Slumdog Millionaire

[FondestMemory]

finally has a trailer.
UN8RaYZBHjo

so stoked. danny boyle is one of the best and most versatile directors working today.

[poppa Q]

So true. Cannot wait to see this.

[poppa Q]

Jesus, I hate to be one of those over-dramatic trailer viewers, but if watching that gives me goosebumps, the film itself is going to have me in tears.

[TJ Wells]

I think it's Danny Boyle's time to shine, Oscar-wise. Which is WAY overdue.

[TJ Wells]

A. What is that song in the second half of the trailer? It sounds really familiar but I can't put my finger on it.

B. Yes, so awesome to see Irfhan Khan again. That man is incredible.

[eMart]

I absolutely loved Sunshine and it was definitely one of my top 5 movies of 2007. I will definitely be there opening week.

[terrycw89]

I really want to see this.

Haha, I just noticed the main character is one of the guys from Skins.

[Thug_Nasty]

saw this over the break.

great movie.

[Recovery Room]

I've now seen this twice and for the life of me can't figure out why it was Rated R.

Either way, absolutely gorgeous/beautiful/stunning/heartwarming/touching/and on and on I could go film. Boyle better get some recognition for what he's pieced together here. The acting, which features mostly unknowns, is perfect and the cinematography is exactly what it needed to be, even breathtaking at times. Freida Pinto is gorgeous so that doesn't hurt either.

[MIKEY_HORROR]

how are people seeing this movie......it makes me sad that I havent...haha

[pshh]

i really want to see this.

[sevinw0rds]

There's finally a screening tonight in Ft. Lauderdale and I am so there, Danny Boyle is just too good. Slumdog, Milk and The Wrestler are the indies I can't wait to see open down here.

[doyouhas?]

A. What is that song in the second half of the trailer? It sounds really familiar but I can't put my finger on it.

B. Yes, so awesome to see Irfhan Khan again. That man is incredible.

hoppipolla by sigur ros.

[Mitch]

Seeing this either today or tomorrow. Somehow I hadn't heard of it before yesterday despite me being a Boyle fan :-/

[Machu505]

Jesus, the local theatres aren't getting Milk, Doubt, or this.

[TJ Wells]

I've now seen this twice and for the life of me can't figure out why it was Rated R.

Either way, absolutely gorgeous/beautiful/stunning/heartwarming/touching/and on and on I could go film. Boyle better get some recognition for what he's pieced together here. The acting, which features mostly unknowns, is perfect and the cinematography is exactly what it needed to be, even breathtaking at times. Freida Pinto is gorgeous so that doesn't hurt either.
Agreed. Anyone who thought it was ridiculous Once got an R rating, this is even more unbelievable.

[aminorthreat55]

This is like 1960s rated R; "did he just fire a weapon?! Oh lord we can't have that on our screens!"

[TK]

I too was confused why it was rated R. But didn't it have fuck in the dialogue more than once? I'm not completely sure.

[Machu505]

I'm really glad this is coming out on DVD before the Oscars. I want to see it before the ceremony!

[TJ Wells]

I too was confused why it was rated R. But didn't it have fuck in the dialogue more than once? I'm not completely sure.
I believe I counted it twice. But honestly, who cares? Anyone who would argue that this deserves to be rated R and the Dark Knight deserves to be PG-13 is insane.

[TK]

I believe I counted it twice. But honestly, who cares? Anyone who would argue that this deserves to be rated R and the Dark Knight deserves to be PG-13 is insane.

I was surprised the Dark Knight wasn't rated R. But, I think that's just the general acknowledgment of movies in the US, you can say fuck only once if you want it to be PG-13. I'm not sure why, but it is how it is.

[slickwataris]

Slumdog Millionaire is rated R because it is targeted to an adult audience. Violence and language do not matter.

[TJ Wells]

A movie like Slumdog Millionaire is exactly the kind of movie kids should be watching, and I don't think it's targeted towards adults at all. The Dark Knight, on the other hand, is, and no kid under 13 should ever see that movie.

[slickwataris]

Kids don't want to see Indian movies. I can guarantee that. Slumdog Millionaire has a limited audience. If it was rated PG adults would assume it's a children's movie. But American kids don't want to see Indian movies. If it was rated PG it would not have made any money whatsoever. By rating it R, adults assume that it has adult content thereby giving the movie a larger audience it would have if it was rated PG or PG-13. There might not have been any sexual content, but there was plenty of innuendo. There might not have been any blood, but there was plenty of violence. American kids would not identify with the Indian culture in the movie. Only adults would understand the cultural differences.

The Dark Knight couldn't have been rated R. Batman=kids. It would have been a horrible marketing move to delete half of your audience.

[TJ Wells]

Kids don't want to see Indian movies. I can guarantee that. Slumdog Millionaire has a limited audience. If it was rated PG adults would assume it's a children's movie. But American kids don't want to see Indian movies. If it was rated PG it would not have made any money whatsoever. By rating it R, adults assume that it has adult content thereby giving the movie a larger audience it would have if it was rated PG or PG-13. There might not have been any sexual content, but there was plenty of innuendo. There might not have been any blood, but there was plenty of violence. American kids would not identify with the Indian culture in the movie. Only adults would understand the cultural differences.

