The Music Forum Favorite Artists: Results!

[chipdip18]

Here are the results! Enjoy and discuss.

30.) The Lawrence Arms

29.) The Format

28.) The Get Up Kids

27.) Godspeed You! Black Emperor

26.) Anberlin

25.) At the Drive-In

24.) Bob Marley & the Wailers

23.) Cursive

22.) Bruce Springsteen

21.) Something Corporate

20.) Modest Mouse

19.) Saves the Day

18.) Sigur Rós

17.) Weezer

16.) Descendants

15.) New Found Glory

14.) mewithoutYou

13.) Neutral Milk Hotel

12.) Death Cab For Cutie

11.) Thrice

10.) Thursday

http://i526.photobucket.com/albums/cc346/chipdip18/thursday.jpg

9.) Jimmy Eat World

http://i526.photobucket.com/albums/cc346/chipdip18/JimmyEatWorld.jpg

8.) Jack's Mannequin

http://i526.photobucket.com/albums/cc346/chipdip18/band.jpg

7.) Bright Eyes

http://i526.photobucket.com/albums/cc346/chipdip18/bright-753845.jpg

6.) Bob Dylan

http://i526.photobucket.com/albums/cc346/chipdip18/dylan.jpg

5.) Iron & Wine

http://i526.photobucket.com/albums/cc346/chipdip18/iron-and-wine-sam-beam.jpg

4.) blink-182

http://i526.photobucket.com/albums/cc346/chipdip18/Blink-182.jpg

3.) Brand New

http://i526.photobucket.com/albums/cc346/chipdip18/brandnew.jpg

2.) Radiohead

http://i526.photobucket.com/albums/cc346/chipdip18/radiohead.jpg

1.) The Beatles

http://i526.photobucket.com/albums/cc346/chipdip18/beatles-the-the-beatles-1192706.jpg



Discuss!

[versus_god]

1/30

[Genuma]

I was about to say first.

[chipdip18]

1/30

The Lawrence Arms?

[Jumpoff]

Hahahahhaha, the Lawrence Arms snuck onto this.

But really. I hate this list more than any of the others so far.

[Genuma]

What the fuck? How does jack's Mannequin make top 10? One album. And Weezer should probably be lower than 17, seeing they realeased two good albums. Shouldn't talk about that, though, since I put them in my top 10. Springsteen deserves a top 10, not 22. And I'm surprised the Larry Arms made it.

[chipdip18]

Really? Why?

[versus_god]

1.) The Lawrence Arms
http://media.collegepublisher.com/media/paper746/stills/oknmlba7.jpg

[chipdip18]

What the fuck? How does jack's Mannequin make top 10? One album. And Weezer should probably be lower than 17, seeing they realeased two good albums. Shouldn't talk about that, though, since I put them in my top 10. Springsteen deserves a top 10, not 22. And I'm surprised the Larry Arms made it.

Jack's really surprised me, Soco had a lead for a while but Jack's kept showing up where Soco didn't.

[Genuma]

Look at those foxy sons of bitches.

[Jumpoff]

Really? Why?

Well, if you were asking me, then just look at Genuma's post to see most of my opinion.

Hell, only one guy in the top 10 was a person I even had in my list :-p

[Genuma]

Jack's really surprised me, Soco had a lead for a while but Jack's kept showing up where Soco didn't.
SoCo made mine I think.

[chipdip18]

The bottom 10 is awesome though. I don't care what you think.

[Getup and Dance]

Damn, no hip hop artists made it, I am kind of suprised since I did see alot of NAS and 2pac on lists.

[chipdip18]

SoCo made mine I think.

SoCo is still on there.

[Genuma]

Now for positives: Blink is still good in my book, but I think I forgot them on my list. Those Beatles fellows are cool. Say Anythng wasn't top 10.

[chipdip18]

Damn, no hip hop artists made it, I am kind of suprised since I did see alot of NAS and 2pac on lists.
They were way too low.

[chipdip18]

Now for positives: Blink is still good in my book, but I think I forgot them on my list. Those Beatles fellows are cool. Say Anythng wasn't top 10.


Neither was Thrice.

[Jumpoff]

The bottom 10 is awesome though. I don't care what you think.

It had Marley, Springsteen, Cursive and the Lawrence Arms. Not a fan of the others. However, I'll take those four over the top 10.

[Genuma]

Damn, no hip hop artists made it, I am kind of suprised since I did see alot of NAS and 2pac on lists.
I don't think I did any hip-hop on mine. I thought we might break into genres later and didn't want to cheat out any of my favorite bands.
SoCo is still on there.
Yeah, just lower.
The bottom 10 is awesome though. I don't care what you think.
It's pretty cool I guess. It has Springsteen, who's a juggalo so it can't be all bad.

[Jumpoff]

Damn, no hip hop artists made it, I am kind of suprised since I did see alot of NAS and 2pac on lists.

I honestly expected that. Hell, I'm happy Marley made the list of all people.

[chipdip18]

It had Marley, Springsteen, Cursive and the Lawrence Arms. Not a fan of the others. However, I'll take those four over the top 10.

Cursive and The Lawrence Arms were two really big surprises.

[versus_god]

It had Marley, Springsteen, Cursive and the Lawrence Arms. Not a fan of the others. However, I'll take those four over the top 10.
Totally.

[Genuma]

I guess no one but me had ICP. :-(

[Jumpoff]

Cursive and The Lawrence Arms were two really big surprises.

This list actually seems more stereotypical than the favorite albums list :shrug: Maybe because there was no post limit. Don't know.

[Genuma]

I'm so glad Springsteen made it at least. #2 right there. Which is kind of like #1.

[Getup and Dance]

Im somewhat suprised Blink made it above Iron & Wine.

[chipdip18]

This list actually seems more stereotypical than the favorite albums list :shrug: Maybe because there was no post limit. Don't know.

Well i think it would have turned out to be a more satisfying list if there was a post limit. Too many opposers. I wanted it to be like 1k.

[versus_god]

More Ergs!

[chipdip18]

Im somewhat suprised Blink made it above Iron & Wine.

Really? I'm surprised Iron & Wine was so high.

[Jumpoff]

I'm so glad Springsteen made it at least. #2 right there. Which is kind of like #1.

Yeah. That's a good thing. I honestly only recently got into him so he wasn't on mine though he shoudl've been. Marley was the only guy in my top 5 to make it :-p

I'm surprised NoFX didn't make it.

