View Full Version : Which Green: Anthony or Dallas?
voncorn
09/22/08, 08:17 AM
My vote goes to Dallas Green, since City And A Colour is pretty decent.
I dislike Saosin, I hate Circa Survive, and I can't stand The Sounds Of Animals Fighting. Haven't heard Anthony Green's solo stuff, but I don't expect to be very fond of any of it.
absolutecrunk
09/22/08, 08:25 AM
http://www.jazzpolice.com/images/stories/AlGreen.jpg
hockeyguitar99
09/22/08, 08:25 AM
Anthony Green by miles.
Regards
09/22/08, 08:33 AM
Forest green imo.
xBITCHxPLEASEx
09/22/08, 08:34 AM
Anthony.
absolutecrunk
09/22/08, 08:36 AM
The correct answer is that if you answer, you're wrong.
alice+interiors
09/22/08, 08:45 AM
lol, City and A Colour. Shows how much you really are into the band.
Regards
09/22/08, 08:45 AM
The correct answer is that if you answer, you're wrong.
I should've known. I also screw these trick questions up.
White Noise
09/22/08, 09:25 AM
Not really a fan of either anymore, but Anthony, even though he has the most annoying stage presence.
lindZ629
09/22/08, 09:42 AM
Neither, they're both horrible.
Dallas by a long shot.
Although I was pleasantly surprised by Anthony's solo record.
theguy77
09/22/08, 10:15 AM
dallas has a better voice for sure
llwilliamsll
09/22/08, 10:49 AM
The color green...well a more forest green is better than either.
HangsLikeHeaven
09/22/08, 10:50 AM
Neither beaver.
Punkk_Bitchh
09/22/08, 10:57 AM
Man,
Thats hella hard.
But im going to have to choose Anthony Green.
His voice is so different,
And his song writting skills are amazing.
summer skin
09/22/08, 11:22 AM
http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y112/Vordrax/Creepy%20pictures/jollygreen.jpg
lenard27
09/22/08, 11:24 AM
Although I like both and I think Anthony is the better singer, Dallas isn't too far behind and I love Alexisonfire. So he got my vote.
KatieKutthroat.
09/22/08, 12:38 PM
http://www.jazzpolice.com/images/stories/AlGreen.jpg
exactly what i thought when i saw this thread.
nonamesleft
09/22/08, 01:00 PM
Dallas.
Getup and Dance
09/22/08, 01:04 PM
Damn I wanted to be the first person to say Al Green.
Getup and Dance
09/22/08, 01:11 PM
Also Derrick Green is better than those two.
http://blog.petegraham.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2007/02/derrick.jpg
fadedmemories
09/22/08, 01:16 PM
Anthony Green
I don't see why anyone thinks Dallas Green is any good
Getup and Dance
09/22/08, 01:28 PM
Anthony Green
I don't see why anyone thinks Dallas Green is any good
I dont see why anyone thinks Anthony Green is any good.
fadedmemories
09/22/08, 01:37 PM
I dont see why anyone thinks Anthony Green is any good.
:shrug: Me too :-)
theguy77
09/22/08, 02:13 PM
http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y112/Vordrax/Creepy%20pictures/jollygreen.jpg
hahahaa
Here It Goes
09/22/08, 02:14 PM
What a bunch of collectively stupid answers.
Both Anthony Green and Dallas Green have incredible voices. Anthony's is ridiculously high, which somehow fits the music he makes, but can also get inredibly annoying.
Dallas Green's voice shouldn't be judged on the basis of those who have heard Alexisonfire. His voice is lost in that band. To the few posters who think that Dallas Green doesn't have a good voice, listen to "Hello, I'm in Delaware" by City and Colour, and change your mind. I don't know many people who can hit that note at the end.
JnLULIGekIA
theguy77
09/22/08, 02:16 PM
What a bunch of collectively stupid answers.
Both Anthony Green and Dallas Green have incredible voices. Anthony's is ridiculously high, which somehow fits the music he makes, but can also get inredibly annoying.
Dallas Green's voice shouldn't be judged on the basis of those who have heard Alexisonfire. His voice is lost in that band. To the few posters who think that Dallas Green doesn't have a good voice, listen to "Hello, I'm in Delaware", and change your mind. I don't know many people who can hit that note at the end.
haha, its only a Bb. anyone with a tenor II range or above can hit it without too much straining and some baritones can. he goes two notes higher than that, hitting a C in the alexisonfire song "no transitory".
but i will say dallas has more control over his voice than practically any "scene" singer i know of
summer skin
09/22/08, 02:18 PM
haha, its only a Bb. anyone with a tenor II range or above can hit it without too much straining and some baritones can.
but i will say dallas has more control over his voice than practically any "scene" singer i know of
Too bad he was in in Alexisonfire so is automatically gay and stupid.
thread win.
Getup and Dance
09/22/08, 02:19 PM
What a bunch of collectively stupid answers.
