Put Your Favorite Bands Albums in Order...

[notoaststereo]

...from best to worst.

Sorry if this has already been done before but I check the search function and nothing really came up.


Third Eye Blind: Third Eye Blind>Blue>Out of the Vein

Foo Fighters: The Colour and The Shape>There Is Nothing Left To Lose>One By One>Foo Fighters>Echoes Silence Patience and Grace>In Your Honor

Wilco: Yankee Hotel Foxtrot>Sky Blue Sky>Summerteeth>A Ghost Is Born>Being There>AM

Jimmy Eat World: Clarity>Futures>Stay On My Side Tonight EP>Bleed American>Chase This Light>Static Prevails

[SLoT]

This was done a while ago, I couldn't find it either though...

[notoaststereo]

This was done a while ago, I couldn't find it either though...then this could be a new one if the other one is gone.

[SLoT]

then this could be a new one if the other one is gone.
Right on.

Bayside: Bayside>Walking Wounded>Sirens and Condolences

Promise Ring: Nothing Feels Good>Wood/Water>Very Emergency>30 Degrees Everywhere

I would do MxPx, but they've got too much music for me to decide on while I'm at work.

[theguy77]

Brand New: Deja > TDAG >> demos >>> YFW

Thrice: TAI > Vheissu >>> IOS > TAITA >> IC

[bowl of oranges]

Bright Eyes: I'm Wide Awake... > Lifted > Cassadaga > Fevers... > Digital Ash... > Letting off the Happiness

Sigur Ros: Agaetis Byrjun > Takk... > ( ) > Von

Death Cab For Cutie: Transatlanticism > Plans > The Photo Album > Narrow Stairs > Something About Airplanes > We Have The Facts...

Iron & Wine: Our Endless Numbered Days > The Shepherd's Dog > The Creek Drank The Cradle

Modest Mouse: The Moon & Antarctica > The Lonesome Crowded West > Good News... > This Is A Long Drive... > We Were Dead...

mewithoutYou: [A-->B]: Life, Brother Sister, Catch For Us The Foxes

[ThisIsNotDan]

Foo Fighters: S/T = Colour and the Shape > There Is Nothing Left To Lose > In Your Honor = Echoes Silence Patience and Grace >>> One By One

Cave In: Jupiter = Antenna > Perfect Pitch Black > Tides Of Tomorrow EP > Until Your Heart Stops

Gatsbys American Dream: Volcano > Ribbons and Sugar > S/T > Land Of Lost Monsters > Why We Fight

Brand New: TDAG >>> Deja >>>>>>>>>>> YFW

Get Up Kids: Guilt Show > On A Wire > STWHA >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Four Minute Mile

[KatieKutthroat.]

The Beatles: Abbey Road > Revolver > Sgt. Pepper's > Let it Be > Rubber Soul > The Beatles (The White Album) > Magical Mystery Tour > A Hard Day's Night > Help! > With the Beatles > Beatles for Sale > Please Please Me

The Doors (yeah, i know they're overrated and not that great and whatnot, but I still like 'em): The Doors > The Morrison Hotel > LA Woman > Waiting For the Sun > Strange Days >> The Soft Parade >> everything after Morrison's death

[wewascontenders]

Saves the Day: Stay What You Are > Through Being Cool > Can't Slow Down > Sound the Alarm > In Reverie > Under the Boards

The Get Up Kids: Something to Write Home About > Guilt Show > Four Minute Mile > On a Wire > Eudora

American Nightmare: We're Down Till We're Underground > Background Music > Year One

[Anderson]

Boy Sets Fire - After The Eulogy, Misery Index, The Day The Sun Went Out, This Crying This Screaming, Tomorrow Come Today

[daftknight]

Mae: Destination: Beautiful > The Everglow > Singularity > Destination: B-Sides

Anberlin: NTFP > Cities > Blueprints > Lost Songs

Copeland: Beneath Medicine Tree > In Motion > Eat Sleep Repeat > Know Nothing Stays the Same
(I'm omitting Know Nothing Stays the Same only because I haven't purchased it yet...)

[cscwell107]

This is way too hard

[IWasaCamera]

Nick Drake: Pink Moon >>>>>> Bryter Layter >>>>> Five Leaves Left

Bonnie "Prince" Billy: I See A Darkness > Master And Everyone > Lie Down In The Light > Superwolf > The Letting Go > Ease Down The Road > Sings Greatest Palace Music > The Brave And The Bold

Bob Dylan: Highway 61 Revisited > Blonde On Blonde > Bringing It All Back Home > Nashville Skyline > The Freewheelin' Bob Dylan > Desire > Blood On The Tracks > Another Side Of Bob Dylan > John Wesley Harding > New Morning > Love And Theft > The Times They Are A-Changin' and so on.

Neil Young: After The Gold Rush > On The Beach > Comes A Time > Harvest Moon > Tonight's The Night > Rust Never Sleeps > Everybody Knows This Is Nowhere > Harvest > Hawks & Doves > Times Fades Away and so on.


Too much work so I'll stop here.

[Renee]

Saves the Day: Stay What You Are > Through Being Cool > Can't Slow Down > Sound the Alarm > In Reverie > Under the Boards

The Get Up Kids: Something to Write Home About > Guilt Show > Four Minute Mile > On a Wire

American Nightmare: We're Down Till We're Underground > Background Music > Year One
Eudora?

[wewascontenders]

Eudora?

how dare you point out my mistake. anywho, eudora goes last.

[Regards]

This was done a while ago, I couldn't find it either though...
It was done in the general, but not here.

mewithoutYou - Brother Sister > A --> B Life > Catch For Us The Foxes.

[Renee]

how dare you point out my mistake. anywho, eudora goes last.
:-p I only really like a handful of songs from Eudora and Four Minute Mile, so it's understandable.




I guess EPs aren't counting here?

[Dr. Acula]

Cause Im bored.

Radiohead: Ok Computer > Kid A > In Rainbows > The Bends > Hail to the Thief > Amnesiac > Pablo Honey

Wilco: Yankee Hotel Foxtrot > Being There > A Ghost is Born > Sky Blue Sky > Summer Teeth > AM

AFI: Sing The Sorrow > Art of Drowning > Black Sails in the Sunset > Shut Your Mouth and Open Your Eyes > DecemberUnderground > Very Proud of Ya > Answer That and Stay Fashionable

Thursday: War All The Time > A City By The Light Divided > Full Collapse > Waiting

Brand New: The Devil and God are Raging Inside Me > Deja Entandu > Your Favorite Weapon

Bright Eyes: Im Wide Awake, It's Morning > Lifted > Cassadaga > Fevers and Mirrors > Digital Ash > Letting Off The Happiness

Fugazi: Red Medicine > Repeater > 13 Songs > The Argument > Steady Diet of Nothing > End Hits (the albums I have)

Rocket From The Crypt: Scream, Dracula Scream > RFTC > Group Sounds > Hot Charity/Cut Carefully > Circa:Now! > Live From Camp X-Ray > Paint as a Fragrance

The Hold Steady: Boys and Girls in America > Stay Positive > Seperation Sunday > Almost Killed Me

Nick Drake: Pink Moon > Bryter Layter > Five Leaves Left

Hot Water Music: Forever and Counting > No Division > Fuel for the Hate Game > Caution > A Flight and a Crash > The New What Next

Jawbreaker: 24 Hr Revenge Therapy > Dear You > Bivouac > Unfun

[Circa1628]

im not counting most EP's or cover albums and live stuff, etc.


