Hardcore

[Wez1212Yes]

Who are the best of these Hardcore Punk bands?I love them all but for different reasons however I always appreciated,seeing as Hardcore Pun especially was an attack on genericism,Refused and Fucked Up 'cos unlike so many oters they experimented rather than becoming so generic after a few album's.However Converge are certainly the most brutal and Bad Brains deserve mentioning for the simple reason the genre wouldn't exist as it does today without them.

[mht]

Other:

The Trouble/Panic

[Wez1212Yes]

Other:

The Trouble/Panic

Cool choice I should of listed another option sorry haha.

[lightcollapse]

From Ashes Rise was an awesome band.

[Wez1212Yes]

From Ashes Rise was an awesome band.

Yep they were I'm sorry I should of listed an option for other haha I didn't expect so many people to choose other though so I left it.

[Czarsy]

Definitely Bad Brains.

[AnchorDown]

From Ashes Rise was an awesome band.
dave is a rad guy !!!

[StreetSurgery]

Bad Brains shaped hardcore punk,
but my fave is Have Heart.

[Stephen Chamberlain]

Other: Blink 182

Nah, I say Refused because they were the most innovative/forward-thinking,

Fucked Up is bringing some experimentation, too, with their long songs and ambitious concepts.

[ThemChains]

I don't think I can answer this question...but alot of the bands mentioned under other are better than the options listed. Far better.

[Pat k]

Is this a joke? Bad Brains, easy.

[SoggY ThE OnE]

Most of these are not hardcore.
I picked Refused and Bad Brains(only true hardcore band on the list)

[shit stroll]

what?

[Czarsy]

Most of these are not hardcore.
I picked Refused and Bad Brains(only true hardcore band on the list)

What the fuck are you talking about?

[crappypunkrock]

H2o

[shit stroll]

H2o
no.

[summer skin]

"Time for some h2 oh yeaaaah"
http://www.simpsonstrivia.com.ar/simpsons-photos/wallpapers/duff-man.jpg

[crappypunkrock]

no.
yes

[AlternateToLife]

Doubt I consider them Hardcore Punk but Fugazi is my favorite of the list.

[Wez1212Yes]

Other: Blink 182

Nah, I say Refused because they were the most innovative/forward-thinking,

Fucked Up is bringing some experimentation, too, with their long songs and ambitious concepts.

Cool yeah I love Fucked Up.

[Wez1212Yes]

H2o

H2O as much as I love them are just pop-punk with shouty gang vocals.

[Wez1212Yes]

Doubt I consider them Hardcore Punk but Fugazi is my favorite of the list.

They are classed as melodic hardcore usually.

[AlternateToLife]

They are classed as melodic hardcore usually.

:shrug:

[shit stroll]

They are classed as melodic hardcore usually.
lol.

[Wez1212Yes]

:shrug:

Well they are or hardcore punk what else have you heard them classed as,other than post-hardcore and indie(which they aren't).

[AlternateToLife]

Well they are or hardcore punk what else have you heard them classed as,other than post-hardcore and indie(which they aren't).

I don't really base my opinions on what I've heard them classed as. Maybe I should but I don't.

[shit stroll]

Well they are or hardcore punk what else have you heard them classed as,other than post-hardcore and indie(which they aren't).
stop posting.

[ThemChains]

Well they are or hardcore punk what else have you heard them classed as,other than post-hardcore and indie(which they aren't).
Que?
stop posting.
This.

[MyNameIsRoss]

I said Bad Brains and Converge, but not a very good poll considering all these bands are of different time periods,sub genres etc. They're all great bands, however.

[Wez1212Yes]

I said Bad Brains and Converge, but not a very good poll considering all these bands are of different time periods,sub genres etc. They're all great bands, however.

That'sthe reason I did it partly to see which era was most popular.

[Wez1212Yes]

stop posting.

I'm not gonna stop posting ona thread that I created.

[Wez1212Yes]

I don't really base my opinions on what I've heard them classed as. Maybe I should but I don't.

I don't base my opinions on what i've heard someone classed as 'cos then I'd be calling Blink 182 punk haha but Fugazi are hardcore punk or at least derived from the genre anyway.

[AlternateToLife]

I'm not gonna stop posting ona thread that I created.

I think he meant in general ;-)

I don't base my opinions on what i've heard someone classed as 'cos then I'd be calling Blink 182 punk haha but Fugazi are hardcore punk or at least derived from the genre anyway.

Well I'm gonna have to disagree with you. Simple enough?

[ThemChains]

I think he meant in general ;-)


And he doesn't just mean the General Forum.

[Wez1212Yes]

And he doesn't just mean the General Forum.

Oh well fair enough just 'cos you disagree with something I say.

[AlternateToLife]

And he doesn't just mean the General Forum.

Haha nice.

[wewascontenders]

i approve of the posters in this thread. :thumbup:

[Wez1212Yes]

I think he meant in general ;-)



Well I'm gonna have to disagree with you. Simple enough?

What do you call Fugazi by the way.

[Wez1212Yes]

i approve of the posters in this thread. :thumbup:

How do you mean.

[AlternateToLife]

What do you call Fugazi by the way.

I've never really put any thought into it, I just don't classify them as harcore anything.

[shit stroll]

What do you call Fugazi by the way.
post hardcore.

