Tell All Your Friends or Take This To Your Grave

[rcrook]

Both are amazing albums that jump started two bands career. They have both hit the big time selling out arenas but which release was better?

[JulieLynn]

Of course i'm going to say TTTYG....

[karenxcore]

TELL ALL YOUR FRIENDS...duh

[FeynmanWannabe]

TAYF, easily.

[ForlrnPerplxity]

this shouldn't even be close

[oh_its_julio]

Definitely TAYF. But Shouldn't "Brand New - You Favorite Weapon" be here too. It came out at around the same time and also jumped started their careers.

[rcrook]

Definitely TAYF. But Shouldn't "Brand New - You Favorite Weapon" be here too. It came out at around the same time and also jumped started their careers.

brand new is not as mainstream as TBS or FOB.

[googirl8907]

Take This To Your Grave...one of my fav cds period

[SickOfStars]

Tell All Your Friends, no contest.

[Cheshire_Buddha]

TAYF for the win.

[oh_its_julio]

brand new is not as mainstream as TBS or FOB.

Obviously, but it definitely jump started their careers. They played stadiums, and most of us listened to YFW around the same time as TAYF and TTTYG. Plus the acronym has a "Y" in it too :)

[rcrook]

Obviously, but it definitely jump started their careers. They played stadiums, and most of us listened to YFW around the same time as TAYF and TTTYG. Plus the acronym has a "Y" in it too :)


Brand New has not gone on arena tours like TBS or FOB...end of discussion.

[karenxcore]

Obviously, but it definitely jump started their careers. They played stadiums, and most of us listened to YFW around the same time as TAYF and TTTYG. Plus the acronym has a "Y" in it too :)

Your..haha

[youcomebeforeyo]

Tayf.

[Cheshire_Buddha]

Obviously, but it definitely jump started their careers. They played stadiums, and most of us listened to YFW around the same time as TAYF and TTTYG. Plus the acronym has a "Y" in it too :)

Just create a YFW vs. TTTYG thread. One of those will probably pop up in the next couple of weeks anyway.

[oh_its_julio]

Just create a YFW vs. TTTYG thread. One of those will probably pop up in the next couple of weeks anyway.


We all seem to love Brand New here.

I'm new though. So, I'll wait a little before starting my own threads ;)

[takingbackrufio]

How I feel about TAYF is pretty obvious by now.

[nfggc10]

TAYF by a mile in every aspect

[Cue the Sun]

tttyg.

[ThisIsNotDan]

Brand New has not gone on arena tours like TBS or FOB...end of discussion.

what do you call the Dashboard tour, you douche?

[Branevember31]

Take This To Your Grave

[nfggc10]

We all seem to love Brand New here.

I'm new though. So, I'll wait a little before starting my own threads ;)
no need to make that poll anyway. yfw would win by a bigger margin than tayf is winning this one.

[xJangsterrx]

WAY too hard for me to pick...

I remember when both cds came out though, i think i was like... 11 or 12 and i heard the songs over at a friends house, and then like a month or so later i saw the Grand Theft Autumn/Where Is Your Boy? video and was like, they're pretty good..

But then i saw the 'Cute Without The "E" (Cut From The Team)' video, and i was kind of like "meh... i like the whole two vocalists idea, and it works for them, but they could do better.."

So to sum it all up in a nutshell, i can't pick between the two, cause they both have had, and still have a tremendous influence on the type of music i listen to today.

[gcmaniac]

tayf...

[JTMcKrackles]

Tttyg.

[oh_its_julio]

Brand New has not gone on arena tours like TBS or FOB...end of discussion.


Brand New never toured with Dashboard on an arena tour?
Yeah, I'm pretty sure they did... for two and a half months.

... "end of discussion"

dumbass

[nfggc10]

Brand New never toured with Dashboard on an arena tour?
Yeah, I'm pretty sure they did... for two and a half months.

... "end of discussion"

dumbassindeed

[punk shawn]

tell all your friends.

[mybreakingpoint]

anyone who chose Take This To Your Grave deserves to be shot and buried in a pile of their own entrails

[mutiny]

tttyg, no contest. i've never been a fan of taking back sunday, though, so i'm biased.

[avengedtbs]

both were great albums but heres why tell all your friends was better....take this to your grave is the kind of album that you play really loud in the car with a bunch of your friends and just sing every song, having a great time...however tell all your friends was more influential upon the listener than take this to your grave. countless number of people have listened to tell all your friends and when it was over, thought about how much they could relate to that album (and you can also play it really loud in the car with a bunch of your friends and sing every song having a great time)...therefore TAYF was a better release because of how much people could relate to it and how much influence it had upon people

[cmarierk]

anyone who chose Take This To Your Grave deserves to be shot and buried in a pile of their own entrails

hahahh.
agreed.

