Tokyo Police Club [Archive] - AbsolutePunk.net

mattybobviously

04/27/08, 10:42 AM

I am really enjoying it, but with that said, I agree with Pitchfork's sentiment that I kind of expected bigger things on this, and while it's fun and catchy, musically it's kind of middle-of-the-road.

bowl of oranges

04/27/08, 10:51 AM

i've yet to listen to this, but i loved A Lesson In Crime EP

Machu505

04/27/08, 10:56 AM

Awesome band.

kafe

04/27/08, 01:37 PM

Elephant Shell isn't quite as good as A Lesson In Crime, but I still like it more each time I listen to it.

Osto

04/27/08, 05:27 PM

Yeah the full length is dissapointingly pretty good and not fantastic like expected.

Genuma

04/27/08, 05:28 PM

I didn't get this at all.

Until The Bombs

04/27/08, 05:39 PM

Really like the older stuff, just got Elephant Shell today.

IWasaCamera

04/27/08, 06:43 PM

Not good.

Until The Bombs

04/27/08, 07:51 PM

Not good.

After one listen I completely disagree.

FeynmanWannabe

04/27/08, 08:01 PM

Searched and didn't find a thread.
I think that Elephant Shell is extremely addictive. They're not over-hyped, they deserve it.

Discuss. Yes, they are.

SubrosaSeductiv

04/27/08, 08:05 PM

Not that great, sound like a melo-dramatic version of The Killers.

IWasaCamera

04/27/08, 08:07 PM

After one listen I completely disagree.
As expected.
Yes, they are.
Ha, I didn't even see that he posted that. Ridiculous hype.

Until The Bombs

04/27/08, 08:11 PM

As expected.

Haha.

Ha, I didn't even see that he posted that. Ridiculous hype.
Virtually everything is over-hyped.

IWasaCamera

04/27/08, 08:14 PM

Virtually everything is over-hyped.
Disagree. Quite a few bands aren't given nearly enough attention.

Until The Bombs

04/27/08, 08:22 PM

Disagree. Quite a few bands aren't given nearly enough attention.

Yeah, like the 5 bands/artists that each person thinks aren't given enough recognition. The other 99.999% of bands are then "over-hyped, overrated."

Even if they were over-hyped at one point, from what I've read/heard, this album hasn't been getting particularly good reviews anyway (outside of the AP.net review). Can't see how they are still over-hyped given that. Unless virtually all bands/artists are over-hyped.

Colorblind!

04/27/08, 08:28 PM

Not that great, sound like a melo-dramatic version of The Killers.

Really!?

and I like this better then the ep. The song they redid off it is great.

IWasaCamera

04/27/08, 08:31 PM

Yeah, like the 5 bands/artists that each person thinks aren't given enough recognition. The other 99.999% of bands are then "over-hyped, overrated."
I'm sure you could name me countless artists that aren't given enough recognition. Anyone truly into music probably can. It's a rather sweeping generalization to claim that virtually everything is over-hyped. Besides, a portion of the acts remaining would be adequately "hyped" leaving those over-hyped with a far smaller percentage anyway.
Even if they were over-hyped at one point, from what I've read/heard, this album hasn't been getting particularly good reviews anyway (outside of the AP.net review). Can't see how they are still over-hyped given that. Unless virtually all bands/artists are over-hyped.
The music they write doesn't warrant the attention they receive. It isn't so much the favorable/unfavorable reviews that are pertinent, but rather their sudden prominence and individuals name-dropping them everywhere you look.

Until The Bombs

04/27/08, 08:43 PM

I'm sure you could name me countless artists that aren't given enough recognition. Anyone truly into music probably can. It's a rather sweeping generalization to claim that virtually everything is over-hyped. Besides, a portion of the acts remaining would be adequately "hyped" leaving those over-hyped with a far smaller percentage.

A sweeping generalization that is correct. That's why people so comfortably throw it out all the time. You or I could name all the acts that we feel aren't given due attention and it's still such a percentage of acts within the larger picture.

