Which Alchemy Index Album Will Sell Best?

[inCinerate.1028]

Between Vol. 1 & 2 and then later to come Vol. 3 & 4.

I'm guessing Vol. 1 & 2 because Fire is so awesome and Water is so beautiful. The band described Earh as stripped down and Air as very airy. So i think the first release will sell more.

[Abs Punk Is Gay]

i think it will be close because I think that most people who bought vol. 1&2 will also buy 3&4. But I just think the hype for these albums is so high now that Fire and Water will sell more because there just wont be much of a desire for a new thrice album as there is right now. But i think they will both be close to the same, and I'd be surprised if either of them went gold

[motioncity182]

vol. 1 & 2 will probably sell more. reason being that if people buy that, and don't like it, they won't get 3 and 4. and people won't just buy 3 and 4 without getting 1 and 2 anyways...

[Wolf I Am!]

this poll is pretty stupid

[phoenixinflames]

It's hard to say...but i think "Fire/Water" since Fire's sound sounds most like Thrice's most recent stuff.

[White Noise]

Vol. 1 and 2 will sell more. But its so hard to project, you either hate it or love it.

[fromoc2dc]

i think it will be close because I think that most people who bought vol. 1&2 will also buy 3&4. But I just think the hype for these albums is so high now that Fire and Water will sell more because there just wont be much of a desire for a new thrice album as there is right now. But i think they will both be close to the same, and I'd be surprised if either of them went gold

Exactly what I was thinking.

[Shatter_Glass]

assuming everyone listens to the EP's before they're bought.

hmmmmmm I think more AP fans will purchase VOL. 3 & 4.

[airik625]

around the same

[desipunk7]

I think after finding out how good Fire and Water were, more people will buy Earth and Air. just a theory

[Alex DiVincenzo]

I'd imagine the sales would be very similar, but I'd assume Vol 1&2 would do a little better because it came first