[Getup and Dance]

Really? I'm surprised Iron & Wine was so high.

To me it always seemed like alot of people were always talking about Iron & Wine.

[chipdip18]

Yeah. That's a good thing. I honestly only recently got into him so he wasn't on mine though he shoudl've been. Marley was the only guy in my top 5 to make it :-p

I'm surprised NoFX didn't make it.

NoFX wasn't that close actually. They were on a lot of lists but just too low. Lot's of bands appeared like 11th and after and those points didn't really count up a lot. The top ten made all the difference.

[chipdip18]

To me it always seemed like alot of people were always talking about Iron & Wine.

I see what you mean, but he was like 5th right? I figured like 10th.

[Genuma]

Yeah. That's a good thing. I honestly only recently got into him so he wasn't on mine though he shoudl've been. Marley was the only guy in my top 5 to make it :-p

I'm surprised NoFX didn't make it.
Yeah, I bet he got a lot of low spot on the hipster lsits for all the Nebraska love around here.

There's gonna be hell to pay when that blue fellow gets here.
To me it always seemed like alot of people were always talking about Iron & Wine.
Yeah, I knew they'd be high.
More Ergs!
I had the Ergs! higher than you. But we both put Descendents top 10 and they didn't make it. You know?

[Getup and Dance]

I'm not suprised that Radiohead and The Beatles were going to be the top 2 though.

[chipdip18]

Yeah, I bet he got a lot of low spot on the hipster lsits for all the Nebraska love around here.

There's gonna be hell to pay when that blue fellow gets here.

Yeah, I knew they'd be high.

I had the Ergs! higher than you. But we both put Descendents top 10 and they didn't make it. You know?

Descendents were, and i just checked, 31.

[versus_god]

I hate you, absolutepunk.

[El_Jeffe]

ahh it's a favourites list, can't really complain, even if most of it isn't really my kinda jam. stoked to see marley, as well as others i enjoy like at the drive-in, the boss, radiohead & dylan. but it'd be great to see some more diversity in some areas

where are all these beatle crazed fans coming from? seem to be all the rage again all of a sudden. not a strike against the band, it's just that a few months ago there was only about a handful or two of fans (or so it seems) & now everyone is

[chipdip18]

ahh it's a favourites list, can't really complain, even if most of it isn't really my kinda jam. stoked to see marley, as well as others i enjoy like at the drive-in, the boss, radiohead & dylan. but it'd be great to see some more diversity in some areas

where are all these beatle crazed fans coming from? seem to be all the rage again all of a sudden. not a strike against the band, it's just that a few months ago there was only about a handful or two of fans (or so it seems) & now everyone is

Craig, i would say that the 40-60 out of like 450 was more in your style of music.

[Genuma]

ahh it's a favourites list, can't really complain, even if most of it isn't really my kinda jam. stoked to see marley, as well as others i enjoy like at the drive-in, the boss, radiohead & dylan. but it'd be great to see some more diversity in some areas

where are all these beatle crazed fans coming from? seem to be all the rage again all of a sudden. not a strike against the band, it's just that a few months ago there was only about a handful or two of fans (or so it seems) & now everyone is
Probably about the time Ben made the Sgt. Peppers Classic Discussion thread.
I hate you, absolutepunk.
I know.

:-(

I know.
Descendents were, and i just checked, 31.
Could you just cut out Brand New while no one's looking?
I'm not suprised that Radiohead and The Beatles were going to be the top 2 though.
Not at all.

[versus_god]

Or Say Anything.

[chipdip18]

Could you just cut out Brand New while no one's looking?

.

Haha i was so tempted to mess with Brand New's points during the tallying process.

[chipdip18]

Or Say Anything.

Say Anything and Thrice were lower than i thought they would be actually.

[Genuma]

No one would notice.

HAHAHAHAHHAHA.

But seriosuly, do it.

[chipdip18]

Notice what? :whistle:

[versus_god]

Ay dios mio. Perfect.

[El_Jeffe]

Craig, i would say that the 40-60 out of like 450 was more in your style of music.

oh really, what kinda jams were in there? nick cave must of been close. wtfmates is going to be pissed haha

Probably about the time Ben made the Sgt. Peppers Classic Discussion thread.

haha ya might be on to something there. don't get me wrong, i love ben's input, enjoyed that series of his & that album did deserve a spot in it. but people take things too literal here sometimes, those threads were discussion points & sort of catch up recc, not the bloody gospel haha

[Getup and Dance]

Haha i was so tempted to mess with Brand New's points during the tallying process.

Put Wu tang in Brand New's spot, they deserve it more.

[chipdip18]

oh really, what kinda jams were in there? nick cave must of been close. wtfmates is going to be pissed haha



Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds
Tom Waits
The Slackers


Eh... that's it actually haha.

[Genuma]

Notice what? :whistle:
I notice nothing. But nothing looks so sweet.
oh really, what kinda jams were in there? nick cave must of been close. wtfmates is going to be pissed haha



haha ya might be on to something there. don't get me wrong, i love ben's input, enjoyed that series of his & that album did deserve a spot in it. but people take things too literal here sometimes, those threads were discussion points & sort of catch up recc, not the bloody gospel haha
Ben's a cool guy, he's got great taste in a lot of things. But he's also pretty intimidating to new users. The Classis Discussion were a greta idea, but it got pretty bad in the end. Everyone jumped on every rec loving it. Come on, you can't ike everything.

[chipdip18]

Put Wu tang in Brand New's spot, they deserve it more.

I don't lie on the results! Except for a little bit.

[Genuma]

If Wu Tang was close it could be cool, but they probably had no votes. Haha.

[chipdip18]

Wu Tang was super low. Haha.

[chipdip18]

Actually like 164 out of 453.

[Genuma]

Whoa, they got votes? Haha.

[Getup and Dance]

I saw alot of people had Wu-Tang in the mid level, I had them at like number 3-4 I think.

[chipdip18]

Whoa, they got votes? Haha.


Haha don't let that number fool you.

[chipdip18]

I saw alot of people had Wu-Tang in the mid level, I had them at like number 3-4 I think.


Only you and one other person voted for Wu-Tang.