The music they write doesn't warrant the attention they receive.
I'll accept that, although like I said I disagree.

It isn't so much the favorable/unfavorable reviews that are pertinent, but rather their sudden prominence and individuals name-dropping them everywhere you look.

In my rather limited interaction with you, I find you to be above this, but it sounds a lot to me like the "this band got too popular so now they suck" attitude that so many people carry. I'm sure that's not how you intended it to come off, but that's what it sounds like.

IWasaCamera

04/27/08, 08:51 PM

A sweeping generalization that is correct. That's why people so comfortably throw it out all the time. You or I could name all the acts that we feel aren't given due attention and it's still such a percentage of acts within the larger picture.
This is merely my opinion and the acts I find unworthy of their prominence are only so in certain musical circles. With that being said, within my framework and coupling the under-recognized with those given adequate attention, it isn't as lopsided as you would make it seem.
I'll accept that, although like I said I disagree.
That's fair.
In my rather limited interaction with you, I find you to be above this, but it sounds a lot to me like the "this band got too popular so now they suck" attitude that so many people carry. I'm sure that's not how you intended it to come off, but that's what it sounds like.
haha that was never my intent. I've always disliked this band, from when they were playing in my friend's basements to this day. It's just that before the past year and a half or so, they could suck and be off my radar for the most part. This is no longer possible.

SubrosaSeductiv

04/28/08, 11:59 AM

Really!?

and I like this better then the ep. The song they redid off it is great.

Don't get me wrong I like it, it's just not amazing.

kearn1tm

04/28/08, 12:30 PM

I'm digging Elephant Shell, but I've found that, one of the reasons I enjoyed them so much was that they always came in bite-sized portions. Their two EPs were personal pan pizzas comprised of barely 2-minute long toppings. Whereas an entire LP of the same is far too filling. That's a personal problem, I know. I also find the vocals slightly jarring. On the EPs, there was a slight emotional disconnect, possibly due to the megaphony sound. On the LP, it's as though Dave Monks is trying to actually sing, and it isn't bad, but it's not what I initially fell in love with. It's as though they've conformed to that midwestern umbrella emo sound of the rest of their Saddle Creek peers.

All things considered, it's still a fun debut LP and I'm glad they found a home at Saddle Creek.

Until The Bombs

04/28/08, 12:32 PM

I'm digging Elephant Shell, but I've found that, one of the reasons I enjoyed them so much was that they always came in bite-sized portions. Their two EPs were personal pan pizzas comprised of barely 2-minute long toppings. Whereas an entire LP of the same is far too filling. That's a personal problem, I know. I also find the vocals slightly jarring. On the EPs, there was a slight emotional disconnect, possibly due to the megaphony sound. On the LP, it's as though Dave Monks is trying to actually sing, and it isn't bad, but it's not what I initially fell in love with.

All things considered, it's still a fun debut LP and I'm glad they found a home at Saddle Creek.

I was really suprised to see they ended up there, given the relative buzz around them when they came out.

kearn1tm

04/28/08, 12:38 PM

I was really suprised to see they ended up there, given the relative buzz around them when they came out.

Me too. Saddle Creek isn't the smallest of indie labels, but given the lip service Spin, Rolling Stone, Pitchfork, the blogosphere and fans were throwing at the band, I'd assumed they'd land at a larger, more prominent label. I remember hearing word that V2 was trying to sign them.

Until The Bombs

04/28/08, 12:41 PM

Me too. Saddle Creek isn't the smallest of indie labels, but given the lip service Spin, Rolling Stone, Pitchfork, the blogosphere and fans were throwing at the band, I'd assumed they'd land at a larger, more prominent label. I remember hearing word that V2 was trying to sign them.

It's probably much smarter on their part as is. Saddle Creek probably gives them more room to do what they want to do, while still offering a fair amount of influence within the music world.

kearn1tm

04/28/08, 12:55 PM

It's probably much smarter on their part as is. Saddle Creek probably gives them more room to do what they want to do, while still offering a fair amount of influence within the music world.

