More timeless album ?

[passingtime49]

New Found Glory - Self Titled/2000

Saves The Day - Stay What You Are/2001

[Machu505]

Stay What You Are

[Cuddleworthy]

stay what you are, no question

[MADSTA]

Neither.

I have not heard either of these albums.

[Machu505]

Neither.

I have not heard either of these albums.

Get on that shit!

[augustana]

stay what you are, without a doubt. i really can't stand nfg's self-titled or any of their other releases.

[passingtime49]

Neither.

I have not heard either of these albums.
You can't go wrong with either, but you really should check out both. In my opinion, my favorite bands best work.

[nevernevernever]

wow, two albums i loved when they came out my freshman year in high school
saves the day has had the more lasting effect

[notoaststereo]

new found glory

[phoenixinflames]

I love NFG, but as far as timeless goes...Stay What You Are by faaaaaar.

[weworemasks]

Neither.

I have not heard either of these albums.

jesus christ.

swya is std's best album in my opinion, and s/t is definitely not nfg's best.

[Jsmall]

I like both of them but Std's "Stay what you are" is way better. Saves the day can do no wrong in my opinion though...so it isn't that close.

[EamonKid]

Some girls are crazy!

[MADSTA]

You can't go wrong with either, but you really should check out both. In my opinion, my favorite bands best work.

Get on that shit!

jesus christ.

swya is std's best album in my opinion, and s/t is definitely not nfg's best.
I've been meaning to check out Stay What You Are for a while actually. I've heard a few songs from Sound The Alarm, and I liked what I heard, and everyone says that SWYA is their best, so I figured I should get it.

[passingtime49]

I've been meaning to check out Stay What You Are for a while actually. I've heard a few songs from Sound The Alarm, and I liked what I heard, and everyone says that SWYA is their best, so I figured I should get it.
The only thing is, the two albums have a totally different sound from one another. I believe you'll enjoy it, a lot.

[SJPrice99]

2 fantastic albums. tough choice, NFG s/t was by far their best release, and they havent come close since - in my opinion, through being cool was STD's best, with stay what you are a VERY close 2nd. id have to go with NFG in this one, but its almost too close to call.

[liar23]

stay what you are by a lot

[jbaseball44]

I like nfg but this isn't close. Stay What You Are by a wide margin.

[IWasaCamera]

Two dreadful albums.

[jbaseball44]

Two dreadful albums.

Which one is less dreadful?

[jay_klinkhammer]

Nothing Gold Can Stay is NFG's best!

[tcemoo]

I voted Stay What You Are, simply because Self-Titled isn't even NFG's best work.

[jawstheme]

Stay What You Are goes in my cd player waaaaay more often.

[Kid Defender]

Saves The Day!! I'm so surprised that they are winning, but of course they should be.

[jbaseball44]

Saves The Day!! I'm so surprised that they are winning, but of course they should be.

I'm not overly surprised because i feel that most people believe that NFG's best work isn't there self titled. Plus, Stay What You Are is beloved on this site (i believe it was around #23 on the music fourms favorite 40 album list).

[GetUpNotGhetto]

The only thing is, the two albums have a totally different sound from one another. I believe you'll enjoy it, a lot.

every one of STD's albums has its own sound...thats kindda the reason they are so timeless...when you have a band that tweaks their sound a little bit everyone bitches 'its not like the original' but when they stay exactly the same its boring to buy the same album again. STD's releases each album with their own unique sound and feel to it, so each on is refreshing in their own way. i think SWYA is the best one, but in reverie has an even nicer sound at some times. their even earlier stuff i never got into cause it was poorly recorded really fast pop punk, but the b-sides cd is fantastic, and anything they play acoustic is near perfection.

[delvec19]

Never liked Saves The Day...the singer always sounded like a girl to me.

[IWasaCamera]

Which one is less dreadful?
Honestly couldn't say. I'd cringe at being forced to listen to either.

[carnotaurhunter]

Some girls are crazy!

Just listen to what I have to say about it!

[peterock]

stay what you are definitely. i would choose Nothing Gold Can Saty over Nfg's self titled anyday also....

[anamericangod]

New Found Glory gets played alllllllllllllllll the time still.

[Protested Hero]

Lightning bolts again. We become firefliessssss

[Protested Hero]

Two dreadful albums.

