Infinity On High vs. The Black Parade

[Emotional-Punk]

Fall Out Boy and My Chemical Romance are two bands that are up there on my list of fav.s, but as far as their new CDs go Fall Out Boy did a lot better job in my opinion. The Black Parade is cool because it has a consistant theme and there are some good lyrics as exspected... Garard's voice even sounds better. But is the band just growing or are they selling out? They sound wayy different. Fall Out Boy's is better in my opinion because even though the subject matter of the songs changed and there is less screaming it's more Fall Out Boy. It's destinct that they aren't selling out , but just growing up. I think that's the determining factor in which was a better accomplishment by the band.
Maybe I'm wrong. What do you think?

[scream4me]

IOH>TBP by a lot

[Brokenhill]

Theres already a thread and poll on this...but I would say TheParade

[sputniksignals]

I would say neither, because I don't like either. Jump on my nuts right now, go ahead, I dare you

[rosieh93]

they are both amazing musically and i really liek both bands but id hav to say the black parade.... i have both whole albums and i dont skip any songs on the black parade and i find myself skipping a few on ioh so yea.

and yea., there was a thread liek this b4

[rosieh93]

I would say neither, because I don't like either. Jump on my nuts right now, go ahead, I dare you

haha. i admire your truthflness.. so i decline yor dare and i spare your nuts

[Emotional-Punk]

Sorry, I'm new.

[sputniksignals]

Sorry, I'm new.
I was aware of this by your post count and your join date. But then again, one can never go off of that

[rosieh93]

yea well im new too.. on this account.. hehe
my (idiot) friend deleted my old one :(

take that as a lesson.. dont tell you password to ANYONE.. and know as many as possible

[Emotional-Punk]

I was aware of this by your post count and your join date. But then again, one can never go off of that
Heh... Didn't see that. =P Shows how observant I am.

[walking_person]

yea well im new too.. on this account.. hehe
my (idiot) friend deleted my old one :(

take that as a lesson.. dont tell you password to ANYONE.. and know as many as possible

all of my friends have no interest in this site.

[Just An End]

you're a sellout

[rosieh93]

all of my friends have no interest in this site.

ok..cool

[MIKEY_HORROR]

yea well im new too.. on this account.. hehe
my (idiot) friend deleted my old one :(

take that as a lesson.. dont tell you password to ANYONE.. and know as many as possible


i dont hink you can delete accounts?....so what the hell are you talking about....

but if you can then...ok..pretend i didnt say that last comment

[tcemoo]

I think The Black Parade is better... simply because MCR showed that their band is more than what they've shown on past efforts. They really expanded their horizons and really brought the rock.

Fall Out Boy's new disc... while great, doesn't show the same maturing that MCR's did. It's the same sound I was expecting from Fall Out Boy. It did expand on what they had brought to the table previously, but I just feel that MCR evolved a lot more than FOB did in this effort.

Both discs, however, own the pants off their predecessor. I won't say the same about IOH vs TTTYG, but TBP is easily the best MCR record to date.

[Emotional-Punk]

I think The Black Parade is better... simply because MCR showed that their band is more than what they've shown on past efforts. They really expanded their horizons and really brought the rock.

Fall Out Boy's new disc... while great, doesn't show the same maturing that MCR's did. It's the same sound I was expecting from Fall Out Boy. It did expand on what they had brought to the table previously, but I just feel that MCR evolved a lot more than FOB did in this effort.

Both discs, however, own the pants off their predecessor. I won't say the same about IOH vs TTTYG, but TBP is easily the best MCR record to date.

I actually loved Three Cheers For Sweet Revenge. I like it better than The Black Parade and I could listen to it again and again. I won't say that TCFSR is that much better, but there's something about it...

[rosieh93]

i dont hink you can delete accounts?....so what the hell are you talking about....

but if you can then...ok..pretend i didnt say that last comment

i dont know but whatever she did she fucked it up and i dont know what or where it is.. i miss it :(

[DesiDitz2525]

Infinity on High! (I'm not biased at all) :-|

[Matthew Tsai]

ok, fall out boy's record was better, but screaming makes good pop punk/screamo, so your points aren't valid because you don't like screaming.

[Emotional-Punk]

ok, fall out boy's record was better, but screaming makes good pop punk/screamo, so your points aren't valid because you don't like screaming.

I like screaming...

[colette]

I agree completely. Well, my opinion may not be as fair anyways, simply because FOB has always been number 1 for me, while MCR has stayed lower on my favs list.
But I still agree. I got both their CDs at the same time, and I swear I listen to the new FOB atleast three times a day. But I get bored with the MCR faster.
And I really can't say MCR has evolved more. I actually think FOB did. Plus its cool that their new populairity and publication hasn't really gotten to them like it has to MCR. MCR has become more and more about the image, in my opinion.

so... IOH>TBP

[bobby runs]

Fall Out Boy and My Chemical Romance are two bands that are up there on my list of fav.s, but as far as their new CDs go Fall Out Boy did a lot better job in my opinion. The Black Parade is cool because it has a consistant theme and there are some good lyrics as exspected... Garard's voice even sounds better. But is the band just growing or are they selling out? They sound wayy different. Fall Out Boy's is better in my opinion because even though the subject matter of the songs changed and there is less screaming it's more Fall Out Boy. It's destinct that they aren't selling out , but just growing up. I think that's the determining factor in which was a better accomplishment by the band.
Maybe I'm wrong. What do you think?


i agree with what you're saying but switch the bands around. ioh sounds like fall out boy selling out and sounding shitty at that. and tbp is my chem making great music.

