what bands should do live albums with Symphony Orchestras

[theseacaptain]

i got this idea from S&M and another thread

personally i'd like to hear:
Chiodos
Coldplay
The Mars Volta
Pixies
Smashing Pumpkins
Screaming Trees
Cake
and possibly Flogging Molly

[domotime2]

haha Flogging Mollly with a full orchestra would be amazing ha....

but it has to be like "epic" kind of bands...with enough slower songs to go with it, like Pixies, smashing, volta were all good choices....


i could see Thursday having one

[summer skin]

haha Flogging Mollly with a full orchestra would be amazing ha....

but it has to be like "epic" kind of bands...with enough slower songs to go with it, like Pixies, smashing, volta were all good choices....


i could see Thursday having one
wut?

[theseacaptain]

most Prog would be good

like Dream Theater, Queensryche or Symphony X

i did think Chiodos would be, but upon listening again...most of their songs are orchestrated anyways

OPETH! i forgot Opeth, by God that would be awesome

[summer skin]

most Prog would be good

like Dream Theater, Queensryche or Symphony X

i did think Chiodos would be, but upon listening again...most of their songs are orchestrated anyways

OPETH! i forgot Opeth, by God that would be awesome
What the fucking fuck?

[theseacaptain]

What the fucking fuck?


listen closer, its a lot more Prog than it seems

and Bone Palace Ballet had a lot of orchestral additions to it

[summer skin]

listen closer, its a lot more Prog than it seems

and Bone Palace Ballet had a lot of orchestral additions to it
No.

[theseacaptain]

No.


or keep a closed-mind, whatever you prefer

personally i like to see the beauty in all music, rather than completely shut myself off from the possibility

especially when its obvious, such as in this case

[summer skin]

Chiodos being prog is one of the most insanely idiotic things I have ever heard. At no point in your rambling, incoherent response were you even close to anything that could be considered a rational thought. Everyone in this room is now dumber for having listened to it. I award you no points, and may God have mercy on your soul.

[theseacaptain]

first of all, quoting Billy Madison just shows idiocy

second of all, actually listen rather than assume
the time shifts
the complete turns in musical style, mid-song
the vocal style in general
the synth arrangements

i could go on, but you seem to not be worth my time, according to previous posts

[Regards]

Chiodos being prog is one of the most insanely idiotic things I have ever heard. At no point in your rambling, incoherent response were you even close to anything that could be considered a rational thought. Everyone in this room is now dumber for having listened to it. I award you no points, and may God have mercy on your soul.
:appl:

I might have to sig this.

[theseacaptain]

now if only it were true

[Regards]

Its funny becuase its true. Having string come from a keyboard is not prog.

[Getup and Dance]

first of all, quoting Billy Madison just shows idiocy

second of all, actually listen rather than assume
the time shifts
the complete turns in musical style, mid-song
the vocal style in general
the synth arrangements

i could go on, but you seem to not be worth my time, according to previous posts

Im sure you think The Fall of Troy is a progressive band also.

[boykosaurus]

Anberlin perhaps.

This is a terrible thread. Chiodos? Really?

[summer skin]

first of all, quoting Billy Madison just shows idiocy

second of all, actually listen rather than assume
the time shifts
the complete turns in musical style, mid-song
the vocal style in general
the synth arrangements

i could go on, but you seem to not be worth my time, according to previous posts
vocal style has been done to death, band is the equivalent of musical aids.

[theseacaptain]

Im sure you think The Fall of Troy is a progressive band also.


Post-Hardcore actually, the same genre i put Chiodos under

i just said that Chiodos had proggy elements, not that they were prog

[summer skin]

Post-Hardcore actually, the same genre i put Chiodos under

i just said that Chiodos had proggy elements, not that they were prog
HAHAHAHAHAHA
sig'd

[theseacaptain]

HAHAHAHAHAHA
sig'd


for truth

if not, for sigger's idiocy

[AP_Punk]

Wow.

[theseacaptain]

why do the elitists always find the good threads?

[summer skin]

New direction for the thread: Guess Theseacaptain's age.

[Getup and Dance]

Post-Hardcore actually, the same genre i put Chiodos under

i just said that Chiodos had proggy elements, not that they were prog

Do you know who Rush is?


Have you ever heard of Yes?


That is progressive rock none of those bands you are talking about have "Proggy" Elements, I also hate the genre of "Post Hardcore" because everyone places every fucking shit scene band in there with no reason to it.

[theseacaptain]

Do you know who Rush is?


Have you ever heard of Yes?


That is progressive rock none of those bands you are talking about have "Proggy" Elements, I also hate the genre of "Post Hardcore" because everyone places every fucking shit scene band in there with no reason to it.

of course, i've actually seen Rush live twice, i know what i'm talking about, i'm just not an elitist with an amazingly closed-mindset

and the 3 main Scene genres are Post-Hardcore, Metalcore and Pop-Punk, that's just how it is

[summer skin]

of course, i've actually seen Rush live twice, i know what i'm talking about, i'm just not an elitist with an amazingly closed-mindset

and the 3 main Scene genres are Post-Hardcore, Metalcore and Pop-Punk, that's just how it is
this man/boy preaches the truth.

[theseacaptain]

this man preaches the truth.



odd, seeing as how you've been attempting an argument this entire time


and if you had any base intelligence when it comes to the mind, you'd know age and intelligence really can't be compared, you can't make a blanket statement on an entire group of people, that's called stereotyping

EDIT: *sigh* nice edit

[Getup and Dance]

of course, i've actually seen Rush live twice, i know what i'm talking about, i'm just not an elitist with an amazingly closed-mindset

and the 3 main Scene genres are Post-Hardcore, Metalcore and Pop-Punk, that's just how it is

Which is why I hate using genres now adays because every band that uses screaming with softer music is "Post Hardcore", every crappy band that plays in drop D is "Metalcore" and everything else is "Pop-punk" which half the bands young kids like you put into these genres dont even have the sound as the genre.