Haha. You're so queer. I don't think I've ever seen you post something positive.

[atticusfinch]

The person who said they haven't heard SWYA makes me feel really old. hahaha.

Anyway, SWYA>NFG s/t by a mile, especially since I got to see Saves the Day play the whole thing in order recently. AMAZING. Such a great live band.

But so is NFG. I'd go with Sticks and Stones as their best.

[IWasaCamera]

Haha. You're so queer. I don't think I've ever seen you post something positive.
You clearly need to read more threads.

[MyNameIsRoss]

Wow, tough, both mean so much to me, and take me back to a simpler time.But I would have to say STD.

[fulltiltxb00gie]

nfg i can listen through for hours on end. stay what you are just gets boring.

[SoCoSquid4]

i still listen to this NFG album every few weeks. cant resist.

[White Noise]

Never really been fond of either. But I like SWYA a little more I think.

[midtown4657]

saves the day. but if it were nothing gold can stay? NFG.

[smelltheglove]

if this was betweeen NFG-s/t and "through being cool", I woudl have voted for 'through being cool", however, NFG's S/t is the more classic in my opinion when compared to SWYA

Ah, to be 20 again and see NFG/Alk3/STD on the same bill for $10...one can dream

[myplasticyou]

nothing gold can stay vs. stay what you are might be a different story, but in this case, swya def takes it

[untitled94]

Nfgnfgnfgnfgnfg

[allthruwinter]

Goddamn this is a good poll. Really hard choice, but I picked Stay
What You Are, because that's probably my favorite album of all time. And while I do think self titled is NFG's best album, and I still listen to it all of the time, it doesn't get to me the way that Stay What You Are always does.

[hockeyguitar99]

i love new found glory

but the STD album is just amazing

[dubey]

There is only one correct answer to this poll and it's STD.

[bobby runs]

NFG!!!

I spin that shit like once a week.

[bobby runs]

Neither are even remotely timeless.
What is more timeless than in relation to the genre and time.

[aircourtneys]

Saves the Day 100%.No questions asked

[TKTKrob]

Stay What You Are is just a more timeless album. It's more original as well. When people look back on the genre, NFG's s/t will blend in much more with their contemporaries than Stay What You Are will.

[SingleDoubt]

Neither.

I have not heard either of these albums.

ha. fail.

[whiteboypain]

Neither.

I have not heard either of these albums.

you're kidding i hope..

[whiteboypain]

i love them both a ton, but stay what you are is my favorite album of any album, period.

[SwishMX48]

NFG self titled initially got me really into the type of music I listen to today, but as far as timeless goes I'd have to say Stay What You Are destroys it. I think Sticks and Stones is the most timeless NFG album for me, I will be listening to that every summer non-stop for a long time I'm sure.

[bobby runs]

NFG self titled initially got me really into the type of music I listen to today, but as far as timeless goes I'd have to say Stay What You Are destroys it. I think Sticks and Stones is the most timeless NFG album for me, I will be listening to that every summer non-stop for a long time I'm sure.
i think s/t will always have a place in my heart and then coming home its easily their most underrated album.

[MADSTA]

you're kidding i hope..
Nope!

[Redsox255]

for me a tougher call would be sticks and stones v. stay what you are. gotta go w/ swya

[Alex DiVincenzo]

Nfg

[passingtime49]

every one of STD's albums has its own sound...thats kindda the reason they are so timeless...when you have a band that tweaks their sound a little bit everyone bitches 'its not like the original' but when they stay exactly the same its boring to buy the same album again. STD's releases each album with their own unique sound and feel to it, so each on is refreshing in their own way. i think SWYA is the best one, but in reverie has an even nicer sound at some times. their even earlier stuff i never got into cause it was poorly recorded really fast pop punk, but the b-sides cd is fantastic, and anything they play acoustic is near perfection.
You should check out a song called "The Choke" off of their album "Can't Slow Down".

[passingtime49]

Did anyone else realize that Lionel Richie has albums titled, "Coming Home" and "Can't Slow Down" in his catalog ? Weird.

[atainder]

Swya!

[lftcoastenvy05]

NFG of course

[zerock]

Stay what you are definitely.

[screamoutmyname]

2 of my favorites... gotta go with saves the day, though...