The Dark Knight couldn't have been rated R. Batman=kids. It would have been a horrible marketing move to delete half of your audience.
I completely disagree. No little kid should ever see The Dark Knight. It's incredibly disturbing and violent.

[Adeniz19]

Slumdog Millionaire is rated R because it is targeted to an adult audience. Violence and language do not matter.This is ridiculous logic.

[poppa Q]

Kids don't want to see Indian movies. I can guarantee that. Slumdog Millionaire has a limited audience. If it was rated PG adults would assume it's a children's movie. But American kids don't want to see Indian movies. If it was rated PG it would not have made any money whatsoever. By rating it R, adults assume that it has adult content thereby giving the movie a larger audience it would have if it was rated PG or PG-13. There might not have been any sexual content, but there was plenty of innuendo. There might not have been any blood, but there was plenty of violence. American kids would not identify with the Indian culture in the movie. Only adults would understand the cultural differences.

The Dark Knight couldn't have been rated R. Batman=kids. It would have been a horrible marketing move to delete half of your audience.

All true.

I completely disagree. No little kid should ever see The Dark Knight. It's incredibly disturbing and violent.

The latter part of your post is true, but what are you disagreeing with? He didn't say anything about whether or not kids should see it, and what he said about its rating is spot on.

[Mitch]

Just got back from this movie, I liked it a lot. I was very confused as to why it was rated R, glad to see I wasn't the only one.

Also, the theater was packed. The only row with available seats when the movie started was the very front. Two girls were even sitting on the stairs, haha. Wasn't really expecting it to be that crowded.

[JHSace923]

Absolutely loved this film. I think Danny Boyle's won his Oscar with this one. Simply incredible.

[TK]

Absolutely loved this film. I think Danny Boyle's won his Oscar with this one. Simply incredible.

I do not. The film was greater, but there have been others that were better in my opinion.

[JHSace923]

I do not. The film was greater, but there have been others that were better in my opinion.

Who? I've yet to see Frost/Nixon, Milk, and The Wrestler so I could be wrong, but as of now it's my favorite.

[TK]

Who? I've yet to see Frost/Nixon, Milk, and The Wrestler so I could be wrong, but as of now it's my favorite.

Milk tops it, AMC 20 is playing it, so it is something I definitely recommend you see. And I have not seen the other two to decide if it is better or not.

[JHSace923]

Milk tops it, AMC 20 is playing it, so it is something I definitely recommend you see. And I have not seen the other two to decide if it is better or not.

I'm definitely looking forward to seeing that, I love Gus Van Sant. Also wanna see Benjamin Button. I wish The Wrestler would come here sooner.

[fluke182]

This was one of the single best movies I've ever seen. The movie as a whole was simply triumphant. I almost got up and cheered during parts. Such an emotional roller coaster, so amazing. Now tied with Wall E as my favorite of the year.

[ikikwe]

I just got back from it, and it was amazing. It deserves every ounce of praise it recieves.

[mouood]

Saw it tonight. Loved it.

[Miss Heartcore]

When I saw the promo pictures I immediately thought the guy looked like Adrian. Adrian, however, claims he's better looking.

I agree.

[dashboard1190]

Saw this today. Loved it.

It's so a-typical while still having common themes in it.

Cinematography, acting, directing, everything was phenomenal.

[stayillogical]

Saw it today as well and loved it. The end credits amused me A LOT. I've heard some complaints, but I thought it was the cherry on top.

[IamTheINDUSTRY]

thought it was good. the directing is the best part. cinematography as well. i didn't think it was better than the majority of the other "award contenders" though.

[Rawrr]

Had a choice between this, or Milk last night. Saw this, was pretty good.

[dashboard1190]

Had a choice between this, or Milk last night. Saw this, was pretty good.

Make sure you see MIlk though.

[TJ Wells]

I think it's a lock for Cinematography, Director, Adapted Screenplay and Score, and an almost lock for Best Picture.

[dashboard1190]

I think it's a lock for Cinematography, Director, Adapted Screenplay and Score, and an almost lock for Best Picture.

Wins or nominations?

[dashboard1190]

I think it's a lock for Cinematography, Director, Adapted Screenplay and Score, and an almost lock for Best Picture.

I think it will be nominated for all of these and probably win Cinematography, Adapted Screenplay, and Score (and possible Director).

But I think The Curious Case of Benjamin Button will take Best Picture. Once you see it, I think you'll agree.

[fluke182]

So when are we starting an Oscar thread? What's everyone feeling as the five candidates?

So far: Milk, Slumdog, Button, and Frost/Nixon feel like they're definites. I can't really think of who the fifth will be, but I feel like it will come from a group that is comprised of Wall E, Revolutionary Road, Doubt, and the Wrestler. I feel like that's the way the wind is blowing this Oscar season.

[dashboard1190]

So when are we starting an Oscar thread? What's everyone feeling as the five candidates?

So far: Milk, Slumdog, Button, and Frost/Nixon feel like they're definites. I can't really think of who the fifth will be, but I feel like it will come from a group that is comprised of Wall E, Revolutionary Road, Doubt, and the Wrestler. I feel like that's the way the wind is blowing this Oscar season.

Wall-E will be nominated (and win) Best Animated Feature.

I think (hope) Revolutionary Road gets the nomination. I can't wait to see it.

(And can someone explain me the appeal of The Wrestler?)

