That ONE Album (Version 1.0)

[mybreakingpoint]

what's that ONE album by a band, the one you HATE compared to loving all of their other albums?

NFG's Catalyst would be mine

[nateisawesome]

Weezer - Malandroit

[bobby runs]

what's that ONE album by a band, the one you HATE compared to loving all of their other albums?

NFG's Catalyst would be mine


i second that. there are some good songs, but overalll as an album i really dislike it.

[love_american_style]

Deftones s/t

[BGP]

hot cross - fair trades and fairwells

[okc0mputer]

hot cross - fair trades and fairwells

why? its good

i bet a lot of people will say in reverie haha

[PDon11]

Incubus - Crow Left of the Murder

[PDon11]

The Flaming Lips - everything pre-soft bulletin

[mht]

any album released by Van Halen after year 1985.

[Wobbie]

i bet a lot of people will say in reverie haha
They'd be very wrong.

[ActorInThisPlay]

Yellowcard - Lights and Sounds

[ActorInThisPlay]

why? its good

i bet a lot of people will say in reverie haha
In Reverie is good...

[hailthewarrior]

Yellowcard - Lights and Sounds

yup.

[Music=Peace]

Fall Out Boy - Infinity On High

[Vicky82]

Greenday - American Idiot

[TakeLotsWithAlcohol]

Fear Before the March of Flames- Art Damage
Weezer- Make Believe and Maladroit
Blink 182-Self-titled.

[TakeLotsWithAlcohol]

Weezer - Make Believe

They had never put a foot wrong before this but what a let down.


Dude, you did listen to Maladroit, didn't you?

[Wobbie]

Weezer - Make Believe

They had never put a foot wrong before this but what a let down.
hahaha. Yeah, same for me. I even loved Maladroit.

It's ironic that the song on this album that sounds the least like Weezer, is the song i like the best though (Freak Me Out). You'd think that by me wanting an album that is like what they'd done before, i'd like the couple of songs that sound like their previous stuff, haha :shrug: But yes. Shitty album.

[Wobbie]

Dude, you did listen to Maladroit, didn't you?
Maladroit was rad. I loved it. Weezer with big(ger) solos and fucking attitude! haha.

[TakeLotsWithAlcohol]

Maladroit was rad. I loved it. Weezer with big(ger) solos and fucking attitude! haha.


The only songs I liked on it were the singles, it was weird. Usually I hate singles but Maladroit had goog singles.

[Cheshire_Buddha]

I enjoyed it, too. But compared to the other albums it's probably the weakest. I think the band themselves did a good job at covering the songs they did to a 'T', but I'm just not a fan of cover albums.

[enossel]

First, the obvious ones

Underoath - Chasing Safety
Saves the Day - In Reverie
Fall Out Boy - Infinity On High

And then these,

Coheed and Cambria - Good Apollo
Further Seems Forever - Hide Nothing
Less Than Jake - In With The Out Crowd (not counting Losers, Kings, et cetera, that shouldnt even be considered a CD)
Rage Against The Machine - Renegades
Regina Spektor - Songs (yes, I will include her. dont hate)
Rufio - The Comfort of Home
Saosin - Self Titled (OH NO HE DI-INT!)

[mybreakingpoint]

First, the obvious ones

Underoath - Chasing Safety
Saves the Day - In Reverie
Fall Out Boy - Infinity On High

And then these,

Coheed and Cambria - Good Apollo
Further Seems Forever - Hide Nothing
Less Than Jake - In With The Out Crowd (not counting Losers, Kings, et cetera, that shouldnt even be considered a CD)
Rage Against The Machine - Renegades
Regina Spektor - Songs (yes, I will include her. dont hate)
Rufio - The Comfort of Home
Saosin - Self Titled (OH NO HE DI-INT!)

haha i don't know you, but i really, really don't like you

having Hide Nothing and In Reverie on your list disgusts me.

