Dookie - Enema Of the State

[Scottt]

So there's the ''Green Day Blink 182'' thread, but people seem to have gone off Green Day because of American idiot, so, just out of these two albums, which is better?
If you hate American Idiot, just pretend it doesn't exsist, and think of the old Green Day.

[MIKEY_HORROR]

Dookie by far

[meliisssaaaa]

dookie!

[IATA4224]

ummm how many more blink/gd comparisons we going to have

[falloutboy.]

dookie started it all for me.

[Cheshire_Buddha]

Dookie > Enema of the State

...but in my opinion

Dude Ranch > Dookie

[ojgio]

This was tough.

[SeanEBoy2686]

tough... but enema of the state got me into the music i listen to just b/c of when it was released... i didnt here of dookie until after than (both are solid though)

[ihatecayte]

dookie. by far.

[thatwasamoment]

Enema started it off for me, but I was only 9 and it had a huge impact on me.

I suppose for the older folks, Dookie would have that effect on them.

[josiahh]

dookie should win this hands down.

[secretsociety92]

dookie should win this hands down.
Yes it should because it is a really good album.

[FallOutBoyIsGod]

dookie just because its a cd named after a slang term for poo. i mean, seriously, it doesnt get much more fabulous then that. :-D

[Smash Adams]

dookie just because its a cd named after a slang term for poo. i mean, seriously, it doesnt get much more fabulous then that. :-D
do u know what an enema is?
I voted for dookie btw

[loganmmm]

ummm how many more blink/gd comparisons we going to have

Not nearly as many comparisons as we've been having between Taking Back Sunday and Brand New.

[Scottt]

dookie just because its a cd named after a slang term for poo. i mean, seriously, it doesnt get much more fabulous then that. :-D

You're supposed to pick one of them for the music, fool.

[DRUMMERGIRL121]

i went with dookie
its one of my all time favorite albums

[TeenageMustache]

dookie. no question about it.

[smelltheglove]

Dookie got me into punk music. It came out when I was 14, probably the ideal age to be when it came out, I assume it was the same for everyone who was 14 when Enema came out. I was 19 when Enema came out, and while I loved the shit out of it, it didn't have nearly the impact or the historic significance that Dookie had and has on me and in regards to how I got into this genre.

[FreshyFresh23]

This is not really a fair comparison. Enema came out when Warning came out for Green Day. Enema is MUCH better than Warning.

Dude Ranch is more comparable to Dookie and Dude Ranch wins. This is really pretty arbitrary

[ashesofapril234]

I love love love Dookie, it was one of the first albums I ever really listened to.

[rickmo]

dookie is for the kids who were listening since the begining

[pinklipgloss]

Never listened to green day all my life.

[jetsto]

Never listened to green day all my life.
your missing out

[Alex Djaferis]

dookie

but this is totally depending on how old you are. i dont expect anyone younger then 20 to pick dookie.

[Thug_Nasty]

enema got me into music. its a great poppy album that you can listen through from start to finish and like every song you hear.

[Branevember31]

shit...i hit the wrong one


Dookie by miles and miles

[Branevember31]

dookie

but this is totally depending on how old you are. i dont expect anyone younger then 20 to pick dookie.


:wave:

[ihatecayte]

109 - 70: enema ftw... currently

seriously?
what the fuck?
that makes me cringe a little

[fenderkid212]

I voted for dookie, but enema was a big influence on me when i was younger.

[JulieLynn]

Dookie. No doubt about it.

although I love Blink

[burnout86]

both were breakthrough albums for their time.

but dookie pwns

[bankrom]

dude ranch

[ESundy36]

Dookie.

[IPS Josh]

Dookie > Enema of the State

...but in my opinion

Dude Ranch > Dookie

My thoughts exactly.

[TheOtherAndrew]

If everyone's saying Dookie, why is Enema winning by so much?
I vote Enema because it was literally the first CD I ever bought and the CD that got me into music in the first place. I do think Dookie is very good though.

[loveisdead]

dookie

but this is totally depending on how old you are. i dont expect anyone younger then 20 to pick dookie.
i'm 19 and picked dookie...i had that little blue tape since i was like 7...they're the reason i started listening to the music i listed to but enema is what got me passionate about music. it was really hard to pick but i gave it to dookie cause i remember playing ken griffey junior baseball for super nintendo while having that on in the background.

[.Jase.]

Um Enema of the State.

Sheesh.

[TSLROCKS]

no question blink hands down 1 of the greatest cds ever

[JWS1986]

Enema... because i hate green day.

[SynesthesiaX]

Nothing can beat Blink 182, even that plus 44 and angels and speedways or whatever stuff they made up.

[suchatragedyx]

Haha. That's hardly fair.
Green day to Blink?
Dookie.

[noelle34]

i like them both

[peacelovemusic]

Billie Joe is not only hot, but an awesome singer/songwriter/guitarist. Not a single drummer from the last two decades could stand up to Tre Cool, and Mike Dirnt, he's good... Well, Dookie over Enema. Blink-182 never quite suited me.

[whiteboypain]

Dookie.

[TonightInFlames]

I love them both.
But blink changed my life :]

[bagdad]

yeah i guess it depeds how old you were when each came out...i was in 6th grade when dookie came out and that helped progress getting me into "punk"...but i still remember skipping school in 11th grade to get enema the morning it came out, and being utterly dissapointed the first time through it, but the second time i loved it...but neither of these albums compare to the greatness or influence of punk in drublic in my opinion...

[berky11]

Dookie

plus, All The Small Things suck