Third Eye Blind

1.S/T
2.Out Of The Vein
3.Blue

Saves the Day

1. Through Being Cool
2. Stay What You Are
3. Under The Boards
4. Sound The Alarm
5. In Reverie
6. Can't Slow Down

Senses Fail

1. Let It Enfold You
2. From Depths Of Dreams
3. Still Searching

Thrice

1. Illusion of Safety
2. Artist In The Ambulance
3. Alchemy 1 + 2
4. Vheissu
5. Alchemy 3 + 4
6. Identity Crisis

Armor For Sleep

1. What To Do When You're Dead
2. Smile For Them
3. Dream To Make Believe

The Used

1. S/T
2. Lies For The Liars
3. In Love And Death

Atreyu

1. The Curse
2. Suicide Notes and Butterfly Kisses
3. Deathgrip On Tommorow
4. Lead Papers Sails Anchor

Goo Goo Dolls

1. Dizzy Up The Girl
2. A Boy Named Goo
3. Gutterflower
4. Let Love In
5. Superstar Car Wash
6. Hold Me Up
7. Jed
8. S/T

New Found Glory

1. S/T
2. Nothing Gold Can Stay
3. Sticks and Stones
4. Coming Home
5. Catalyst


Thursday

1. Full Collapse
2. War All The Time
3. A City By The Light Divided
4. Waiting

Taking Back Sunday

1. Where You Want To Be
2. Tell All Your Friends
3. Louder Now

Dashboard Confessional

1. The Places You Have Come To Fear The Most
2. Swiss Army Romance
3. The Shade Of Poison Trees
4. Dusk & Summer
5. A Mark, A Mission, A Brand, A Scar

Deftones

1. White Pony
2. Saturday Night Wrist
3. Around The Fur
4. S/T
5. Adrenaline

Dredg

1. Catch Without Arms
2. El Cielo
3. Leitmotif

Poison The Well

1. Opposite Of December
2. Versions
3. Tears From The Red
4. You Come Before You
5. Distance Makes The Heart Grow Fonder



thats it for now

[kearn1tm]

The Fall: Hex Enduction Hour > Dragnet > The Wonderful and Frightening World of The Fall > Room To Live > The Unutterable > Grotesque (After the Gramme) > The Frenz Experience > Live at the Witch Trials > the rest

Kaki King: Legs to Make Us Longer > Dreaming of Revenge > Everybody Loves You > ...Until We Felt Red

Elvis Costello (and various): This Year's Model > Get Happy!! > My Aim is True > Imperial Bedroom > Brutal Youth > Armed Forces > Spike > Almost Blue > When I Was Cruel > Painted From Memory > Momofuku > The Sweetest Punch (with Bill Frisell) > the rest

Pretty Girls Make Graves: Good Health > The New Romance > Elan Vital

Iron & Wine: The Shepherd's Dog > Woman King (EP, but Jezebel is one of the best songs he's written and merits its inclusion as was much better than the other two LPs) > The Creek Drank the Cradle > Our Endless Numbered Days

[SLoT]

wow. i seem to disagree with a bunch of these. oh well.

[notoaststereo]

Thrice: TIOS>TAITA>Vhiessu>TAI3+4>TAI1+2>IC

[Chromefox]

In order of personal preference:

Brand New: TDAG > Deja > YFW

Radiohead: In Rainbows > Kid A > OK Computer > Amnesiac = HTTT > The Bends > Pablo Honey

Muse: Black Holes and Revelations > Origin of Symmetry > Absolution > Showbiz

[Circa1628]

Thrice: TIOS>TAITA>Vhiessu>TAI3+4>TAI1+2>IC

this is pretty close to mine

[doyouhas?]

In order of personal preference:

Brand New: TDAG > Deja > YFW

Radiohead: In Rainbows > Kid A > OK Computer > Amnesiac = HTTT > The Bends > Pablo Honey

Muse: Black Holes and Revelations > Origin of Symmetry > Absolution > Showbiz

really? this doesnt make any sense. the only acceptable answer for this is if youre just not very old and youre most familiar with in rainbows.

[Circa1628]

really? this doesnt make any sense. the only acceptable answer for this is if youre just not very old and youre most familiar with in rainbows.


...or it's personal preference

[Gwytherspoon]

Alkaline Trio- Goddamnit> Maybe I'll Catch Fire> Good Mourning>Self-Titled> Remains> From Here To Infirmary> Agony and Irony.> Crimson.
Glassjaw- Everything you ever wanted to know about silence> worship and tribute

I would do the cure but id be here all day.

[bowl of oranges]

Bright Eyes: Im Wide Awake, It's Morning > Lifted > Cassadaga > Fevers and Mirrors > Digital Ash > Letting Off The Happiness:highfive:
Our Bright Eyes lists match!

[Troggy]

Thrice

1. Illusion of Safety
2. Artist In The Ambulance


New Found Glory

1. S/T
2. Nothing Gold Can Stay
3. Sticks and Stones
4. Coming Home
5. Catalyst

Poison The Well

1. Opposite Of December
2. Versions
3. Tears From The Red
4. You Come Before You
5. Distance Makes The Heart Grow Fonder

I like the Thrice and NFG, I feel the same way. The best PTW album is You Come Before You, but even if it is not your favorite there is no way Versions or Tears is better. I would accept it at #2 if Opposite of December is the top choice. Discuss.

Pretty Girls Make Graves: Good Health > The New Romance > Elan Vital

Iron & Wine: The Shepherd's Dog > Woman King (EP, but Jezebel is one of the best songs he's written and merits its inclusion as was much better than the other two LPs) > The Creek Drank the Cradle > Our Endless Numbered Days

Are you trying to make me angry? ;-)


Incubus: Morning View > Make Yourself > Light Grenades > Crow > SCIENCE > Enjoyincubus > Fungus Amongus

[S9Dallasoz]

Anberlin: NTFP > Cities > Blueprints > Lost Songs



I like that.

Butch Walker - Left of Self-centered > Letters > The Rise & Fall...

Jimmy Eat World - Bleed American > Futures > Chase This Light > Clarity > Static Prevails

Stroke 9 - Rip It Off > Nasty Little Thoughts > Last of the Intl. Playboys > All In

Sugarcult - Lights Out > Start Static > Palm Trees

Black Lab - see The Sun > Passion Leaves a Trace > Your Body Above Me

Brand New - Devil & God > Deja > YFW

Bunch of other bands with 1 or 2 albums - Thriving Ivory, Radford, Audrye Sessions, Innerpartysystem...

