Which is the better double disc?

[nicj28]

I went with In Your Honor.

[MIKEY_HORROR]

Foo Fighters... but i felt both were pretty weak compared to other releases by both bands

[falloutboy.]

foo fighters more solid than red hot.

[trindaddy]

im not a fan of foo fighters, and like rhcp much much more, so i went with them.

[guitarsmash0r]

in your honor

[Brokenhill]

Never heard either of them...exept the ones that hit the radio

[El_Jeffe]

stadium arcadium

[Asterisk]

in your honor, definitely

[animmortalsoul]

Stadium Arcadium is pretty sweet.

[tonighttonight0]

in your honor

[nerdvglc]

red hot chili peppers rocked stadium arcadium pretty hard...frankly, i am concerned for the well being of the planet because this shouln't be a close poll...

[IATA4224]

Foo Fighters, even though you could have probably put any other band and I would have voted for them.. I think this Foo Fighter disc is their weakest but its better than the Chili Peppers... Yuck!

[Plodbax]

I felt way to disapointed with Stadium Arcadium so i went with In Your Honor

[whiteboypain]

Foo Fighters

[notoaststereo]

foo fighters. dave grohl is my hero.

[IATA4224]

red hot chili peppers rocked stadium arcadium pretty hard...frankly, i am concerned for the well being of the planet because this shouln't be a close poll...


You should be more concerned about the planet when bands that do not deserve to have record deals are given them.. The Red Hot Chili Peppers have not done anything different since maybe Blood Sugar.. In fact, they are the same band that releases the same material over and over.. The three singles that they put out this year sounded the exact same.. They are a joke and its time for them to retire...

Long Live MR. Bungle, the REAL California band..

Anyway, Foo Fighters > RHCP

[C@RR!3]

Stadium Arcadium

[gnp8472]

i might get shit for this, but beyond their numerous catchy singles and the beautiful-ness that is "Californication" the album... i really dont like RHCP at all. and Stadium Arcadium is just a bunch of the stuff i don't like.

besides, In Your Honor has one of the best opening tracks EVER. seriously, that opener is beast... and i liked the dichotomy of loud/soft on the two discs... showcased Foo Fighters range.

[LifeKillsRebels]

dang this is a close poll...
i went with foo fighters

[myplasticyou]

mellon collie and the infinite sadness crushes both

[maffy]

I couldn't get through Stadium Arcadium without being overwhelmed with boredom.

So, the Foo get my vote ...but sadly, just barely.

[TheWeakest]

stadium baby, but that may be because i haven't given In Your Honor much playing time

[SungDuck88]

foo fizzle.

[petey536]

RHCP for sure

[halifaxonfire]

as much as i wanna say RHCP, i can't. Stadium Arcadium just gets boring so fast. In Your Honour isn't an awesome cd by any means either, but better than Stadium Arcadium.

[Cheshire_Buddha]

Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness...oh, fuck. It's not on there. Eh, screw both of them.

[shlepRICKY]

WTF


The Wall

Phisical Grafitti

The White Album

if you dont know who wrote them then your a disgrace

[Brokenhill]

mellon collie and the infinite sadness crushes both


Chyea.

[tragic_xxx_]

stadium arcadium.. way better... =]

[Branevember31]

Foo Fighters

[lindZ629]

Foo Fighters, but I did enjoy Stadium Arcadium

[phoenixinflames]

Melancholy and the Infinite Sadness.

[blimpcityhero11]

In Your Honor...

[Scottt]

Stadium Arcadium. I only listen to 'End Over End' and 'The Deepest Blues Are Black' on In Your Honour.

[sasalukac]

wow, my vote just made it 132:132... this is a very close poll

[halifaxonfire]

tie!