[TJ Wells]

Wins or nominations?
Wins. And based on how it's going right now, I think Button is behind this, F/N AND Milk. IMO it's a big longshot.

[dashboard1190]

Wins. And based on how it's going right now, I think Button is behind this, F/N AND Milk. IMO it's a big longshot.

Interesting.

While I thought Milk and Slumdog were great, I think the Academy will favor the "epic" again. (Titanic, LOTR)

[TJ Wells]

See normally I would agree with you, but in economic times like these, with a movie that is SO relevant to what the country is going through right now, I think it's going to be Slumdog. Plus, the praise for Button isn't nearly as universal as Slumdog (Ebert, who gives EVERYTHING ****, gave it ** 1/2).

ALL that being said, i'm still excited to see it.

[dashboard1190]

See normally I would agree with you, but in economic times like these, with a movie that is SO relevant to what the country is going through right now, I think it's going to be Slumdog. Plus, the praise for Button isn't nearly as universal as Slumdog (Ebert, who gives EVERYTHING ****, gave it ** 1/2).

ALL that being said, i'm still excited to see it.

That's an interesting way to look at it. In that case, I can see how it could win.

(On a side note, I read your top ten movies and completely agree with your statement about how 'if you would have told me a year ago my favorite movie would be about an indian kid on a gameshow...'. I only saw the film because it was getting so much attention. I knew very little about it, but by the end, I had such a deep interest and compassion for Jamal and Latika that it caught me off guard.)

[TJ Wells]

Interesting note: since ROTK, no movie has won more than five Oscars. And The Aviator is the only one that's done that.

[TJ Wells]

That's an interesting way to look at it. In that case, I can see how it could win.

(On a side note, I read your top ten movies and completely agree with your statement about how 'if you would have told me a year ago my favorite movie would be about an indian kid on a gameshow...'. I only saw the film because it was getting so much attention. I knew very little about it, but by the end, I had such a deep interest and compassion for Jamal and Latika that it caught me off guard.)
I heard that if Fox Searchlight hadn't picked it up, it would've gone straight to DVD.

[TJ Wells]

Finally, let's not forget how evil the Academy has been to Fincher. ZERO nominations for Zodiac is just unforgivable.

[jbaseball44]

Finally, let's not forget how evil the Academy has been to Fincher. ZERO nominations for Zodiac is just unforgivable.
Agreed, although i loved this movie i am probably going to be split between this, Benjamin Button and Forst/Nixon. And my heart goes to Benjamin Button because of Fincher and Pitt.

[TJ Wells]

I think if it comes down to Button and Slumdog, one will win Director, the other Picture.

[jbaseball44]

That would be nice, i would be satisfied with that.

[Mitch]

Slumdog should win cinematography if not just for the wonderful chase scene (imo) in the beginning.

[fluke182]

Wins. And based on how it's going right now, I think Button is behind this, F/N AND Milk. IMO it's a big longshot.
I agree. Button has been getting middling reviews and comparable notes to Forrest Gump, a movie widely considered as a mistake victor of Best Picture. I think it's going to be very good, but if it's better than Frost/Nixon or Slumdog, I'll be shocked.
Interesting note: since ROTK, no movie has won more than five Oscars. And The Aviator is the only one that's done that.
That is a truly surprising note. The Aviator huh? I did not see that coming, but honestly, I don't see that changing this year unless everyone all of a sudden decides Doubt is a lot better than it is.

[TJ Wells]

I agree. Button has been getting middling reviews and comparable notes to Forrest Gump, a movie widely considered as a mistake victor of Best Picture. I think it's going to be very good, but if it's better than Frost/Nixon or Slumdog, I'll be shocked.

That is a truly surprising note. The Aviator huh? I did not see that coming, but honestly, I don't see that changing this year unless everyone all of a sudden decides Doubt is a lot better than it is.
Interestingly both screenplays written by the same guy.

And I really like no movie winning more than four Oscars. The show gets kind of boring when you know one movie is going to win big. Takes the fun out of guessing.

[fluke182]

Interestingly both screenplays written by the same guy.

And I really like no movie winning more than four Oscars. The show gets kind of boring when you know one movie is going to win big. Takes the fun out of guessing.
That is always way better. I hate the coronation ceremony at the Oscars, when everyone knows what's going to happen.

I did not know that Button was an Eric Roth joint.

[gloriousmuse]

Just got back from seeing this. Wow. I thought Milk was my film of the year, Slumdog just took the spot. I agree with the Best Score and Screenplay nominations though. Hell, even Director.

[terrycw89]

Great movie. I'd be surprised if it didn't win any Oscars.

[TJ Wells]

My dad made a good point when we were watching it; this is like a modern day Rocky.

[shwaz499]

My dad made a good point when we were watching it; this is like a modern day Rocky.

How is it like a modern day rocky? I just saw "The Wrestler'. THAT is more like a modern day rocky (If it were brilliantly made). Any way...slumdog is incredible. I was blown away by all aspects.

[stayillogical]

I love this movie more and more in retrospect. I can't find anything wrong with it. I was engaged from beginning to end and I really cared about the story. It was also beautifully made, of course. Wow, this might be my top movie of the year. I still have to watch Benjamin Button, Revolutionary Road, Wrestler, and Milk though. We'll see.

[fantasma]

"locke....big ben. right next to sean connery's flate."