[theguy77]

Thrice

1. Illusion of Safety
2. Artist In The Ambulance
3. Alchemy 1 + 2
4. Vheissu
5. Alchemy 3 + 4
6. Identity Crisis


Thrice: TIOS>TAITA>Vhiessu>TAI3+4>TAI1+2>IC
FAILLLLL

[Neo Cassady]

The Ataris: Blue Skies > End is Forever > So Long, Astoria > Welcome the Night > Anywhere But Here

Bright Eyes: this:I'm Wide Awake... > Lifted > Cassadaga > Fevers... > Digital Ash... > Letting off the Happiness

Thursday: War All the Time > Full Collapse > ACBTLD > Waiting

Thrice: TAITA > Alchemy > Vhiessu > Illusion of Safety > Identity Crisis

[hailthewarrior]

Thrice:

TAITA > Vheissu > Water > Air > TIOS > Earth > Tracks 2-4 of Fire > IC > Fire 1, 5, 6 > First EP

Emery:

The Weak's End > The Question > I'm Only A Man

Underoath:

DTGL > TOCS > TCOT > Survive, K > COTP > AOD

Brand New:

TDAG > DEJA > YFW

Anberlin:

Cities = NTFP > Blueprints > Lost Songs

Copeland:

BMT > IM = ESR

mewithoutYou:

Brother, Sister > A-B Life > Catch For Us The Foxes

[versus_god]

Descendents
1. Milo Goes To College
2. I Don't Wanna Grow Up
3. Everything Sucks
4. Cool To Be You
5. All
6. Enjoy!

Dead Kennedys
1. Fresh Fruit For Rotting Vegetables
2. In God We Trust
3. Plastic Surgery Disasters
4. Give Me Convenience Or Give Me Death
5. Frankenchrist
6. Bedtime For Democracy

Hot Water Music
1. No Division
2. Caution
3. Forever And Counting
4. Fuel For The Hate Game
5. A Flight And A Crash
6. The New What Next
7. Finding The Rhythms

The Lawrence Arms
1. The Greatest Story Ever Told
2. Apathy And Exhaustion
3. Oh! Calcutta!
4. Cocktails & Dreams
5. Ghost Stories
6. A Guided Tour Of Chicago

[Carlo Marx]

Propagandhi - Today's Empires, Tomorrow's Ashes > Potemkin City Limits > Less Talk More Rock > How To Clean Everything

[Carlo Marx]

Dillinger Four - Midwestern Songs of The Americas > Vs. God > Situationist Comedy > This Shit is Genius

[hailthewarrior]

Thursday: War All the Time > Full Collapse > ACBTLD > Waiting

I agree! :highfive:

[versus_god]

Propagandhi - Today's Empires, Tomorrow's Ashes > Potemkin City Limits > Less Talk More Rock > How To Clean Everything

Dillinger Four - Midwestern Songs of The Americas > Vs. God > Situationist Comedy > This Shit is Genius
I was going to do both of these but I'm too indecisive.

[Neo Cassady]

I agree! :highfive:

:woot:



The Weakerthans: Reconstruction Site > Reuinion Tour > Left and Leaving > Fallow
...but the first 3 are extremely close.

[Carlo Marx]

I was going to do both of these but I'm too indecisive.

yeah, i was shocked to see you didn't do d4, so i jumped on that one pretty quick.

[Carlo Marx]

:woot:



The Weakerthans: Reconstruction Site > Reuinion Tour > Left and Leaving > Fallow
...but the first 3 are extremely close.

disagree.

I'd have to go with Left & Leaving > Reconstruction Site > Reunion Tour > Fallow

[rorschach]

Against Me!: As the Eternal Cowboy> New Wave> Reinventing Axl Rose> Searching for a Former Clarity

Brand New: TDAG> Deja> YFW

Say Anything: ...Is a Real Boy> IDOTG> Baseball> Menora/Majora

Every Time I Die: Hot Damn> Gutter Phenomenon> The Big Dirty (Havnt heard Last Night in Town)

Radiohead: OK Computer>The Bends>Amnesiac>Hail to the Thief> Kid A> In Rainbows> Pablo Honey

The Hold Steady: Seperation Sunday> Boys & Girls in America> Stay Positive

Blink 182: Dude Ranch> Enema> S/T> TOYPAJ

Jawbreaker: 24 Hour Revenge Therapy> Dear You> Unfun> Biovauc

Kanye West: Late Registration> Graduation> College Dropout

[Neo Cassady]

Blink 182: Dude Ranch> Enema> S/T> TOYPAJ

Cheshire? Buddha?

[thespearkid]

Say Anything: ...Is a Real Boy > IDOTG > Baseball > Junior Varsity > Menora/Mejora

Weezer: Pinkerton > The Blue Album > The Red Album > The Green Album > Make Believe > Maladroit (I wanted to include Songs from the Black Hole but since it was never officially released...)

The Beatles: Revolver > The White Album > Sgt. Pepper > Abbey Road > Rubber Soul > Let It Be > Everything Else

Kanye West: Late Registration > The College Dropout > Graduation

The Matches: Decomposer > A Band in Hope > E. Von Dahl

The White Stripes: White Blood Cells > Elephant > Icky Thump > De Stijl > Get Behind Thee Satan > The White Stripes

Doing this made me notice that a lot of the bands I like only have one or two albums.

[rorschach]

Cheshire? Buddha?

I cant really speak on releases I haven't heard yet. Which is also why The Hold Steady's debut album isn't listed either.

[Neo Cassady]

I cant really speak on releases I haven't heard yet. Which is also why The Hold Steady's debut album isn't listed either.

Ah, gotcha. Cheshire Cat will not disappoint.

[Chris Fallon]

Less Than Jake:Hello Rockview > Losing Streak > Borders and Boundaries > GNV FLA > Anthem > B Is For B-Sides > Pezcore > In With The Out Crowd

Marvelous 3: Ready Sex Go > Hey! Album > Math & Other Problems

Lagwagon: Blaze > Hoss > Let's Talk About Feelings > Resolve > Double Plaidinum > Let's Talk About Leftovers > Duh > Trashed

EDIT: Troggy, thank you for reminding me of the b-sides record! duh!

[versus_god]

Resolve > Hoss > Blaze > Let's Talk About Feelings > Double Plaidinum > Let's Talk About Leftovers > Trashed > Duh

:-0

[Troggy]

Less Than Jake:Hello Rockview > Losing Streak > Borders and Boundaries > GNV FLA > Anthem > Pezcore > In With The Out Crowd

Less Than Jake: Hello Rockview > Losing Streak > Anthem > B is for B Sides > Borders and Boundaries > GNV FLA > Pezcore > In With The Out Crowd

:nod:

[versus_god]

Losing Streak > Hello Rockview > Pezcore > GNV FLA > Anthem > Borders and Boundaries > In With The Out Crowd

[Chris Fallon]

Love you both.

[Troggy]

Love you both.

Plenty of ways to arrange LTJ albums but I really do like Anthem, it's great.

The Black Keys: Rubber Factory > Thickfreakness > Big Come Up > Magic Potion > Attack & Release

[Chris Fallon]

I actually like every LTJ record... even IWTOC. Just not as high on my list as others.

[Kid B]

really? this doesnt make any sense. the only acceptable answer for this is if youre just not very old and youre most familiar with in rainbows.
...Yes it does.

[Kid B]

Say Anything: ...Is a Real Boy > IDOTG > Baseball > Junior Varsity > Menora/Mejora

Weezer: Pinkerton > Songs from the Black Hole > The Blue Album > The Red Album > The Green Album > Make Believe > Maladroit

The Beatles: Revolver > The White Album > Sgt. Pepper > Abbey Road > Rubber Soul > Let It Be > Everything Else

Kanye West: Late Registration > The College Dropout > Graduation

The Matches: Decomposer > A Band in Hope > E. Von Dahl

The White Stripes: White Blood Cells > Elephant > Icky Thump > De Stijl > Get Behind Thee Satan > The White Stripes

Doing this made me notice that a lot of the bands I like only have one or two albums.
Pshh this is impossible. Never been leaked or released. It would be a huge deal if it was.

