Fight Club or American History X?

[speakhandsforme]

two very well-received Edward Norton films....which one do you prefer?

for my money, it's AMX

[MIKEY_HORROR]

Fight Club gets my vote...its my favorite all time movie... but American History X is probably in my top 10

[Smash Adams]

american history x has a serious message, and is worth discussing, not to insult fight club

[loganmmm]

Fight Club made me think a lot deeper than American History X. So, it got my vote.
Although American History X is a great movie.

[josiahh]

american history x has a serious message, and is worth discussing, not to insult fight club


Fight Club has an extremely important and serious message as well that is worth discussing.


this was hella-hard to decide, but i did go with Fight Club because American History X makes me way too depressed...but holy god what an incredible movie.

[Smash Adams]

Fight Club has an extremely important and serious message as well that is worth discussing.


this was hella-hard to decide, but i did go with Fight Club because American History X makes me way too depressed...but holy god what an incredible movie.

I find I'm in the minority here, but I couldn't imagine discussing fight club in class

[captainamazing4]

fight club, but its very very close

[Sp1tF1r3]

Fight Club

[makeasound]

American History X. One of few movies I still can't stop watching when it's on, no matter how many times I've seen it.

Another good Edward Norton movie is Primal Fear.

[newfoundmichael]

Gah, Norton is my favorite actor and these are two of my favorite movies...I'd have to go Fight Club though. I did my term paper on it.

[SeanEBoy2686]

fight club

[SgtFumunda]

Fight Club is was written better. It has a more global and timeless message than American History X.

[gregplaysdrums]

a more timeless message than one regarding racism? hmmmm.....

[blckout20]

Chuck Palahniuk is the man. I voted for Fight Club, both are really good movies but FC was more in depth and made me think more. Also, it was a movie I could watch over and over again moreso than AHX.

[bobby runs]

fight club ftw because its just a great movie. great "cameos" from other stars but the thing that really takes it is that it is more than a movie in my mind.

[ojgio]

Fight Club gets my vote. Aha, two Ed Norton flicks. Rounders fans say "I".

[altemose09]

i was just about to make this poll, weird.
i went with American History X

[lftcoastenvy05]

hard decision, i love fight club, but i went with american history x for the message it sends.

[heytheredelilah]

well since they both have good messages, i went with the next girl instinct i had and picked the movie with the hottest actors. fight club.

[YOUWONTKNOW]

i like fight club..but how can someone compare these two? completely different movie types. American History X wins without any doubt in my mind

[Fedaykin]

I find I'm in the minority here, but I couldn't imagine discussing fight club in class
depends what sort of class
in my modern american writers class we discussed Palahniuk , who wrote Fight Club and his "surprise ending" style of writing

accordingly, id pick fight club the book over fight club the movie

[underthetalking]

fight club ftw because its just a great movie. great "cameos" from other stars but the thing that really takes it is that it is more than a movie in my mind.

It looks like a movie, sounds like a movie, hell, even smells like a movie. Its a movie. Not much past that.

[Smash Adams]

depends what sort of class
in my modern american writers class we discussed Palahniuk , who wrote Fight Club and his "surprise ending" style of writing

accordingly, id pick fight club the book over fight club the movie

I was thinking more of a sociology type class

[Fedaykin]

It looks like a movie, sounds like a movie, hell, even smells like a movie. Its a movie. Not much past that.
except of course for the fact that it is also a book

[altemose09]

holy shit when i voted it was 50 to 50 which means ahx only got 7 more and fight club got 50

[Vismund_Cygnus]

Fight Club...easily the most quotable movie ever.

[Smog01]

Fight Club was amazing! So was American History X, but Fight Club just blows my mind.

[AP_Punk]

I love both.

I think I'd have to go with Fight Club.

[Slimefoot]

i havnt yet seen american history x but
fight club is my fav movie ever made

second to memento
which u really should check out

[nerdvglc]

fight club, but it's really close...i LOVE both of those movies, and ed norton is one of my favorite actors of all time

[FUCKDIRTYWIPES]

amx

[trindaddy]

fight club. i've watched it about a bazillion times. amx is great as well.

[sasalukac]

Fight Club gets my vote. Aha, two Ed Norton flicks. Rounders fans say "I".

I!

[Garrett Miller]

I find I'm in the minority here, but I couldn't imagine discussing fight club in class

I actually did study fight club in class the teacher gave us this article to read and it was about consumerism and it talked about fight club, it was the greatest day in class ever

[dbuns]

fuck these are my two favorite movies. edward norton blows any actor out of the water. but that's all opinion.

[boysdontcry17]

most people dont get the existentialist issues in fight club

[Branevember31]

Amx

[Gumbyjag]

AMX hands down.

[himynameiszack]

Damn, my two favorite movies. Went with Fight Club though.

[SunnyInPhilly]

Never seen AMX, but I wasn't really a big fan of Fight Club. It was ok.

[abandonship]

Hmm, I really liked them both. I'd have to watch them again to decide.

[MADSTA]

I've still yet to see AHX. It's on my list.

[RecklessXRandy]

Fight Club, AHX is good too.

[Deadbolt23]

Both great films. American History X is better in my opinion though.

[murrich]

American History X

[Feenucks]

Fight Club made me think a lot deeper than American History X. So, it got my vote.
Although American History X is a great movie.

This.

[And Hours Pass]

I find I'm in the minority here, but I couldn't imagine discussing fight club in class
I don't have to imagine it because i have! The direction in that movie and how the camera is used to validate the twist at the end upon additional viewings is incredible.

While I voted for FC, I also love AHX. Both are brilliant films.