NFL Awards

[Broken Parachute]

I figured might as well make an official thread.

NFC MVP:
AFC MVP:

NFL Offensive Player of the Year:
NFL Defensive Player of the Year:

NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year:
NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year:

NFL Comeback Player of the Year:

NFL Coach of the Year:

I'll post mine later.

[FondestMemory]

NFL MVP: ladanian tomlinson

NFL Offensive Player of the Year: ladanian tomlinson
NFL Defensive Player of the Year: jason taylor

NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year: marques colston
NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year: aj hawk

NFL Comeback Player of the Year: chad pennington
NFL Coach of the Year: sean payton

these aren't all necessarily who i think will win, just who i would vote for.

[thejetstolehome]

MVP: tomlinson.

OPOTY: tomlinson
DPOTY: taylor

OROTY: colston
DROTY: demeco ryans

[dekdog11]

NFC MVP: brees
AFC MVP: tomlinson (tomlinson overall mvp)

NFL Offensive Player of the Year: tomlinson
NFL Defensive Player of the Year: jason taylor

NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year: VY/jones drew
NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year: demeco ryans

NFL Comeback Player of the Year: chad pennington

NFL Coach of the Year: sean payton

[LeftWideOpen]

NFC MVP: Drew Brees
AFC MVP: LaDanian Tomlinson (overall MVP)

NFL Offensive Player of the Year: Frank Gore
NFL Defensive Player of the Year: Jason Taylor

NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year: Maurice Jones Drew
NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year: Demeco Ryans

NFL Comeback Player of the Year: Chad Pennington

NFL Coach of the Year: Eric Mangini

[justinevans]

NFC MVP: Drew Brees
AFC MVP: Tominson
NFL MVP: Tomlinson

NFL Offensive Player of the Year: Tomlinson
NFL Defensive Player of the Year: Jason Taylor

NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year: McNeil/Jones-Drew
NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year: Demeco Ryans

NFL Comeback Player of the Year: Jeff Garcia/Chad Pennington

NFL Coach of the Year: Sean Payton/Eric Mangini

[livethesounds]

NFC MVP: Drew Brees
AFC MVP: Ladanian Tomlinson
NFL MVP: Tomlinson

NFL Offensive Player of the Year: Ladanian Tomlinson
NFL Defensive Player of the Year: Jason Taylor

NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year: Maurice Jones-Drew
NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year: AJ Hawk

NFL Comeback Player of the Year: Chad Pennington

NFL Coach of the Year: Sean Payton

[mikeford]

clean sweep of every award for Joey Harrington

[xbrokendownx]

NFC MVP: Drew Brees, Saints
AFC MVP: LaDainian Tomlinson, Chargers

NFL Offensive Player of the Year: LaDainian Tomlinson, Chargers
NFL Defensive Player of the Year: Jason Taylor, Dolphins

NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year: Marquez Colston, Saints
NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year: Demeco Ryans, Texans

NFL Comeback Player of the Year: Chad Pennington, Jets

NFL Coach of the Year: Eric Mangini, Jets

[justinevans]

NFC MVP: Drew Brees
AFC MVP: Ladanian Tomlinson
NFL MVP: Tomlinson

NFL Offensive Player of the Year: Ladanian Tomlinson
NFL Defensive Player of the Year: Jason Taylor

NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year: Maurice Jones-Drew
NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year: AJ Hawk

NFL Comeback Player of the Year: Chad Pennington

NFL Coach of the Year: Sean Payton

Demeco Ryans 156 tackles. AJ Hawk 121.
All other stats are the same except Hawk had one more int.

It is close, but I think Ryans gets it.

[FondestMemory]

Demeco Ryans 156 tackles. AJ Hawk 121.
All other stats are the same except Hawk had one more int.

It is close, but I think Ryans gets it.

i agree in that ryans will more than likely get it. my vote would go to hawk though. being the anchor of the 12th ranked defense is pretty damn impressive for a rookie.

not to take away from ryans' fantastic season, i feel voting for him would be punishing hawk for having better teammates around him.

that's just me though.

[Broken Parachute]

NFC MVP: Drew Brees
AFC MVP: Ladainian Tomlinson (overall MVP)

NFL Offensive Player of the Year: Ladainian Tomlinson
NFL Defensive Player of the Year: Champ Bailey

NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year: Marques Colston
NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year: Kamerion Wimbley (Ryans had a WAY better year..but since this voting means nothing, I just chose Wimbley to give him some respect. He had a great season on a horrible defense).

NFL Comeback Player of the Year: Chad Pennington

NFL Coach of the Year: Sean Payton (Eric Mangini comes SO close)

[Dirty Ernie]

clean sweep of every award for Joey Harrington

Runaway for coach of the year.