[El_Jeffe]

Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds
Tom Waits
The Slackers


Eh... that's it actually haha.

that's awesome though, 3 great bands. did cave beat out waits? man ya'd wanna be keepin' that on down low if kilo is floating around haha

Ben's a cool guy, he's got great taste in a lot of things. But he's also pretty intimidating to new users. The Classis Discussion were a greta idea, but it got pretty bad in the end. Everyone jumped on every rec loving it. Come on, you can't ike everything.

haha i see what you mean. point noted, i need to be more aggressive with ska recc's, is the take home message. "hey you! you funkin' listen to this!"

[chipdip18]

that's awesome though, 3 great bands. did cave beat out waits? man ya'd wanna be keepin' that on down low if kilo is floating around haha



Hahaha. But Cave was above Waits.

[Jumpoff]

haha i see what you mean. point noted, i need to be more aggressive with ska recc's, is the take home message. "hey you! you funkin' listen to this!"

Nono, you must get Ben to harrass everyone and anyone about listening to them and have him make his next few Classic album threads about ska bands. In a few months Bob Marley, Toots, and The Slackers will take the top 10! haha.

[chipdip18]

Nono, you must get Ben to harrass everyone and anyone about listening to them and have him make his next few Classic album threads about ska bands. In a few months Bob Marley, Toots, and The Slackers will take the top 10! haha.

See i feel cool cause i own albums from all three of those bands!

[Jumpoff]

Waits was one of my top 3, how many people even voted him? haha

[chipdip18]

Waits was one of my top 3, how many people even voted him? haha


He was 48th.

[Jumpoff]

Oh well. Next time he'll sneak into the top 10! I am still laughing that LA managed to break in. If only BTMI! could take Jack's Mannequin's spot.

[Genuma]

Waits was one of my top 3, how many people even voted him? haha
He was somewhere in my list.
that's awesome though, 3 great bands. did cave beat out waits? man ya'd wanna be keepin' that on down low if kilo is floating around haha



haha i see what you mean. point noted, i need to be more aggressive with ska recc's, is the take home message. "hey you! you funkin' listen to this!"
If you really want it to work go with the "This band is 99%" better than everything you listen to." that always gets people scared and insecure.

[chipdip18]

Oh well. Next time he'll sneak into the top 10! I am still laughing that LA managed to break in. If only BTMI! could take Jack's Mannequin's spot.

Hahaha in a perfect world?

[Genuma]

Lawrence Arms were pretty low on my list, but I still helped them ashieve victory with ym last minute submission. Also, I helped the Descendents. Mission accomplished.

[micahistheballs]

Where the hell are all these Beatles fans?

I knew there were a few in Ben, Katie, and myself, but number one. Really?

Anyways Radiohead, mewithoutYou, and Dylan all made it so my top 3 was represented. I'm alright.

[chipdip18]

Lawrence Arms were pretty low on my list, but I still helped them ashieve victory with ym last minute submission. Also, I helped the Descendents. Mission accomplished.

Good work! I didn't vote for either of them, but i think that since The Format, Cursive and Bob Marley, were on my list, i did my part.

Where the hell are all these Beatles fans?

I knew there were a few in Ben, Katie, and myself, but number one. Really?

The Beatles were on like 80% of the lists, probably for fear of getting made fun of for now having the greatest band of all time on their list. Courtesy of Ben.

[Genuma]

Good work! I didn't vote for either of them, but i think that since The Format, Cursive and Bob Marley, were on my list, i did my part.



The Beatles were on like 80% of the lists, probably for fear of getting made fun of for now having the greatest band of all time on their list. Courtesy of Ben.
I didn't have the Beatles! :-0

[micahistheballs]

Good work! I didn't vote for either of them, but i think that since The Format, Cursive and Bob Marley, were on my list, i did my part.



The Beatles were on like 80% of the lists, probably for fear of getting made fun of for now having the greatest band of all time on their list. Courtesy of Ben.
I guess so. I hate the obligation to like them in a way.

They were early teens in my list so yeah. About how much did they win by?

[chipdip18]

I didn't have the Beatles! :-0


way to be a 20%er.

[Jumpoff]

I didn't have the Beatles! :-0

Neither did I :highfive:

[chipdip18]

I guess so. I hate the obligation to like them in a way.

They were early teens in my list so yeah. About how much did they win by?


haha do you really really want to know?

[Genuma]

way to be a 20%er.
I'm finally a minority!
Neither did I :highfive:
20% five!

[micahistheballs]

haha do you really really want to know?
Yeah. I refuse to believe that the Beatles are really the forum's favourite.

[chipdip18]

Yeah. I refuse to believe that the Beatles are really the forum's favourite.

Two points.

[El_Jeffe]

Hahaha. But Cave was above Waits.

that's awesome, i adore waits, but cave takes the cake!

Nono, you must get Ben to harrass everyone and anyone about listening to them and have him make his next few Classic album threads about ska bands. In a few months Bob Marley, Toots, and The Slackers will take the top 10! haha.

haha wouldn't that be a sight

See i feel cool cause i own albums from all three of those bands!

so you should! own those albums or not, you're not afraid to explore across the musical realm, that's what makes you even cooler mate

[micahistheballs]

Two points.
This means I'm the reason my favourite band isn't number one. Fucking great.

[fadedmemories]

no midtown? I'm surprised

[chipdip18]

that's awesome, i adore waits, but cave takes the cake!



haha wouldn't that be a sight



so you should! own those albums or not, you're not afraid to explore across the musical realm, that's what makes you even cooler mate

So i'm going to take a screenshot of this post and frame it.


Israel Kamakawiwo'ole is one of my favorite artists now. Such amazing stuff. Same with The Slackers, i can't get enough of Self-Medication, i'm waiting for some cash to pick up Redlight. Basically, if you don't explore the musical realm, check out other genres, etc. you are an idiot.

[chipdip18]

This means I'm the reason my favourite band isn't number one. Fucking great.

:pet: I really do feel sorrow for you.

no midtown?

77th.

[micahistheballs]

:pet: I really do feel sorrow for you.



77th.
It's all good. I just wish mewithoutYou was higher really.

Radiohead not being one doesn't bug me, but like I keep saying, I just don't believe the Beatles are that well loved on here. I'd honestly be happier if Brand New was number one because I could believe that haha.

Doesn't getting a compliment from Craig feel great?

[Genuma]

Midtown was my number 11. Don't tell anyone or I'll kill you. You know?

[chipdip18]

It's all good. I just wish mewithoutYou was higher really.

