View Full Version : MDC Review
Ryan Mills
01/15/05, 11:15 PM
I've posted a review of MDC (http://free.freespeech.org/deadcops/mainhome.htm) - Millions of Dead Cops/More Dead Cops right here (http://www.absolutepunk.net/reviews/showproduct.php?product=583).
I've decided to take some time and review some older albums that are important in some way. I will mostly concentrate on punk and hardcore, though won't limit it to those styles. If you have anything you'd like to see, post it in the replies and I'll consider it.
Trainwrecker
01/15/05, 11:29 PM
I don't know if it's a viable option, but I'd definitely like to see some classics reviewed.
Jawbreaker
Rites Of Spring
Moss Icon
Texas Is The Reason
Knapsack
Slowdive
Some new stuff I'd also love to see covered: Circle Takes The Square, Yaphet Kotto, Xiu Xiu, The Appleseed Cast, Cursive, These Arms Are Snakes.
I know that's a lot of suggestions, but just throwing some ideas out there.
robdobi
01/15/05, 11:33 PM
some aren't necessarily "important in some way" but i feel they are solid albums kids missed out on.
jawbreaker - dear you
grade - under the radar
the lawrence arms - the greatest story ever told
engine down - demure
also, dig into some good "screamo" such as 400 years, joshua fit for battle, there were wires, neil perry, the assistant, you and i etc...
Ryan Mills
01/15/05, 11:33 PM
I don't know if it's a viable option, but I'd definitely like to see some classics reviewed.
Jawbreaker
Rites Of Spring
Moss Icon
Texas Is The Reason
Knapsack
Slowdive
Some new stuff I'd also love to see covered: Circle Takes The Square, Yaphet Kotto, Xiu Xiu, The Appleseed Cast, Cursive, These Arms Are Snakes.
I know that's a lot of suggestions, but just throwing some ideas out there.
I reviewed CTTS already...it's in the reviews database. I'll take some of those into consideration for sure.
some aren't necessarily "important in some way" but i feel they are solid albums kids missed out on.
jawbreaker - dear you
grade - under the radar
the lawrence arms - the greatest story ever told
engine down - demure
also, dig into some good "screamo" such as 400 years, joshua fit for battle, there were wires, neil perry, the assistant, you and i etc...
Demure is such a good album. Songbird is one of my favorite songs ever
TomCantSlowDown
01/16/05, 12:21 AM
Lifetime!
Trainwrecker
01/16/05, 12:36 AM
I'd love to see a 'Dear You' review. It's got two of my favorite three Jawbreaker songs ever, 'Accident Prone,' and 'Bad Scene Everyone's Fault.'
The third of these being 'Indictment,' off of 24 Hour Revenge Therapy.
Do the classics, you know the real punk stuff. Taking Back Sunday, Rufio, Yellowcard.
Wait, I mean....
The Promise Ring
At The Drive-In
Coalesce
Dismemberment Plan
Far
The Weakerthans
I would love to see what this site would rate these bands.
punkerx99
01/16/05, 03:53 AM
Thank you for reviewing this album. I don't even listen to MDC, but I just might now.
I would like to see these reviewed:
Refused- The Shape of Punk to Come
Lifetime- Jersey's Best Dancers
Gorilla Biscuits- Start Today
7 Seconds- Walk Together, Rock Together
Floorpunch- Fast Times at the Jersey Shore
Black Flag- Damaged
Minor Threat- Complete Discography
Thanks for being the man.
InaGreendase
01/16/05, 07:54 AM
I'd like to see a Dear You review only just to see what you think of the production. Let alone the fact that it was originally released by Geffen, I think it's horribly underproduced and I can't understand why everyone bitches about a supposed "gloss" on it. Yeah, it's a little better sound-wise than any of the band's earlier work, but it still has a really rough feel to it and they could've done way more stuff with Blake's voice than they did.
Rufio21
01/16/05, 07:58 AM
american nightmare, old converge, kill your idols, planes mistaken for stars, suicide file,
Rid Ickulous
01/16/05, 08:30 AM
How about some of the new wave of old schol hardcore or whatever it's called these days?
I really feel that many kids are missing out on the whole thing, especially since victory is so big these days and 10 years ago they totally kicked ass when it came to this genre.. Review some of the easy-listeneing newer gateway bands such as bane, stretch arm strong and so on. And, you should totally review "last of the famous", porcell from shelter/youth of today/judge/whatever new band with some other multi-band dudes and 2 swedes, it's totally pop punk but i'm hoping it will cause a boom in just plain old school fun hardcore, but i'm probably wrong.
Loserkidwk
01/16/05, 08:35 AM
you should review:
Misfits- Static Age
Circle Jerks- Golden Shower Of Hits
Minor Threat- Complete Discography
Ramones- road To Ruin
Jawbreaker- Dear You
Adolescents- S/T
Rufio21
01/16/05, 08:54 AM
How about some of the new wave of old schol hardcore or whatever it's called these days?