[oh_its_julio]

both were great albums but heres why tell all your friends was better....take this to your grave is the kind of album that you play really loud in the car with a bunch of your friends and just sing every song, having a great time...however tell all your friends was more influential upon the listener than take this to your grave. countless number of people have listened to tell all your friends and when it was over, thought about how much they could relate to that album (and you can also play it really loud in the car with a bunch of your friends and sing every song having a great time)...therefore TAYF was a better release because of how much people could relate to it and how much influence it had upon people

Agreed TAYF has been the first album in the car whenever I'm out with friends for a while now. People who hated TBS before listening to TAYF sing to every word now.

[mybreakingpoint]

i agree with what avengedtbs said.

i know what it feels like when John yells "best friends means i pull the trigger; best friends means you get what you deserve". or "i know you well enough to know you never loved me"

and i simply shake my head at the stupidity of "i wouldn't piss to put you out" and "stop burning bridges, drive off of them". while "clever" in their own stupid little ways, neither are anything relatable, or atleast not to the extent of TAYF.

i can listed to TTTYG whil taking a shit.

i can listen to TAYF whenever i feel like shit.

[writeacliche]

To anyone saying TTTYG is less relatable than TAYF is a little extreme. Both are poppunk albums with alot of similarities. I find that at times TAYF is overly dramatic and TTTYG can identify with alot of people in our generation (teens).

[oh_its_julio]

To anyone saying TTTYG is less relatable than TAYF is a little extreme. Both are poppunk albums with alot of similarities. I find that at times TAYF is overly dramatic and TTTYG can identify with alot of people in our generation (teens).

It can go both ways. In my opinion they can both be a little over dramatic, but thats how we remember certain lines in songs. Atleast with me the lines I remember the most are the ones that are over dramatized.

[tonighttonight0]

both were good albums
but tell all your friends was better

[pinklipgloss]

TAYF. No explanations needed.

[Talib Scottie]

TAYF destroys anything FOB has ever done.

[BN3131]

Both were very good but i was able to get into tttyg a lot more than tayf.

[lostfear]

Brand New>>Taking Back Sunday>>>>>>Fall Out Boy

but I love them all

Pete simply just compare to Jesse and Adam.

[oh_its_julio]

Brand New>>Taking Back Sunday>>>>>>Fall Out Boy

couldn't agree more :D

[mrzippo3]

If you think TTTYG is better than TAYF then you're obviously a crack baby.

[This_Is_The_End]

tell all your friends

[brentford]

umm its all about where you want to be...
dizzuhh...

[chronomic]

tttyg is one of my top 10.

tayf is in my top 3.


tttyg was like a puch to the nuts. tayf is like getting shot in the face.

[avengedtbs]

umm its all about where you want to be...
dizzuhh...
i hope you are joking...

[Tyler Revolution]

TAYF, easily. But I do love TTTYG.

[Tyler Revolution]

both were great albums but heres why tell all your friends was better....take this to your grave is the kind of album that you play really loud in the car with a bunch of your friends and just sing every song, having a great time...however tell all your friends was more influential upon the listener than take this to your grave. countless number of people have listened to tell all your friends and when it was over, thought about how much they could relate to that album (and you can also play it really loud in the car with a bunch of your friends and sing every song having a great time)...therefore TAYF was a better release because of how much people could relate to it and how much influence it had upon people

What are you talking about? Being able to relate to an album more so than another, doesn't make it a better album, and either does being able to play an album loud in a car with a bunch of friends. Maybe to you, but you can only speak for yourself. And in your post, you're talking as if you know that more people were affected by a certain album than another. You don't know, and you can't make those kinds of calls for other people.

[TellYourFriends]

Tell All Your Friends still gets me hyped. It never gets old.

[petey536]

I went with TTTYG, but its such a hard choice

[xwisebuddhax]

Fob>tbs

[radjerryrad]

Tell All Your Friends

[Grant, Postla..]

easily TAYF. Can anyone tell me though. Did tbs take their second album name Where You Want To Be. From On the Might Of Princes ?? They from Long island arent they? I've often wondered and never been able to find out. Im assuming they did cos its a bit too bigger coincedence not to be.

btw On the Might Of Princes are sweet.

[stop my heart]

Tell all your friends is amazing! although i havnt actualy heard Fall out boy's first album but they aint realy anything special.