Radiohead not being one doesn't bug me, but like I keep saying, I just don't believe the Beatles are that well loved on here. I'd honestly be happier if Brand New was number one because I could believe that haha.

Doesn't getting a compliment from Craig feel great?


Feels so good. Yeah, i know what you mean, but i seriously believe that people were pressured into voting for The Beatles.

[Jumpoff]

It's all good. I just wish mewithoutYou was higher really.

Radiohead not being one doesn't bug me, but like I keep saying, I just don't believe the Beatles are that well loved on here. I'd honestly be happier if Brand New was number one because I could believe that haha.

haha yeah. Beatles fans came out the woodworks apparently. Brand New or Say Anything as number one would've made more sense to me.. and STILL puzzled over how jack's managed to get on here.

[Getup and Dance]

Im not a big fan of this list, Im just going to say that.

But its mainly because im not one of the norm on this site.

[micahistheballs]

I didn't know there were many Jack's fans either, but oh well. Blink also surprised me by being that high.

Where are these Beatles fans?

[chipdip18]

haha yeah. Beatles fans came out the woodworks apparently. Brand New or Say Anything as number one would've made more sense to me.. and STILL puzzled over how jack's managed to get on here.

Well with all this recent Glass Passenger hype and the love for Everything In Transit, I'm not surprise they cracked the list. But top ten? Crazy talk. I'm surprised about Say Anything too, much much lower.

[micahistheballs]

Well with all this recent Glass Passenger hype and the love for Everything In Transit, I'm not surprise they cracked the list. But top ten? Crazy talk. I'm surprised about Say Anything too, much much lower.
Where did Say Anything end up at?

[chipdip18]

Where did Say Anything end up at?

Like the 17th i think.

[micahistheballs]

Like the 17th i think.
No, they're not even in the top 30.

[chipdip18]

No, they're not even in the top 30.

Ah forgot! We made a joke, they are where the Descendents are.

[micahistheballs]

Ah forgot! We made a joke, they are where the Descendents are.
Oh okay.

I don't get it.

[chipdip18]

Oh okay.

I don't get it.

Basically a statement. Descendents > Say Anything, i'll change it back.

[versus_god]

Noooooooo!

[Jumpoff]

Should've put them in instead of Jack's Mannequin. Really, noone would care. :-p

[chipdip18]

Should've put them in instead of Jack's Mannequin. Really, noone would care. :-p


I think i would have to change the picture too!

[Genuma]

[ Big Boobs An Issue!? 7-08-08]
dear dr.psyko
im a young lette living in cali and i mean young and ever since i was 9 ive had really big boobs. now im 15 and a 42 DD alot of people say i have amazing breasts but for some reason my boyfriend doesnt like them. he always tells me anytiing more then a handful is a waste. i really care about him and i want to be with him but i dont know if i can if all he can do is judge me. he has been pressuring me alot lately not for sex but to get a breast reduction. i just dont know if he is worth my time or not...please help
mrs.monoxide


Well I guess that this just goes to show you that some guys don't like big boobs, or rather he doesn't like the attention that you get because of them. As far as I know, you wouldn't be able to get breast reduction surgery until you are 18 anyways (unless of course your parents said it was okay, and even then I think you have to do it for medical reasons or insurance will not cover it). My point is that unless you want to do it, or have a medical need to do it, don't do it. I strongly believe in the take me for who I am or go away. You could always try talking to him about why he wants you do this so badly. I would assume that he knew ya had them when you two met, and it didn't bother him then. I would bet that it is
not completely because he thinks they are too big, but because he doesn't like the thought of others staring at his girl's breasts. Just remember, nothing is worth doing if you truly do not want to do it. If you do something because someone else talked you into it, or guilted you into it, then you are opening yourself up for regret later on.

MCL
Dr Psyko

[Jumpoff]

I think i would have to change the picture too!

Should do.

[versus_god]

chipdip18 is a fascist.

http://img237.imageshack.us/img237/9332/desayanythingja7.jpg

[Regards]

I'm honestly surprised Converge didn't make it.

[El_Jeffe]

new found glory are the lasting troopers on this board. i don't actually listen to the band, but year, after year, after year, that band makes an appearance somewhere on these sorts of lists. it doesn't matter what members do or don't take part, music or general forum, they just always seem to be there. good on them i guess, must have a loyal fanbase

[funkel]

Where are these Beatles fans?
They were my number one.

Shame 65dayofstatic didn't make it, but probably only 3 people voted for them.

[wtfmates]

Nooooooo, nick cave and the bad seeds didn't make it. Better list than expected though.

[allhourcymbals]

3/30 I think. No Tim Finn or Split Enz :-( And TLA last? What's going on here? :-( You know?

[Regards]

Oh, and 10/30. I'm also kinda shocked that mwY isn't higher on the list.

[versus_god]

3/30 I think. No Tim Finn or Split Enz :-( And TLA last? What's going on here? :-( You know?
And that terrorist chipdip18 replaced the Descendents with Say Anything, you know? Ay dios mio.

[allhourcymbals]

And that terrorist chipdip18 replaced the Descendents with Say Anything, you know? Ay dios mio.
Stupid terrorists. :-(


They need more punk in their lives.

[versus_god]

Lawrence Arms
USA
USA
USA

[allhourcymbals]

If I could go back and redo my list, it would be as follows:

1. Finn Brothers
2. Finn Brothers
3. Lawrence Arms
4. Finn Brothers
USA.


New Zealand?


What?



You know?

:-(

[versus_god]

1. USA
2. Lawrence Arms
3. You know?
4. Ergs!
5. Michael Savage
6. ALLHOURCYMBALS
7. :-(

[allhourcymbals]

Well. At least I'm above :-(

I'd put VERSUS_GOD at .5, too good for the list, you know? It's like, a given.

[versus_god]

I like you guys. You know? I really do.

[allhourcymbals]

I get this a lot.



From you, you know?

[versus_god]

I like to think of ALLHOURCYMBALS as a mischievous badger.

[allhourcymbals]

I think someone's trying to tell me something.

[versus_god]

:-(

[allhourcymbals]

You're spilling the bong water all over the bed, VERSUS_GOD, you know? :-(

[murrich]

10/30

I'm disappointed there's no Simon and Garfunkel or Neil Young, were either of those two close?

[Dr. Acula]

no Hot Water Music? :-0

[handlikesecret]

14/30

very surprised Jack's made number 8, ahead of Jimmy Eat World. i'm pleased that Blink was so high though. and even though they weren't on my list, i'm happy that The Beatles are #1.

