When will Rolling Stone learn how to review hip hop....

[live.]

Lil Wayne - The Carter III 4.5/5
http://www.rollingstone.com/reviews/album/21080575/review/21127308/tha_carter_iii


I'm sorry.
no it's not.

[Nevuk]

haha. Rolling Stone has always been a fairly shitty music review source.

[Tyler Revolution]

As of right now I would give it a 3.5, but I'm almost positive with the way it's growing on me it'll end up being a 4.

[IWasaCamera]

Because Rolling Stone reviews albums from other genres so adequately.

[chipdip18]

My friend bought it today and played it nonstop. It's not so bad actually. I was pleasantly surprised. Some very weak tracks, like that awful single Lollipop.

[Yes. And?]

When people stop caring about Rolling Stone?


















Hmmmm.

[TheOtherAndrew]

Because Rolling Stone reviews albums from other genres so adequately.
This.

[xBITCHxPLEASEx]

When people stop caring about Rolling Stone?


















Hmmmm.


the only reason I get it in the mail is because we're out of toilet paper.

[thespearkid]

Haven't heard this album yet but I sincerely doubt Lil Wayne is the best rapper alive.

[Angylion Gefell]

Why do you expect RS to do something well?

[chipdip18]

Haven't heard this album yet but I sincerely doubt Lil Wayne is the best rapper alive.

Duh. There are way better rappers.

[Dre Okorley]

RS is always disappointing. That top 100 guitarists list was just pathetic..

[Ouch]

the only reason I get it in the mail is because we're out of toilet paper.

lol.

[Ouch]

RS is always disappointing. That top 100 guitarists list was just pathetic..

Agreed.

Top 100 guitar songs, but it still sucked as a list.

I mean, "Teen Spirit" in the top 10, fuck that.

[Dre Okorley]

Yeah, actually that might of been the list I was thinking of...either way, it's ridiculous--all of their "best and worsts" "tops and leasts".

[Ouch]

They've never been any good at anything.

[kearn1tm]

When people stop caring about Rolling Stone?


















Hmmmm.

Many already have. Most generations born within the '80s don't really look at Rolling Stone as the epitome of the "Rock & Roll spirit" that generations that predate us do. It was the zeitgeist of the times in the late '60s through the beginning of the '80s. However, I'd be hard pressed to find anyone under the age of 28 or so who actually held RS in the esteem our parents did.

[stereomouse]

rolling stone sucks in general, end of story.

[Ouch]

rolling stone sucks in general, end of story.

The best thing said all day.

[hockeyguitar99]

the only reason I get it in the mail is because we're out of toilet paper.


ZING

[hockeyguitar99]

Rolling Stone is a magazine a pay any sort of attention to, however i do like this album, its actually pretty good.