[thejetstolehome]

TAYF.

c

[thejetstolehome]

Tell all your friends is amazing! although i havnt actualy heard Fall out boy's first album but they aint realy anything special.

listen to TTTYG and you'll change your mind.

[TAYF152]

TAYF>Any album released in the last five years.

[thejetstolehome]

i absolutely love the album but i wouldn't go that far.

[chronomic]

listen to TTTYG and you'll change your mind.

tttyg is a very special album. tayf is just ridic, god i cant even say how sweet that album is. so raw

[thejetstolehome]

tttyg is a very special album. tayf is just ridic, god i cant even say how sweet that album is. so raw

i'll never get sick of either.

[chronomic]

so good as setting bad examples, listen chic ive had all i can han-duuuuulllll

[thejetstolehome]

we won't stand for hazy eyes anymore.

[chokeychicken]

anyone who chose Take This To Your Grave deserves to be shot and buried in a pile of their own entrails

my thoughts exactly.

anybody choosing take this to your grave is an assclown. what the hell are you thinking? tell all your friends is a music STAPLE in this scene. it is one of the most perfect records released in this genre.

take this to your grave, as much as i like it, has like 6 solid songs. maybe 7. and a lot of them sound similar.

TAYF, no question. this shouldnt even be a poll.

[mybreakingpoint]

are you turned on?

[mybreakingpoint]

my thoughts exactly.

anybody choosing take this to your grave is an assclown. what the hell are you thinking? tell all your friends is a music STAPLE in this scene. it is one of the most perfect records released in this genre.

take this to your grave, as much as i like it, has like 6 solid songs. maybe 7. and a lot of them sound similar.

TAYF, no question. this shouldnt even be a poll.

amen.

[chronomic]

are you turned on?

im getting chills just singing these songs in my head. so awesome

[TAYF152]

It's my fist vs. the bottle (and thanks god you weren't there to watch me hit bottom)

[chokeychicken]

she'll destroy us all then find a way to blame it on somebody else.

(it took me 3 years to figure out what he was saying)

[chronomic]

she'll destroy us all then find a way to blame it on somebody else.

(it took me 3 years to figure out what he was saying)

haha such a great line too

[chronomic]

god bless john nolan

[xJangsterrx]

But I love the way you'd roll excuses off the tip of your toungue, as i slowly fall apart..

[mybreakingpoint]

this is me with the world on the tip of my tongue and my eye through the scope down the barrel of a gun...

...remind me not to ever act this way again.

this is you trying hard to make sure that you see, with the girl on your arm and your heart on your sleeve...

...remind me not to ever think of you again.







you can more or less quote every single line of this album. i know it by heart. doesn't get much better than TAYF, that's for sure.

comparing TAYF and TTTYG is like comparing Keirra Knightley to Rosie O'Donnell; which one wold you rather wake up to every morning?

[walshknilb281]

so good as setting bad examples, listen trick ive had all i can han-duuuuulllll


not trying to be a dick just pointing it out

and for me TAYF

[DroppedUrPocket]

I was about to break my fucking monitor if TTTYG was winning.

[nfggc10]

I was about to break my fucking monitor if TTTYG was winning.i'm surprised it's not considering the average age of people here keeps falling...

[DroppedUrPocket]

she'll destroy us all then find a way to blame it on somebody else.

(it took me 3 years to figure out what he was saying)

Not to be a dick, but it's:

She'll destroy us all before she's through and find a way to blame somebody else.

[nfggc10]

Not to be a dick, but it's:

She'll destroy us all before she's through and find a way to blame somebody else.yep

[thejetstolehome]

i'm surprised it's not considering the average age of people here keeps falling...

this place makes me feel old.

[takingbackrufio]

anybody choosing take this to your grave is an assclown. what the hell are you thinking? tell all your friends is a music STAPLE in this scene. it is one of the most perfect records released in this genre.
Completely agree.

[nfggc10]

this place makes me feel old.ha seriously, especially when it's invaded by 13 or 14 year olds raving about music that's written about things they're not even old to have gone through yet.

[brewsterbuffalo]

Either No Matter Where We Go...! or Turn Up the Punk, We'll Be Singing.

O WATE LOL.

[cmarierk]

ha seriously, especially when it's invaded by 13 or 14 year olds raving about music that's written about things they're not even old to have gone through yet.

yay im older than 14

and i still really love tayf

[FuryCore]

Haha, was that a ruse a few months back when it was posted on here that Adam was talking about re-recording TAYF and re-releasing it? That had to be a joke.

I mean, THAT would be an amazingly sellout thing to do, and a dumbass thing to do, at that.