[mybreakingpoint]

FSF "How To Start A Fire" would be another for me

I've never understood the love for this album or his voice. I think "Hide Nothing" was their best effort, and even "The Moon Is Down" kicks HTSAR's ass, imo.

[AShannon04]

I think I'm gonna have to say

Offspring- Splinter
Fall Out Boy- From Under The Cork Tree


FSF "How To Start A Fire" would be another for me

I've never understood the love for this album or his voice. I think "Hide Nothing" was their best effort, and even "The Moon Is Down" kicks HTSAR's ass, imo.

I love Hide Nothing.

[makeasound]

I'm going to third the vote for Yellowcard's Lights & Sounds"... I had been so excited for this CD, and there are only three songs that are remotely listenable on it. So, so disappointed.

Also Thrice - Vheissu. I keep going back and trying again, but I just can't get into it.

[TJ Wells]

in reverie is not only not the weakest std album, i'd make an argument that it's their best album.

[MIKEY_HORROR]

Deftones s/t


Good Call thats what i was coming in here to say..... also Pantera- reinventing the steal

[mybreakingpoint]

I love Hide Nothing.

i love you haha

[HangsLikeHeaven]

alexis' watch out & s/t shit all over crisis

[love_american_style]

Good Call thats what i was coming in here to say..... also Pantera- reinventing the steal

yeah that Pantera album blowed.

[halifaxonfire]

Oasis - Standing On The Shoulders Of Giants
New Found Glory - Catalyst
Taking Back Sunday - Louder Now
Blink 182 - s/t

[Scott Weber]

Further Seems Forever - Hide Nothing
The Ataris - Welcome the Night
Rx Bandits - And the Battle Begun
Sparta - Porcelain
Thrice - Vheissu

[weworemasks]

hands down, further seems forever - hide nothing. the record doesn't exist for me, as it's an abomination to the FSF name.

i regret the day i paid 15 dollars to see jon bunch perform songs i've loved for years and completely take a shit on them.

he was a fucking joke, and i walked out in the middle of their set, after he attempted "on legendary."

[Scott Weber]

hands down, further seems forever - hide nothing. the record doesn't exist for me, as it's an abomination to the FSF name.

i regret the day i paid 15 dollars to see jon bunch perform songs i've loved for years and completely take a shit on them.

he was a fucking joke, and i walked out in the middle of their set, after he attempted "on legendary."
Seriously. He fucking blew. He couldn't even hit half the notes that Chris or Jason did, so he'd just throw his mic into the crowd and let the kids sing it. It was totally lame.

[snakeinmyboots]

Jimmy Eat World - Static Prevails

[Scott Weber]

Jimmy Eat World - Static Prevails
You like the self-titled LP released in 1994 but you don't like Static Prevails?

[live4music]

Incubus- Light Grenades

[snakeinmyboots]

You like the self-titled LP released in 1994 but you don't like Static Prevails?

I don't think I have ever heard the LP released in 1994 to be honest. I am pretty sure I have heard most everything else. IMO Static Prevails is their weakest cd that I have/heard, I guess I will look out for that LP then.

[Scott Weber]

I don't think I have ever heard the LP released in 1994 to be honest. I am pretty sure I have heard most everything else. IMO Static Prevails is their weakest cd that I have/heard, I guess I will look out for that LP then.
It's a lot worse than Static Prevails, haha.

[snakeinmyboots]

It's a lot worse than Static Prevails, haha.

ouch ha ha, its tough to follow a Clarity anyways.

[mybreakingpoint]

haha wow. i LOVE Static Prevails, And The Battle Begun, and most of all those, Hide Nothing hahaha

but to each his own, for sure

and ya, JEW's 1994 self-titled is terrible hahah i really, really enjoy Static Prevails when i'm in the right mood for it

RXB cannot do and have not done any wrong ever, in my book

and Hide Nothing was by far my favorite FSF album. maybe just because i'm a huge Sense Field enthusiast, but, i honestly think it was their best album.

