Favorite Thrice Album

[TheZeroKid]

Since, Thrice is awesome, I made a poll about their discography. I decided to make The Alchemy Index into just one album that encompasses all 4 EPs since it's technically one album. So, which album is your favorite Thrice achievment?

[Protested Hero]

Vheissu.

[KyleMcr]

This is a very tough choice, but i'm going to have to say The Artist In the Ambulance.

[phoenixinflames]

I'm going with The Alchemy Index. Illusion of Safety being right behind it, but that's more for nostalgic reasons.

[cassusriff]

So hard to choose! I'll go with the album that personally affected me the most.

I bought Artist in the Ambulance first so that one had a pretty big impact.
Got IOS after AITA, so it didn't have as big of an affect on me.
Vheissu took me over a year to settle into.
The Alchemy Index may have saved my life... so that is the winner.

[CH!MP]

The Artist...fave album ever pretty much. Vheissu is a really great album but i love every song on The Artist... and i dig the heavyness, so it wins.

Artist>Vheissu>Alchemy>Illusion>Identity Crisis

[Paulb-182]

Illusion

[smelltheglove]

they're all good, but "illusion of safety" is definitly my favorite.

Illusion of safety>vheissu>artist in the ambulance>alchemy index>identity crisis

[White Noise]

Musically their best is Vheissu, but TAITA will always hold that special place in my heart.

[Anthony Lutz]

The Artist In The Ambulance ftw!

[cason eat world]

Vheissu is perfect in every way.

[princesschad]

Vheissu is a damn perfect album.

[Deadbolt01]

Used to think IOS, now its Vheissu.


1. V
2. IOS
3. TAI
4. TAITA
5. IC

[PubeyLewis]

If you really think anything after Artist in the Ambulance is their "best," then you must like really boring music.

Just play some old Thrice and it'll wake you out of your coma.

That is one band that went from, "my new favorite band" to "sounds like elevator music"

Please one day come back with some good stuff...

[Kid B]

Vheissu fucking owns all of them

[callingallcars]

this poll was the hardest thing ive ever had to choose from

[king marcello]

Vheissu all the way.

then Artist

Then Alchemy Index

Then Illusions

[Kid B]

Vheissu > IOS > TAITA > TAI > IC

[SuNDaYSTaR]

The Artist In The Ambulance. Very close call with Vheissu though.

[Sic Transit Zeb]

alchemy index easily

[Alex DiVincenzo]

Illusion of Safety. Can't get into the newer stuff, just too slow for me.

[theguy77]

they never realized their potential as a band until TAI. i cant stand how sooo many of their fans want them to return to shallow scene music. the music is fun and definitely gets you going at a show but thrice are not just another one of those bands anymore, they stand out, they're doing a lot with their music and creativity, their music has substance now.

vheissu still counts though, that album has substance it just isnt as expressive or diverse as TAI.

[porttheman]

IOS for me

[Poochemist]

If you really think anything after Artist in the Ambulance is their "best," then you must like really boring music.

Just play some old Thrice and it'll wake you out of your coma.

That is one band that went from, "my new favorite band" to "sounds like elevator music"

Please one day come back with some good stuff...

False. I started getting into Thrice shortly after the Illusion of Safety was released. I loved it. I loved the follow-up. But Vhiessu is the most dynamic, interesting, and in my opinion, best release they've come out with. It transcends "hardcore punk."

[xerovision1]

artist in the ambulance. if you disagree, you're wrong.

[xSpillFiction]

So tough. I picked the Artist in the Ambulance, but The Illusion of Safety was a close second.

[phoenixinflames]

If you really think anything after Artist in the Ambulance is their "best," then you must like really boring music.

Do you realize how silly this makes you sound?

[Ryzenfall]

Vheissu is actually kind of perfect. I picked the Alchemy Index though. I really need to buy the rest of their entire albums previous.

[roju]

Aita

[Neo Cassady]

TAITA. It's also the only album I own on both CD and vinyl.

[yourprivateeye]

vheissu. top 5 best albums of all time.

it's so hard to put them in order. all are so amazing yet so different.

[midtown4657]

damn. you guys really dig that Vheissu record. i never even got through it. never heard the alchemy index. but probably one of the first two. i said illusion, but i dunno. identity crisis is pretty sweet too..

[SethGrandpa]

The Artist In The Ambulance. It's one of my favorite records ever. The most perfect mix of being heavy and still having supreme melody I've that ever heard. And I don't care for any of Thrice's stuff after that, it all feels like it's trying too hard to be deep and progy, but it just fails.

[Fedaykin]

how could anyone vote for identity crisis? other than phoenix ignition i find that whole album to be fairly useless

[Crosswind Ghost]

Vheissu > TAITA > TAI > IOS > IDC

[Domenic182]

What the hell are you people smoking?

[Broden Terry]

The Alchemy Index :nod:

[Theseventhson]

The Alchemy Index is the only one I like, the rest is meh.

[TotalCollapse]

Vheissu