[Clarett'sGreyGoose]

NFC MVP: Drew Brees
AFC MVP: Tomlinson

NFL Offensive Player of the Year: Tomlinson
NFL Defensive Player of the Year: Jason Taylor, MIA (fuck the Roider Merriman)

NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year: Marques Colston, NO/ Maurice Jones-Drew, JAX/ Marcus McNeill, SD
NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year: DeMeco Ryans, HOU

NFL Comeback Player of the Year: Chad Pennington, NYJ

NFL Coach of the Year: Sean Payton, NO

[Brownpants06]

NFL MVP: Brees

NFC MVP: Brees
AFC MVP: LT

NFL Offensive Player of the Year: LT
NFL Defensive Player of the Year: Adalius Thomas

NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year: Colston
NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year: Aj Hawk

NFL Comeback Player of the Year: Chad Pennington

NFL Coach of the Year: Eric Mangini

[fire on my lips]

NFC MVP: Drew Brees
AFC MVP: LaDanian Tomlinson (overall MVP)

NFL Offensive Player of the Year: Frank Gore
NFL Defensive Player of the Year: Jason Taylor

NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year: Maurice Jones Drew
NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year: Demeco Ryans

NFL Comeback Player of the Year: Chad Pennington

NFL Coach of the Year: Eric Mangini

Why choose Gore over LT for Offensive Player of the Year?

NFC MVP: Drew Brees
AFC MVP: LaDanian Tomlinson

NFL Offensive Player of the Year: LaDanian Tomlinson
NFL Defensive Player of the Year: Jason Taylor

NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year: Maurice Jones Drew
NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year: A.J. Hawk

NFL Comeback Player of the Year: Chad Pennington

NFL Coach of the Year: Sean Payton (I want Mangini to win, but Payton will)

[bigmike]

MVP: LT
OPOTY: LT
DPOTY: Jason Taylor
Off ROTY: Maurice Jones-Drew
Def ROTY: AJ Hawk
Comeback Player: Chad Pennington
Coach of the Year: Eric Mangini. Jets aren't as talented as the saints are and he took them to the playoffs. Payton has been nothing but amazing and I will root for the Saints to win the superbowl, but Mangini, IMO, has done more with less than Payton has.

Also, I picked Jones-Drew for the OROTY but I would prefer that Marcus McNeill get's it. Dude has been one of, if not the best, LT in football this year for the chargers.

[LeftWideOpen]

Why choose Gore over LT for Offensive Player of the Year?

because i dont like the idea of the same guy winning both awards

[bigmike]

because i dont like the idea of the same guy winning both awards
yeah... but LT had the best offensive season in the NFL.

[fromwithin]

Coach of the Year: Eric Mangini. Jets aren't as talented as the saints are and he took them to the playoffs. Payton has been nothing but amazing and I will root for the Saints to win the superbowl, but Mangini, IMO, has done more with less than Payton has.

Also, I picked Jones-Drew for the OROTY but I would prefer that Marcus McNeil get's it. Dude has been one of, if not the best, LT in football this year for the chargers.

I agree with these statements 110%. It's sad that Payton will win it because of the sympathy angle.

[bigmike]

I agree with these statements 110%. It's sad that Payton will win it because of the sympathy angle.
well, one could also argue that Payton took a franchise with nothing but losing tradition and turned them into division champions in his first season and that changing an entire culture of losing while getting 26 (i think?) new players to mesh and buy into his philosophies so soon is tougher than what Mangini did.

I don't think Payton wins it on sympathy, he's definitely proven he deserves it and I won't mind if he gets it, but I think Mangini is more deserving.

[justinevans]

because i dont like the idea of the same guy winning both awards

LT than Steven Jackson...not Frank Fumbles Gore.

[justinevans]

demeco ryans won def roty

[Trainsaw]

VY won O roty

[justinevans]

VY won O roty

gay.

[LeftWideOpen]

what a joke

[bigmike]

fucking ridiculous.

[rcrook]

how the fuck does reggie bush only get 3 votes and devin hester gets 0. what a fucking scene.

[livethesounds]

i told you so. :-)

I think most people knew he would win it, and apparently the voters looked at more than numbers. witch as i said would be the only way he would not win it.

Congrats to Demeco Ryans on Defensive rookie of the year as well.

[LeftWideOpen]

the worst part about this is that titan homers are going to use this as part of their defense in future discussions, as if he deserved it.

i'd equate the meaningfulness of this to being selected for the MLB All Star Game, if you know what i'm saying.

[thejetstolehome]

Congrats to Demeco Ryans on Defensive rookie of the year as well.

at least he deserved his award.

[FondestMemory]

i hope he did the heisman pose when he was given the award.

[bigmike]

the worst part about this is that titan homers are going to use this as part of their defense in future discussions, as if he deserved it.

i'd equate the meaningfulness of this to being selected for the MLB All Star Game, if you know what i'm saying.
Yeah for real. But I think NFL Awards go out the window when they reward a cheater with a spot on their all star roster.

[mikeford]

wow great the NFL awards are about as meaningful as the Gold Glove now.