[TJ Wells]

How is it like a modern day rocky? I just saw "The Wrestler'. THAT is more like a modern day rocky (If it were brilliantly made). Any way...slumdog is incredible. I was blown away by all aspects.
Down and out guy comes out of nowhere to capture the hearts of a nation. It's EXACTLY like Rocky.

[Thomas Balkcom]

absolutely incredible

[Thomas Balkcom]

The opening and closing sequences of this film blew me away

[tait]

just finished watching it. wow, what a great movie

[Mitch]

Even better the second time around.

[fluke182]

Watching it right now for the third time in six days. I'm disgustingly obsessed. It actually improves with repeat viewings. I love this movie so much, it's untouchable in the top spot for me.

[Miss Heartcore]

Hmmm these comments are really making me want to see this.

[Mitch]

The flashbacks in the train station are perfect, including when the ones it shows as he kisses her scar.

[Ailite]

It did great one critics year end lists

[fluke182]

The flashbacks in the train station are perfect, including when the ones it shows as he kisses her scar.
The one with the scar kills me every time. When the flashback goes backwards with the music...man, it just tears me up. It's so incredible.

[MusicTalks]

I'm gonna see this tonight. Enough waiting.

[dashboard1190]

I think it's interesting that Lataki's jewlery (when she is a belly dancer/whatever) foreshadows her scar.

In case someone didn't catch that.

[a speedo model]

Trying to download this, it's taking forever.

[stayillogical]

Trying to download this, it's taking forever.

Why? You can watch it streaming with dvd quality. Just go to ninjavideo.net.

[Recovery Room]

Why? You can watch it streaming with dvd quality. Just go to ninjavideo.net.
I have never heard of this site until now and .... thank you very much.

[Rawrr]

Is the dancing at the end a hommage to Bollywood or something?

[Recovery Room]

Is the dancing at the end a hommage to Bollywood or something?
Yeah.

[WFUJerseyJon]

Hmmm these comments are really making me want to see this.

it's playing in red bank currently, and i'm interested as well.




although at this point (and i mean no disrespect to mr. ledger and the dark knight) i'm not sure ive seen a better feature and/or performance this year than mickey rourke and the wrestler.

[a speedo model]

Why? You can watch it streaming with dvd quality. Just go to ninjavideo.net.
My internet is far too slow to properly stream the film, if I was at school I would no doubt. But for now, I have to download films over the course of a couple days, haha.

[Miss Heartcore]

although at this point (and i mean no disrespect to mr. ledger and the dark knight) i'm not sure ive seen a better feature and/or performance this year than mickey rourke and the wrestler.
:-0 You saw it already?!?

[jbaseball44]

Trying to decide if i like this or Benjamin Button better. It's a tough choice.

[stayillogical]

Trying to decide if i like this or Benjamin Button better. It's a tough choice.

Both solid, but I like this more.

[jbaseball44]

Both solid, but I like this more.
Right now i am leaning that way as well. I am seeing Frost/Nixon Tomorrow and hoping that is just as good as these two, the reviews it got have me thinking it will be.

[WFUJerseyJon]

:-0 You saw it already?!?

:-p Yup. I got the hook ups yo.

[Miss Heartcore]

:-p Yup. I got the hook ups yo.
M-(

[ActorInThisPlay]

this movie was excellent. very well written, very well acted...I can definitely see why this is up for Best Picture.

[XEmoBoyShandorX]

Wow this movie was so good! This is by far one of my favorite movie's of 2008.

[TJ Wells]

Right now i am leaning that way as well. I am seeing Frost/Nixon Tomorrow and hoping that is just as good as these two, the reviews it got have me thinking it will be.
It's really not, at least in my opinion. I don't think it even remotely deserves to be in the discussion for Best Picture.

[aminorthreat55]

It's really not, at least in my opinion. I don't think it even remotely deserves to be in the discussion for Best Picture.
I agree. I just ranked it within what I've seen thus far this year and its at #10 out of 17.

[jbaseball44]

It's really not, at least in my opinion. I don't think it even remotely deserves to be in the discussion for Best Picture.
I am sorry to hear that, i was just going based on the reviews i have seen for Frost/Nixon. Out of Slumdog and Benjamin Button, i think i like Slumdog slightly better.

[namembal]

Great movie.

Really happy to see Bombay represented in it's true light. They really captured both phases of Bombay's timeline - early nineties with the Hindu-Muslim riots and the present decade.

[TJ Wells]

I really think this movie wouldn't be nearly as much of a frontrunner in a better economy. The whole story really speaks to what the world is going through right now.

[stayillogical]

I really don't get what you mean by that TJ. Elaborate.

I've seen kids begging on the street in Guatemala. This issue is nothing new to me. I wasn't aware that it's any more relevant today.

[jbaseball44]

I really don't get what you mean by that TJ. Elaborate.

I've seen kids begging on the street in Guatemala. This issue is nothing new to me. I wasn't aware that it's any more relevant today.
I think he is saying that due to the poor economic situation in America and other places, a sort of rags to riches story really appeals to people.

[stayillogical]

I think he is saying that due to the poor economic situation in America and other places, a sort of rags to riches story really appeals to people.

Oh, that... eh, I think that's reaching. Rags to riches has always been popular. It's everyone's dream to be a millionaire.