[Chris Fallon]

Yeah, I would not count that as a Weezer release. Rank the albums that have been officially released.

[Kid B]

It's got like 40 songs. He's either lying or wrong. The closest he could be is Alone: The Home Recordings of Rivers Cuomo. Maybe Pinkerton. Either way, he's wrong.

[Chris Fallon]

I count Weezer releases. Six albums. That's it haha

Imagine how many albums that were never released you could count then? That's cheating.

[thespearkid]

Pshh this is impossible. Never been leaked or released. It would be a huge deal if it was.
Every song from the collection has had it's demo leaked with the exception of one. Lots of people have put together fan interpretations made up from the demos. I downloaded one of them.

http://www.albumsix.com/bboard/viewtopic.php?f=8&t=1836

[Kid B]

Yeah but that still isn't SFTBH. I will be downloading one of those though lol.

[thespearkid]

I count Weezer releases. Six albums. That's it haha

Imagine how many albums that were never released you could count then? That's cheating.
Again, with the exception of one song, all the demos are floating around and Rivers finished the album so I count it as a lost album. But if it matters at all, I'll edit the post.

[Chris Fallon]

Still not a proper album. That's a separate category.

[thespearkid]

Yeah but that still isn't SFTBH. I will be downloading one of those though lol.
I know but it's amazing so I counted it.

[Kid B]

I know but it's amazing so I counted it.
Hey, that link doesn't work. Is there anywhere else I could find it?

[makeasound]

This is really hard. Haha.
But a lot of fun to really sit and think about the records and which ones you listen to the most.

Autopilot Off
Make A Sound > Looking Up > Autopilot Off EP > All Bets Off EP > Cooter/Slick Shoes split EP

Over It
Step Outside Yourself > The Strand > Silverstrand > Timing Is Everything > Outer Banks > Welcome To Virginia: The Ready Series

New Found Glory
Sticks & Stones > New Found Glory > From The Screen To Your Stereo pt. 2 > Catalyst > Nothing Gold Can Stay > Tip of the Iceburg > From The Screen To Your Stereo > Coming Home > It's All About The Girls EP

The Monkees (not counting the tons of greatest hits/boxsets/bsides records, just their actual albums)
Pisces, Aquarius, Capricorn, & Jones, ltd > The Monkees > Headquarters > More of the Monkees > Instant Replay > The Birds, The Bees, and The Monkees > Head > Pool It > The Monkees Present: Micky, David, Michael > Justus > Changes

Sugarcult
Palm Trees & Powerlines > Lights Out > Start Static > Wrap Me Up In Plastic

The Beatles
A Hard Days Night! > Revolver > Beatles for Sale > Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Heart's Club Band > Rubber Soul > Abbey Road > Past Masters vol.2 > Help! > Let It Be > Magical Mystery Tour > The Beatles > Love > Past Masters vol.1 > With The Beatles > Yellow Submarine > Please Please Me

Lostprophets
Start Something > The Fake Sound of Progress > Liberation Transmission

Good Charlotte
Good Charlotte > The Chronicles of Life & Death > The Young And The Hopeless > Good Morning Revival

[Chris Fallon]

The Monkees hahaha

I can't believe you put AHDN as your favorite Beatles album. That takes a pair.

[Kid B]

He put Beatles For Sale Before Abbey Road, Let It Be, and MMT!

[Chris Fallon]

Yeah, not feeling that list. Abbey Road is my favorite followed by Sgt. Pepper ... their early stuff can't hold a candle to the stuff they did after 1966.

[mouood]

Blink-182 - Dude Ranch > EOTS > Untitled > TOYPAJ > Cheshire Cat > Buddha

Saves The Day - Stay What You Are > Through Being Cool > In Reverie > Can't Slow Down > Sound The Alarm > Under The Boards

Jimmy Eat World - Futures > Clarity > Bleed American > Chase This Light > Static Prevails

Radiohead - OK Computer > Kid A > In Rainbows > HTTT > The Bends > Amnesiac > Pablo Honey

[makeasound]

The Monkees hahaha

I can't believe you put AHDN as your favorite Beatles album. That takes a pair.
I know it's definitely not the popular opinion. But it's the one that contains the largest amount of my favorite songs in their catalog, so I put it on top because of that.

[Chris Fallon]

It's all good :-)

[notoaststereo]

FAILLLLLhaha, whats yours.

EDIT: i saw it on the front page. eh, i like the older stuff because it was the time i started getting into this kind of music. but thrice has always been releasing solid music. my no means to i think any of their albums are bad. some are just better.

[Genuma]

Songs From The Black Hole release with the whole band performing it plz. That would blow my mind. And probably not work at all.

[francescaa]

brand new - deja entendue > devil and god > your favourite weapon

something corporate - leaving through the window > north > audioboxer

taking back sunday - tell all your friends > where you want to be > louder now

anberlin - never take friendship personal > blueprints > cities

[thespearkid]

Hey, that link doesn't work. Is there anywhere else I could find it?
I wouldn't know. If you've got aim, I could sign on right quick and send it to you.

Songs From The Black Hole release with the whole band performing it plz. That would blow my mind. And probably not work at all.
A lot of the songs have the full band already. I'd love to hear a mixed and mastered version too though.

[francescaa]

Blink-182 - Dude Ranch > EOTS > Untitled > TOYPAJ > Cheshire Cat > Buddha

Saves The Day - Stay What You Are > Through Being Cool > In Reverie > Can't Slow Down > Sound The Alarm > Under The Boards

Jimmy Eat World - Futures > Clarity > Bleed American > Chase This Light > Static Prevails

Radiohead - OK Computer > Kid A > In Rainbows > HTTT > The Bends > Amnesiac > Pablo Honey



I'd swap through being cool and stay what you are - I just think through being cool is a damn near perfect pop punk album.

[Genuma]

Lagwagon - Blaze, Resolve, Hoss, Let's Talk About Feelings, Double Plaidinum, Let's Talk About Leftovers, Trashed, Duh

Weezer - Pinkerton, Blue Album, Green Album, Maladroit, Red Album, Make Believe

Butch Walker/Marvelous 3 - Letters, ReadySexGo, Left of Self-Centered, Hey! Album, Math and Other Problems ,Rise And Fall....