[weworemasks]

FSF "How To Start A Fire" would be another for me

I've never understood the love for this album or his voice. I think "Hide Nothing" was their best effort, and even "The Moon Is Down" kicks HTSAR's ass, imo.

what the fuck? jason gleason has the most incredible range. even if you think how to start a fire was horrible, there is no denying that man's vocal talent.

and i'm laughing at you for thinking hide nothing is their best effort. christ.

[Dirty Ernie]

The last three 311 albums.

[weworemasks]

The last three 311 albums.

hahahahaha ouch.

[altemose09]

fall out boy - eowyg

[FOBPrettyNPunk]

Weezer - Make Believe

[mybreakingpoint]

what the fuck? jason gleason has the most incredible range. even if you think how to start a fire was horrible, there is no denying that man's vocal talent.

and i'm laughing at you for thinking hide nothing is their best effort. christ.

hahaha? so funny? laugh all you want, i could care less.

i really don't care for gleason's voice; i've never been able to get into it. i couldn't begin to tell you why.

and i simply love Bunch's. always have, so that's probably where my love for Hide Nothing comes from.

great range or not, doesn't mean i'm going to like his voice. to each his own.

[duhpunk]

Sum 41- Chuck
Blink 182- Blink 182
MxPx- Let's Rock

[El_Jeffe]

Oasis - Standing On The Shoulders Of GiantsNew Found Glory - Catalyst
Taking Back Sunday - Louder Now
Blink 182 - s/t

haha random nothings: robbie williams (friend of the band at the time) upon hearing that album sent noel gallagher a funeral wreath with an attached note saying "R.I.P. heard your latest album - with deepest sympathy, robbie williams" haha

[mybreakingpoint]

i don't like anything by Oasis. period. haha

[El_Jeffe]

i don't like anything by Oasis. period. haha

even (what's the story) morning glory? haha that's one of my all-time favourite albums. 90's oasis is so good mate, i recon anyway

[mybreakingpoint]

i'll check it out just because you said so man hahaha

and i respect you more than 99% of the posters on this site

i just haven't heard anything by oasis before that i've been into

but i'll give that an album a shot

[halifaxonfire]

i'll check it out just because you said so man hahaha

and i respect you more than 99% of the posters on this site

i just haven't heard anything by oasis before that i've been into

but i'll give that an album a shot
if you like it, give Definitely Maybe a shot too man. its their debut, and one of the best debut albums ever, imo.

[kelseyleah]

i'd have to go with 'louder now.'

[El_Jeffe]

i'll check it out just because you said so man hahaha

and i respect you more than 99% of the posters on this site

i just haven't heard anything by oasis before that i've been into

but i'll give that an album a shot

oh cheers mate. you're a favourite of mine as well, even if we have differing opinions on tunes, i always enjoy your input into threads. great poster & hey if we enjoyed the same stuff, this would be one hell of a boring site haha

but ye that album i fantastic. got a lot of the well know hits like wonderwall, don't look back in anger, champange supernova etc. there's not a weak tune on it i recon

[mybreakingpoint]

oh cheers mate. you're a favourite of mine as well, even if we have differing opinions on tunes, i always enjoy your input into threads. great poster & hey if we enjoyed the same stuff, this would be one hell of a boring site haha

but ye that album i fantastic. got a lot of the well know hits like wonderwall, don't look back in anger, champange supernova etc. there's not a weak tune on it i recon

we enjoy some of the same stuff haha

RXB for example :-D

but ya, i'm pleasantly surprised that i'm enjoying this album much better than i thought

it'll take a few more listens to make a final verdict on, but, great rec man, thank you

[captainamazing4]

i gotta go with taking back sunday - tayf

[patrickhowell]

what's that ONE album by a band, the one you HATE compared to loving all of their other albums?

NFG's Catalyst would be mine

Really? I like Catalyst better than Sticks and Stones.