[CellarGhosts]

woah, Im surprised TLA made it. Bottom of the list, yeah, but still...

not a bad list overall

[handlikesecret]

woah, Im surprised TLA made it. Bottom of the list, yeah, but still...

not a bad list overall
agreed, i think it's pretty fair for the most part.

[bowl of oranges]

Solid list. I thought it'd be a lot worse.

[sandra92]

lool . there's only one band in the final list that was in mine ..
but this is a good list .

[IWasaCamera]

Really? I'm surprised Iron & Wine was so high.
Everyone's been all about them since The Shepherd's Dog. Not surprising.
where are all these beatle crazed fans coming from? seem to be all the rage again all of a sudden. not a strike against the band, it's just that a few months ago there was only about a handful or two of fans (or so it seems) & now everyone is
Good question. I was about the only person with Beatles albums in the last favorites thread. Now they're #1, what the hell happened?
Where the hell are all these Beatles fans?

I knew there were a few in Ben, Katie, and myself, but number one. Really?
Ahem.
I just don't believe the Beatles are that well loved on here. I'd honestly be happier if Brand New was number one because I could believe that haha.
It's simply a matter of a few users having them at #1 or somewhere near the top. Doesn't mean there are that many fans around.
Feels so good. Yeah, i know what you mean, but i seriously believe that people were pressured into voting for The Beatles.
Probably, what with them not having ONE album in the last favorites thread.

[handlikesecret]

lool . there's only one band in the final list that was in mine ..
but this is a good list .
who was it?

[Chromefox]

I'm pleased that JM made the top 10. I am mostly satisfied that my favourites were represented, though I didn't vote.

[handlikesecret]

I'm pleased that JM made the top 10. I am mostly satisfied that my favourites were represented, though I didn't vote.
haha you're just reaping the benefits from our hard work, eh?

:highfive:

[sandra92]

who was it?

blink-182

[handlikesecret]

blink-182
:highfive: good call.

[alltimecam]

the top 10 looks really good.
other than brand new

[sandra92]

:highfive: good call.

Yep (;

[micahistheballs]

Everyone's been all about them since The Shepherd's Dog. Not surprising.

Good question. I was about the only person with Beatles albums in the last favorites thread. Now they're #1, what the hell happened?

Ahem.

It's simply a matter of a few users having them at #1 or somewhere near the top. Doesn't mean there are that many fans around.

Probably, what with them not having ONE album in the last favorites thread.
Sorry to have forgotten you Vinh.

[IWasaCamera]

Sorry to have forgotten you Vinh.
:-) All better now.


Also noteworthy is how Dylan fans popped up out of nowhere too. Back in March, not one of Bob's albums made the cut. Now he's one of the most beloved artists here.

[chipdip18]

chipdip18 is a fascist.

http://img237.imageshack.us/img237/9332/desayanythingja7.jpg


You are hurting my feelings.

[chipdip18]

10/30

I'm disappointed there's no Simon and Garfunkel or Neil Young, were either of those two close?

57th
no Hot Water Music? :-0

42nd


Oh and Converge for whoever asked was 35th.

[Chromefox]

haha you're just reaping the benefits from our hard work, eh?

:highfive: That's how I roll. ;-)

[AlternateToLife]

I feel the need to elaborate here.

30.) The Lawrence Arms :thumbup:
31.) The Format :shrug:
28.) The Get Up Kids :shrug:
27.) Godspeed You! Black Emperor :clap:
26.) Anberlin :thumbdwn:
25.) At the Drive-In :thumbup:
24.) Bob Marley & the Wailers (ONLY AT 24? :angry:)
23.) Cursive :mellow:
22.) Bruce Springsteen :dance:
21.) Something Corporate :shrug:
20.) Modest Mouse :explode:
19.) Saves the Day :wallbash:
18.) Sigur Rós :thumbup:
17.) Weezer :thumbup:
16.) Say Anything :shrug:
15.) New Found Glory :nono:
14.) mewithoutYou :-d
13.) Neutral Milk Hotel :celebrate:
12.) Death Cab For Cutie :thumbup:
11.) Thrice :thumbdwn:
10.) Thursday :shrug:
9.) Jimmy Eat World :party:
8.) Jack's Mannequin :shrug:
7.) Bright Eyes :thumbup:
8.) Bob Dylan :woot:
5.) Iron & Wine :appl:
4.) blink-182 :yuk:
3.) Brand New :-/
2.) Radiohead :thumbup:
1.) The Beatles (No Shit)

[KatieKutthroat.]

4/30 for me. Lame. And I too am wondering where all the Beatles fans came from.

[AlternateToLife]

I got 14/30. But I'm lame and unoriginal so that works well for this board.

[putup or shutup]

11/40 (that I agree with, I didn't vote or whatever)

ATD-I and SoCo should have been higher in my book, but ah, what can you do. Stoked Brand New was in 3rd though.

[AlternateToLife]

Ah yes mine is also what I agree with. My voting got 8/30

[doyouhas?]

9/30. and it should have been 10 because i somehow forgot to put dylan on there.:hitself:

[micahistheballs]

9/30 I believe.

I wonder who had the highest number of bands on there.

[chipdip18]

9/30 I believe.

I wonder who had the highest number of bands on there.

Machu maybe.

[The Database]

lol silly list

[chipdip18]

I am 11/30.

[allhourcymbals]

Ughhhhhhhhh no.

[chipdip18]

Ughhhhhhhhh no.


??

[GuitarR0cker1]

I am 12/30, not bad list overall.

[allhourcymbals]

??
Not you, don't worry.

[chipdip18]

Not you, don't worry.

I'm glad. I feel like i bother you sometimes by asking you to help me out with albums so much. If there is anyway i could help you i will!

[handlikesecret]

Machu maybe.
how many did he have?

[chipdip18]

how many did he have?

I remember he had a lot when i was tallying, i dont know for a fact though.

[chipdip18]

He had 19/30

[handlikesecret]

he beat me.

[Yes. And?]

lol

[GuitarR0cker1]

he beat me.
How many did you get? I got 12/30.

[handlikesecret]

How many did you get? I got 12/30.
14/30

lol
did you make a list?

[allhourcymbals]

I'm glad. I feel like i bother you sometimes by asking you to help me out with albums so much. If there is anyway i could help you i will!
I don't mind, I'll send more funk your way, I just haven't really had the time to sit and upload them lately. If you want though, I can send you a list of a few albums that you'd be able to find on your own.

