PDA

View Full Version : Shittier Live Voice

creedsucks
12/27/04, 02:27 PM
Which has the worst voice live?

Neither one of these fuckers are on pitch live
Shellular
12/27/04, 02:39 PM
hmm. i like both. so i cant vote.
SuperWoman7700
12/27/04, 02:40 PM
hmm. i like both. so i cant vote.

Same here.
mondeoman
12/27/04, 02:40 PM
I saw em both at Warped Tour and Ryan Key and Yellowcard were by far the worst. Well unless you count Jordan from NFG. TERRIBLE
PunkDrums182
12/27/04, 02:41 PM
never heard the early november live, but i have heard yellow card and he wasnt bad..
SilverStar89
12/27/04, 02:43 PM
When I saw Yellowcard awhile back Ryan's voice was pretty sucky throughout the show and I saw the Early November back in the summer and Ace put on an awesome show and his voice was awesome.
Louise Heng
12/27/04, 02:50 PM
when I saw yellowcard around halloween, he was right on for most of it. I've never heard TEN live though, so I couldn't say.
SC0926
12/27/04, 03:55 PM
ive seen them both. I thought the dude from Yellowcard wasnt too bad...Ace's voice was a little off when i saw him...nothing horrible..but a bit..than again, he only sang like 3 or 4 songs cuse he got knocked out during the set...but anywho. i voted for him. ah well. i still like the early november, and I can make a mess like nobodys business
The Dove Song
12/27/04, 04:05 PM
I voted Ryan. I've seen them both but I think Ace had the better voice. Yet, I love both of them. But yeah. Ace had the better voice live.
takingback98
12/27/04, 05:14 PM
ive never seen the early november libe but i saw yellowcard and it wasnt half bad so i voted for ace
YearsGoneBy
12/27/04, 06:31 PM
ace and the early november put on a kick ass live show, i saw them in the summer and last week and they were fine. great stuff but i did see vma's and yellowcard sucked.
irthesteve
12/27/04, 07:18 PM
they both have great live shows, neither voices are that terrible, but ace is near flawless live, so i voted him over ryan. but ryan doesnt sound bad
Greg
12/27/04, 07:18 PM
those were horrible choices
mondeoman
12/27/04, 08:25 PM
ive seen them both. I thought the dude from Yellowcard wasnt too bad...Ace's voice was a little off when i saw him...nothing horrible..but a bit..than again, he only sang like 3 or 4 songs cuse he got knocked out during the set...but anywho. i voted for him. ah well. i still like the early november, and I can make a mess like nobodys business
He got knocked out? I wanna hear about this.
Lueda Alia
12/27/04, 08:49 PM
Yellowcard may not be all that great, but they're so awesome live. I was really blown away by their performance at Warped.
SuperWoman7700
12/27/04, 08:56 PM
i dont think either of them suck live. although i will admit that some nights ryan key is WAY off. i've seen yellowcard a lot and i think only once was ryan really bad. ive only seen TEN live twice and ace was good both times.
FalloutGuy
12/27/04, 11:43 PM
Without a shadow of a doubt, Ryan sucks large amounts of ass when performing live.
punklet2101
12/27/04, 11:50 PM
I've never seen TEN, but i've seen Yellowcard twice and he sounded good both times... he sounded just like he does on CD's.

The first time I saw Yellowcard was better, they played acoustically in a beer garden.. they had no microphones but their voices were really powerful, they sounded great.. especially the violin guy, he was really good.
deathgrin
12/28/04, 10:25 AM
Ryan definitely.
tRigGerFinGeR
12/28/04, 10:37 AM
Wait, I've seen Yellowcard live and they were fuking amazing, really i thought his signing was awesome...
Greg
12/28/04, 10:49 AM
ace was fucking amazing live when i saw TEN. but that ICMAM vid on DTR.com he couldnt hit the hight notes. but i cant either. so i still say he's great. or smething
firecrackermank
12/28/04, 11:02 AM
haven't heard any of them live.
irthesteve
12/28/04, 11:23 AM
these wer'ent very good choices, shoulda done taking back sunday vs. coheed or something
Lueda Alia
12/28/04, 01:12 PM
taking back sunday sucked so much when I saw them at warped.
irthesteve
12/28/04, 02:44 PM
taking back sunday sucked so much when I saw them at warped.
i enjoyed the show probably just cuz i was in front and such, but the vocals werent too good...
OiPunk
12/28/04, 08:09 PM
I saw em both at Warped Tour and Ryan Key and Yellowcard were by far the worst. Well unless you count Jordan from NFG. TERRIBLE
Yeah I heard Yellowcard sucked what was happening?
Jim Morgan
12/28/04, 09:12 PM
nfg, yc, and ten all have great voices live, there have been times ive seen them and they havent been that great.

one im not to fond of is halifax
Mouse
12/29/04, 11:51 AM
Ryan, to me, has the shittier voice. Ryan has great energy, but the vocals leave something to be desired.

But, it's all good. Nobody is perfect.
yc_mest
12/30/04, 12:29 PM
i cant believe people think ryan has a band voice live. his voice is better then 95% of the bands out there on this site. he one of the few people that actually have a good voice