"At Least I'm Known For Something" and "All Downhill From Here" are two of my favorite NFG tracks ever...

[lilRIPsta]

My third fav Weezer record, i like it more than the Green Album.


i agree totally. i hated green but enjoyed Maladroit somewhat

[asthesoulman]

i agree totally. i hated green but enjoyed Maladroit somewhat
burndt jamb, love explosion, space rock, and december aren't half bad.

[mjr20]

i gotta go with taking back sunday - tayf


please say that is an april fools joke

[ThisIsNotDan]

Cave In - Beyond Hypothermia (i pretend that UYHS is their first)
Poison The Well - Distance... (terrible)
Deftones - Adrenaline (not necessarily bad, but it just pales in comparison to later releases)
Foo Fighters - One By One (screams AVERAGE)
Nine Inch Nails - Pretty Hate Machine and With Teeth (one is too electro-pop, and the other was way too lackluster for a motherfucking 6 YEAR WAIT).
Metallica - St. Anger (fucking terrible).

[notoaststereo]

gatsbys american dream - why we fight
thrice - identity crisis (its a good album, but not nearly as good as anything else thrice has done.)
yellowcard - lights and sounds.

[eltroyo11]

Sugarcult - Palm Trees and Power Lines

It doesn't even come close to Start Static.

[drmsofpsilocybi]

popaganda - head automatica
sphere in the heart of silence - john frusciante
led zeppelin - coda, presence, in through the out door.
mae - everglow
three cheers for sweet revenge - mcr
ummagumma - pink floyd
in reverie - saves the day

[duhpunk]

Sugarcult - Palm Trees and Power Lines

It doesn't even come close to Start Static.

eh, "eleven" is worse. start static was an amazing album tho.

[patrickhowell]

popaganda - head automatica
sphere in the heart of silence - john frusciante
led zeppelin - coda, presence, in through the out door.
mae - everglow
three cheers for sweet revenge - mcr
ummagumma - pink floyd
in reverie - saves the day

I agree with Mae... Everglow is miserable.

But I love In Reverie... I really don't get why everyone hates it.

[Yes. And?]

Apparently, "City By A Light Divided" sucked compared to other Thursday albums? I dunno..I don't have it...yet.

Oh, and I love "The Black Parade", but not as much as My Chemical Romance's older stuff.

[mikearduini9]

popaganda - head automatica
sphere in the heart of silence - john frusciante
led zeppelin - coda, presence, in through the out door.
mae - everglow
three cheers for sweet revenge - mcr
ummagumma - pink floyd
in reverie - saves the day

You like My Chem's first album better than Three Cheers? yuck.

I strongly disagree with the Everglow.

In Reverie is amazing, what's wrong with some of you people?

[Scott Weber]

You like My Chem's first album better than Three Cheers? yuck.

I strongly disagree with the Everglow.

In Reverie is amazing, what's wrong with some of you people?
In Reverie is a solid album, but it is by far the worst Saves the Day record.

[lolimkate]

angels and airwaves - we don't need to whisper
jamisonparker - sleepwalker
sum 41 - chuck
oh, and green day - american idiot (obviously)

[guitargal313]

Eh I think people cast American Idiot off too soon. Its seriously a pretty intricate plot line for a rock opera once you read through all of it. Sure its a different style but their experimenting with sound. Just a thought. ^^

[halifaxonfire]

angels and airwaves - we don't need to whisper
jamisonparker - sleepwalker
sum 41 - chuck
oh, and green day - american idiot (obviously)
Angels & Airwaves has one album, and JamisonParker has one album and an ep. how can you not like one of their albums compared to the others if there are no others? :shrug:

[capnhook54]

Red Hot Chili Peppers - 'One Hot Minute'

[capnhook54]

Angels & Airwaves has one album, and JamisonParker has one album and an ep. how can you not like one of their albums compared to the others if there are no others? :shrug:

I think he means compared to other DeLonge work.