In Defense Of The Genre Or ...Is A Real Boy

[TSLROCKS]

IDOTG or IARB?

[TSLROCKS]

Gotta be IARB. Such a fantastic album from start to finish. Not one moment I get bored at all.

[tommyhaych]

IARB for me, deffo. Max was at an awesome level of pretension which created some of the best music ever written to a disc. The new album, to me, shouts "Hey, I can get places with my cockiness, lets turn it up a notch!!"

[adam289]

In Defense Of The Genre

[just.Starla.]

both are amazing. but i think i'm going with IDOFTG

[ManicanParty49]

I can't stand In Defense. Just personal preference though. IARB gets my vote.

[anamericangod]

This should be more one sided than a Brand New poll.

[Alex DiVincenzo]

Love them both but not much tops IARB

[marleymartin22]

This should be more one sided than a Brand New poll.
HA!

[doitforjay]

In Defense of the Genre easilly.



Oh...you like Monty Python too then. Makes sense.

[phoenixinflames]

I don't skip around on IARB.

I DO skip around on IDOTG because 2/3 of the tracks are stupid.

Just cause you wrote 27 songs doesn't mean they should all go on your next record.

[darkmartheight]

IARB. not even a question in my mind.

[SeanEBoy2686]

Is A Real Boy...

I am surprised that it's not closer though, considering the reception of IDOTG among users on this site

[I'm DC]

As much as I like In Defense of the Genre, I Love ... Is A Real Boy.

IDOTG has a few songs that- if they weren't on the record, I wouldn't mind. Where as I can't listen to ...Is A Real Boy without hearing Belt first and Admit It last.

[IceAge/HeatWave]

while i love both, max seems so much more intellectual and disturbed on IARB. the new one was a tad to reliant on his insane, wandering side.

IARB FTW

[hockeyguitar99]

I love IDOTG, and it will always be one of my favorite records, so thats what I voted for.

[nashiscash1324]

In Defense takes the cake in my opinion...but i really enjoy both

[notoaststereo]

iarb

[tait]

Iarb

[Keagan Ilvonen]

IARB lol. No contest.

[Alexx Miller]

I'm a fan of shorter records, so IARB. Man I feel guilty...

[jjjkman]

i love both, i like almost every say anything song there is, but ...Is A Real Boy is just amazing, probably in my top 3 albums

[J Me]

...Is a Real Boy by a mile. it's flawless and probably one of my favorite albums. not saying much since im 15

[11:11]

this was over before it began.

[justletgo]

Menora/Mejora?

[Matt008]

...Is a real boy.. not even fucking close

[iKrazie]

i dont really like say anything......but i voted for IDOTG just to read the thread XD

[SSLYBY]

I didn't even think this was debatable.. IARB all the way.

[ChevyAlligator]

I couldn't see why you'd vote for In Defense....

Even if it was a single disc of the best songs on the album, it'd still be behind ... Is A Real Boy.

[FayeQC]

As much as I love IDOTG, songs like spidersong and woe are too awesome.

[MyWorldEntire]

I enjoy more songs on IDOTG, so I went with that.

[Kid B]

This argument has been done so many times.

[speakhandsforme]

If IARB didn't have "Alive With the Glory of Love," I'd likely go with IDOTG...but the cd which hosts my favorite song must get the vote.

[thespearkid]

Two wonderful albums. IARB is a classic though.

[hf57]

IARB by far. i still think IDOTG would have been much better as just one album.

[handlikesecret]

i love both, but IARB gets it.

[Indoor Living]

For me, There's too much filler on In Defense.

[BigAl]

IARB.
I listen to it every day.

[x1onexwo1fx]

i love all except four songs off of idotg. i probably havent spent enough time with iarb, but i really don't understand why iarb is winning by so much. i personally think the ratio of filler songs on iarb is greater.

[seraph1214]

Definitely IARB. IDOTG was cool but had some mad filler.

[fadedmemories]

IARB. No contest.

[Theseventhson]

Iarb

[AussieBoy]

IARB... only cause its semi related to .. was a real boy. and thats got the only SA songs i like (alive & ..sexual too)

[junjunzero]

IARB is the classic and the better album hands down but IDOTG is underrated and also a great album...too many people dismiss it `cuz it dosen`t sound like IARB and they are missing out on another great album. a different experince but also a very exciting one.