Both Anthony Green and Dallas Green have incredible voices. Anthony's is ridiculously high, which somehow fits the music he makes, but can also get inredibly annoying.
Dallas Green's voice shouldn't be judged on the basis of those who have heard Alexisonfire. His voice is lost in that band. To the few posters who think that Dallas Green doesn't have a good voice, listen to "Hello, I'm in Delaware" by City and Colour, and change your mind. I don't know many people who can hit that note at the end.
JnLULIGekIA
Derrick Green is still better.
Here It Goes
09/22/08, 02:20 PM
haha, its only a Bb. anyone with a tenor II range or above can hit it without too much straining and some baritones can. he goes two notes higher than that, hitting a C in the alexisonfire song "no transitory".
but i will say dallas has more control over his voice than practically any "scene" singer i know of
Man, good answer. Are you seriously some sort of singing expert? I can't pick out notes like that. All I know is that it sounds high.
I'm an AG fanboy so he gets my vote. Dallas green isn't too bad either, I like alexisonfire a lot.
summer skin
09/22/08, 02:26 PM
Too bad he was in in Alexisonfire so is automatically gay and stupid.
thread win.
um excuse me but this thread is done.
theguy77
09/22/08, 02:30 PM
Man, good answer. Are you seriously some sort of singing expert? I can't pick out notes like that. All I know is that it sounds high.
yeah well i mean im not really a singing expert per se im still working on my technique but i do know my theory and have perfect pitch to an extent.
it probably sounds super high in that song because thats the only time he belts the whole time, so the dynamic of his voice is a lot more punchy and loud, whereas in an alexisonfire song hes belting the whole time, and since alexisonfire generally makes a loud style of music, loud singing fits in the mix in a lot more subtle way.
Getup and Dance
09/22/08, 02:30 PM
um excuse me but this thread is done.
Fuck you Summer Skin.
summer skin
09/22/08, 02:32 PM
Fuck you Summer Skin.
What do I look like? SickofStars?
City and The Colour is astoundingly awful, so I guess Anthony Green.
Here It Goes
09/22/08, 02:35 PM
yeah well i mean im not really a singing expert per se im still working on my technique but i do know my theory and have perfect pitch to an extent.
it probably sounds super high in that song because thats the only time he belts the whole time, so the dynamic of his voice is a lot more punchy and loud, whereas in an alexisonfire song hes belting the whole time, and since alexisonfire generally makes a loud style of music, loud singing fits in the mix in a lot more subtle way.
Yeah, true about the loudness. Well, that Bb is slightly out of my range, I mean I can hit it with falsetto of course but I can't belt it. Ha so I may not be that good of a singer after all! What sort of notes should an average person be able to hit?
Getup and Dance
09/22/08, 02:38 PM
What do I look like? SickofStars?
Yes, yes you do.
summer skin
09/22/08, 02:40 PM
Yes, yes you do.
Why, thank you.
theguy77
09/22/08, 02:43 PM
Yeah, true about the loudness. Well, that Bb is slightly out of my range, I mean I can hit it with falsetto of course but I can't belt it. Ha so I may not be that good of a singer after all! What sort of notes should an average person be able to hit?
i mean, it depends on your range. having a range that isnt focused highly doesnt make you a bad singer at all. the Bb is just out of my range as well. you're probably a baritone like me. while most scene singers are in that tenor II range you can still do a lot with a baritone one, most notably you can work on your lower notes and make them sound really smooth and breathy, you know utilize what you have.
IWasaCamera
09/22/08, 05:25 PM
Sam Beam.
Dallas by a long shot.
Although I was pleasantly surprised by Anthony's solo record.
co sign
softhands
09/22/08, 05:27 PM
Both are awesome...I couldn't pick a favorite.
StopActingDumb
09/22/08, 05:29 PM
City and Colours lyrics are too lame. It distracts me. Anthony Green FTW.
tiphany
09/22/08, 06:47 PM
Not really a fan of either anymore, but Anthony, even though he has the most annoying stage presence.
I went to a show with with Thrice headlining this summer and Pelican and Circa Survive supporting. My friends convinced me to go b/c I really wanted to see Pelican. Needless to say Pelican played for about a half hour and I was stuck watching Anthony Green jump around on stage like fucking Richard Simmons.
City and Colours lyrics are too lame. It distracts me. Anthony Green FTW.
City and Colour are too lame as a whole.
A Love American
09/22/08, 07:02 PM
Dallas.
Cuddleworthy
09/22/08, 08:32 PM
don't get all the hate on anthony's stage presence of all things. i dig the dance moves
thesafeword
09/22/08, 08:37 PM
Dallas Green fucking sucks and TTN was pretty damn good, so Anthony Green.
