PDA

View Full Version : Piebald - Accidental Gentlemen


Tony Pascarella
02/07/07, 06:27 PM
Piebald - Accidental Gentlemen
Release Date: January 23, 2007
Record Label: SideOneDummy

Piebald's Accidental Gentlemen is a lesson in social consciousness and certainly a crash course in Travis Shettel's sardonic wit. The band's fifth album has a little something for everyone, with plenty of focus on the piano-pop sound that they have been playing for more than ten years.

"Don't Tell Me Nothing" is a strong track on the first part of the album that will surely draw in fans of Ben Folds, despite the lack of piano. If you're not getting enough of the keyboards, be sure to flip back one track to "A Friend of Mine," which could have been ripped straight from Rockin' the Suburbs. Following the swift kick in the ass from "Don't Tell Me Nothing," is the aggressive "There's Always Something Better to Do." While searching for standouts on Accidental Gentlemen, don't forget the acerbic "Nature Wins," which combines slicing dual guitar riffs and a fierier Piebald than we expected on this CD. The instrument parts are well orchestrated and provide plenty of diversity to the 13 songs on this disc. The vocals are bland overall, however, and that diminishes some of the replay value in the long run.

One of the mildly irritating things for some fans will be the analog tape on which Piebald recorded most of this album. While Alex Newport (At the Drive-In) mixed the music, the raw sound can end up a bit crusty at times. It certainly leaves one wondering what might happen if the band cleaned up their sound and added some gloss to it, as well as fleshing out the richness of the sound. What really sticks in your mind after listening to Accidental Gentlemen a few dozen times is…nothing substantial. The lasting value of the album seems very hit or miss. Aside from a few clever lines or a catchy hook, Accidental Gentlemen simply isn't as memorable as it tries to be. The album is one step forward and one step back, leaving listeners no better or no worse off. If you already like Piebald, add this one to your collection, but it may not pique the interest of too many new fans unless they sit at home mourning the demise of Troubled Hubble.

Buy Piebald's Accidental Gentlemen on iTunes (http://click.linksynergy.com/fs-bin/stat?id=PjIvm57kicI&offerid=78941&type=3&subid=0&tmpid=1826&RD_PARM1=http%253A%252F%252Fphobos. apple.com%252FWebObjects%252FMZStor e.woa%252Fwa%252FviewAlbum%253Fi%25 3D206313144%2526id%253D206313138%25 26s%253D143441%2526partnerId%253D30 )

1. Opener
2. A Friend of Mine
3. Don't Tell Me Nothing
4. There's Always Something Better to Do
5. Strangers
6. Oh, the Congestion
7. Shark Attack
8. On and On
9. Getting Mugged and Loving It
10. Life on the Farm
11. Nature Wins
12. Roll On
13. We Cannot Read PoetryAP.net Profile (http://www.absolutepunk.net/piebald) | Myspace (http://www.myspace.com/piebald) | Official Site (http://www.piebald.com)

Blake Solomon
02/07/07, 08:24 PM
your first line is great, im kind of surprised at the score though. cheers.

Steve Henderson
02/07/07, 09:15 PM
This is a Russ-size review :P

Nowisnotthetime
02/07/07, 09:56 PM
I wish Piebald wouldn't put out these average releases they have done recently. They lost steam after the "American Heart" (UHOH am I allowed to say that on this site? haha) era and haven't been able to put out anything catchy since. I agree with this review and it's actually hard to write anything lengthy about a review that just doesn't grab you too much in any way.

Darren McLeod
02/07/07, 10:21 PM
i enjoyed the raw production.

declanmcmanus
02/07/07, 10:43 PM
Piebald is about putting out records that they like regardless of what people think. That's what I love about them. The fact that the record isn't "polished" makes it that much more true to who they are. And that you say the "mildly irritating thing" is that they recorded on analog tape is hilarious! If they wanted everyone to like them they would put out a mediocre record every year. But, they don't! They put out records when they want. That too me is the calling card of valid, respected artists like Piebald.