I really feel that many kids are missing out on the whole thing, especially since victory is so big these days and 10 years ago they totally kicked ass when it came to this genre.. Review some of the easy-listeneing newer gateway bands such as bane, stretch arm strong and so on. And, you should totally review "last of the famous", porcell from shelter/youth of today/judge/whatever new band with some other multi-band dudes and 2 swedes, it's totally pop punk but i'm hoping it will cause a boom in just plain old school fun hardcore, but i'm probably wrong.
I wouldnt really call bane new school. Last of the famous do also have one or two catchy songs.
They headlined skatefest and literally 10 people stayed to watch them. They were out of place.
left_punk
01/16/05, 10:00 AM
Holy shit, you reviewed an MDC album, I love you!
Ok, now review Reagan Youth and/or some Propagandhi records too!
burnpianoisland
01/16/05, 10:15 AM
Lifetime!
points for you...lifetime is the shizzzzznit
Ryan Mills
01/16/05, 10:15 AM
I'd like to see a Dear You review only just to see what you think of the production. Let alone the fact that it was originally released by Geffen, I think it's horribly underproduced and I can't understand why everyone bitches about a supposed "gloss" on it. Yeah, it's a little better sound-wise than any of the band's earlier work, but it still has a really rough feel to it and they could've done way more stuff with Blake's voice than they did.
I've actually written a review for Dear You a little while ago for a different site (of the reissue). I personally love the record.
burnpianoisland
01/16/05, 10:19 AM
Holy shit, you reviewed an MDC album, I love you!
Ok, now review Reagan Youth and/or some Propagandhi records too!
propaghandi! YES! i love you. everything those guys have done is awesome.
aminorthreat55
01/16/05, 10:32 AM
Thank you for reviewing this album. I don't even listen to MDC, but I just might now.
I would like to see these reviewed:
Refused- The Shape of Punk to Come
Lifetime- Jersey's Best Dancers
Gorilla Biscuits- Start Today
7 Seconds- Walk Together, Rock Together
Floorpunch- Fast Times at the Jersey Shore
Black Flag- Damaged
Minor Threat- Complete Discography
Thanks for being the man.
Yes.
swindlington
01/16/05, 01:24 PM
Punk:
The Mekons- Rock n Roll
Crass- Penis Envy
The Ex- Dizzy Spells
Pere Ubu- The Modern Dance
Gang of Four- Entertainment
Operation Ivy- Energy
The Toasters- Don't let the bastards get you down
The Specials- first one
Buzzcocks- Singles going steady
Rudimentary Peni- EP-LP
The Fall- This Nation's Saving Grace
Talking Heads- Talking heads: 77
DNA- DNA on DNA
Homosexuals- S/T
DOA- Any
Choking Victim- No gods, no managers
Nomeansno- 0+2=1
etc.:
Neutral Milk Hotel- any
Augie March- Strange Bird
Giant Sand- Is all over....the map
Angus Maclaurin- Glass Music
Weakerthans- Reconstruction Site
They Might Be Giants- Flood; Apollo 18
Rid Ickulous
01/16/05, 04:29 PM
I wouldnt really call bane new school. Last of the famous do also have one or two catchy songs.
They headlined skatefest and literally 10 people stayed to watch them. They were out of place.
Well, bane is still a band, so i didn't really mean new school, more just that they are one of the leading forces in the sort of revival of old school hardcore. And to Ryan, review anything from bridge 9, that would be cool to see on here.
And about last of the famous, yeah, they have 2 catchy songs, but the fact that hardcore dudes are playing poppunk on carson dalys label will always overshadow the music. Would be cool if they got big though because they havn't forgotten where they're from.
Bloody_Lil_Boy
01/16/05, 06:17 PM
You should really consider reviewing these...
From First To Last- Dear Diary, My Teen Angst Has A Body Count
The Matches- E. Von Dohl Killed The Locals
The Killers- Hot Fuss
Thursday- War All The Time
UnderOath- They're Only Chasing Safety
Hawthorne Heights- The Silence In Black And White
Talib Scottie
01/16/05, 09:17 PM
You should really consider reviewing these...
From First To Last- Dear Diary, My Teen Angst Has A Body Count
The Matches- E. Von Dohl Killed The Locals
The Killers- Hot Fuss
Thursday- War All The Time
UnderOath- They're Only Chasing Safety
Hawthorne Heights- The Silence In Black And White
most of these these arent exactly ryan's forte... try another reviewer
thenewline
01/16/05, 09:35 PM
most of these these arent exactly ryan's forte... try another reviewer
iam sure he was joking lol if not then idk............review some bob dylan or johny cash now thats punk
swindlington
01/16/05, 09:37 PM
iam sure he was joking lol if not then idk............review some bob dylan or johny cash now thats punk
Or some good ol' Link Wray.
Talib Scottie
01/17/05, 01:01 AM
iam sure he was joking lol if not then idk............review some bob dylan or johny cash now thats punk
steve miller band - abracadabra or either the pete townshend album with let my love open the door on it
fork_in_outlet
01/17/05, 11:41 PM
Minor Fucking Threat.
vBulletin v3.6.0, Copyright ©2000-2012, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.