[Broken Parachute]

That's a joke. I can't believe Bush, Jones-Drew, or Colston didn't get it.

[iihungrieii]

how mad are you guys going to be when merriman wins dpoy

[leftstranded]

NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year: Kamerion Wimbley (Ryans had a WAY better year..but since this voting means nothing, I just chose Wimbley to give him some respect. He had a great season on a horrible defense).
probably wouldn't pick him. but you bring up a great point.

that d is just plain horrible

[sweethypocrisy]

how mad are you guys going to be when merriman wins dpoy
jason taylor will win it, if merriman wins it i might stop watching the nfl.

[justinevans]

how mad are you guys going to be when merriman wins dpoy

if that happens I'll hire someone to cut your balls off.

[arenasequalsmvp]

That's a joke. I can't believe Bush, Jones-Drew, or Colston didn't get it.

Same, how the fuck does VY get it for a 65.7 QB rating?

[sweethypocrisy]

Same, how the fuck does VY get it for a 65.7 QB rating?
cuz he wins lols (even though his team didnt make the playoffs...)

[leftstranded]

cuz he wins lols (even though his team didnt make the playoffs...)
i think the media is the exact reason why he won. the media hyped the hell out of him in texas, they hyped the hell out of him when he came out.

and they hyped the hell out of every big play he made. i would have liked to see someone that put up some better numbers, like jones-drew, or bush, or colston

[leftstranded]

chad pennington did end up getting comeback player of the year

[Brownpants06]

and lt mvp, i wish brees got it.

[justinevans]

and lt mvp, i wish brees got it.

why should Brees get it?

[Brownpants06]

Because the Saints won their division. The chargers have tons of talent compared to the saints.

[justinevans]

Because the Saints won their division. The chargers have tons of talent compared to the saints.

The Chargers were 14-2 and for the most part with the same talent they got 5 more wins with a rookie qb in the AFC, let alone the AFC west.
The Saints played in a weak NFC with a bunch of underachievers in their division and fairly bad defenses. They passed a hell of a lot in an artificial stadium. They had plenty of talent on offense. 2 Good running backs. A good WR, a decent line, and a surprising rookie in Colston. Tomlinson had more rushing tds than Brees had passing. He had the most TDs in football and that rarely happens...ever

[thejetstolehome]

The Chargers were 14-2 and for the most part with the same talent they got 5 more wins with a rookie qb in the AFC, let alone the AFC west.
The Saints played in a weak NFC with a bunch of underachievers in their division and fairly bad defenses. They passed a hell of a lot in an artificial stadium. They had plenty of talent on offense. 2 Good running backs. A good WR, a decent line, and a surprising rookie in Colston. Tomlinson had more rushing tds than Brees had passing. He had the most TDs in football and that rarely happens...ever

yup.

[xbrokendownx]

Because the Saints won their division. The chargers have tons of talent compared to the saints.









reggie bush, deuce mccallister, joe horn, marques colston, devery henderson, scott fujita, charles grant, will smith




yea, the saints have NO talent at all....


not to mention the saints division was shit compared to the AFC west.



anyone that doesnt think LT is the mvp is on PCP

[rocktometal]

anyone that doesnt think LT is the mvp is on PCP

I hate the chargers, but I have to respect LT. MVP for sure.

[FondestMemory]

lt was hands down the mvp, but the fucking voting is flawed.

a case could be made very easily for brees, so i can understand giving him first place votes. i really thought he'd end up with more than 4 though.

but what really gets me, is that peyton manning got two first place votes. seriously? not to take anything away from manning, but compared to the season brees and lt had, how does he even get a single vote higher than third? absolutely ridiculous.

[rcrook]

lt was hands down the mvp, but the fucking voting is flawed.

a case could be made very easily for brees, so i can understand giving him first place votes. i really thought he'd end up with more than 4 though.

but what really gets me, is that peyton manning got two first place votes. seriously? not to take anything away from manning, but compared to the season brees and lt had, how does he even get a single vote higher than third? absolutely ridiculous.


it is the Most Valuable Player award...im a chargers fan and i was all about LT. But if you think about the Colts they're awful without Peyton Manning. Yeah he had a down year but he is still very valuable to his team.

[FondestMemory]

it is the Most Valuable Player award...im a chargers fan and i was all about LT. But if you think about the Colts they're awful without Peyton Manning. Yeah he had a down year but he is still very valuable to his team.

i'm not saying he isn't, but you can't make a stronger case for him than you can brees or lt.

[rcrook]

i'm not saying he isn't, but you can't make a stronger case for him than you can brees or lt.

and that's exactly why brees and LT got more votes...end of debate.

[FondestMemory]

and that's exactly why brees and LT got more votes...end of debate.

i'm not debating anything, i'm saying it's bullshit that manning got any first place votes at all.

just proves that they really need to reevaluate who they're giving votes to.