Last One: Tell All Your Friends vs. Say It Like You Mean It

[mikeyystyles]

This is the last one, since Take this to your grave won out.. I want to know where Tell all your friends stands.

[as_we_learn]

TAYF, but that's because I haven't heard Say it Like You Mean it

[TSLROCKS]

Say It Like You Mean It one of the best album in my opinion. only 1 album can top it which is take off your pants and jacket by Blink 182 other than that only Based on a True Story

[Branevember31]

Tayf

[IATA4224]

The only poll I'd ever vote TBS on..

[underthetalking]

No contest at all.

[MIKEY_HORROR]

Tell All Your Friends.. no doubt at all

[hornerlas]

say it like you mean it no doubt...

[.Dylan]

To hell with you and all your friends. it's on

[MattRM]

TAYF, but that's because I haven't heard Say it Like You Mean it

Whaaaaaaaaaaaat? Haven't heard it?!

[thatwasamoment]

both classics, but tayf takes the cake.

[SellMyOldClthes]

Wait...TTTYG beat out TAYF? Absolute joke.

[avengedtbs]

BEST FRIENDS MEANS YOU PULL THE TRIGGER. BEST FRIENDS MEANS YOU GET WHAT YOU DESERVE! nuff said

[InDireNeedSF]

I can't believe this is even a poll, is there really any question? "Tell All Your Friends" was just it... to compare TSL SILYMI, is just.... crazy

[avengedtbs]

its not really that crazy cause in the other poll when it was TAYF vs. TTTYG...SILYMI was brought up quite a bit

[as_we_learn]

BEST FRIENDS MEANS YOU PULL THE TRIGGER. BEST FRIENDS MEANS YOU GET WHAT YOU DESERVE! nuff said
I love this song so fuckin bad. It's great.

[avengedtbs]

I love this song so fuckin bad. It's great.
there is a lot i would give up to hear it live with adam, john, eddie, shaun, and mark on stage

[as_we_learn]

there is a lot i would give up to hear it live with adam, john, eddie, shaun, and mark on stage
Yeah that would be so fucking crazy. That would be the tits

[avengedtbs]

Yeah that would be so fucking crazy. That would be the tits
i would lose my voice easily and jizz in my pants...at the same time

[flyeast]

Tell All Your Friends.

Duh.

[as_we_learn]

i would lose my voice easily and jizz in my pants...at the same time
Dude who wouldn't!

[avengedtbs]

not too many....i wouldnt mind hearing the ballad of sal villenueva either just cause they havent played that since the "break-up"

[mikeyystyles]

I think what it comes to is, a simple poll of Take this to your grave vs. Tell all your friends. Since Chroma got killed against TTTYG, and SILYMI held some water against TTTYG. What do you think?

[SeanEBoy2686]

TAYF, but that's because I haven't heard Say it Like You Mean it

what? wow!

i voted for Say It Like You Mean It.... its one of the first albums to get me into what I listen to today

[whiteboypain]

I love both, but i'm gonna have to go with Tell All Your Friends on this one..

[avengedtbs]

I think what it comes to is, a simple poll of Take this to your grave vs. Tell all your friends. Since Chroma got killed against TTTYG, and SILYMI held some water against TTTYG. What do you think?
already been done...and TAYF pwned

[avengedtbs]

or maybe it was under the poll of best debut...but TAYF pwned TTTYG in that poll

[Alex DiVincenzo]

Damn, this is really close. I have to give it up for SILYMI by the slightest bit.

[mikeyystyles]

Haha what ever it was lets do 1 more then. Forr all the marblesss!!!

[MADSTA]

Tell All Your Friends.

[FUCKDIRTYWIPES]

TAYF. NO contest.

[captainamazing4]

tayf easily...

[collapse]

Tell All Your Friends


But both are great albums regardless.

[Deadonarrival08]

i can't say anything with out laughing hahaha

[CherubRock]

TAYF is classic

[dskiz]

Tell All Your Friends hands down.

[animmortalsoul]

Tell All Your Friends. I hate the Starting Line.

[M.C COB]

TAYF for sure

[You Won't Know]

there is a lot i would give up to hear it live with adam, john, eddie, shaun, and mark on stage

I think that would be badass, because I never got to see the first version of TBS live, but I heard they are MUCH tighter musically now, if not as crazy.

Also, this poll is a joke to me, TAYF destroys TSL. Think of the far-reaching impact of TAYF vs the Starting Line. Even if you think TSL has influenced many bands, they are probably not playing the quality of music I want to hear vs. bands influenced by Taking Back Sunday.

[i am]

TAYF.
absolutely no question about it.
Say It... is good, but TAYF is just...yeah...in my opinion at least...

[azlisa]

come on! tbs.

[meliisssaaaa]

tell all your friends is my vote

[glimmeratziii]

roughest poll EVER. i seriously sat here and debated with myself for about 5 minutes. pulled up itunes. tried to logically figure out which one is better. i finally settled on silymi but even now i'm not so sure. they're both incredible.

[bethebean66]

This one easily goes out to TAYF. TBS was perfect on this album, which is sad because nothing has yet to compare to it. SILYMI, good album... I'm a bigger fan of Based on a True Story. Next poll, you should try seeing which does better, Louder Now or Based on a True Story... in my opinion, a lot tougher. As for this poll... Taking Back Sunday still stands on top.

[Zeran]

is this poll a joke?

[loveisdead]

This one easily goes out to TAYF. TBS was perfect on this album, which is sad because nothing has yet to compare to it. SILYMI, good album... I'm a bigger fan of Based on a True Story. Next poll, you should try seeing which does better, Louder Now or Based on a True Story... in my opinion, a lot tougher. As for this poll... Taking Back Sunday still stands on top.
Good idea with putting Based on a True Story against Louder Now. I don't know what would be more appropriate though, Based on a True Story vs. Louder Now or Based on a True Story vs. Where You Want to Be since they are both bands second releases.