[wtfmates]

Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds - Tender Prey > The Boatmans Call > Let Love In > From Her To Eternity > Abatoir Blues/Lrye of Orpheus > No More Shall We Part > Henry's Dream > The Good Son > Dig, Lazerus, Dig > Your Funeral.... My Trial > Noctourama

Brand New - The Devil and God Are Raging Inside of Me > Deja > Favorite Weapon

The Blood Brothers - Burn, Piano Island, Burn > Crimes > Young Machetes > This Adultery is Ripe > March on Electric Children

Anberlin - Cities > Blueprints > Never Take Friendship Personal

Bright Eyes - Fevers and Mirrors > Lifted > I'm Wide Awake > Letting Off the Happiness > Cassadaga > Digital Ash > A Collection of Songs

[sandra92]

Linkin Park : Hybrid Theory > Hybrid Theory EP > Meteora > Reanimation > Minutes to Midnight
Blink-182 : Dude Ranch > Blink-182 > Enema of the State > Take off your pants and jacket > Cheshire cat > Buddah
Arctic Monkeys : Whatever people say I am , that's the way I am not > Favourite Worst Nigthmare

[nikaidoh]

Not my favorite bands, just the ones that come off the top of my head



Dead Kennedys- 1. Fresh Fruit for Rotting Vegetables> 2. Frankenchrist 3. Bedtime for Democracy> 4. Plastic Surgery Disasters

Sage Francis- 1. Personal Journals> 2. Hope> 3. Healthy Distrust> 4. Human The Death Dance

Lightning Bolt- 1. Wonderful Rainbow> 2. Hypermagic Mountain> 3. Ride the Skies> 4. Lightning Bolt

[wtfmates]

Not my favorite bands, just the ones that come off the top of my head



Dead Kennedys- 1. Fresh Fruit for Rotting Vegetables> 2. Frankenchrist 3. Bedtime for Democracy> 4. Plastic Surgery Disasters

Sage Francis- 1. Personal Journals> 2. Hope> 3. Healthy Distrust> 4. Human The Death Dance

Lightning Bolt- 1. Wonderful Rainbow> 2. Hypermagic Mountain> 3. Ride the Skies> 4. Lightning Bolt



Nice, I would rate sage in the same exact order.

[wewascontenders]

Blood Brothers: March On Electric Children > Burn Piano Island > Rumors Laid Waste > Young Machetes > Crimes > This Adultery Is Ripe

[mouood]

I'd swap through being cool and stay what you are - I just think through being cool is a damn near perfect pop punk album.

I used to agree with you on that. Recently though, I've swapped them. SWYA just has some of my favorite STD songs: Firefly, This Is Not An Exit, Nightingale.

[nikaidoh]

Nice, I would rate sage in the same exact order.

oh hellz yea, i didn't even know there were any other strange famous fans on AP

[Mirrorsandfevers]

Bright Eyes: Digital Ash>Lifted>Fevers>Cassadaga>Awake>>>Happiness>Collection

[IWasaCamera]

The Beatles - Abbey Road > Sgt Peppers > Revolver > White Album > Rubber Soul > Let it Be.
Whoa when did this happen?

[chipdip18]

Bright Eyes: Digital Ash>Lifted>Fevers>Cassadaga>Awake>>>Happiness>Collection


Whoa Digital Ash is your number one? craziness.

[Mirrorsandfevers]

Whoa Digital Ash is your number one? craziness.

I really couldn't tell you why, but I enjoy it a lot.

[travisjeffery]

bright eyes.
I'm Wide Awake, It's Morning>Fevers & Mirrors>Lifted...>Digital Ash in a Digital Urn>Casadaga

circa survive
Juturna>On Letting Go

devil wears prada
Plagues>Dear Love: A Beautiful Discord

underoath
Cries of the Past>The Changing of Times>Act of Depression>Define the Great Line>They're Only Chasing Safety

[Neo Cassady]

bright eyes.
I'm Wide Awake, It's Morning>Fevers & Mirrors>Lifted...>Digital Ash in a Digital Urn>Casadaga

:eyebrow:

[chipdip18]

Haha well good for you! I like that album, and most people here do not like it at all.

[Chromefox]

really? this doesnt make any sense. the only acceptable answer for this is if youre just not very old and youre most familiar with in rainbows. Suck me; my taste is allowed to differ from everyone else's.

I didn't say In Rainbows was their best, I said it was in order of personal preference.

[liar23]

the format
dog problems>interventions and lullabies>b sides and rarities

[IWasaCamera]

Because I'm bored:

My Morning Jacket: At Dawn >>>>>>>>>>> Acoustic Citsuoca > It Still Moves > Z > Chocolate And Ice > The Tennessee Fire >>>> Evil Urges

Simon & Garfunkel: Bridge Over Troubled Water >> Sounds Of Silence > Bookends > Parsley, Sage, Rosemary, And Thyme >>> Wednesday Morning, 3 A.M.

Paul Simon: Still Crazy After All These Years > Paul Simon > The Rhythm Of The Saints > Graceland > There Goes Rhymin' Simon > Hearts And Bones

Belle & Sebastian: If You're Feeling Sinister > Dear Catastrophe Waitress > Tigermilk > The Boy With The Arab Strap > Storytelling > Fold Your Hands Child, You Walk Like A Peasant > The Life Pursuit

[Chris Fallon]

Lagwagon - Blaze, Resolve, Hoss, Let's Talk About Feelings, Double Plaidinum, Let's Talk About Leftovers, Trashed, Duh

Weezer - Pinkerton, Blue Album, Green Album, Maladroit, Red Album, Make Believe

Butch Walker/Marvelous 3 - Letters, ReadySexGo, Left of Self-Centered, Hey! Album, Math and Other Problems ,Rise And Fall....
You combined Butch... interesting, but nice.

I love your Lagwagon list, btw

[Genuma]

You combined Butch... interesting, but nice.

I love your Lagwagon list, btw
Swt! I didn't want to make seperate lists for the two, even though most people wouldn't have known the difference.

[Chris Fallon]

Swt! I didn't want to make seperate lists for the two, even though most people wouldn't have known the difference.
Yeah, I did just M3 but it's all goooood. You are still an American icon.

[Circa1628]

I like the Thrice and NFG, I feel the same way. The best PTW album is You Come Before You, but even if it is not your favorite there is no way Versions or Tears is better. I would accept it at #2 if Opposite of December is the top choice. Discuss.





I got into them when Opposite of December came out, next was Tears From The Red, so those two CD's have been huge for me because they have been out for a while now. The reason Versions is so high is because when I bought that I was addicted immediatly, a feeling I hadn't felt from one of their albums since Opposite. I thought Tears From The Red was solid, but it took more time to get into. It probably looks bad having You Come Before You so low, but low for PTW is high, if that makes sense. I love all their albums, it just took longer for me to get into You Come Before You. Don't get me wrong it has some epic songs (Ghostchant, Crystal Lake) but I usually listen to the other three before I listen to that CD. Trust me just because it's at four does not mean I don't think it's a great CD. Hope this clears it up.

[Troggy]

I got into them when Opposite of December came out, next was Tears From The Red, so those two CD's have been huge for me because they have been out for a while now. The reason Versions is so high is because when I bought that I was addicted immediatly, a feeling I hadn't felt from one of their albums since Opposite. I thought Tears From The Red was solid, but it took more time to get into. It probably looks bad having You Come Before You so low, but low for PTW is high, if that makes sense. I love all their albums, it just took longer for me to get into You Come Before You. Don't get me wrong it has some epic songs (Ghostchant, Crystal Lake) but I usually listen to the other three before I listen to that CD. Trust me just because it's at four does not mean I don't think it's a great CD. Hope this clears it up.

Fair enough, that's why I asked. What makes YCBY their best record for me isn't those songs you mentioned, but it is the songs where they took risks like "Apathy is a Cold Body" and "Sounds like the End of the World". Versions had some additional elements added, but the songs never really stuck for me. YCBY is a great balance of the loud and soft, familiar and new and has a great batch of songs to boot. One of my favorite records.