[Bockcity]

The praise for this film is kinda becoming annoying to me. By no means is it a bad film cause I liked it but Best Picture??? I dont think so. And this is coming from somebody that loves Boyle films.

In the end, its a bonefied Bollywood film.

[stayillogical]

I didn't see any random song and dance sequences.

[a speedo model]

I really don't get what you mean by that TJ. Elaborate.

I've seen kids begging on the street in Guatemala. This issue is nothing new to me. I wasn't aware that it's any more relevant today.
Are you assuming because it's nothing new to you that it isn't to other people? Interesting...

[aminorthreat55]

I'm gonna disagree with TJ on that one too. The "current economic environment" card is the most overplayed line around, and I'm not just talking about comments made relative to the film industry or specific films.

[stayillogical]

Are you assuming because it's nothing new to you that it isn't to other people? Interesting...

Well, that was just one example I gave for myself. Sorry, it was the first that came to mind about that issue. But there have been plenty of other movies, books, etc about kids growing up in difficult circumstances. And Angelina Jolie adopts one every year.

[Until The Bombs]

Finally showing in my area. Might try to catch it tomorrow.

[Recovery Room]

I didn't see any random song and dance sequences.
The end credits is a huge dance sequence.

[Recovery Room]

In regards to this being the frontrunner for Best Picture, I have no problem with that.

I think it's a better film, as a whole, than The Wrestler, Milk and The Reader.

Haven't decided if it's better than Doubt or The Curious Case of Benjamin Button yet, though.

And I still need to see Frost/Nixon and Revolutionary Road.

[poppa Q]

Trying to decide if i like this or Benjamin Button better. It's a tough choice.
I preferred this, but...
Right now i am leaning that way as well. I am seeing Frost/Nixon Tomorrow and hoping that is just as good as these two, the reviews it got have me thinking it will be.
I'd have to give it further thought, but I enjoyed this and Frost/Nixon nearly equally.
It's really not, at least in my opinion. I don't think it even remotely deserves to be in the discussion for Best Picture.
I agree. I just ranked it within what I've seen thus far this year and its at #10 out of 17.
I usually agree with the two of you (for the most part), but I guess F/N just struck me particularly well -- I absolutely loved it.
And Angelina Jolie adopts one every year.

lol

[stayillogical]

The end credits is a huge dance sequence.

Yeah, I loved that homage to Bollywood. SOOO MUCH. But, the movie itself was nothing like a Bollywood film. Those are like soap opera musicals. Don't get me wrong, I love Bollywood. But this deserves no comparison to it.

[Recovery Room]

Yeah, I loved that homage to Bollywood. SOOO MUCH. But, the movie itself was nothing like a Bollywood film. Those are like soap opera musicals. Don't get me wrong, I love Bollywood. But this deserves no comparison to it.
Oh yeah, I totally agree with you, I thought you missed that entire dance sequence, haha, my bad.

[stayillogical]

Oh yeah, I totally agree with you, I thought you missed that entire dance sequence, haha, my bad.

Oh okay. To be completely honest, it was my favorite part of the movie. Hahaha, it was just so unexpected. I flipped out. My sister thinks I'm nuts.

[Recovery Room]

Oh okay. To be completely honest, it was my favorite part of the movie. Hahaha, it was just so unexpected. I flipped out. My sister thinks I'm nuts.
Hahaha

My favorite part is definitely at the end when Jamal and Latika are embracing on the train station platform and text on the screen pops up and says: "It is written." Oh man, I just lost it then.

/sissy

[Until The Bombs]

Fantastic film. At the least, a nomination for best film is deserving.

[anamericangod]

The praise for this film is kinda becoming annoying to me. By no means is it a bad film cause I liked it but Best Picture??? I dont think so. And this is coming from somebody that loves Boyle films.

In the end, its a bonefied Bollywood film.

I agree with this. It was a good movie, but I don't think it's deserving of a Best Picture nod. There was nothing particularly fantastic about it. The story was unbelievably predictable, the acting was decent, and the pacing was almost annoying.

[cantnokdahustle]

I agree with this. It was a good movie, but I don't think it's deserving of a Best Picture nod. There was nothing particularly fantastic about it. The story was unbelievably predictable, the acting was decent, and the pacing was almost annoying.

Agreed. The pacing was awful and the story was unoriginal. I get the whole destiny turn, but that doesn't mean you can completely ignore the development of Jamal's love interest. I didn't buy into the love story, because I didn't have a clue as to who Latika was.

How anyone is putting this above Wall*E is beyond me. Sure it was better than Button, but that doesn't deserve a best picture nod either.

[narcoleptic953]

Agreed. The pacing was awful and the story was unoriginal. I get the whole destiny turn, but that doesn't mean you can completely ignore the development of Jamal's love interest. I didn't buy into the love story, because I didn't have a clue as to who Latika was.

How anyone is putting this above Wall*E is beyond me. Sure it was better than Button, but that doesn't deserve a best picture nod either.

Button and this were great
and Wall-E was far too boring to be considered the years best.

[ActorInThisPlay]

Agreed. The pacing was awful and the story was unoriginal. I get the whole destiny turn, but that doesn't mean you can completely ignore the development of Jamal's love interest. I didn't buy into the love story, because I didn't have a clue as to who Latika was.