[MIKEY_HORROR]

Tell All Your Friends.... but both are really good albums. just more memories and all w/ TAYF

[Take Heart]

TAYF blows TTTYG out of the water

[Take Heart]

I was about to break my fucking monitor if TTTYG was winning.

When I saw the poll and went to vote, I literally cringed as i was waiting to see the results, because I thought TTTYG would be ahead by a landslide.

[atticus1492]

Come on. TAYF.

[christopher™]

its all about tell all your friends!

[chronomic]

you can more or less quote every single line of this album. i know it by heart. doesn't get much better than TAYF, that's for sure.

comparing TAYF and TTTYG is like comparing Keirra Knightley to Rosie O'Donnell; which one wold you rather wake up to every morning?

the only album i can really compare to tayf is yfw. i know that its cliche as crap, but theres a reason its cliche. i pretty much consider them the same album but just written by different people.

[wombat]

take this to your grave

[chokeychicken]

take this to your grave

your post count probably matches your age.

[FF4889]

If it wasn't for Tell All Your Friends, I wouldn't be listening to any of the bands discussed on this site. That album completely changed my views on music and musical tastes. It will forever be one of my favorite albums of all time.

[nfggc10]

your post count probably matches your age.haha most likely

I question anyone who actually picks TTTYG over TAYF..

[TAYF152]

If it wasn't for Tell All Your Friends, I wouldn't be listening to any of the bands discussed on this site. That album completely changed my views on music and musical tastes. It will forever be one of my favorite albums of all time.

Couldn't have said it better myself. Right on.

[karenxcore]

I think the lyrics in TAYF are way better than TTTYG.

[DroppedUrPocket]

When I saw the poll and went to vote, I literally cringed as i was waiting to see the results, because I thought TTTYG would be ahead by a landslide.

That's exactly what I was thinking.

And, go Wigglytuff!

[nfggc10]

I think the lyrics in TAYF are way better than TTTYG.by an infinite amount also

[mybreakingpoint]

your post count probably matches your age.

probably matches her IQ as well if she chose TTTYG :-)

[chronomic]

probably matches her IQ as well if she chose TTTYG :-)

key words there are 'her' and 'she'






oh snap

[mybreakingpoint]

oh snap indeed haha

[xJangsterrx]

I made my decision... Definately, TAYF..

Don't get me wrong, i love both bands/cds, but TAYF got me into all the music i listen to now... TAYF and blink-182 got me listening

[pinklipgloss]

I think the lyrics in TAYF are way better than TTTYG.

far more superior.

[haleygoodbye]

TAYF deffinately.

[atticus1492]

For some reason, I am angry that these two cd's are being compared.

[TAYF152]

Wow the albums they could have made if nolan would have stuck with tbs...

[wearitloud]

For some reason, I am angry that these two cd's are being compared.


I'm not really angry, I just think it's weird.
For me, there's no contest, it's TAYF.

Maybe the point of this was to weed out those who have taste and those who don't?

[FF4889]

Wow the albums they could have made if nolan would have stuck with tbs...


I really wish they would of put out just one more album with John and Shaun before they left.

[_kelly]

tayf is my number one favorite album, but tttyg is one of my top 3 albums.
but tayf is miles ahead of anything else

[johnh5304]

I still listen to TAYF so I'll go with that. I can't stand fall out boy anymore.

[trindaddy]

tttyg by far. and im pretty sure tbs isn't "selling out arenas" or getting nearly the exposure or record sales as fob

[thejetstolehome]

tttyg by far. and im pretty sure tbs isn't "selling out arenas" or getting nearly the exposure or record sales as fob

so that makes TTTYG the better album? and, yea, a few months ago TBS was doing all that. still, though, it has nothing to do with the argument. TTTYG, while catchy and an album that i love, cannot hold a candle to the raw emotion that is TAYF. TAYF era Taking Back Sunday was always, and will always, be better than ANY era Fall Out Boy.

[laryssa]

I like both albums but I don't hestiate to say TAYF.

[IHopeYourAlone]

This should be a landslide. TAYF by far.

[fenderkid212]

wow, those are my two favorite albums pretty much. I went with TAYF.

[Talib Scottie]

You Know How I Do > Tell That Mick
Bike Scene > Dead On Arrival
Cute Without the E >>>>>>>>>> Grand Theft Autumn
No I in Team > Saturday
Great Romances of the 21st Century > Homesick at Space Camp
Ghost Man on Third > Sending Postcards...
Timberwolves at New Jersey > Chicago
Blue Channel > Pros and Cons
You're So Last Summer > Grenade Jumper
Head Club > Calm Before the Storm

and maybe Patron Saints is better than Ballad of Sal Villanueva.

