PDA

View Full Version : All Time Low - So Wrong, It's Right


go go gadget!
07/09/08, 07:10 PM
All Time Low - So Wrong, It’s Right
Record Label: Hopeless Records
Release Date: September 25, 2007

Clothing company sponsors and screaming 14-year olds aside, All Time Low is a pop-punk band. And it shows: their first full-length, So Wrong, It’s Right[/I}, is 40+ minutes of catchy riffs, fast-paced rock and gang background vocals.

Kicking off with “This Is How We Do,” All Time Low draws heavy influence from bands like New Found Glory and blink-182. The opener’s rapid guitars and soaring vocals set the tone for the rest of the twelve-song record. Singles “Dear Maria, Count Me In” and “Six Feet Under the Stars” are stellar, and the cough preceding a sample of the quartet's staple guitar riffs at the beginning of “Dear Maria” makes for a creative beginning. No song really stands out as the worst, because they all sound the same; they’re all mildly enjoyable, but containing nothing particularly striking. However, “Let It Roll,” the second track and an easy sing-a-long, quickly grew irritating. Call me cynical, but the happy-go-lucky chorus was grinding and repetitive.

Automatic Loveletter’s Juliet Simms joins vocalist Alex Gaskarth on “Remembering Sunday,” an acoustic love-lost number. A die hard fan may enjoy the slowed-down aspect of the song and Gaskarth’s forlorn vocals, but another listener could cringe at the melodramatic lyrics matched with Simms’ howling guest vocals.

While it’s bubbly and catchy, [I]So Wrong, It’s Right is fairly generic. “The Beach,” “Shameless,” and “Vegas” showcase its lack of originality with lyrics like “My friends are a different breed / My friends are everything.” The record itself is not a bad one: it’s an enjoyable romp dedicated to having fun. Working with pop-punk royalty Mark Hoppus on their second album will probably keep their sound in a similar vein, but hopefully boost their creative juices.

New Found Glory, pop punk, Fall Out Boy
myspace.com/alltimelow (http://www.myspace.com/alltimelow)

fadedmemories
07/11/08, 02:58 AM
well written review imo, cause some people find it so easy to rip this band to shreds, the rating should be higher though, the only lyrics you used as an example (of how it lacked originality) were from one song. btw swir is their second full length, the party scene was their first album

EchoPark
07/11/08, 06:51 AM
no word yet exists in the English language, slang or otherwise, to describe or encompass the shitiness of this band.

And yes to plagarise Chris Hannah of Propagandhi, I do recognize the irony in my statement as I know that the band and their eager and devoted fans couldn't care less about what I have to say.

ReedAreTheUnion
07/11/08, 07:32 AM
Haha if you didn't like the lyrics you definitely were not looking very deep...there's a very obvious hidden meaning (and also hidden theme) throughout each song and also the whole record.
Very funny once you give the lyrics a good listen with a bit of a dirty mind.

go go gadget!
07/11/08, 12:40 PM
well written review imo, cause some people find it so easy to rip this band to shreds, the rating should be higher though, the only lyrics you used as an example (of how it lacked originality) were from one song. btw swir is their second full length, the party scene was their first album
You're right, my mistake. And thank you!

Joe DeAndrea
07/12/08, 12:43 PM
Good review. :wave:

handlikesecret
07/14/08, 01:16 PM
well done.

RelientMayday
07/15/08, 12:34 AM
no word yet exists in the English language, slang or otherwise, to describe or encompass the shitiness of this band.

And yes to plagarise Chris Hannah of Propagandhi, I do recognize the irony in my statement as I know that the band and their eager and devoted fans couldn't care less about what I have to say.


Just because you do not like the band does not make them a "shitty" band as you seemed to put it. There is someone out there to hate every band but please do not think that your opinion of the band is the only one that matters. Everyone that I know loves this band and loves this CD. I think this CD is very well put together and is a very good representation of the genre of the band. This CD very well shows the pop-punk style of All Time Low. As for the slow song of the CD, the acoustic "Remembering Sunday", I personally love it. It shows a deeper side of All Time Low's usual upbeat, happy sound. But that is just my opinion.

All in all I think this is a definite up and coming band that will be huge one day. In my opinion, amazing band, amazing CD. But that's just me.

thesaddestfilm
07/15/08, 03:28 AM
lol @ this

get up kidd
07/17/08, 11:53 AM
There not THAT bad. Kinda...

ikikwe
07/17/08, 02:20 PM
Well written review. I completely agree with the lasting value score and the description of this album as "an enjoyable romp." Nice job.

birtcho
07/17/08, 03:03 PM
the ratings are way too low

BalancingacT
07/17/08, 04:51 PM
"Fairly generic"? What's your idea of "really generic"?

Not trying to sound mean; just stating a point.

gr33ndayfr3ak
07/17/08, 04:58 PM
this band does deserve more credit than this review gives them..
recording, selling [out?], and signing all aaround them age of being legal? that does take talent.
i compare this band to Panic, because they have one thing in common [and ONLY one thing..for the most part]: achieving so much success and getting shit on for it.
Panic's debut album went gold [i think?]. although they get so much crap for it, it takes an extreme amount of talent [plus a good amount of luck] to become so instantly popular.
it seems like the more popularity and success a band achieves, the more haters they get.

for what it's worth, this album has been stuck in my stereo since i got it, and for good reason.
if you like catchy pop-punk with moderately clever but extremely sing-along-able lyrics, this band is for you.
...although i dont quite see the FOB reference. lyrically, maybe a tiny bit. but to me, FOB is much more 'mature' [if you will..]

Cole06
07/17/08, 06:35 PM
I like that line from Vegas that you hated on :(

rpk004
07/17/08, 07:38 PM
i absolutely loved put up or shut up but i could never get into this because i couldn't find anything on the album that stood out. good review though.

jonnointherough
07/17/08, 07:44 PM
The score is accurate. Too many bands here get completely ridiculous high scores in reviews; to give this album an 80, or a 70 for that matter, would be a gross misunderstanding.

Good review.

cake eater
02/03/09, 07:44 AM
i just think of this album is as good ol' driving music.

UnderclasHero
06/11/10, 02:49 PM
How about greatest album of all time??