How anyone is putting this above Wall*E is beyond me. Sure it was better than Button, but that doesn't deserve a best picture nod either.
Wall-E was good but not even close to best of the year.

[narcoleptic953]

Wall-E was good but not even close to best of the year.

It's also nowhere near the best Disney/Pixar film. If Toy Story 1 and 2 didn't get consideration for the Oscar's top prize, neither should this.

[ActorInThisPlay]

It's also nowhere near the best Disney/Pixar film. If Toy Story 1 and 2 didn't get consideration for the Oscar's top prize, neither should this.
exactly...The Incredibles and Finding Nemo were both better as well.

[stayillogical]

:yawn:

[last light]

Didn't love this. I thought it was good, but not in the best picture of the year category for me.

[narcoleptic953]

exactly...The Incredibles and Finding Nemo were both better as well.

Agreed. I'm glad they're doing Toy Story 3. I think they need to get back to what made them great in the first place. I feel like they've lost a lot of their thunder on the past few.

[aminorthreat55]

Agreed. I'm glad they're doing Toy Story 3. I think they need to get back to what made them great in the first place. I feel like they've lost a lot of their thunder on the past few.
Hardly.

[aminorthreat55]

It's also nowhere near the best Disney/Pixar film. If Toy Story 1 and 2 didn't get consideration for the Oscar's top prize, neither should this.
This is dumb. Sure Wall-E isn't Toy Story, but why should the fact that it is not as good as a film from 15 years ago preclude it from being competitive among films that came out this year? It's the award for Best Picture of 2008. Is it not possible for Wall-E to be a competitive film in a year where there are no hands down favorites? Particularly given that the Academy doesn't have a great track record with picking the best nominees/winners.

[cantnokdahustle]

Button and this were great.

No, they weren't; they were better than others in a very weak fall.

[chokeychicken]

saw it tonight. loved it. it is breath taking at parts. cinematography is wonderful. story is predictable, but it not the ending that we care about - it is how he arrives at that ending that makes this so fantastic.

[a speedo model]

Fuck, still need to see this, I may wait for the DVD release on Feb.

[fluke182]

saw it tonight. loved it. it is breath taking at parts. cinematography is wonderful. story is predictable, but it not the ending that we care about - it is how he arrives at that ending that makes this so fantastic.
Exactly.

[aminorthreat55]

Fuck, still need to see this, I may wait for the DVD release on Feb.
It will most likely still be in theatres in February, assuming it gets nominated for a handful of Oscars.

[narcoleptic953]

No, they weren't; they were better than others in a very weak fall.

dude, you liked wall-e. that's like the epitome of boring.

[narcoleptic953]

This is dumb. Sure Wall-E isn't Toy Story, but why should the fact that it is not as good as a film from 15 years ago preclude it from being competitive among films that came out this year? It's the award for Best Picture of 2008. Is it not possible for Wall-E to be a competitive film in a year where there are no hands down favorites? Particularly given that the Academy doesn't have a great track record with picking the best nominees/winners.

I hope you realize that only one animated film has ever been nominated for best picture. Wall-E doesn't deserve to be the second, and I can guarantee you that it won't be.

[Lueda Alia]

This isn't playing here, sadly. I guess I'll have to download it, unless they start playing it in theaters because of all the hype that it's getting.

[Until The Bombs]

I hope you realize that only one animated film has ever been nominated for best picture. Wall-E doesn't deserve to be the second, and I can guarantee you that it won't be.

The films selected are judged within the context of that year. How many other animated films have been nominated is irrelevant.

[narcoleptic953]

The films selected are judged within the context of that year. How many other animated films have been nominated is irrelevant.

No, it's not. Animated films have been the most praised and well reviewed films of over half the years in the past decade. The fact that the academy has only nominated one animated film in 80-odd years of the show tells us something about them. Even if Wall-E was on par with the best of the year (which I don't believe is true), the addition of the animated film category a few years ago has essentially guaranteed that it will never happen again.

[fluke182]

No, it's not. Animated films have been the most praised and well reviewed films of over half the years in the past decade. The fact that the academy has only nominated one animated film in 80-odd years of the show tells us something about them. Even if Wall-E was on par with the best of the year (which I don't believe is true), the addition of the animated film category a few years ago has essentially guaranteed that it will never happen again.
The fact that you hated Wall-E really, really makes me question your humanity. That's one of the most soulful and basely joyous movies I've ever seen. That's like hating life right there.

Which is strange, because I think (in your posts around here) we have really similar movie taste besides that. But hey, can't always agree on everything.

[narcoleptic953]

The fact that you hated Wall-E really, really makes me question your humanity. That's one of the most soulful and basely joyous movies I've ever seen. That's like hating life right there.

Which is strange, because I think (in your posts around here) we have really similar movie taste besides that. But hey, can't always agree on everything.

I wouldn't say I hated it, but I don't really see what the fuss is about. Maybe I need to give it another shot?

[stayillogical]

The fact that you hated Wall-E really, really makes me question your humanity. That's one of the most soulful and basely joyous movies I've ever seen. That's like hating life right there.

Which is strange, because I think (in your posts around here) we have really similar movie taste besides that. But hey, can't always agree on everything.

Hahahaha, THIS.