[notoaststereo]

tayf. im surprised not as many people are saying tttyg

[Drew Beringer]

TAYF easily, this is no contest.

[Take Heart]

tttyg by far. and im pretty sure tbs isn't "selling out arenas" or getting nearly the exposure or record sales as fob

That's probably the worst argument I've ever read on this site, and that's saying a lot.

[xerovision1]

definitely tell all your friends. amazing.

[chronomic]

take this to all your friends

[DroppedUrPocket]

take this to your p3t3 dick

[thejetstolehome]

tell all your seandas to take this to your superbowl.

[chronomic]

the finest line divides a night well spent from a waste of time

[killahhqueen]

tttyg, but tayf is amazing too. i can see why a lot more people are voting for tayf here

[thejetstolehome]

yea, 'cause it's the better album.

[chronomic]

yea, 'cause it's the better album.

qlwnd

[Take Heart]

I'd like to see the results of this poll if girls 16 and younger weren't allowed to vote.

[Take Heart]

TTTYG, hands down. When I listen to it now, it still holds up and is great fun to listen to.

TAYF just sounds like teenagers whining.

I'm about to move to New Zealand, I hope everyone there doesn't have the same terrible taste in music as you X-)

[Take Heart]

Wellington. I kid with the "terrible taste" of course, just an exaggeration because I feel you can't compare TAYF to TTTYG.

But I'm well aware that the musical taste of young people over there is probably going to leave much to be desired

[sirrie]

Fo sho, I'm Wellington too. Yeah, it's pretty tough when most of my friends first heard of Fall Out Boy because "Sugar, We're Goin' Down" was on the radio.

But as long as you have an internet connection, you'll survive.

Well that depends, broadband is pretty shit here too.

yayyy wgtn people!!
/isalooser

[chokeychicken]

TTTYG, hands down. When I listen to it now, it still holds up, the hooks sound great, and it gets me energised.

TAYF just sounds like teenagers whining. Looking back, the singing is terrible, the production is mediocre, and I can't feel the lyrics, because I'm not a chump anymore.

you can't fucking feel the lyrics?

my head is about to explode.

tell all your friends makes TTTYG look like a Celene deon record

[Iamhome]

Neither of these bands can sing their songs live... At least TBS can (or does) play them decently...

[Andy K]

For me it is a pretty hard choice, but I have to go with Tell All Your Friends.

[Talib Scottie]

If you can listen to TAYF without rocking the fuck out, then something is wrong with you.

[mybreakingpoint]

If you can listen to TAYF without rocking the fuck out, then something is wrong with you.

no joke.

and whoever said they can't relate to TAYF

has probably never had a date and lives with their mom and/or are still a little kid, in which case, wait a few more years, and you'll see.

anyone who can't relate to TAYF has never had a gf/bf and/or best friend.

ever.

[chronomic]

no joke.

and whoever said they can't relate to TAYF

has probably never had a date and lives with their mom and/or are still a little kid, in which case, wait a few more years, and you'll see.

anyone who can't relate to TAYF has never had a gf/bf and/or best friend.

ever.

your avatar is fuuuucked up dude

[megan*]

tttyg. im sorry. both are good. but tttyg definitly wins

[chronomic]

ouch

[mybreakingpoint]

your avatar is fuuuucked up dude

hahahahaha you like it. :-D

[mybreakingpoint]

tttyg.

liar.

im sorry.

liar.

both are good.

liar.

but tttyg definitly wins

liar.



...liar.

[chronomic]

hahahah

[chronomic]

if were keeping score

[mybreakingpoint]

ahahahahahaha

we're all choir boys at best!

[chronomic]

hahaha that was seamless

[mybreakingpoint]

hahaha perfect.


"spin" was the only dong i really loved on the new album :-(

[chronomic]

hahaha perfect.


"spin" was the only dong i really loved on the new album :-(

hahahaa i hope it is the only dong u loved.







jkjk, yeah the record is good for a song here and there....no staying power tho

[atticus1492]

hahaha perfect.


"spin" was the only dong i really loved on the new album :-(

dong.

[karenxcore]

Haha

[thejetstolehome]

both are good. but tttyg definitly loses

yea, definitely, you're right.

i don't understand how people think tttyg is better. there is not one song on it that is better than any one track on tayf.

liar.



liar.



liar.



liar.



...liar.

hahahahahahahahahaha amazing.

hahaha perfect.


"spin" was the only dong i really loved on the new album :-(

i haven't listened to "louder now" in months.

