PDA

View Full Version : For Canadiens Only


Chris March
07/11/04, 07:54 PM
Northstar (http://www.northstarrock.com)'s video for For Members Only has been added to MTV Canada. But still, why isn't this band bigger with their latest release, Pollyanna?

ReFused23
07/11/04, 08:03 PM
agreed, awesome band

Soolastsummer5
07/11/04, 08:23 PM
I think they have gotten a bigger fan base. but i thought theyd blow up ? but w/e they fuckin rock still

ghostyouare
07/11/04, 08:40 PM
I think they didn't explode because pollyanna was one of the biggest disappointments of this year, The cd was nothing compared to "Is this thing loaded?"

threefeetdeep
07/11/04, 08:55 PM
pollyanna was an excellent cd. many great songs. there could have been more, but it was still awesome. sure, it wasn't is thing loaded?, but it was on par.

XPrettyXWasteX
07/11/04, 09:26 PM
Because people are dumbasses and don't know good music.

Anyways, regardless of whether you found Pollyanna to be a "disappointment" or not (which I firmly believe it was the latter), it is still a better record than most bands mentioned on this site could even hope to create.

Spaulding44
07/11/04, 09:34 PM
is it for Canadiens or Canadians only??????? cuz if its for just canadiens, thats only the the french part....if its for canadians its for all of us, i dont mind sharing with the americans

CROMagnon
07/11/04, 09:44 PM
I think they didn't explode because pollyanna was one of the biggest disappointments of this year, The cd was nothing compared to "Is this thing loaded?"
You're honestly the first person I've seen saying that. Nothing against that, I'm just saying.


But I do prefer Pollyanna to Is This Thing Loaded?, and Pollyanna, in my opinion, will probably end up as the most underrated of the year.

ProlongedIrony
07/11/04, 10:14 PM
why isn't this band bigger with their latest release, Pollyanna?

because they blow?

SmashUrGuitars
07/11/04, 10:25 PM
the recording quality on is this thing loaded sucked but it was still a great cd, though the choppy quality might have turned some off, just a thought.

WSUskee
07/11/04, 11:01 PM
Yeah I thought they would be bigger too they arent all that original kinda like a mix between Brand New and NFG but thats whats popular now so I thought this record would be big. Also the first 3 or 4 songs are really good and then its like whats this shit anyone else feel this way?

saintjoel
07/11/04, 11:14 PM
because the cd didnt get nearly enough distro or promo

NeverForever
07/12/04, 06:11 AM
Where can I see the video?

thursday112
07/12/04, 07:40 AM
I love Northstar, but if they want to get a bigger fanbase they need to get out there and tour some more for this new album. If they got on warped tour it prolly could have helped them a lot.

tshorty528
07/12/04, 08:08 AM
are you guys kidding? a disappointment? becuase they blow? is this some kind of joke? a mix between brand new and NEW FOUND Fing Glory? wow. Northstar's lyrics are probably right now the best in the business if not 2nd to geoff from thursday, the guitar parts are awesome strumming nothing too easy and well placed and written, the structures are amazing, the meanings are like 5 per each song, i feel sorry if you think northstar sucks, and i can't wait til you post about how awesome some underground band is because they didnt have a chorus in their song, and believe me i dont like stuff thats too poppy, northstar is amazing.

UrOwNdIsAsTer11
07/12/04, 08:33 AM
This album didn't blow up because everyone who DLed the album, didn't go out and buiy it. I heard some ridiculous figure like that the album was DLed 12,000 times... Thats alot of missing copies

XPrettyXWasteX
07/12/04, 08:59 AM
are you guys kidding? a disappointment? becuase they blow? is this some kind of joke? a mix between brand new and NEW FOUND Fing Glory? wow. Northstar's lyrics are probably right now the best in the business if not 2nd to geoff from thursday, the guitar parts are awesome strumming nothing too easy and well placed and written, the structures are amazing, the meanings are like 5 per each song, i feel sorry if you think northstar sucks, and i can't wait til you post about how awesome some underground band is because they didnt have a chorus in their song, and believe me i dont like stuff thats too poppy, northstar is amazing.
That's exactly what I was thinking.. these people are fools to say Northstar blows.

Both of Northstar's albums are incredible, the music and lyrics. They're amazing live as well and are/have been touring in promotion of Pollyanna. And from what I hear they tried to get on Warped but are only doing some "regional" Warped dates. They also have a full-page article in the current issue of Alternative Press.

They're completely underrated. And you all can say for whatever reason you want, not enough touring, not enough promotion.. so on, but maybe it's also because people have gotten lazy. Everyone wants to sit back and be spoon fed their "new favorite band" by some TV commercial.

OnLegendary21
07/12/04, 09:13 AM
The only reason I like Is This Thing Loaded over Pollyanna is because the songs could have been done much better. To My Better Angel on the Beer: The Movie soundtrack totally blows the album version away. It's like they recorded the album version right after they woke up, it's all sleepy.

CROMagnon
07/12/04, 09:30 AM
That Brand New/NFG comparison, well, that surprised me. Wow. Just wow.

LeftWideOpen
07/12/04, 12:13 PM
Northstar's lyrics are probably right now the best in the business if not 2nd to geoff from thursday.

While I agree with Northstar writing excellent lyrics, as does Geoff from Thursday, I don't think Dustin from Thrice gets nowhere near enough credit for his words. I can't think of any frontman that is as eloquent as him. I know this isnt related to the post, but when I saw what you said I felt like sharing.

weworemasks
07/12/04, 01:15 PM
Because people are dumbasses and don't know good music.

Anyways, regardless of whether you found Pollyanna to be a "disappointment" or not (which I firmly believe it was the latter), it is still a better record than most bands mentioned on this site could even hope to create.

hey, you are awesome. bye.

as of today, pollyanna is the best record ive heard all year. northstar is one of the best bands around. not only do they write fucking amazing songs, they kick your ass live. i love this band.

Darren McLeod
07/12/04, 05:04 PM
ETID has the best lyrics in my opinion. Logic Of Crocodiles is amazing. Thrice and Thursday also have great lyrics.

ghostyouare
07/12/04, 09:02 PM
While I agree with Northstar writing excellent lyrics, as does Geoff from Thursday, I don't think Dustin from Thrice gets nowhere near enough credit for his words. I can't think of any frontman that is as eloquent as him. I know this isnt related to the post, but when I saw what you said I felt like sharing.
Agreed. NO ONE and I mean NO ONE can hold a candle to him (i never understood that i just understand it, you understand that??)

ghostyouare
07/12/04, 09:10 PM
Also Chris Caraabra or whatever his name is before he touched an electric guitar all his lyrics were great.