[ThemChains]

Oh well fair enough just 'cos you disagree with something I say.

I believe the word is "because".

[wewascontenders]

this argument is over nothing. one side is saying fugazi evolved from hardcore and the other is saying they're post hardcore. you're all agreeing.

[Wez1212Yes]

post hardcore.

Yeah i've heard that but firstly I disagree and secondly after hardcore,punk,metal,pop-rock,alt rock to me there are no other genre's 'cos people seem to invent new one's everyday and it's stupid.Obviously I mean rock genre's haha.

[ThemChains]

this argument is over nothing. one side is saying fugazi evolved from hardcore and the other is saying they're post hardcore. you're all agreeing.

I'm not even arguing, it's the best part of being involved in the argument.

[Wez1212Yes]

this argument is over nothing. one side is saying fugazi evolved from hardcore and the other is saying they're post hardcore. you're all agreeing.

You are correct.

[Wez1212Yes]

I believe the word is "because".

Well spotted ain't you a genius I shorten words fucking deal with it.

[wewascontenders]

Yeah i've heard that but firstly I disagree and secondly after hardcore,punk,metal,pop-rock,alt rock to me there are no other genre's 'cos people seem to invent new one's everyday and it's stupid.Obviously I mean rock genre's haha.

yep, let's just ignore everything we're too dumb to understand. i see a future here.

I'm not even arguing, it's the best part of being involved in the argument.

that was more so for smart guy up there.

[ThemChains]

Well spotted ain't you a genius I shorten words fucking deal with it.
Yes, feed me your anger, feed me, feed me.
yep, let's just ignore everything we're too dumb to understand. i see a future here.



that was more so for smart guy up there.

Oh Greg. You dastardly man you.

[Wez1212Yes]

yep, let's just ignore everything we're too dumb to understand. i see a future here.



that was more so for smart guy up there.

I am not too dumb to understand but seriously sub-genre's are for twats.

[Wez1212Yes]

Yes, feed me your anger, feed me, feed me.


Oh Greg. You dastardly man you.

I ain't angry.

[ThemChains]

I ain't angry.

Yea, I'm fucking dealing with it.

[wewascontenders]

I am not too dumb to understand but seriously sub-genre's are for twats.

oh yeah man, i completely agree. fuckin twats need to stop doing shit to confuse us even more, right?

[shit stroll]

I am not too dumb to understand but seriously sub-genre's are for twats.
fake account.

[ThemChains]

fake account.

With a name like Wez1212YES, it's gotta be fake.



amirite?

[Wez1212Yes]

oh yeah man, i completely agree. fuckin twats need to stop doing shit to confuse us even more, right?

I'm not confused but I think half the time people invent sub-genre's for no god damn reason,you know you're either punk or not in a metal band or not.

[Wez1212Yes]

fake account.

Well how the fuck can you make a fake account.

[wewascontenders]

:hitself:

[ThemChains]

:hitself:

lol

[Wez1212Yes]

:hitself:
Well come on explain every genre you've ever heard and i'll prove that half of them sound the bloody same.

[wewascontenders]

sometimes i just get to into it. i start to enjoy myself.

[ThemChains]

Well come on explain every genre you've ever heard and i'll prove that half of them sound the bloody same.

This can't be true.

[wewascontenders]

i could so turn this into a race discussion if i wanted to.

[Wez1212Yes]

i could so turn this into a race discussion if i wanted to.

Eh.

[ThemChains]

i could so turn this into a race discussion if i wanted to.

George Bush doesn't care about black people.


Greg, am I doing it rite?

[Wez1212Yes]

This can't be true.

Well it's true so come on explain what is the difference between bands of let's say pop-rock, pop-punk you knowwhat makes Valencia deserve the term pop-punk(which they aren't) and certain others pop-rock when they sound the same,sing about the same subject matters and whinge just as much as everyone else.

[wewascontenders]

George Bush doesn't care about black people.


Greg, am I doing it rite?

i was going to take a different angle, but you just shit on that hypothetical chest.

[wewascontenders]

Well it's true so come on explain what is the difference between bands of let's say pop-rock, pop-punk you knowwhat makes Valencia deserve the term pop-punk(which they aren't) and certain others pop-rock when they sound the same,sing about the same subject matters and whinge just as much as everyone else.

lets go.....bands.......valencia......po p.....turkey......subject i approve of..... whinge??!?!?!........valencia...... promise of redemtion....pop-rock....., right?

[Wez1212Yes]

lets go.....bands.......valencia......po p.....turkey......subject i approve of..... whinge??!?!?!........valencia...... promise of redemtion....pop-rock....., right?

Not quite getting it but whatever,maybe you all need to realise half of the sub-genre's that you Americans invent just to seem cool and make it sound like it's something new have been tried and tested already over here in the UK.

[wewascontenders]

correct, uk > usa. would you like door number one, two, or three?

[Wez1212Yes]

correct, uk > usa. would you like door number one, two, or three?

What's behind each,countries,bands what.

[wewascontenders]

tea, crumpets, and poor dental care.

[ThemChains]

tea, crumpets, and poor dental care.

ZING!

[Wez1212Yes]

tea, crumpets, and poor dental care.

Haha.

[love_american_style]

it was between Bad Brains and Converge for me.