[boykosaurus]

A MAN-BOY!?!?!?

Oh shiiiiiii-

[summer skin]

odd, seeing as how you've been attempting an argument this entire time


and if you had any base intelligence when it comes to the mind, you'd know age and intelligence really can't be compared, you can't make a blanket statement on an entire group of people, that's called stereotyping

EDIT: *sigh* nice edit
in other words, you're 14.

[theseacaptain]

Which is why I hate using genres now adays because every band that uses screaming with softer music is "Post Hardcore", every crappy band that plays in drop D is "Metalcore" and everything else is "Pop-punk" which half the bands young kids like you put into these genres dont even have the sound as the genre.


that's how its been forever

every 5 or so years, there are a few genres that COMPLETELY take over, at this point it's the 3 aforementioned

[theseacaptain]

in other words, you're 14.


off by a few

nice to see you actually listened to what was said

[summer skin]

12?

[theseacaptain]

i didn't expect absolutepunk to attempt such a strong support of stereotypes, i'm fairly aghast

but nice to know i should have faith in my fellow man

[summer skin]

I'm gonna use uncommon words to throw people off my scent.

[Getup and Dance]

10

[AP_Punk]

i'm an elitist! :woot:

[Getup and Dance]

i didn't expect absolutepunk to attempt such a strong support of stereotypes, i'm fairly aghast

but nice to know i should have faith in my fellow man

I like how you support a strong scene kid sterotype.

[theseacaptain]

I'm gonna use uncommon words to throw people off my scent.


or whatever fits the situation best

since when is aghast an uncommon word?

[Getup and Dance]

i'm an elitist! :woot:

no you arent

[theseacaptain]

I like how you support a strong scene kid sterotype.


cynicism=scene?

[AP_Punk]

no you arent

:smackhim:

[summer skin]

or whatever fits the situation best

since when is aghast an uncommon word?
Since you said it to be mature like fear before.

[theseacaptain]

Since you said it to be mature like fear before.


as i said, it best fit the situation

what other word would i use? appalled would've probably gotten the same reaction, surprised isn't a negative enough connotation

[Getup and Dance]

Since Chiodos is Progressive.

Lets fuck up the genre's some more.

Circa Survive is now Grindcore everyone go to there local record stores and change these up.

[summer skin]

as i said, it best fit the situation

what other word would i use? appalled would've probably gotten the same reaction, surprised isn't a negative enough connotation
waah waah I said Chiodos was prog and expected no negative replies.

[theseacaptain]

waah waah I said Chiodos was prog and expected no negative replies.


i said they had proggy elements, not that they were Prog

"i can take things out of context and bastardize meanings!"

[theseacaptain]

Since Chiodos is Progressive.

Lets fuck up the genre's some more.

Circa Survive is now Grindcore everyone go to there local record stores and change these up.


nobody said they were progressive

[summer skin]

i said they had proggy elements, not that they were Prog

"i can take things out of context and bastardize meanings!"
"I like to bastardize genres and say tfot is post hardcore"

[theseacaptain]

"I like to bastardize genres and say tfot is post hardcore"


saying one band has elements of a genre it isn't part of is not bastardization

and The Fall Of Troy is Post-Hardcore with Mathcore tendencies, or the other way around depending on your perspective

[summer skin]

saying one band has elements of a genre it isn't part of is not bastardization

and The Fall Of Troy is Post-Hardcore with Mathcore tendencies, or the other way around depending on your perspective
pretty sure they classify themselves as blowjob metal.
band is just a way for Thomas to score money for smack.

[theseacaptain]

pretty sure they classify themselves as blowjob metal.
band is just a way for Thomas to score money for smack.


okay

[summer skin]

okay
I also like how you say a band is one genre, then when someone refutes you you say that you said they just have "elements of that genre". Kudos.

[Getup and Dance]

Faith Hill has elements of Thrash metal.

[theseacaptain]

I also like how you say a band is one genre, then when someone refutes you you say that you said they just have "elements of that genre". Kudos.


i didn't...

i said that Chiodos isn't prog, but has those elements, if that's what you're mentioning

[boykosaurus]

saying one band has elements of a genre it isn't part of is not bastardization

and The Fall Of Troy is Post-Hardcore with Mathcore tendencies, or the other way around depending on your perspective

Nope.

[summer skin]

Post-Hardcore actually, the same genre i put Chiodos under

i just said that Chiodos had proggy elements, not that they were prog

saying one band has elements of a genre it isn't part of is not bastardization

and The Fall Of Troy is Post-Hardcore with Mathcore tendencies, or the other way around depending on your perspective
self pwn


also, if there's only 3 genres how does mathcore fit into there?

[theseacaptain]

Nope.

obviously so

[DilesMavis]

Faith Hill has elements of Thrash metal.

lmaolmao.

[summer skin]

Hammer ons and pull offs = mathcore.

[summer skin]

So I guess I win then...

[boykosaurus]

No silly, mathcore is lots of tapping with effects to the max.

[Regards]

delaypedalcore

[ambiguous.dude]

blink-182 with an orchestra could be awesome. Strange, but awesome.

[mattmatumbo]

No silly, mathcore is lots of tapping with effects to the max.

QFT!

edit: this thread is the lolz