[Circa1628]

Fair enough, that's why I asked. What makes YCBY their best record for me isn't those songs you mentioned, but it is the songs where they took risks like "Apathy is a Cold Body" and "Sounds like the End of the World". Versions had some additional elements added, but the songs never really stuck for me. YCBY is a great balance of the loud and soft, familiar and new and has a great batch of songs to boot. One of my favorite records.


yeah, it is a really solid album, like I said just because it's low on my list does not mean I don't listen to it non-stop. PTW is top ten for me. They did take a lot of risks on that album, same with Versions, a lot of people don't like those risks, but I like them.

[FeynmanWannabe]

R.E.M:
Automatic for the People > Murmur > Reckoning > Life's Rich Pageant > Document > Chronic Town EP > Fables of the Reconstruction > Green > New Adventures in Hi-Fi > Out of Time > Accelerate > Monster

The Magnetic Fields:
69 Love Songs > Holiday = The Charm of the Highway Strip > Get Lost >
i > The Wayward Bus > Distortion > Distant Plastic Trees

Page France:
Hello, Dear Wind > Come, I'm A Lion! > Pear EP > Page France and the Family Telephone > Sister Pinecone EP > Tomato Morning EP

Belle & Sebastian: (full-lengths)
If You're Feeling Sinister > Tigermilk > The Life Pursuit > Dear Catastrophe Waitress > The Life Pursuit > The Boy With The Arab Strap > Fold Your Hands Child, You Walk Like a Peasant

[Genuma]

Yeah, I did just M3 but it's all goooood. You are still an American icon.
Just like juggalos!

[dakotaisrad]

I'll do my favorite Japanese and American band.

Dir en grey:
Gauze > Withering To Death. > Vulgar > Kisou > Macabre > The Marrow of a Bone > sixUGLY > Missa

Say Anything:

...Is A Real Boy > Baseball > In Defense

[hockeyguitar99]

Saves The Day:

Through Being Cool > Stay What You Are > Can't Slow Down > Sound The Alarm > Under The Boards > In Reverie

Alkaline Trio

Goddamnit > From Here To Infirmary > Maybe I'll Catch Fire > Agony & Irony > Good Mourning > Crimson

New Found Glory

Sticks and Stones > New Found Glory > Coming Home > Catalyst > From The Screen pt. 2 > Nothing Gold

[zaron5551]

Third Eye Blind
1. Third Eye Blind
2. Blue
3. Out of the Vein

The Matches
1. Decomposer
2. A Band in Hope
3. E Von Dahl Killed the Locals

Blue October
1. The Answers
2. Consent to Treatment
3. History for Sale
4. Foiled

Thrice
1. Vheussiu (I can never spell it)
2. Alchemy Index (all four)
3. other Thrice (not really a fan)

Finch
1. Say Hello To Sunshine
2. Finch EP
3. What It Is To Burn

The Offspring
1. Ixnay on the Homre
2. Smash
3. Ignition
4. Americana
5. The Offspring
6. Rise and Fall, Rage and Grace
7. Splinter
8. Conspiracy of One

[hf57]

just some random bands for fun because i'm bored...

John Mayer
Room For Squares > Heavier Things > Continuum > Inside Wants Out

Copeland
Beneath Medicine Tree > In Motion >>> Eat, Sleep, Repeat

The Early November
For All Of This > The Rooms Too Cold > Acoustic EP > TMTMTP

The Starting Line
SILYMI > BOATS > Direction > MYAH EP > WHOSO EP

[IWasaCamera]

Belle & Sebastian: (full-lengths)
If You're Feeling Sinister > Tigermilk > The Life Pursuit > Dear Catastrophe Waitress > The Life Pursuit > The Boy With The Arab Strap > Fold Your Hands Child, You Walk Like a Peasant
Is The Life Pursuit meant to be ahead of Dear Catastrophe Waitress? It shows up twice so I can't tell.

[ForeverDelayed]

This is hard, but I'll try.....

The Posies
Dear 23 > Amazing Disgrace > Failure > Every Kind of Light > Frosting on the Beater > Success > the live albums

Elliott Smith
XO > Either/Or > Roman Candle > Figure 8 > New Moon > self titled > From A Basement on the Hill

The Clash
London Calling > Sandinista! > self titled > Give 'Em Enough Rope > Combat Rock > Cut The Crap

Manic Street Preachers
Holy Bible > This Is My Truth Tell Me Yours > Lifeblood > Send Away The Tigers > Everything Must Go > Know Your Enemy > Generation Terrorists > Gold Against The Soul

Low
Secret Name > Long Division > I Could Live In Hope > Trust > Curtain Hits The Cast > Drums and Guns > Things We Lost In The Fire > The Great Destroyer

Straylight Run
The Needles The Space > Prepaer To Be Wrong > self titled

Radiohead
Kid A > OK Computer > Amnesiac > In Rainbows > The Bends > I Might Be Wrong > Pablo Honey > Hail To The Thief

Ehh... not all of my favorites, but I think that's enough for now.

[ForeverDelayed]

Is The Life Pursuit meant to be ahead of Dear Catastrophe Waitress? It shows up twice so I can't tell.
I haven't put much thought into how I'd rank their albums, but I'd most certainly put DCW far far ahead of Life Pursuit.

[IWasaCamera]

Low
Secret Name > Long Division > I Could Live In Hope > Trust > Curtain Hits The Cast > Drums and Guns > Things We Lost In The Fire > The Great Destroyer
haha I think every Low fan would have The Great Destroyer last as well.
I haven't put much thought into how I'd rank their albums, but I'd most certainly put DCW far far ahead of Life Pursuit.
Definitely. The Life Pursuit is rather unimpressive.

[m_rue]

I guess I'll just do official releases...

the Starting Line
Based On a True Story > Say It Like You Mean It > With Hopes of Starting Over ep > Direction > The Make Yourself at Home ep

[failingwithease]

Straylight Run: The Needles The Space > Self-Titled > Prepare to Be Wrong

Tegan and Sara: The Con = This Business of Art > If It Was You = So Jealous > Under Feet Like Ours

Brand New: TDAG > Deja > YFW

Okkervil River: Don't Fall In Love With Everyone You See > Black Sheep Boy > The Stage Names > The Stand Ins > Down the River of Golden Dreams

Regina Spektor: Songs > Soviet Kitsch > 11:11 > Begin to Hope

Say Anything: ...Is A Real Boy > In Defense of the Genre > Menorah/Majora > Baseball

Something Corporate: North > Leaving Through the Window > Ready...Break > Audioboxer

[3mpire]

I'm not as familiar with their earlier work, so I'll only put their latest work.

Abbey Road > Revolver > Magical Mystery Tour > Sgt. Pepper's > The White Album > Let It Be > Rubber Soul

[adam289]

Radiohead: OK Computer > The Bends > In Rainbows > Kid A > Amnesiac > Hail To The Thief > Pablo Honey

[Klatzke]

I like the Thrice and NFG, I feel the same way. The best PTW album is You Come Before You, but even if it is not your favorite there is no way Versions or Tears is better. I would accept it at #2 if Opposite of December is the top choice. Discuss.



Are you trying to make me angry? ;-)


Incubus: Morning View > Make Yourself > Light Grenades > Crow > SCIENCE > Enjoyincubus > Fungus Amongus
Versions would be first in my list..

[KidRobot]

Cursive The Ugly Organ>Happy Hollow>Domestica
Umbrellas Illuminare>Beach Front Property>s/t
Copeland ESR>>BMT=In Motion

[Troggy]

haha I think every Low fan would have The Great Destroyer last as well.

oops, that's the only one I have heard by them, guess I know why I didn't really enjoy it that much outside of a few songs.

