The constant debate between my friends...

[kbauer]

Cake or Pie?

Mind you Im not considering brownies or cookies as cake.

Cheesecake counts as cake as well as cupcakes due to the cake namesake, Ice cream cake dosent count though because its just ice cream in cake form.
Vote wisely.

[simplyme]

Pie. Fo' Sho'

[chiodos13]

cake, but only if its ice cream cake... other than that pie would have to take this one

[polock]

put candles in a cake its a birthday cake, put candles in a pie someones drunk in the kitchen, and u never here about a hot chick jumpin out of a pie

[JustAnotherPoet]

both. eating is a favorite past time of mine

[kbauer]

put candles in a cake its a birthday cake, put candles in a pie someones drunk in the kitchen, and u never here about a hot chick jumpin out of a pie


lol good points but that dosent pretain to witch taste better.

[the sob]

put candles in a cake its a birthday cake, put candles in a pie someones drunk in the kitchen, and u never here about a hot chick jumpin out of a pie



ahahhahahahahahahahahah.

[halifaxonfire]

PIE. Hands down.

[Burning Star IV]

no question it's cake. unless it's key lime pie, which defeats all forms of cake.

[trindaddy]

some pie with ice cream, as long as that counts. Nothing like hot apple pie with a scoop o vanilla on top.

not to mention i hate icing and frosting. so dor the most part i dont like cake

[omgjames]

always cake, unless its a really good apple pie, with cinamin-y apples that are still sweet and a good crust... then pie. but i voted cake

[thatwasamoment]

punch and pie

[loganmmm]

I went with cake because I consume it more than pie.
Cake = Birthdays, anniversaries, graduations, weddings, ect.
Pie = Thanksgiving.

[MIKEY_HORROR]

CHEESECAKE is my fav.... but i consider it Pie...although cake is in the name..haha

[kbauer]

some pie with ice cream, as long as that counts. Nothing like hot apple pie with a scoop o vanilla on top.

not to mention i hate icing and frosting. so dor the most part i dont like cake


Pie with ice cream does definately count, to me adding ice cream is like adding frosting to cake.

I like pie better because its good on its own frosting just make it better, cake has the frosting crutch and it gets dry too...hmmm...pie stays fesh for a dosent dry out or get all crumbley.


COME ON PIE PEOPLE VOTE!!!!!

[polock]

pie can be nice and warm though

[whiteboypain]

Pie. It seems more satisfying.

[trindaddy]

we'll just tell your mother that uhh we ate it all

[Jase.]

My mum's apricot cheesecake = :-0 .

[katcherbball]

cake, but ice cream is my favorite.

[noodledancer]

cupcakes > mini tarts

[Alex DiVincenzo]

It really depends on the type of each, but in general I'd say pie.

[.Dylan]

What the hell is going on!? Obviously pie kicks all sorts of ass.

[Brokenhill]

Pies gross...I dont want no apples or peaches.

Gimme some chocolate cake. With Fudge Icing. With a chocoloate milk on the side.

;-)

[kbauer]

Pies gross...I dont want no apples or peaches.

Gimme some chocolate cake. With Fudge Icing. With a chocoloate milk on the side.

;-)


haha healthy, but its desert food, we know its not meant to be healthy.

[ryanh12]

there are so many factors that are invovled.....i dont know

[heartsynapse]

Funfetti Cake, seriously.

[kbauer]

there are so many factors that are invovled.....i dont know

My thinking was imagine Thanksgiving pie up against birthday cake. But think, even though that pie would taste better with ice cream, it does taste pretty good on its own but that cake needs that frosting or else it dosent taste like much.

[norarae]

cake. there just isn't a whole lot of good pie..

[tommyhaych]

and u never here about a hot chick jumpin out of a pie

She probably will be hot, but not in the conventional sense.

I was forced by gunpoint to vote pie. It's in my heritage as a resident of North England.

[Silver Bullets]

I like fruit pies. banana cream.

cake is too sweet for me.

[tonythetiger432]

Cake, for cheesecake.

[Kotz1]

Cake - especially their first album...

[gnp8472]

Cake.

for one reason: cupcakes. there is no pie that can stand up to cupcakes.

i mean, when SNL raps about Magnolia Bakery Cupcakes, you KNOW its good hahahaha.

[IanIsSuperRad]

Okay, you cannot seriously count Cheesecake as a cake. Sure, it has the word cake in the name, but think about it. When you think of cake you see a soft, spongy, sweet bread-like material with frosting on top. Whereas the characteristics of a pie is a crust filled with some kind of filling often with a kind of fruit on top. What category does cheesecake seem to fit in?

You be the judge.