A-Rod vs. Ernie Banks

[thejetstolehome]

another one, i'm on a roll with these.

Ernie Banks:

19 seasons: .274 avs, .330 obp, 512 hr, 1636 rbis, .500 slg, 763 bb, 1236 so

Alex Rodriguez:

14 seasons: .306 avg., .386 obp., 470 hr, 1363 rbi, .575 slg, 825 bb, 1410 so

[Branevember31]

I'm gonna say A-Rod, though it got a lot closer when I remembered his performances in the playoffs


Once he has a good postseason, its A-Rod definitely

[Broken Parachute]

Alex Rodriguez

He's on pace for about 1000 HR's.

[Branevember31]

Alex Rodriguez

He's on pace for about 1000 HR's.


yeah...lets just hope he doesnt pull a Griffey and get hurt for 5 straight seasons

[kshtoinks12]

A-rod, although he does sure strike out a lot.

[thejetstolehome]

i went with A-Rod but i still think Ernie Banks is one of the most underrated players in the history of the game.

[make_this_hurt]

Ernie Banks.

But only because A-Rod is gay.

[Smithers]

well they both have the same number of rings.

burn.

[bduke13]

I picked Arod but its kind of crazy how many more times he has struck out

[bigmike]

I picked Arod but its kind of crazy how many more times he has struck out
And how close they are in HR's considering the fewer number of years ARod's played.

[Split2nd]

Banks doesn't have an advantage in anything... why is this a tough choice?