[fluke182]

I wouldn't say I hated it, but I don't really see what the fuss is about. Maybe I need to give it another shot?
My bad. Hated was a strong word. But yeah. I suggest giving it additional shots until you realize you love it. A lot.
Hahahaha, THIS.
*bows*

[GRIFFARD]

this was really really good. the theater I was at was far too loud sound of the movie wise, but I still really enjoyed myself

[cantnokdahustle]

dude, you liked wall-e. that's like the epitome of boring.

Please, stick around and feel free to express your opinion on film in the most simplistic ways possible. My Jr. High students are able to support their arguments with evidence. No se puede?


saw it tonight. loved it. it is breath taking at parts. cinematography is wonderful. story is predictable, but it not the ending that we care about - it is how he arrives at that ending that makes this so fantastic.

That doesn't make up for the fact that Latika has zero development. Who is she? We know who Jamal is, and she shows up at three set intervals. I didn't hate the movie, but it doesn't deserve the praise it has been handed (again it's been a disappointing fall). Danny Boyle is a great director and the overall story arch was refreshing, but it often dove into simplistic stock (the brother's redemption, first train station scene, the phone, etc...). However, the Amitab scene was insanely funny.

[fluke182]

That doesn't make up for the fact that Latika has zero development. Who is she? We know who Jamal is, and she shows up at three set intervals. I didn't hate the movie, but it doesn't deserve the praise it has been handed (again it's been a disappointing fall). Danny Boyle is a great director and the overall story arch was refreshing, but it often dove into simplistic stock (the brother's redemption, first train station scene, the phone, etc...). However, the Amitab scene was insanely funny.
AMITAB BACHCHAN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!

I would give anything for an avatar of little Jamal covered with crap raising his autograph to the sky. That is the hardest I laughed in the theater all year. I did not see that coming.

[stayillogical]

I don't think it's as easy as simple=bad and complex=good. This is a terrible notion.

[cantnokdahustle]

I don't think it's as easy as simple=bad and complex=good. This is a terrible notion.

Agreed, but stock will never be better than merely mediocre.

[Jessooker]

new avatar to show my adoration for this movie. i want to see it again.

[mattybobviously]

Was a bit of a let down, granted I came in with high expectations, but I guess I just wasn't that impressed, I don't know. I have a weird feeling about it, I thought the ending was beautiful, but for whatever reason I just didn't feel engaged.

BEAUTIFUL cinematography though, that I cannot question.

[Recovery Room]

new avatar to show my adoration for this movie. i want to see it again.
Ended up seeing this three times in the theater.

[Jessooker]

Ended up seeing this three times in the theater.

I'm jealous!

[narcoleptic953]

Ended up seeing this three times in the theater.

I don't think I could do that. Not only is there so much other stuff I still need to see, I'm just not the kind of guy that can watch a movie over and over in quick succession like that.

[Recovery Room]

I don't think I could do that. Not only is there so much other stuff I still need to see, I'm just not the kind of guy that can watch a movie over and over in quick succession like that.
Well, I went alone the first time because I had some time to kill and I was in the area of a theater that was actually playing it. The second and third time I had people that really wanted to go and I didn't mind since I absolutely loved it. I can see what you're saying because there have been tons of other movies I've wanted to see as well; fortunately I've been able to get to those too, though.

[Recovery Room]

I'm jealous!
I love your avatar, by the way.

Absolutely loved how they did that.

[Jessooker]

I love your avatar, by the way.

Absolutely loved how they did that.

thanks! me too.

i love that film so much. danny boyle is my favorite and he keeps proving it more and more.

[fluke182]

Ended up seeing this three times in the theater.
Twice in theater and once at my house - in 6 days. Intense!

[stayillogical]

Saw this just now in theaters for the first time, my third time overall seeing it. I can't get enough of it. I was really happy to see the theater packed, although it was funny the the majority were over 40. Also, people stayed for the credits sequence. I only wish my sister would have helped me start a clap, haha.

Yelling "Amitabh Bachchan" is the new "I drink your milkshake" in my house.

[a speedo model]

It will most likely still be in theatres in February, assuming it gets nominated for a handful of Oscars.
Really? At work we have a release date for February 24th...hmmm, it's a mistake.

[aminorthreat55]

Really? At work we have a release date for February 24th...hmmm, it's a mistake.
They'll keep it in theatres as long as they can. The more people they can get out to see it before the Oscars, the more people they will have supporting it and tuning in to see how many awards it wins. You see it all the time, particularly with movies that have already had a full run which are now returning to theatres months later (I've Loved You So Long, Rachel Getting Married, etc.).

[aminorthreat55]

I hope you realize that only one animated film has ever been nominated for best picture. Wall-E doesn't deserve to be the second, and I can guarantee you that it won't be.
Thanks for not responding to my point and instead taking it in another direction (I'm attacking your silly reasoning, not the Academy's silly reasoning, nor the likelihood of it being nominated). Also, congratulations on being yet another obtuse individual who accepts the positive reality of the Academy.

[aminorthreat55]

The films selected are judged within the context of that year. How many other animated films have been nominated is irrelevant.
I wouldn't go so far as to say its irrelevant but you would be correct to say that it is not indicative of a given films chances to be nominated.