[chipdip18]

I don't mind, I'll send more funk your way, I just haven't really had the time to sit and upload them lately. If you want though, I can send you a list of a few albums that you'd be able to find on your own.

Thanks that would be greatly appreciated.

[allhourcymbals]

Yuup, sometime tonight then.

[x togepi x]

the beatles at number 1? i thought everyone here was like "OMG THEY'RE SO OVERRATED"

haha, i guess that confirms who throws shit on their list to look intelligent and who actually knows what they're talking about.

[chipdip18]

the beatles at number 1? i thought everyone here was like "OMG THEY'RE SO OVERRATED"

haha, i guess that confirms who throws shit on their list to look intelligent and who actually knows what they're talking about.


Haha exactly.

[x togepi x]

Haha exactly.


i think you could probably do this list every year and get radically different results based on what bands its cool to like.

[chipdip18]

i think you could probably do this list every year and get radically different results based on what bands its cool to like.

If we don't have a post limit. We have to have a post limit.

[allhourcymbals]

the beatles at number 1? i thought everyone here was like "OMG THEY'RE SO OVERRATED"

haha, i guess that confirms who throws shit on their list to look intelligent and who actually knows what they're talking about.
I will never understand why people do this.

[x togepi x]

If we don't have a post limit. We have to have a post limit.

i don't think this would effect anything. last year this list wouldn't have had things like bruce springsteen or iron & wine.

[allhourcymbals]

If we don't have a post limit. We have to have a post limit.
There should be an IQ limit, not post limit hahah. Really, you never know who knows what they're talking about and people that could just reiterate other things they've heard on AP, or just name whatever bands. Post count does not separate the two.

[x togepi x]

I will never understand why people do this.

to look deep, you'd be surprised how many people want to look cultured and intelligent by having bands they don't like on their ipod. it's the same with books they won't read on their bookshelf.

it's the kind of thing that drives people to have "favorite band" lists of about 50 bands.

[chipdip18]

i don't think this would effect anything. last year this list wouldn't have had things like bruce springsteen or iron & wine.

I agree with Iron & Wine, but i think that Bruce would have been on the bottom still. The votes for him were close to the top and few and far between. There's no way we can eliminate trend-based voting, but we could narrow it down with a post limit.

[chipdip18]

There should be an IQ limit, not post limit hahah. Really, you never know who knows what they're talking about and people that could just reiterate other things they've heard on AP, or just name whatever bands. Post count does not separate the two.

Yeah, you are right. But how could we judge something like an IQ limit here on AP? Realistically, we can't, but a post limit could make up for some of that you know? Ugh, in a perfect world we wouldn't have to deal with these variables.

[Yes. And?]

I think only one of my favorite bands (Thursday) made it. Might be wrong, too lazy to check back.

[handlikesecret]

does this mean i'm not an idiot/philistine for not having The Beatles on my list?

[chipdip18]

I think only one of my favorite bands (Thursday) made it. Might be wrong, too lazy to check back.


Thursday was a pleasant surprise.

[x togepi x]

does this mean i'm not an idiot/philistine for not having The Beatles on my list?

a bunch of people who were saying they were overrated last week will say yes while continuing to assert periodically that they are overrated.

[murrich]

Yeah, I hate people with low post counts.

[allhourcymbals]

to look deep, you'd be surprised how many people want to look cultured and intelligent by having bands they don't like on their ipod. it's the same with books they won't read on their bookshelf.

it's the kind of thing that drives people to have "favorite band" lists of about 50 bands.
Seriously though, if these people HAVE the music to pretend to like it, why not start listening? It just makes no sense, and makes me want to cry a little.
Yeah, you are right. But how could we judge something like an IQ limit here on AP? Realistically, we can't, but a post limit could make up for some of that you know? Ugh, in a perfect world we wouldn't have to deal with these variables.

I was just sayin'. Post count doesn't mean anything. Personally, I think it should have been a top 20-25, and given reasons for why they chose they band, and what about them puts them at the number they were at. Yeah, it'd be a little more effort, but it'd weed out most of the ones that want to just put a certain artist just to say "Hey, look at me, look who I listen to."

[Yes. And?]

to look deep, you'd be surprised how many people want to look cultured and intelligent by having bands they don't like on their ipod. it's the same with books they won't read on their bookshelf.

That'd take up too much of my ipod space, I keep the stuff I only own too look elite in my itunes library unsynched.

[x togepi x]

Seriously though, if these people HAVE the music to pretend to like it, why not start listening? It just makes no sense, and makes me want to cry a little.


because you don't have to actually listen to a band to talk about it. most people are just pretentious.

[allhourcymbals]

I barely have enough room for all the music that I'd put at the top of my list on my ipod, let alone a band I'd have just to have it. Which are none, I'm sure.

[funkel]

Where did Andrew Jackson Jihad end up in the rankings?

[chipdip18]

Yeah, I hate people with low post counts.

Hahaha, not you.

Seriously though, if these people HAVE the music to pretend to like it, why not start listening? It just makes no sense, and makes me want to cry a little.


I was just sayin'. Post count doesn't mean anything. Personally, I think it should have been a top 20-25, and given reasons for why they chose they band, and what about them puts them at the number they were at. Yeah, it'd be a little more effort, but it'd weed out most of the ones that want to just put a certain artist just to say "Hey, look at me, look who I listen to."

That's true, and to be honest i threw this together pretty fast, which could account for some of any error. Someday we can perfect a way to make lists like these!

[wewascontenders]

oh wow

[handlikesecret]

a bunch of people who were saying they were overrated last week will say yes while continuing to assert periodically that they are overrated.
true enough. in all honesty, i have so much respect for them, i just have yet to get into their albums. same with a lot of what would be considered the "essentials." i really do plan on getting their albums though.

[chipdip18]

Where did Andrew Jackson Jihad end up in the rankings?


153

[allhourcymbals]

because you don't have to actually listen to a band to talk about it. most people are just pretentious.
You have an answer for everything, don't you hahah. So then what'd be the major reasoning behind all of that, to feel "accepted"? Why not just find other people that listen to what you really do listen to? It still makes no sense to me :-( I mean, I get what you're saying, I just don't see what kind of person does this.

[wewascontenders]

Did Life At These Speeds get any votes besides mine?