Most definitely. I'd imagine there's much more freedom at Saddle Creek than V2 would have offered. That said, I do find it odd that they are sounding more like fellow Saddle Creek bands with this latest album.

Until The Bombs

04/28/08, 12:56 PM

Most definitely. I'd imagine there's much more freedom at Saddle Creek than V2 would have offered. That said, I do find it odd that they are sounding more like fellow Saddle Creek bands with this latest album.

You think so? I haven't listened through it more than once yet (I only got it yesterday), but that didn't jump to mind.

disco.tetris

05/05/08, 03:46 AM

Elephant Shell is sooo good. It's been on repeat for about 3 weeks haha.

Haven't heard the EP though.

3mpire

05/05/08, 06:03 AM

Keep meaning to pick up some of their music. Really like the sound they're getting at.

EFA

05/05/08, 05:56 PM

One of my fav bands for sure..

Haven't got round to pickin' up the new album though..
Mixed reviews..
Can't wait for it tho

Colorblind!

05/05/08, 07:15 PM

I still enjoy it, alot.

Ailite

06/09/08, 06:02 PM

I like this band, I'll probably get Elephant Shell when I go out on Wednesday. I'm really digging Your English Is Good.

hockeyguitar99

06/09/08, 06:11 PM

i enjoy the album but its nothing special

mattybobviously

06/09/08, 06:39 PM

Fun album for the summer, pretty good drumming on here, just didn't really fulfill the potential of their EPs

Colorblind!

06/09/08, 08:03 PM

I thought it was better then the ep.

IWasaCamera

06/09/08, 10:33 PM

Still boring.

live.

06/09/08, 11:27 PM

They're nothing special. I do enjoy the song "In A Cave" and the video. Mostly because it was directed by my favorite group of amateur comedians on YouTube.

airik625

06/09/08, 11:43 PM

I love Elephant Shell. Such a great record and fun as hell to listen to. I just wish it was a bit longer.

Osto

06/10/08, 05:33 AM

If it were any longer than it's flaws would only become more apparent. That being said, I enjoy the record.

disco.tetris

06/10/08, 11:25 AM

I'm still loving Elephant Shell too.

bluepoles

06/10/08, 12:14 PM

I casually listen to tpc.. their good but nothing i would get too into.

Cuddleworthy

06/10/08, 12:23 PM

A Lesson in Crime is a lot better than Elephant Shell. With that said, they're an alright band but overrated by most people that listen to them.

IcedOpethBlind

06/10/08, 12:24 PM

love elephant shell (listening as we speak actually, its been awhile) and the EP...

bluepoles

06/10/08, 12:25 PM

A Lesson in Crime is a lot better than Elephant Shell. With that said, they're an alright band but overrated by most people that listen to them.
i agree.

CatDiesel

06/28/08, 10:02 AM

love em

MADSTA

06/28/08, 10:05 AM

Solid band.
The fact that they're Canadian makes me like them more.

CatDiesel

06/28/08, 10:08 AM

I'm gonna buy tix to see em in october

hockeyguitar99

06/28/08, 11:03 AM

Sweet band.

evvandflow

06/23/09, 09:48 PM

This band definitely does not get enough love. Great tunes, underrated lyrics.

Colorblind!

06/23/09, 10:50 PM

After making this thread way long ago, I still don't feel they're overrated.
I guess I'm one of the very few who likes Elephant Shell but I would probably take it over A Lesson In Crime. I can't say I've listened to the new one a whole lot since I bought it, but I love when I do and this makes me want to go put it on. :-)

thesafeword

06/23/09, 11:15 PM

They're okay.

iam_theculprit

06/24/09, 02:29 AM

I've listened to Elephant Shell a lot but haven't listened to their older stuff even though I do have it on my computer. I'll have to do that sometime. I do love Elephant Shell, though. That album was my "summer album" for last year.