[Talib Scottie]

I'd like to thank this thread. For months I haven't really listened to TAYF, but tonight I listened... and it's finally ready to take over again.

[thejetstolehome]

i've been listening to nothing but TAYF all week. well, that and John Fogerty.

[lushintransit]

Definitely TAYF. But Shouldn't "Brand New - You Favorite Weapon" be here too. It came out at around the same time and also jumped started their careers.

Just cause it's a TBS survey, we need to throw Brand New in there?

[lushintransit]

Just create a YFW vs. TTTYG thread. One of those will probably pop up in the next couple of weeks anyway.


Psh, one of those pop up everyday.

[basketcase_006]

Tayf Ftw

[electricbaby]

TTTYG
i dont really like TBS, except for that new song 'liar' is okay.
yeah yeah bash if you want, i just dont like that band
but fall out boy is amazing, IMO

[chronomic]

you know nothing

[Misha-chan]

dont hate me, but i say TTTYG....i love TBS, but im more of a fan of FOB... (as you can tell by my signature...!...)

[underthetalking]

This is how I sum it up.

Adam and John can sing.

Patrick and Pete, not so much.

[nfggc10]

TTTYG
i dont really like TBS, except for that new song 'liar' is okay.
yeah yeah bash if you want, i just dont like that band
but fall out boy is amazing, IMOPop-punk by definition cannot be amazing. And they're not even the best at what they do. The songwriting has gone from pretty good (Evening Out... and TTTYG) to horrendous (FUCT and IOH). The only thing that saves them now is that Patrick's voice keeps getting better in spite of Pete's lyrics getting worse by the record.

[sdbrown]

Pop-punk by definition cannot be amazing. And they're not even the best at what they do. The songwriting has gone from pretty good (Evening Out... and TTTYG) to horrendous (FUCT and IOH). The only thing that saves them now is that Patrick's voice keeps getting better in spite of Pete's lyrics getting worse by the record.
Well if it helps, Patrick wrote a lot of the lyrics for TTTYG, so you probably just don't like Pete's lyrics if you hate FUCT and IOH.

And to the girl with the signature: if you have bright colors and chat speek in your signature, DO NOT point it out unless you want to be ridiculed. I figured I should warn you

[nfggc10]

Well if it helps, Patrick wrote a lot of the lyrics for TTTYG, so you probably just don't like Pete's lyrics if you hate FUCT and IOH.

He's awful. I used to think he was somewhat clever and then I realized that he just rips off his style from American Nightmare. On top of that he writes the most impersonal lyrics that I can think of. Every line follows the same basic formula: I/he/she/we are (verb) (adjective) (noun that is totally unrelated to the adjective yet most 15 year olds will find clever and search for some deeper meaning when there isn't one)

If anyone says they relate to IOH as a whole or that it changes their life then they're liars and will only solidify their teenie bopper status.

[Talib Scottie]

If your favorite song by TBS is on Louder Now, your opinion is null and void.

[nfggc10]

If your favorite song by TBS is on Louder Now, your opinion is null and void.and I will add WYWTB to that statement as well

[Talib Scottie]

and I will add WYWTB to that statement as well

I'd be okay with someone saying Slowdance on the Inside or the Your Own Disaster Alternate version.

However, if they say Photograph is Proof, GTFO

[fallout1819]

I went with TTTYG but I'm starting to think I should have went with TAYF..

[nfggc10]

I'd be okay with someone saying Slowdance on the Inside or the Your Own Disaster Alternate version.

However, if they say Photograph is Proof, GTFODespite a couple of the horrendous songs that are on Louder Now, I would have to say Photograph is the worst song they've ever written.

[Talib Scottie]

Despite a couple of the horrendous songs that are on Louder Now, I would have to say Photograph is the worst song they've ever written.

I don't know what it is about that song, but since I heard it on the Spider Man CD, I've hated it. I actually think I like every song on the CD but that one.

[MIKEY_HORROR]

what is everyones fav. song on Tell All Your Friends ( i was gonna make a poll..but there has been to many pointless polls as of late)

when it comes listening on cd mine is "Ghost Man on Third"

but my fav. live/sing along song is "No "I" In Team"

[thejetstolehome]

Despite a couple of the horrendous songs that are on Louder Now, I would have to say Photograph is the worst song they've ever written.

that's what i said when it first came out.

[nfggc10]

that's what i said when it first came out.I'm still amazed that they didn't notice in the studio how annoying it is to hear "i know you know" repeated 1000 times within a 4 minute time span.