Versions would be first in my list..

I gave it a few listens but nothing really stuck with me. :shrug:

[thespearkid]

Cloud Cult: The Meaning of 8 > Advice from the Happy Hippo > Feel Good Ghosts > Aurora Borealis > They Live in the Sun

[ambiguous.dude]

Alexisonfire

Alexisonfire > Watch Out ! > Crisis

Blink-182

Dude Ranch > Take Off Your Pants And Jacket > Enema of The State > Blink-182 > Cheshire Cat > Buddha > Flyswatter

Coldplay

A Rush of Blood To The Head > Parachutes > Viva la Vida > X&Y

Metallica

Black Album > Ride The Lightning > Master of Puppets > ...And Justice For All > Kill Em' All (Load Re-Load and St. Anger can't be part of my list I hope Death Magnetic will)

Something Corporate

Leaving Though The Window > North > Audioboxer

Weezer

Blue Album > Pinkerton > Make Believe > Maladroit > Green Album > Red Album

[ForeverDelayed]

haha I think every Low fan would have The Great Destroyer last as well.
I like it, it just got old really quickly. Definitely the one I listen to least. I probably should've put in their EP's too, I really love the Songs For A Dead Pilot disc.

[ForeverDelayed]

oops, that's the only one I have heard by them, guess I know why I didn't really enjoy it that much outside of a few songs.

It's not a bad album, and I give them points for trying something different... but really there's a million bands out there doing that same sort of thing that do it much better. If one of the songs you like is Silver Rider, you might like their older stuff. It's typically a lot slower, more mellow and gentle, and emphasis on beautiful harmonies and spiritual lyrics. The first few albums are really lo-fi and drenched in reverb. Of course I'm gonna say go with Secret Name first since that's my favorite, but really they haven't had a lot of misses.

[Troggy]

It's not a bad album, and I give them points for trying something different... but really there's a million bands out there doing that same sort of thing that do it much better. If one of the songs you like is Silver Rider, you might like their older stuff. It's typically a lot slower, more mellow and gentle, and emphasis on beautiful harmonies and spiritual lyrics. The first few albums are really lo-fi and drenched in reverb. Of course I'm gonna say go with Secret Name first since that's my favorite, but really they haven't had a lot of misses.

Oh cool, I'll check it out sometime.

[Justin_stacy]

...from best to worst.

Sorry if this has already been done before but I check the search function and nothing really came up.


Third Eye Blind: Third Eye Blind>Blue>Out of the Vein

Foo Fighters: The Colour and The Shape>There Is Nothing Left To Lose>One By One>Foo Fighters>Echoes Silence Patience and Grace>In Your Honor

Wilco: Yankee Hotel Foxtrot>Sky Blue Sky>Summerteeth>A Ghost Is Born>Being There>AM

Jimmy Eat World: Clarity>Futures>Stay On My Side Tonight EP>Bleed American>Chase This Light>Static Prevails


you have to be kidding.....

[absolutecrunk]

Weezer: Blue > Pinkerton = Red = Green = Maladroit = Make Believe


hahaha had to do it

[micahistheballs]

Nick Drake: Pink Moon >>>>>> Bryter Layter >>>>> Five Leaves Left

Bonnie "Prince" Billy: I See A Darkness > Master And Everyone > Lie Down In The Light > Superwolf > The Letting Go > Ease Down The Road > Sings Greatest Palace Music > The Brave And The Bold

Bob Dylan: Highway 61 Revisited > Blonde On Blonde > Bringing It All Back Home > Nashville Skyline > The Freewheelin' Bob Dylan > Desire > Blood On The Tracks > Another Side Of Bob Dylan > John Wesley Harding > New Morning > Love And Theft > The Times They Are A-Changin' and so on.

Neil Young: After The Gold Rush > On The Beach > Comes A Time > Harvest Moon > Tonight's The Night > Rust Never Sleeps > Everybody Knows This Is Nowhere > Harvest > Hawks & Doves > Times Fades Away and so on.


Too much work so I'll stop here.
I'm surprised to see Blood on the Tracks so low.

[mynameiscarterr]

SAVES THE DAY - In Reverie > Stay What You Are > Through Being Cool > Under The Boards > Ups & Downs > Sound The Alarm > Can't Slow Down

[notoaststereo]

you have to be kidding.....

why? how would you place yours?

[IWasaCamera]

oops, that's the only one I have heard by them, guess I know why I didn't really enjoy it that much outside of a few songs.
Their other work is far slower and not nearly as glossy. Really disappointed with The Great Destroyer.
I like it, it just got old really quickly. Definitely the one I listen to least. I probably should've put in their EP's too, I really love the Songs For A Dead Pilot disc.
Same.
I'm surprised to see Blood on the Tracks so low.
The classic album thread really put it on the forum's map and everyone's all about it now. It's a strong effort but I'll gladly take about 5 other Dylan releases over it any day.

[Troggy]

Their other work is far slower and not nearly as glossy. Really disappointed with The Great Destroyer.

How is "things we lost in the fire"?

[IWasaCamera]

How is "things we lost in the fire"?
Beautiful. My second favorite of theirs.

[Troggy]

Beautiful. My second favorite of theirs.

Okay what's the best? I will get those two.

[micahistheballs]

Their other work is far slower and not nearly as glossy. Really disappointed with The Great Destroyer.

Same.

The classic album thread really put it on the forum's map and everyone's all about it now. It's a strong effort but I'll gladly take about 5 other Dylan releases over it any day.
For me, it's basically a toss up between Highway 61 Revisited, Blonde on Blonde, and Blood on the Tracks. It all depends what day you ask me which my favourite is. Right now, it's Highway 61. They're all so good and represent different sides of him as a songwriter I think.

[IWasaCamera]

Okay what's the best? I will get those two.
Long Division is tops for me.
For me, it's basically a toss up between Highway 61 Revisited, Blonde on Blonde, and Blood on the Tracks. It all depends what day you ask me which my favourite is. Right now, it's Highway 61. They're all so good and represent different sides of him as a songwriter I think.
It changes between Blonde On Blonde and Highway just about every week for me. Important not to forget Bringing It All Back Home either.

[Troggy]

Long Division is tops for me.

Allmusic.com agrees with you ;-)

[IWasaCamera]

haha I don't like that site though. Their "similar artists" feature never delivers anything good.

[Troggy]

haha I don't like that site though. Their "similar artists" feature never delivers anything good.

Yeah i'm not sure where they come up with that part of it, but I like their reviews for the most part, they are way more accurate and unbiased than most sites.

[IWasaCamera]

Yeah i'm not sure where they come up with that part of it, but I like their reviews for the most part, they are way more accurate and unbiased than most sites.
Their reviews are decent in terms of writing although sadly predictable where scores are concerned. You can always tell which albums will receive 4 1/2 or 5 stars.

[Troggy]

Their reviews are decent in terms of writing although sadly predictable where scores are concerned. You can always tell which albums will receive 4 1/2 or 5 stars.

I do hate how they give almost anything indie rock a good score these days but I have found that almost always the albums they rate as being the best are good.

[IWasaCamera]

I do hate how they give almost anything indie rock a good score these days but I have found that almost always the albums they rate as being the best are good.
True for the most part.

