PDA

View Full Version : Alkaline Trio - Agony & Irony


Gumbyjag
08/15/08, 12:18 AM
Alkaline Trio- Agony & Irony
Record Label- Epic
Release Date: July 1, 2008

Think back to your last mental breakdown. How about the last time you've spent a lonely night drunk and depressed? Like a good friend, Alkaline Trio have always been there for you.

Not to say the band hasn't had its own thick and thins. After injuries, a label fallout, and Crimson, it's safe to say Alkaline Trio are poised for a comeback. Multiple listens in, the only people the band seem to be intent on proving are themselves. Old school fans will see little correlation between Agony & Irony and the album using the Lord's name in vain, the obvious being the fact that the harmonic duo of Matt Skiba and Dan Andriano still carry the tunes into the bleak, yet tongue-in-cheek void of catchiness. Not to rule out Derek Grant; in fact, his fills seem to blend in so perfectly, you forget he's even there. While certainly layered and glossy, Agony & Irony is a step below Crimson in the over-produced department.

Without a doubt, the biggest draw of the record (and in every other CD Alkaline Trio has recorded) is the anthemic plethora of choruses shining in every single song. Even the duds ("In Vein," "Lost and Rendered") have their moments of bliss. A piano flourish here and there aid the obvious first single (and well chosen) "Help Me." "Ruin It" may be Alkaline Trio's most diverse song to date with a creepy intro all the way up until the chorus, pulled together with dark guitar accents and Andriano's seductively leery voice.

Careful to not cloud their lyrics with metaphors and symbolism, the words that bounce around Agony & Irony are as straightforward and simplified as ever. Each song tends to its own concerns, the song titles being direct references to the bad news being spewed from the lips of the tag team of vocalists. Yes, the main themes again residing in the bible of self-deprecating glory and unabashed apathy, including verses of blood, guts, and graves.

Alkaline Trio have made a career of shedding light on shitty situations. With Agony & Irony, they continue to grind their work into sharp knives poised to stab even the happiest schmuck whistling on cloud nine. Like the rest of their deep discography, this irresistible plunge into the heart the listener receives hurts so good.

Alkaline Trio's Crimson; Bayside; dark pop punk
Amazon (http://www.amazon.com/Agony-Irony-Deluxe-Alkaline-Trio/dp/B0019M82WG/ref=pd_bbs_sr_2?ie=UTF8&s=music&qid=1218784265&sr=8-2) (Deluxe Edition); Myspace (http://www.myspace.com/alkalinetrio)

ghelms88
09/01/08, 01:03 PM
I really enjoyed this album. 78% seems about right. I would have put it around an 80%

Shin Akuma
09/01/08, 01:14 PM
Crimson was much better!

chochobonewagon
09/01/08, 01:32 PM
yea, i really liked from here to infirmary

kittypants
09/01/08, 02:07 PM
great review, dude!

heyzombiehitler
09/01/08, 02:54 PM
Nice review. This album is the best thing to come out this year.

GoWaitInTheCar
09/01/08, 03:32 PM
Thumbs way down, sadly.

Dan1234
09/01/08, 04:19 PM
At first i really hated this record, but after listening to it 8 trillion times i've come around. My favorite song is Love Love Kiss Kiss.

hockeyguitar99
09/01/08, 05:41 PM
I really like this album, I probably would have given it around an 85, but great review.

SanePsychotic
09/01/08, 05:54 PM
"In Vein" a dud? Seriously?

Why Bother?
09/01/08, 06:41 PM
I love this record, so good.

AMAAS
09/01/08, 07:08 PM
terrible review, the 78% is spot on, but the actual review is bad, "Lost and Rendered" and "In Vein" are probably 2 of the best songs on the CD....while "Ruin It" and "Love Love, Kiss Kiss" are as saturated as a Trio song can get

aolsux
09/01/08, 07:15 PM
I like Crimson so much more than this.

SeanEBoy2686
09/01/08, 09:26 PM
i would rate the album around 80% and, for me, crimson is around 85%. my problem is with the actual review, 'Live Young, Die Fast' is probably the weakest on the album. You didn't mention this, but I can also see why a lot of people don't like 'Love Love Kiss Kiss'. However, for some reason I really enjoy the song despite the fact it doesn't quite fit the Trio song-mold.

singyoutocoma
09/01/08, 10:02 PM
'Live Young, Die Fast' is probably the weakest on the album.

Agreed. "In Vein" and "Lost and Rendered" might be my two favorites on the disc.

That said, I agree with the overarching theme of the review, and it was quite well-written. Good work.

slimfenix182
09/01/08, 10:10 PM
"In Vein" a dud? Seriously?

yeah.
ummm.
no.

haven't heard anyone call "in vein" a dud. one of dan's best songs ever. without a doubt.

DI Pistola
09/01/08, 10:41 PM
I don't think this record is anywhere near as dark or macabre as you make it out to be. Actually a lot more "lighthearted" if the band were ever trying, as they ever have.

mrzippo3
09/01/08, 11:17 PM
I've never really been a fan of Alk3, but I got this cd for free and have really enjoyed it. Can't wait to see them with Rise Against, Thrice, and TGA

smelltheglove
09/02/08, 07:47 AM
its their worst album. overproduced, too many samples, too glossy, lacking heartfelt lyrics, they sound like they're just going through the motions. The first half is pretty decent, "calling all skeletons" and "help me" are clearly the albums standouts. "over and out" and "do you wanna know" are both decent and have some hints of past Trio sound to them. The rest is pretty shitty, "live young die fast" is a corny ballad, "love love kiss kiss" is Andrianos most trite and mediocre song to date, "ruin it" and "lost and rendered" are complete filler and "i found away", which could have been great, is ruined by disco effects and beats during the chorus.

Derek stands out as usual, which is kind of a bad thing...he is clearly the most talented musician in the band and his drumming often stands out too much and conflicts with the feel of the songs, its almost distracting because he is too good and packs too many fills and complex drumming into what are simple pop punk songs.

and the lyrics are piss poor compared to what they used to write. to me, they made a sound for themselves that is hard to evolve from with age, so as they are now in their 30's, it is becoming apparant that their sound was not made to go more than 10 years. to me, they have been on a steady decline of album quality since "from here to infirmiry".

CdMBoarder
09/02/08, 09:03 AM
This album is sweet but I think all albums from alk3 rock! crimson was another awesome release and to me... better than agony and irony

Karl Hansen
09/02/08, 10:34 AM
This has really grown on me and as of today I think it's up to par with "Infirmary" and Good MOurning...which are my favourite Alk3 albums. I'd give it 90%

ouroboros85
10/05/08, 12:51 PM
I don't think this record is anywhere near as dark or macabre as you make it out to be. Actually a lot more "lighthearted" if the band were ever trying, as they ever have.
i couldn't agree more. they have lost what alkaline trio once was. three guys singing about "help me help me" "sing me one last song". come on...