[chipdip18]

true enough. in all honesty, i have so much respect for them, i just have yet to get into their albums. same with a lot of what would be considered the "essentials." i really do plan on getting their albums though.

I'm with you kind of. I've started trying to get into a few of the "Essentials" and there are some i love, like, and don't like.

[x togepi x]

You have an answer for everything, don't you hahah. So then what'd be the major reasoning behind all of that, to feel "accepted"? Why not just find other people that listen to what you really do listen to? It still makes no sense to me :-( I mean, I get what you're saying, I just don't see what kind of person does this.

I don't know really. I've just met so many people who will lie to me about liking certain bands, only to find out that they've either never heard them. it's weird and kind of stupid since it's not like anyone thinks "oh man, this dude listens to at the drive-in, he must be cool as fuck".

[chipdip18]

You have an answer for everything, don't you hahah. So then what'd be the major reasoning behind all of that, to feel "accepted"? Why not just find other people that listen to what you really do listen to? It still makes no sense to me :-( I mean, I get what you're saying, I just don't see what kind of person does this.

With people like Ben on this site who trash you for listening to bad music, it's disheartening to talk about the bands that you like if they aren't the essentials, or considered good music, so people will fudge their own list just to avoid negativity.

Did Life At These Speeds get any votes besides mine?

One other at most.

[wewascontenders]

One other at most.

lameness

[handlikesecret]

I'm with you kind of. I've started trying to get into a few of the "Essentials" and there are some i love, like, and don't like.
yeah, and all people can really ask is that you respect it all in the end. with some people, that's all you'll get, which is fine.

[murrich]

Were The Beach Boys close? I thought they would at least get in the 20's.

[chipdip18]

yeah, and all people can really ask is that you respect it all in the end. with some people, that's all you'll get, which is fine.

Exactly. I respect Bruce Springsteen, but cannot get into his music.

[chipdip18]

Were The Beach Boys close? I thought they would at least get in the 20's.

They lost a lot of love in the second half of looking at lists if i remember right.

[allhourcymbals]

I don't know really. I've just met so many people who will lie to me about liking certain bands, only to find out that they've either never heard them. it's weird and kind of stupid since it's not like anyone thinks "oh man, this dude listens to at the drive-in, he must be cool as fuck".
I wonder where this trend started. People need to learn to enjoy things for the sake of enjoying them, and stop worrying about what everyone else thinks. I don't have any "guilty pleasures", I'm not ashamed for anything I listen to and no one has a reason to be ashamed or yelled at or even liked for what they listen to. Just because you listen to the same band as someone else doesn't automatically mean you're compatible, there's more to it than that.
With people like Ben on this site who trash you for listening to bad music, it's disheartening to talk about the bands that you like if they aren't the essentials, or considered good music, so people will fudge their own list just to avoid negativity.



One other at most.

People need to stand up for themselves. Or just learn to ignore it. Taste is subjective, if he thinks your music is shitty, chances are you're not a fan of what he listens to, you know? Also, Ben has never "trashed my music", I don't have a problem with him like everyone else seems to, and at least he has things to back up his argument as opposed to, oh I don't know, MHT?

[handlikesecret]

Exactly. I respect Bruce Springsteen, but cannot get into his music.
and if people don't respect that, that's their problem.

did The Starting Line rank at all?

[murrich]

They lost a lot of love in the second half of looking at lists if i remember right.

You should just change Brand New to The Beach Boys, haha.

[chipdip18]

I wonder where this trend started. People need to learn to enjoy things for the sake of enjoying them, and stop worrying about what everyone else thinks. I don't have any "guilty pleasures", I'm not ashamed for anything I listen to and no one has a reason to be ashamed or yelled at or even liked for what they listen to. Just because you listen to the same band as someone else doesn't automatically mean you're compatible, there's more to it than that.


People need to stand up for themselves. Or just learn to ignore it. Taste is subjective, if he thinks your music is shitty, chances are you're not a fan of what he listens to, you know? Also, Ben has never "trashed my music", I don't have a problem with him like everyone else seems to, and at least he has things to back up his argument as opposed to, oh I don't know, MHT?


I agree, but the fact is that people are insecure unfortunately. I don't really have a problem with Ben either, he does has reasons back up his ideas. People just need to shake guys like that off. He's just some dude on the internet. People need to stop being wimps when someone is offensive.

[allhourcymbals]

I agree, but the fact is that people are insecure unfortunately. I don't really have a problem with Ben either, he does has reasons back up his ideas. People just need to shake guys like that off. He's just some dude on the internet. People need to stop being wimps when someone is offensive.
I think a lot of people take it as him attacking them, when really he's just looking for a discussion, or even just an argument. It's not a personal attack in any way.

[chipdip18]

and if people don't respect that, that's their problem.

did The Starting Line rank at all?

33rd or 34th.

You should just change Brand New to The Beach Boys, haha.

Haha i changed Say Anything to the Descendents for a while, changed it back, then Verses God called me a facist. Not happening, sorry man.

[chipdip18]

I think a lot of people take it as him attacking them, when really he's just looking for a discussion, or even just an argument. It's not a personal attack in any way.

Yes, but most people can't read tone in typed out messages, and anything that could be rough in anyway is going to be taken in an offensive way. That's how our society works, that's how it'll work on here.

[handlikesecret]

33rd or 34th.
oh cool.

[murrich]

33rd or 34th.



Haha i changed Say Anything to the Descendents for a while, changed it back, then Verses God called me a facist. Not happening, sorry man.


Yeah forget about The Beach Boys plan anyway, I have a better idea, just copy/paste my list and make it the top 30. :-p

[chipdip18]

oh cool.

I was surprised.

[TheOtherAndrew]

1.) The Lawrence Arms
http://media.collegepublisher.com/media/paper746/stills/oknmlba7.jpg
Quoted for correcttttt.

[chipdip18]

Quoted for correcttttt.

I have been determined to find The Greatest Story Ever Told and buy it for at least four months now.

[TheOtherAndrew]

I have been determined to find The Greatest Story Ever Told and buy it for at least four months now.
DO IT BETTER!




x

[allhourcymbals]

DO IT BETTER!




x
x2, you know?

[chipdip18]

DO IT BETTER!




x


Will do sir! Anything you say sir! Yessir! :salute:

[chipdip18]

x2, you know?