[thejetstolehome]

I'm still amazed that they didn't notice in the studio how annoying it is to hear "i know you know" repeated 1000 times within a 4 minute time span.

haha, i remember talking about it in class with 2 girls who didn't really know TBS that well and said how great the song was and i chimed in "actually, it's probably the worst song they've ever written. ever." and they got all mad at me and what not, it was funny.

[nfggc10]

haha, i remember talking about it in class with 2 girls who didn't really know TBS that well and said how great the song was and i chimed in "actually, it's probably the worst song they've ever written. ever." and they got all mad at me and what not, it was funny.I still remember hearing that song for the first time, not sure if it was before or after decade was radio ripped, but I was so disappointed. I couldn't believe, even with John and Shaun leaving, that they could regress that much lyrically and songwriting wise. The rest of that cd is just okay though and I can't remember the last time I listened to it all the way through. Slowdance is easily the best song on it (not including the re-recorded YOD obviously).

[thejetstolehome]

I still remember hearing that song for the first time, not sure if it was before or after decade was radio ripped, but I was so disappointed. I couldn't believe, even with John and Shaun leaving, that they could regress that much lyrically and songwriting wise. The rest of that cd is just okay though and I can't remember the last time I listened to it all the way through. Slowdance is easily the best song on it (not including the re-recorded YOD obviously).

agree on everything--even though i still haven't heard the re-recorded YOD. i loved the old version, though.

[MIKEY_HORROR]

the first time i heard the song i was with a ton of friends, and couldnt really hear the words.. and i didnt think it was too bad.. i was kind of excited

after everyone left i listened again and was so dissapointed, losing Nolan was a huge loss(lyrically and vocally)... both of the newer albums have a couple decent songs on them.. but TAYF did not have one weak track imo... i miss those days

[nfggc10]

agree on everything--even though i still haven't heard the re-recorded YOD. i loved the old version, though.i actually prefer it to the acoustic version which is weird for me.

the first time i heard the song i was with a ton of friends, and couldnt really hear the words.. and i didnt think it was too bad.. i was kind of excited

after everyone left i listened again and was so dissapointed, losing Nolan was a huge loss(lyrically and vocally)... both of the newer albums have a couple decent songs on them.. but TAYF did not have one weak track imo... i miss those daysTheir biggest problem is that they keep re-using the same formula from TAYF for every song they write. As long as they do that, everything will be inferior to that record and they'll never gain new fans and will continue to lose long time fans. You can only put out the same record so many times before people stop listening.

[Talib Scottie]

I just think it's lame. No real reason. It's boring and with an annoying chorus. Even the hard part lacks something

[mybreakingpoint]

"one-eighty by summer"= amazing song

best on WYWTB by far.

"why can't you just be happy? why can't you just be happy?"

"you siad "live up to your first impression", well my best side was your worst invention"

i could relate to that song like no other when it came out.

not TAYF but, bpeople were talking about WYWTB so, i thought i'd chip in hah.

and i said "dong". big deal. get over it, children. :-)

[mybreakingpoint]

Pop-punk by definition cannot be amazing.

i disagree only to the point of saying: Saves The Day. "Stay What You Are" and "Through Being Cool" are both "amazing" pop-punk albums, imo. haha

[OveriseFan]

YES!

I made it a 2:1 ratio exactly.

[mybreakingpoint]

hahahaha ilu

[chokeychicken]

can this thread please be closed? its not even a reasonable poll anymore. its clear that the "older' generation wins.

[TAYF152]

well slowdance is the best song o WYWTB, but the problem with the album is the lack of creativity with the lyrics and the watered down crap they made when nolan left. sure, the songs are catchy and seem fun at first but three listens in you realize the void of not having nolan in the band. i dont hate the cd's but in terms of life changing, TAYF friends will never be topped again. I think they should beg nolan to come back and throw out that loser fred who seems nice but in reality you can tell he screams in front of the mirror while changing his hair styles to try and fit in to the appropriate scene. its pathetic

[mybreakingpoint]

so sick so sick of being tired

[chronomic]

can this thread please be closed? its not even a reasonable poll anymore. its clear that the "older' generation wins.

amen. im about to commit some murder on about 50 people

[.anarkhy]

so sick so sick of being tired

and all so tired of being sick.


so good at setting bad examples.

[jfb392]

TAYF even thought the ringing throughout the album pisses me off.

[chronomic]

TAYF even thought the ringing throughout the album pisses me off.

ive heard about that but i refuse to try and look for it because then i will notice it all the time and then piss me off as it does you



run-on sentences ftw

[CountMeOut923]

damn this is actually a tough choice, both albums are amazing. but in the end TAYF is the winner.