[Tyler Revolution]

Are you fucking kidding me?

[jorn444]

i agree with what you're saying but switch the bands around. ioh sounds like fall out boy selling out and sounding shitty at that. and tbp is my chem making great music.
haha... no.

[The Revisionist]

So... when you sound different than you used to, you sold out?

Man, it's a good thing you're sort of cute, because you are dumb dumb dumb.

[takeweakme]

So... when you sound different than you used to, you sold out?

Man, it's a good thing you're sort of cute, because you are dumb dumb dumb.

yeah, a band improving their sound is totally selling out. i mean, who wants to here them get better?

[This-Is-The-End]

They are both shit.....
Compare them with their earlier stuff
RAWR

DAAAAA

[takeweakme]

mcr's first disc is terrible, imo.
they're definately growing each release.

[simplyme]

IOH, but mostly because I love FOB and MCR is rather boring for me.

[JulieLynn]

IOH.

I'm not too impressed with new MCR...I miss old MCR.

[sputniksignals]

yeah, a band improving their sound is totally selling out. i mean, who wants to here them get better?

Exactly the point I was going to make after reading this comments. God forbid a band evolves and tries something different. We need the same formulaic music album after album after album after all dont we?

[acusticbabe]

IOH definately. BP was just okay. i also am not a big fan of MCR. they're a little too.......intense(i'll be nice).:badmood: no offense to anyone who likes them.

[Iris.]

I don't really feel the evolution or maturing from FOB. If someone were to pick songs from various FOB albums, I would not be able to tell you which came from which album from the style, because IMO all of their albums sound the same.

MCR, on the other hand, has provided some interesting twists and suprises with each album. They have gotten better through time, though, again IMO, TCFSR beats TBP by a slight margin.

*sigh* Opinions, opinions..

[sputniksignals]

I don't really feel the evolution or maturing from FOB. If someone were to pick songs from various FOB albums, I would not be able to tell you which came from which album from the style, because IMO all of their albums sound the same.

MCR, on the other hand, has provided some interesting twists and suprises with each album. They have gotten better through time, though, again IMO, TCFSR beats TBP by a slight margin.

*sigh* Opinions, opinions..

I thought (I could be wrong because I haven't even heard the whole cd and I dont plan on it) that the new FOB cd was really varied and different especially with the songs I have heard so I would assume you could tell which ones were at least from the new one

[black rose]

I don't really feel the evolution or maturing from FOB. If someone were to pick songs from various FOB albums, I would not be able to tell you which came from which album from the style, because IMO all of their albums sound the same.

MCR, on the other hand, has provided some interesting twists and suprises with each album. They have gotten better through time, though, again IMO, TCFSR beats TBP by a slight margin.

*sigh* Opinions, opinions..No evolution from Fall Out Boy? Seriously? Listen to EOWYG and then IOH, and get back to me. There is a world of a difference there. Pete's lyrics [go up and down] but Patrick's vocals are worlds apart, they've gotten so much better over the years. The sound, also, is totally different. Listen to TTTYG and than IOH, and tell me you can't tell a difference in sound.

[black rose]

I thought (I could be wrong because I haven't even heard the whole cd and I dont plan on it) that the new FOB cd was really varied and different especially with the songs I have heard so I would assume you could tell which ones were at least from the new oneYou should atleast give IOH a full listen. It does deserve that much.

[sputniksignals]

You should atleast give IOH a full listen. It does deserve that much.

I'm sure it doesn't

[black rose]

I'm sure it doesn'tI'm sure you're wrong. Even the worst of albums [which isn't IOH by far] deserve a full listen to respect what it has to offer.

[sputniksignals]

I'm sure you're wrong. Even the worst of albums [which isn't IOH by far] deserve a full listen to respect what it has to offer.

I'm pretty sure I'm right about you being wrong about me being wrong because I'm definitely right.

[black rose]

I'm pretty sure I'm right about you being wrong about me being wrong because I'm definitely right.Whatever.:rolleyes:

[Brokenhill]

your gunna let sputnik win like that?

Dont give up without a fight !

[sputniksignals]

your gunna let sputnik win like that?

Dont give up without a fight !

There's no need to fight because I win.

[Brokenhill]

Haha, yea I know.

I dislike FOB, exept a few tracks off of Take This To your Grave

[black rose]

your gunna let sputnik win like that?

Dont give up without a fight !It's pointless.

[sputniksignals]

It's pointless.

More futile on your behalf. There are plenty more talented and better bands out there then MCR or FOB that deserve more publicity, you just need to know where to look.

[black rose]

More futile on your behalf. There are plenty more talented and better bands out there then MCR or FOB that deserve more publicity, you just need to know where to look.I don't even like MCR that much. Anyways, there are many other talented bands, yes I know, thanks. But that doesn't mean I can't love IOH or Fall Out Boy in general.