Will do ma'am! Anything you say ma'am! Yessum! :salute:

[handlikesecret]

I was surprised.
that they were that high or low? i didn't expect them to be in the top 30, that's for sure.

[chipdip18]

that they were that high or low? i didn't expect them to be in the top 30, that's for sure.

That high, even Person L got some points.

[Troggy]

hahahahahaha jacks mannequin wtf

[Genuma]

This list is okay, but there's no ICP. wtf?

juggaloworld.net (http://absolutepunk.net/juggaloworld.net)

[chipdip18]

You and your juggalos.

[Genuma]

Juggalhos, you mean.

juggaloworld.net (http://absolutepunk.net/juggaloworld.net)

[handlikesecret]

All Time Juggalo.

[Yes. And?]

This list is okay, but there's no ICP. wtf?

juggaloworld.net (http://absolutepunk.net/juggaloworld.net)
absolutepunk.net/juggaloworld.net? THAT'D BE EPICNESS.

[allhourcymbals]

absolutejuggalos.orgy

[Genuma]

I'm pitching the idea to Tate to make one supersite.

juggaloworld.net (http://absolutepunk.net/juggaloworld.net)

[handlikesecret]

i'd post so much more often.

[Genuma]

I'd fit in so much better. :-( You know?

juggaloworld.net (http://absolutepunk.net/juggaloworld.net)

[versus_god]

Bring back the Descendents, you know?

:-(

You know?

[allhourcymbals]

Yeah dude.

[Genuma]

Yeah, and make ICP #1. They totally deserve it.

juggaloworld.net (http://absolutepunk.net/juggaloworld.net)

[versus_god]

Yeah fuckhead. Wanna fight?

[Genuma]

They were 31, Courntney. Did you have them? I think it's time for a GULIT TRIP.

juggaloworld.net (http://absolutepunk.net/juggaloworld.net)

[versus_god]

They were #16. chipdip18 is a pinko commie.

[Genuma]

Seriously. Who has dip with their chips? You know?

juggaloworld.net (http://absolutepunk.net/juggaloworld.net)

[allhourcymbals]

They were 31, Courntney. Did you have them? I think it's time for a GULIT TRIP.

juggaloworld.net (http://absolutepunk.net/juggaloworld.net)
Descendents? They were probably between 10-20 on my list, dude.

[allhourcymbals]

Cue Craig with the "Beatles are not the best band in the world" speech.

[Genuma]

Descendents? They were probably between 10-20 on my list, dude.
If they were in your top 10 they would have made it. You know?

[handlikesecret]

About 10 good bands and 20 bad bands.

Top two are however the best two bands of all time so not bad.
haha i knew you'd be pleased when i saw that, Ben.

[versus_god]

Norhtbrook? NORHTBROOK?

[allhourcymbals]

If they were in your top 10 they would have made it. You know?
If ICP were higher on your list THEY would have made it, you know? :-( You know?

[Genuma]

ICP was #1 on my list. I know.

juggaloworld.net (http://absolutepunk.net/juggaloworld.net)

[Genuma]

Norhtbrook? NORHTBROOK?
They were my #0? Where did you have them?!?!?!?!

norhtbrookworld.net (http://absolutepunk.net/norhtbrookworld.net)

[allhourcymbals]

Should have been higher, you know?

[El_Jeffe]

I feel the need to elaborate here.

30.) The Lawrence Arms :thumbup:
31.) The Format :shrug:
28.) The Get Up Kids :shrug:
27.) Godspeed You! Black Emperor :clap:
26.) Anberlin :thumbdwn:
25.) At the Drive-In :thumbup:
24.) Bob Marley & the Wailers (ONLY AT 24? :angry:)
23.) Cursive :mellow:
22.) Bruce Springsteen :dance:
21.) Something Corporate :shrug:
20.) Modest Mouse :explode:
19.) Saves the Day :wallbash:
18.) Sigur Rós :thumbup:
17.) Weezer :thumbup:
16.) Say Anything :shrug:
15.) New Found Glory :nono:
14.) mewithoutYou :-d
13.) Neutral Milk Hotel :celebrate:
12.) Death Cab For Cutie :thumbup:
11.) Thrice :thumbdwn:
10.) Thursday :shrug:
9.) Jimmy Eat World :party:
8.) Jack's Mannequin :shrug:
7.) Bright Eyes :thumbup:
8.) Bob Dylan :woot:
5.) Iron & Wine :appl:
4.) blink-182 :yuk:
3.) Brand New :-/
2.) Radiohead :thumbup:
1.) The Beatles (No Shit)

hahahaha this was the best evaluation of any list ever

it did seem like marley was getting a heap of votes? i thought he'd be higher to, but oh well, an appearance is nice haha

Cue Craig with the "Beatles are not the best band in the world" speech.

haha no way, not this time. i think they're a great band & genuinely do enjoy some of their work. i mean i don't hold them in #1, but i'm definitely not one of those "oh my god sooo overrated, listen to say anything instead!" folks. it's just people blindly buying into hype i don't enjoy & the way that any alternative perspective here is smashed with blind walls of "no, beatles"

[allhourcymbals]

hahahaha this was the best evaluation of any list ever

it did seem like marley was getting a heap of votes? i thought he'd be higher to, but oh well, an appearance is nice haha



haha no way, not this time. i think they're a great band & genuinely do enjoy some of their work. i mean i don't hold them in #1, but i'm definitely not one of those "oh my god sooo overrated, listen to say anything instead!" folks. it's just people blindly buying into hype i don't enjoy & the way that any alternative perspective here is smashed with blind walls of "no, beatles"
haha say anything. oh, you. i was just kidding anyway. you just always seem to chime in.

[Genuma]

Should have been higher, you know?
Well Norhtbrook took #0.

juggaloworld.net (http://absolutepunk.net/juggaloworld.net)

[allhourcymbals]

Followed by EVERYONE else disagreeing haha.
Haha, I've never really made where I stand on the Beatles clear on AP.

[handlikesecret]

Well Norhtbrook took #0.

juggaloworld.net (http://absolutepunk.net/juggaloworld.net)
lol i'm assuming there's a joke behind this?

[El_Jeffe]

Followed by EVERYONE else disagreeing haha.

hahaha fair call & pretty much how it went down. but oh well, i enjoyed the discussion? haha

Haha, I've never really made where I stand on the Beatles clear on AP.

you & your mob picked them over crowded house! don't let the door hit ya, where evolution split ya, on the way out