Anthony Lutz
09/22/08, 09:09 PM
My vote goes to Anthony Green. He's been in so many bands, and all of them are amazing. However, I do love Dallas Green as well, but since he hasn't released as much material and isn't a music making machine like Anthony is, that's why I had to vote for Anthony.
circasuicide
09/22/08, 09:10 PM
anthony. i dont like dallas's voice.
underthetalking
09/22/08, 09:11 PM
Anthony Green is fucking garbage.
jtsnazzy
09/22/08, 09:13 PM
Dallas because his voice makes hot secks with my ears.
xerovision1
09/22/08, 09:17 PM
Ag
thesafeword
09/22/08, 09:19 PM
Dallas because his voice makes hot secks with my ears.
He sounds like he's been smoking for his whole life.
Getup and Dance
09/22/08, 09:21 PM
He sounds like he's been smoking for his whole life.
Anthony Green sounds like he has been kicked in the testicles.
jtsnazzy
09/22/08, 09:25 PM
He sounds like he's been smoking for his whole life.
Then he has one ready for after he's done making love to my ears.
thesafeword
09/22/08, 09:31 PM
City & Colour sucks, Alexisonfire sucks. However, TTN did not suck, Circa doesn't suck and TSOAF is hit and miss, but mostly miss.
Getup and Dance
09/22/08, 09:33 PM
City & Colour sucks, Alexisonfire sucks. However, TTN did not suck, Circa doesn't suck and TSOAF is hit and miss, but mostly miss.
Circa Survive is horrible.
Your argument is invalid.
wtfmates
09/22/08, 09:37 PM
I thought Anthony Green's solo album was pretty okay, so I'll go with him, although neither are all that great.
Cuddleworthy
09/22/08, 09:43 PM
how does dallas' voice suck? i don't see how he sounds like he's been smoking either, his voice sounds very crisp
PoisonInMyVeins
09/22/08, 10:28 PM
yuck, neither.
White Noise
09/22/08, 10:43 PM
I went to a show with with Thrice headlining this summer and Pelican and Circa Survive supporting. My friends convinced me to go b/c I really wanted to see Pelican. Needless to say Pelican played for about a half hour and I was stuck watching Anthony Green jump around on stage like fucking Richard Simmons.
I had that same experience, but I knew in advance he would look like an idiot on stage.
fadedmemories
09/23/08, 02:10 AM
Too bad he was in in Alexisonfire so is automatically gay and stupid.
thread win.
:-d
City & Colour sucks, Alexisonfire sucks. However, TTN did not suck, Circa doesn't suck and TSOAF is hit and miss, but mostly miss.
Agreed
Dallas, city and colour are much better comparatively.
adam289
09/23/08, 04:43 AM
Neither.
cereal4life
09/23/08, 06:19 AM
Dallas, for sure. Better pitch and range.
theguy77
09/23/08, 06:22 AM
He sounds like he's been smoking for his whole life.
are you kidding? his voice doesnt sound raspy or hoarse at all.
theguy77
09/23/08, 06:23 AM
don't get all the hate on anthony's stage presence of all things. i dig the dance moves
yeah, dude's got charisma
Indoor Living
09/23/08, 06:50 AM
Olive Green. I just dig that darker, more raw look.
fadedmemories
09/23/08, 06:53 AM
yeah, dude's got charisma
Agreed
Circa1628
09/23/08, 06:54 AM
Anthony Green
Here It Goes
09/23/08, 11:37 AM
how does dallas' voice suck? i don't see how he sounds like he's been smoking either, his voice sounds very crisp
Quoted for emphasis, which Dallas Green have you all been listening to? His voice is ridiculously perfect, not raspy or off-key at all.
thesafeword
09/23/08, 08:59 PM
Circa Survive is horrible.
Your argument is invalid.
I like Circa, decent chill music and compared to Dallas' bands they're fucking awesome.
Getup and Dance
09/23/08, 09:19 PM
I like Circa, decent chill music and compared to Dallas' bands they're fucking awesome.
Im not a big fan of Alexisonfire, but they are way better that the shit music that is made in Circa Survive.
Your argument is invalid.
thesafeword
09/24/08, 08:39 PM
Circa Survive is a thousand times better than Alexisonfire and Circa isn't even that good.
DilesMavis
10/02/08, 01:37 PM
I kinda liked High and Driving, so Anthony I guess.
I don't think either are 'horrible' or 'shit' as it has been so eloquently put but I like both bands but I prefer City and Colour a little bit and Dallas' voice is fantastic, whereas AG's can sometimes be a little grating.
trashflvrdtrash
10/02/08, 07:14 PM
Dallas ftw.
Klatzke
10/02/08, 07:48 PM
yeah well i mean im not really a singing expert per se im still working on my technique but i do know my theory and have perfect pitch to an extent.
it probably sounds super high in that song because thats the only time he belts the whole time, so the dynamic of his voice is a lot more punchy and loud, whereas in an alexisonfire song hes belting the whole time, and since alexisonfire generally makes a loud style of music, loud singing fits in the mix in a lot more subtle way.
I think if he's good anywhere, it's in "Rough Hands." I don't think it's as much the notes he hits as his delivery/tone.
vBulletin v3.6.0, Copyright ©2000-2012, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.