Chris Fallon
02/07/07, 11:41 PM
A little surprised at the score, but I know the score doesn't always reflect the reviewer's feelings to their fullest.

With that said, I highly enjoy Piebald, and love their sound on each album they have released. I especially like the organic sound they have production-wise, which is ironic, considering what the band does with an environmentally-conscious mindset.

garlicgirl1210
02/08/07, 12:02 AM
nature wins is pretty awesome.
honestly, i wasn't wow-ed by the album but i do like it because i do love piebald.

Co and Ca
02/08/07, 01:15 AM
I need to pick this up.

roxy
02/08/07, 04:21 AM
I don't have to comment for you to know what I'm thinking Tony. :-(

Tony Pascarella
02/08/07, 05:18 AM
Piebald is about putting out records that they like regardless of what people think. That's what I love about them. The fact that the record isn't "polished" makes it that much more true to who they are. And that you say the "mildly irritating thing" is that they recorded on analog tape is hilarious! If they wanted everyone to like them they would put out a mediocre record every year. But, they don't! They put out records when they want. That too me is the calling card of valid, respected artists like Piebald.And I said at the end, if you like them, you will probably dig it, but people that don't/haven't heard them may not be impressed enough to give it a chance.

A little surprised at the score, but I know the score doesn't always reflect the reviewer's feelings to their fullest.

With that said, I highly enjoy Piebald, and love their sound on each album they have released. I especially like the organic sound they have production-wise, which is ironic, considering what the band does with an environmentally-conscious mindset.I like the album; I just feel like it could grab me more. It's good background music and there's a couple of songs I repeat more often, but it isn't as awesome as the lyrics/songwriting might suggest (in my opinion).

RiskyXBandit
02/08/07, 05:23 AM
it's piebald.
i love it.

they will never top the anthem that We Are th Only Friends That We Have gave out.
just like how HRC will never top Sorry About Tomorrow.

but i love the band, so i will continue to support.
i think the album is very laid back, just like all ears all eyes all the time, but just a little more laid back.
i enjoy it, but i do agree, if this was the first record i ever heard by them, i wouldn't be all that impressed, but i would probably still buy the album due to the difference in the style of music they put out compared to a lot of other bands.

Tom Good
02/08/07, 06:36 AM
Great review Tony, I felt the same way when I heard this. Short and to the point.

iLIVE4theMUSIC
02/08/07, 07:48 AM
saying piebald isnt good is like saying pete wentz isnt dreamy.

Steve Henderson
02/08/07, 08:42 AM
saying piebald isnt good is like saying pete wentz isnt dreamy.
Oh lord.

The Fix
02/08/07, 09:09 AM
+10 points for the Troubled Hubble reference

roxy
02/08/07, 09:23 AM
saying piebald isnt good is like saying pete wentz isnt dreamy.

haha, ilu

AdamTheGreat
02/08/07, 09:32 AM
I like old piebald better.

heyguy
02/08/07, 01:29 PM
piebald IS still a great band, but they haven't put out anything that will top venetian blinds yet... those were the days

Waitingtofall4
02/08/07, 01:31 PM
I like old piebald better.
Same here. This isn't horrible, they've just had better.

iLIVE4theMUSIC
02/08/07, 02:17 PM
saying piebald's new album isnt great is like saying cheez wiz wasnt the greatest invention EVER.

iLIVE4theMUSIC
02/08/07, 02:19 PM
...everytime you say piebald's new album isn't great god kills a small hampster.


think of the hampsters.

fullerm
02/08/07, 05:28 PM
this bands underrated-ness goes right up there with hey mercedes

mylastnerv
02/08/07, 06:30 PM
"new fans unless they sit at home mourning the demise of Troubled Hubble."

Nice one.

jeffctown
02/08/07, 08:24 PM
alex newport is the shit. he recorded spiritworld.

Mike Oxmall
02/10/07, 11:35 AM
Is soo underrated. Oh well. This album is really good.

Holly HoX!
03/31/09, 11:22 AM
We're the only friends we have. Best album by far. One of the best albums i own.