[CountMeOut923]

I set up a poll for fav. song off TAYF, lets get that one going!

[ockotacoman]

jerseys best dancers

[Take Heart]

"one-eighty by summer"= amazing song

best on WYWTB by far.

"why can't you just be happy? why can't you just be happy?"

"you siad "live up to your first impression", well my best side was your worst invention"

i could relate to that song like no other when it came out.

not TAYF but, bpeople were talking about WYWTB so, i thought i'd chip in hah.

and i said "dong". big deal. get over it, children. :-)


Correct on all counts. one eighty by summer blows away everything else on WYWTB

[rcrook]

so sick so sick of being tired


whenever i hear the beginning of this song i get this weird feeling inside me because i know that im gonna listen to the best 45 minutes of music

[chronomic]

sometime at night i pray to jesus that noan never left tbs and it has all been just a big dream.

[Take Heart]

It really is a shame. One can only imagine what TBS would have evolved into, and instead we're left with two decent bands instead of one incredible one.

[chronomic]

yeah...i mean i really like SLR, but i would chose the original tbs over them anyday

[RomeoAGoGo]

TTTYG got pwnd.

Nice.

[Take Heart]

Didn't get pwnd nearly as bad as it should have. If you go through the TTTYG votes and remove the female <16 yr old votes, you come up with something more like 92% TAYF.

[chronomic]

Didn't get pwnd nearly as bad as it should have. If you go through the TTTYG votes and remove the female <16 yr old votes, you come up with something more like 92% TAYF.

music makes me look down on people. this poll is an example of that. hahah

[Take Heart]

music makes me look down on people. this poll is an example of that. hahah

Ditto. This poll is a GREAT benchmark for people's musical taste.

[mybreakingpoint]

Correct on all counts. one eighty by summer blows away everything else on WYWTB

:-D

[Take Heart]

:-D

On an unrelated note, someone needs to make a smiley that resembles your avatar. Like now.

[CountMeOut923]

It really is a shame. One can only imagine what TBS would have evolved into, and instead we're left with two decent bands instead of one incredible one.

i couldn't agree more. i think tbs would've remained one of the biggest bands in the scene and stayed consistently that way. i dont know what the hell they are doing now, but it certainly isnt what it could've been

[bobby runs]

haha most likely

I question anyone who actually picks TTTYG over TAYF..


and i question why you have gc in your name next to nfg? seriously good charlotte????? come one.



I think the lyrics in TAYF are way better than TTTYG.

first off your moms better.
second pete was already writing hit lyrics back then and knew how to write songs, where tbs just wrote relatable songs but didnt really know how to write a song.



This is how I sum it up.

Adam and John can sing.

Patrick and Pete, not so much.


your soooooo wrong

adam cant sing for shit


patrick is now able to sing his fucking lungs out.







i chose tttyg because i feel that anyone whpo chooses that album likes their music with a little pop. i have and always will be a pop kid, no matter what band im listening to that week. so i guess the people in here dont like their music with much pop. so yeah cal me dumb or anything but hey fuck you.


and if we are going to throw in other albums i say new found glory's s/t blows every single fucking pop-punk album released in the new millenium.

[chokeychicken]

Tell All Your Friends still gets me hyped. It never gets old.

whenever i hear that first riff, i always go nuts. no matter where i am.

[chronomic]

hey i like this thread. cept for all the rees that picked tttyg

[Take Heart]

hey i like this thread. cept for all the rees that picked tttyg

hahah yeah. The thread would have been better if the poll read:

TAYF or TAYF

[Talib Scottie]

Haha, I know someone did not just attack the one single area that Fall Out Boy actually passes TBS, and that's lead vocals. Patrick can fucking sing.

However, Adam sounding like complete shit is a plus for this record.

[Take Heart]

Haha, I know someone did not just attack the one single area that Fall Out Boy actually passes TBS, and that's lead vocals. Patrick can fucking sing.

However, Adam sounding like complete shit is a plus for this record.

Adam sounds great on TBS albums, he just can't sing for shit live, but I wouldn't disagree that Patrick's vocals surpass Adam's either way

[Adeniz19]

i chose tttyg because i feel that anyone whpo chooses that album likes their music with a little pop. i have and always will be a pop kid, no matter what band im listening to that week. so i guess the people in here dont like their music with much pop. so yeah cal me dumb or anything but hey fuck you.


and if we are going to throw in other albums i say new found glory's s/t blows every single fucking pop-punk album released in the new millenium.TAYF is pop. it might not be as straight forward as TTYG but it's catchy as shit