Best Reality Show of All-Time?

[domotime2]

First ill voice my opinion and then im interested to see whats everyones favorite.

the best and greatest reality TV show of all-time was a little thing called...
MYSTER IN SMALL TOWN X

It was on for only one season during the summer a few years back, and let me tell you, this is EXACTLY what a reality show should be. Now, of course this was obviously scripted and there was nothing real about it...but WHO CARES? 95% of reality shows are scripted and bogus anyways....so whatever.

Mystery in small town x had everything! They gave you a list of about 20 characters/suspects from the town (the priest, cab driver, fisherman, etc.) And you had to guess who the killer was! Every week you got different clues, and every week characters would die off. It was the contestants job to figure out who the killer was by asking the towns people questions and playing games. At the end of the show...two "contestants/detectives" are sent on a mission to find a new clue...1 person comes back with the clue...the other dies..and is off the show.

So you were interested in seeing who wins...AND you got to play along as well, by making your own guesses and trying to figure it out for yourself. Unfortunatley it wasnt succesful, since people were all "this is fake...its stupid"...its a season long Mystery Movie.. thats awesome!


1)Murder in Small Town X
2) Mole: Season 1
3) Americas Most Smartest Model hah

[AShannon04]

I like the Mole: Celebrity Edition
Beauty and the Geek
Survivor: Season 1

Probably more, but I can't think of them at the moment.

[ActionActionFan]

30 Days

[Kif]

The Mole
Hell's Kitchen
Boot Camp

Pimp My Ride was a guilty pleasure too before they switched garages.

[googirl8907]

Beauty and the Geek

[4N6 science]

beauty and the geek was good, hell's kitchen, ROL 1, I love NY 1 and 2, Real World, first few survivors.

[WFUJerseyJon]

Flavor of Love Season 1...Beach week sophomore year my friends and I sat around hung over and watched the entire season when VH1 ran them back to back. It was amazing.

[4N6 science]

flavor of love 1 was great...the past two seasons were so crappy. Flavor Flav is such a desperate need for money.

[gloriousmuse]

I've only watched Sorority Life on MTV and Real World San Diego

[musicfiend]

Best reality show ever: Real World. Real World in the 90s was solid. Now it's not as good but worth the occasional watch.

[matt_bergeron]

Best reality show ever: Real World. Real World in the 90s was solid. Now it's not as good but worth the occasional watch.

this season of the real world is pretty good actually.

[domotime2]

wow.....im sad to hear this list


I Love New York? Flavor of Love?
haha are you guys kidding?

all these shows are exactly the same....retards trying to win the love of some C- Celebrity. there's nothing original or captivating about those shows what soever

pimp my ride is a reality show

[irthesteve]

Survivor and non-celeb seasons of The Mole. I can't wait for the new season tonight

[Burning Star IV]

Kenny vs. Spenny
Gene Simmon's Family Jewels

[drudo182]

The Amazing Race, Survivor, Ultimate Fighter and The Contender.

[lindZ629]

The Amazing Race and Survivor.

[ThexQuietxCull]

Flavor of Love?

[Jessooker]

I love Project Runway.

[illmeetuovrbrd]

murder in small town x was good i forgot about the entire thing. if your talking about reality shows then you mean unscripted.

1. First 48
2. Miami Ink
3. American Chopper

[gloriousmuse]

I love Project Runway.

This season was terrible I thought. I stopped watching after the guy was "dismissed" for the serious infection.

[AlternateToLife]

Beauty and The Geek up until this season. This season had too many twists.


I also enjoy Project Runway but I sure as hell wouldn't call it good.

[irthesteve]

Top Chef if it counts

[SLoT]

Average Joe hands down.

[Roboman]

None of them.

[EndlessMike]

Muder In Small Town X is my favorite reality show of all time. I talk about it constantly and no one ever knows what the hell I'm talking about. I was convinced that I was the only person who ever saw it. They need to bring it back like The Mole, I'd rather see this than the 25th season of Survivor or Big Brother or some other shit.

[laxcrs]

mole season 1

[stayillogical]

Project Runway. The people there are actually already talented (works for Nike, owns a boutique, etc).

[Jessooker]

Top Chef if it counts


yesss.

[zubinmoosa]

I am addicted to Big Brother right now...

[argg_xo]

project runway is the only one i watch religiously. i used to love sorority life too.

[king vs. queen]

fear factor

[wroteurname]

Average Joe FTW!!!!!!

[wroteurname]

First ill voice my opinion and then im interested to see whats everyones favorite.

the best and greatest reality TV show of all-time was a little thing called...
MYSTER IN SMALL TOWN X

It was on for only one season during the summer a few years back, and let me tell you, this is EXACTLY what a reality show should be. Now, of course this was obviously scripted and there was nothing real about it...but WHO CARES? 95% of reality shows are scripted and bogus anyways....so whatever.

Mystery in small town x had everything! They gave you a list of about 20 characters/suspects from the town (the priest, cab driver, fisherman, etc.) And you had to guess who the killer was! Every week you got different clues, and every week characters would die off. It was the contestants job to figure out who the killer was by asking the towns people questions and playing games. At the end of the show...two "contestants/detectives" are sent on a mission to find a new clue...1 person comes back with the clue...the other dies..and is off the show.

So you were interested in seeing who wins...AND you got to play along as well, by making your own guesses and trying to figure it out for yourself. Unfortunatley it wasnt succesful, since people were all "this is fake...its stupid"...its a season long Mystery Movie.. thats awesome!


1)Murder in Small Town X
2) Mole: Season 1
3) Americas Most Smartest Model hah
No lie, Murder in Small Town X was a sick show, my sister and I just talked about it the other day, and how Thibadeault was the killer.

[Chris Fallon]

Joe Schmo has always been my favorite.

[AShannon04]

Top Chef if it counts

love that show. I saw chef Tom Colicchio in NYC a few days ago.

[catscradle]

Joe Schmo has always been my favorite.

i came in here to say this.

[kafe]

Expedition Robinson (swedish version of Survivor) i remember that after the first person who got voted off the show in the first season, he killed himself.

[gilatron5000]

the only ones I really watch are America's Next Top Model and the shows in The Real World franchise.

[bradyreier]

Big Brother has always been a guilty pleasure of mine, so I'm going to have to say that.

[Smithers]

http://www.nydailynews.com/blogs/ilovetowatch/images/mystery.jpg

the pick up artist, bitches.

[popdisaster00]

The Average Joe.

[Chancetobe]

My favorites were (at least for the first few seasons) Beauty and the Geek, Americas Next Top Model, Real World, and really most other reality shows on MTV. You name it, i've probably seen it.

[-PARANOID-]

Does anyone remember the 70s House? Probably not my all time favorite but I sure did love it for some reason.

[tttygxlove]

I loved that show My Big Fat Obnoxious Fiance or however it went, probably my favorite.