Most talented

[speakhandsforme]

.?

choosing between Claudio and Casey is pretty hard...i'll most likely go with the choice that has less votes

[notoaststereo]

casey... although claudio is a geat guitarist sometimes i just cant stand his voice.

[showyourteeth]

thomas erak
straight up

casey is a close second though

[dan.is.empire]

thomas' voice isnt so great...and his lyrics aren't as good as claudio i dont think

[tbag311]

Claudio easily. His guitar skills are amazing, and his lyrics fit perfectly.

[polock]

to do what Thomas Erak does is pretty much fucking amazing

[yourneck]

I love Coheed and Cambria to death, but I think Casey's lyrics are a lot clearer and better than Claudio's. They both tell a story but you can actually understand Casey's, haha. His voice is prettier too.

[sirensiren]

i had to go with claudio on this one. but's really unfair to compare the 3, they're all amazing.

[lilRIPsta]

i picked claudio cuz of his story and guitar playing. Casey has the better voice out of the 3 by far. and thomas is overall talented

[lilRIPsta]

good poll

[BlinkNFG15]

claudio is a schmuck

[GetUpNotGhetto]

claudio by far...if youve ever seen him live or even just understood what anything he does is about youd be blown away too...kudos to secondstage..its his best album vocally i feel

fall of troy's guys pretty fucking sick too, but i dont think he carries the vox or lyrics the way the other two do

[Branevember31]

claudio no contest

[ThrowTheBones]

Claudio is ridiculous with the guitar, and his vocal range is amazing. Casey's great, too.

[SuNDaYSTaR]

Claudio, no contest. Just listen to Everything Evil.

[Alex DiVincenzo]

Not necessarily my favorite, but I'd say Claudio is the most talented.

[buysoap]

i decided to go with casey

[punk shawn]

Claudio, no contest. Just listen to Everything Evil.

thomas, no contest. just listen to any fall of troy song.

[fearthesloths]

Vocals and Lyrics = Claudio
Guitar = Definately Erak, no question

[Eurotrash Drock]

i dont really listen to coheed but probably from what ive seen
lyrics - claudio
vocals - casey
guitar - thomas

i went with casey though.

and yes, dustin kensrue is awesome, but teppai takes care of most of the difficult stuff

[atticus1492]

i could pick thomas just for his playing, but he sings while playing.....incredible

[heytheredelilah]

None

[Carlo Marx]

wow. none.

[lacesout, shane]

I went with Thomas Erak because its incredible the things he plays while he sings.

Claudio is a close second though, i think he has a great voice, is a great guitarist and writes great lyrics.

Casey is a pretty good singer and guitarist, but nothing he does is nearly as impressive as Erak or Sanchez. I don't know about his lyrics with Dear Hunter, but he didn't do much lyrically with TREOS if he did any at all.

[myplasticyou]

erak for how young he is

[speakhandsforme]

Casey is a pretty good singer and guitarist, but nothing he does is nearly as impressive as Erak or Sanchez. I don't know about his lyrics with Dear Hunter, but he didn't do much lyrically with TREOS if he did any at all.
no offense to alex or brendan, but casey made TREOS. If you listen closely, you'll notice the best vocal pieces and lyrics come for Crescenzo, as he has the best voice and by far the best mind...he definately made his lyrical contribution.

[thexflamesxburn]

damn thats a hard choice.

i'd have to say claudio tho, even though im the bigger fan of treos and fall of troy, just because he's proven his legacy over years, while the other two are relatively new, although absolutely incredible.

[0Zero0]

Although Andrew McMahon and Anthony Green are my favorites, Claudio Sanchez is still a musical genius. He gets my vote.

[Zeran]

claudio

[Latane]

Casey because he is the mad scientist ha. If your voting just on guitar skills I might go with the guy from The Fall Of Troy. if your voting on vocals I would definitely go with Claudio because he changed the game (everyone wants to be high pitched now). Lyrics is hard to judge because everyone has a different style. Overall I would go with Casey because he also has the digital thing going on. If you listen to the TREOS album and all of his Dear Hunter material you will see how talented he is with digital sounds and production. If you really don't believe me listen to TREOS before he was in the band...they sounded like just another local band. Alright, sorry for the break down. Later Kids.

[speakhandsforme]

Four year bump. Does Claudio still take the cake?

[drpepper09]

Casey's voice. Jesus fucking Christ.

[UnderclasHero]

Claudiooooo