PDA

View Full Version : The Alchemy Index 1,2,3, or 4?

TSLROCKS
08/31/08, 06:36 PM
Which Alchemy Index EP was your favorite?
11:11
08/31/08, 07:19 PM
I love Earth, especially Moving Mountains and Come All You Weary.
TSLROCKS
08/31/08, 07:20 PM
Mine has to be Fire. Just so fucking awesome
Un'Aria Ancora
08/31/08, 07:33 PM
I went with Water, but Earth and Wind are all so close.
Fire is 4th for me, but it's still great.
xcatharticxlove
09/02/08, 10:31 AM
They're all so amazing it was the hardest thing to even choose
I chose water though
that CD is one of the most inspiring things I have ever heard
although they all are...
AHH its too hard!
TheZeroKid
09/03/08, 11:00 AM
I went with Water, even though I hardly ever listen to a single EP of TAI, I usually listen to the whole thing through and through. I just think Water's sound is waayy cool.
WhitestKidUKnow
09/04/08, 09:14 AM
i say air, but fire is a really really close number 2
iKrazie
09/04/08, 09:24 AM
moving mountains =]
MinusTheFear
09/04/08, 11:36 AM
Earth by far.
How can you say no to the Blues. Insanely talented.
tonighttonight0
09/04/08, 06:58 PM
I had to go for Earth, Come All You Weary is just amazing
ForeverDelayed
09/04/08, 07:16 PM
I'm not really big on Thrice, but Water really caught my ear. But in all fairness, I haven't heard anything from the 3 and 4 except the songs on myspace, so I can't definitively say 2 is my favorite yet.
BrokenMirror
09/05/08, 02:14 AM
Water>Air>Fire>>>Earth
tacosforcharles
09/05/08, 01:10 PM
Water blows me away every time. Goodness.
darkmartheight
09/05/08, 01:50 PM
i said air. but i should have clicked water.

both are mind exploding.
jbaseball44
09/05/08, 02:31 PM
Water
stdfly
09/06/08, 07:51 AM
water. air is close though.
Alex DiVincenzo
09/06/08, 08:52 AM
Fire
Co and Ca
09/06/08, 02:18 PM
Water.
princesschad
09/06/08, 06:50 PM
Water>Air>Earth>Fire.
J Me
09/06/08, 09:14 PM
Air. Daedalus is incredible. Water was a close second though
yourprivateeye
09/06/08, 09:16 PM
earth>fire>water>air

but my favorite thrice song (and 2nd all time favorite song ever) is daedalus.
makeasound
09/07/08, 01:18 PM
Mine has to be Fire. Just so fucking awesome
What he said.
SuNDaYSTaR
09/08/08, 08:00 PM
Aqva.
CloseToShore
09/09/08, 03:40 PM
Chose Water, but it was tossup between that and Air. Earth and Fire were both awesome in their own way, but I fell in love with Water the moment I heard it.
emkvetwin
09/09/08, 03:56 PM
Air. Daedalus and Broken Lungs are both incredible songs, and there isn't a weak song there. Water is a close second... Lost Continent, Night Diving, and The Whaler are all jaw-dropping.
Deadbolt01
09/11/08, 02:24 PM
I decided on water.
Scott Farcas
09/13/08, 01:09 PM
Earth hands down