
awwgereee
08/17/10, 07:32 PM
those are good bands.

my favorites always go radiohead, because i feel like they're the best group i listen to, then foo fighters, because they got me into music, and then its usually the band i've listened to most at the time. these days thats mewithoutYou.

both are good. i;ve never listened to mewithoutYou :gasp: right?
IceAge/HeatWave
08/17/10, 07:56 PM
both are good. i;ve never listened to mewithoutYou :gasp: right?

Ha definitely look into them. They're different, but the album brother, sister is one of my all time favorites.
awwgereee
08/17/10, 08:00 PM
Ha definitely look into them. They're different, but the album brother, sister is one of my all time favorites.

listening right now :)
IceAge/HeatWave
08/17/10, 08:17 PM
listening right now :)

Get ready to live haha

in a sweater poorly knit is one of the best songs ever. On YouTube you cab find videos of Jesse Lacey (brand new) on stage performing it with them. One of the most epic things I've ever seen.
awwgereee
08/17/10, 08:44 PM
Get ready to live haha

in a sweater poorly knit is one of the best songs ever. On YouTube you cab find videos of Jesse Lacey (brand new) on stage performing it with them. One of the most epic things I've ever seen.

weird cause that was the first song i listened to haha