[Troggy]

True for the most part.

It just helps since I can't get to listen to everything, you know?

[IWasaCamera]

It just helps since I can't get to listen to everything, you know?
Yeah, I know what you mean. I tend to place more importance on what's said than the scores though.

[Troggy]

Yeah, I know what you mean. I tend to place more importance on what's said than the scores though.

Yeah that's true, I run across that a lot on there. Some of their older reviews could use updating because the score / description conflict.

[Justin_stacy]

why? how would you place yours?

well Being There is probably one of the top ten albums ever record, so seeing it second to last on your list, particularly behind a far lesser album like A Ghost Is Born, is a little shocking.

If I had to pick an order, which I normally wouldn't do with one of my favorite bands:
Being There, SummerTeeth, Sky Blue Sky, AM, Yankee Hotel Foxtrot.....and A Ghost Is Born (which is the only album by Tweedy that I thought was of a sub quality standard).

[Troggy]

well Being There is probably one of the top ten albums ever record, so seeing it second to last on your list, particularly behind a far lesser album like A Ghost Is Born, is a little shocking.

If I had to pick an order, which I normally wouldn't do with one of my favorite bands:
Being There, SummerTeeth, Sky Blue Sky, AM, Yankee Hotel Foxtrot.....and A Ghost Is Born (which is the only album by Tweedy that I thought was of a sub quality standard).

I really enjoy Being There too and would definitely not put it near the bottom of Wilco releases.

[notoaststereo]

well Being There is probably one of the top ten albums ever record, so seeing it second to last on your list, particularly behind a far lesser album like A Ghost Is Born, is a little shocking.

If I had to pick an order, which I normally wouldn't do with one of my favorite bands:
Being There, SummerTeeth, Sky Blue Sky, AM, Yankee Hotel Foxtrot.....and A Ghost Is Born (which is the only album by Tweedy that I thought was of a sub quality standard).understandable. i just dont see being there in the same was as you, but you've absolutely convinced me to listen to it more to see what i'm missing from the album.

[Justin_stacy]

to be fair, I'm more taken by their pre-yankee sound, when they/he still incorporated elements of Uncle Tupelo into their sound.

[all is on.]

I guess I'll just do official releases...

the Starting Line
Based On a True Story > Say It Like You Mean It > With Hopes of Starting Over ep > Direction > The Make Yourself at Home ep

really? BOATS is your favorite? i have to strongly disagree with that.

the starting line: SILYMI>direction>make yourself at home>BOATS>with hopes of starting over

say anything: ...is a real boy>IDOTG>menorah/majora

motion city soundtrack: i am the movie>commit this to memory>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>even if it kills me (most disappointing album ever.)

something corporate: leaving through the window>audioboxer

[m_rue]

really? BOATS is your favorite? i have to strongly disagree with that.

the starting line: SILYMI>direction>make yourself at home>BOATS>with hopes of starting over

say anything: ...is a real boy>IDOTG>menorah/majora

motion city soundtrack: i am the movie>commit this to memory>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>even if it kills me (most disappointing album ever.)

something corporate: leaving through the window>audioboxer

Yep. I know I'm in the minority, but I love everything about that album.

[notoaststereo]

to be fair, I'm more taken by their pre-yankee sound, when they/he still incorporated elements of Uncle Tupelo into their sound.
yeah, i thought so. i do enjoyed it, but i also enjoy the evolution of his writing and music.

[takemyhand]

Chiodos: The Heartless Control Everything>All's Well That Ends Well>Bone Palace Ballet.
PlayRadioPlay! The Frequency>Texas.
Fall Out Boy From Under The Cork Tree>Take This To Your Grave>Infinity On High.
mmm. most of my other favorite bands only have one album or EP out, or I don't feel like putting them in order, this was hard hah.

[jaguarlove]

The Blood Brothers: Burn Piano Island Burn > Crimes > Young Machetes > March On Electric Children > This Adultery Is Ripe
Brand New: The Devil and God Are Raging Inside Me > Deja Entendu > Your Favourite Weapon
At the Drive-In: Relationship Of Command > In/Casino/Out > Acrobatic Tenement

[Hockeywall]

Motion City Soundtrack: Even If It Kills Me= Commit This To Memory= I Am The Movie[I can't choose..]
The Matches: Evon Dahl Killed The Locals>Decomposer>A Band In Hope
Anberlin: Never Take Friendship Personal>Cities=Blueprints For The Blackmarket

[seraph1214]

blink-182: TOYPAJ>Dude Ranch>Untitled>EOTS>Cheshire Cat

Foo Fighters: S/T>TCATS>ESPG>In Your Honor>TINLTL>One by One

Saves the Day: Through Being Cool>SWYA>Sound the Alarm>Can't Slow Down>Under the Boards>In Reverie

Weezer: The Blue Album>Pinkerton>The Green Album>SFTBH>Maladroit>The Red Album>Make Believe

[SLoT]

Saves the Day: Through Being Cool>SWYA>Sound the Alarm>Can't Slow Down>Under the Boards>In Reverie

There are probably six people on this planet that think In Reverie is their best work... I just so happen to be one of them. Oh well. Everyone's allowed to like whatever the fuck they want.

[stupidtyonparad]

Brand New
-the devil and god are raging inside me
-tie between deja entendu and your favorite weapon

Foo Fighters
-there is nothing left to loose
-skin and bones
-echoes silence patience grace
-the color and the shape
-in your honor
-foo fighters
-one by one

Against Me!
-...as the eternal cowboy
-searching for a former clarity
-reinventing axl rose
-new wave
-vivida vis!

Reel Big Fish
-our live album is better than your live album
-turn the radio off
-cheer up!
-monkeys for nothing and the chimps for free
-we're not happy till your not happy
-why do they rock so hard (but the set up is #1)

Rancid
-life wont wait
-lets go
-...and out come the wolves
-rancid
-indestructable
-rancid (2000) <--piece of crap.

Blink 182
-blink 182
-take off your pants and jacket
-the enema strikes back (the mark tom and travis show)
-dude ranch
-enema of the state
-chesire cat

and let it be known strictly rude by big d and the kids table is beyond sick

[myplanforescape]

Black Rebel Motorcycle Club: Howl>Baby 81>B.R.M.C.>Take Them On, On Your Own

Glassjaw: Worship and Tribute> EYEWTKAS> Kiss Kiss Bang Bang

The Jesus and Mary Chain: Psychocandy=Honey's Dead> Stoned and Dethroned> Munki> Automatic> Darklands> Sound of Speed, Hate Rock & Roll, Barbed Wire Kisses

Red Hot Chili Peppers: Blood Sugar Sex Magik=By the Way> Californication> Uplift Mofo Pary Plan> Freaky Styley = Mother's Milk> Stadium Arcadium> S/t> One Hot Minute

[mynameiscarterr]

There are probably six people on this planet that think In Reverie is their best work... I just so happen to be one of them. Oh well. Everyone's allowed to like whatever the fuck they want.

I agree.
Saves The Day is my favorite band and In Reverie is my favorite release they've put out.
It's just soooo beautiful. Hahahaha.

[chipdip18]

This is my favorite order for Bright Eyes, without EPs.
Lifted > Fevers and Mirrors = I'm Wide Awake It's Morning > Digital Ash in a Digital Urn > Cassadaga > Noise Floor > Letting Off the Happiness