[a speedo model]

They'll keep it in theatres as long as they can. The more people they can get out to see it before the Oscars, the more people they will have supporting it and tuning in to see how many awards it wins. You see it all the time, particularly with movies that have already had a full run which are now returning to theatres months later (I've Loved You So Long, Rachel Getting Married, etc.).
Figures, oh well. At least I'll see it on the big screen, keep fucking missing the movies I want to see. Gotta love Indiana...

[narcoleptic953]

Thanks for not responding to my point and instead taking it in another direction (I'm attacking your silly reasoning, not the Academy's silly reasoning, nor the likelihood of it being nominated). Also, congratulations on being yet another obtuse individual who accepts the positive reality of the Academy.

what the fuck does this even mean?

[reckoner]

i did not enjoy this movie.
it seemed generic and predictible.
and i thought that the dialouge for the kids was too mature and that bothered me.
Latika has zero development.
and this.
i really dont get how so many people liked it.

[MIKEY_HORROR]

I think Latika developed pretty nicely. Haha

But anyways I love this movie and it is probably in my top 5 of all time right now.

[stayillogical]

She doesn't need to be developed. That's inconsequential. The movie is about Jamal. It's his journey, his story.

[sdbrown]

^exactly

I just saw it this afternoon, I loved it. My whole family did and we are a hard group to please

[cantnokdahustle]

She doesn't need to be developed. That's inconsequential. The movie is about Jamal. It's his journey, his story.

And she is the driving force behind his journey, his story, and I didn't give two shits about her.
Sure we care what Jamal likes because we spent time with him and we know him. However, we didn't know her, because he didn't know her. They spent a couple weeks together when they were 8 and a day together when they were 12. Why is she worth it?

[stayillogical]

You can't explain romance to a cynic.

Edit: I meant "you" in general. So, I can't explain.

[cantnokdahustle]

You can't explain romance to a cynic.

So Before Sunrise/Sunset aren't romantic films?

[Illuminate]

I loved this movie. But don't think it deserves best picture. Best screenplay-yes. Picture no.

[Thomas Balkcom]

I loved this movie. But don't think it deserves best picture. Best screenplay-yes. Picture no.

in your opinion what deserves best picture?

[stayillogical]

I've never seen either so I don't know how it fits into the discussion. Have you ever seen Amelie?

[Illuminate]

in your opinion what deserves best picture?

I really loved Benjamin Button. I haven't seen The Wrestler yet though. I'm gonna go see it tomorrow. What's your take on all this?

[Mitch]

I've never seen either so I don't know how it fits into the discussion. Have you ever seen Amelie?

You've never seen Before Sunrise / Before Sunset?

Oh my. Please, go rent them.

[Thomas Balkcom]

I really loved Benjamin Button. I haven't seen The Wrestler yet though. I'm gonna go see it tomorrow. What's your take on all this?

My feelings as of right now is that Slumdog Millionaire deserves it,but The Wrestler was phenomenal.

[Thomas Balkcom]

You've never seen Before Sunrise / Before Sunset?

Oh my. Please, go rent them.

They are both added to my queue

[Illuminate]

My feelings as of right now is that Slumdog Millionaire deserves it,but The Wrestler was phenomenal.

Yeah I'm excited to see it. Have you seen em' all?

[mattybobviously]

Want to echo what a couple other people said. I understood the emotional pain of feeling responsible for leaving someone behind (that was the strong point of the film to me), but I couldn't get in to the rest of the relationship because she was so poorly constructed. Yes, it's his journey and we care about him, but I thought he was acting like an idiot.

Also, maybe this was just my theatre, but I went deaf halfway through the film. Drove me insane.

[Thomas Balkcom]

Yeah I'm excited to see it. Have you seen em' all?

Depends on what you mean by all, but I think I have seen all the major ones but Doubt and The Reader

[Illuminate]

Depends on what you mean by all, but I think I have seen all the major ones but Doubt and The Reader

By all I mean the nominees, I guess. Ha. Yeah I saw Doubt. I liked it. I didn't see The Reader yet though.

[stayillogical]

You've never seen Before Sunrise / Before Sunset?

Oh my. Please, go rent them.

Never had the chance or gone out of my way to see them. I know what they're about and I'm in a romantic mood, so I'll try and watch them this week.

[Mitch]

Never had the chance or gone out of my way to see them. I know what they're about and I'm in a romantic mood, so I'll definitely watch them this week.

Fixed :-)

[cantnokdahustle]

I've never seen either so I don't know how it fits into the discussion. Have you ever seen Amelie?

Before Sunrise/Sunset. Two days and two fully formed characters that equal the greatest romance of the past 30+ years on film.

Question #2. Yes, My wife watches it on her birthday, every year, and anytime it is playing at the local Drafthouse; it is her favorite film. I understand what you are getting at, but I felt removed from that love story as well. However, we knew that Amelie was a bit of a romantic and a little quirky, so it was easier to swallow the love story bit, as we always kind of feel she is strangely perky.

[stayillogical]

I like this discussion and I'll come back when I'm not on my sidekick and in the midst of a LOTR marathon.

[SkyHeldUpByStar]

I have now seen this, Benjamin Button, Frost/Nixon, Milk, and The Wrestler. Slumdog captured my heart more than the others. Don't get me wrong, I loved those other films (Mickey Rourke really is fantastic) but wow...this movie is it for me.

[Ailite]

I did truly love this movie, but I'd say Benjamin Button and Wall-e were worlds better.

[stayillogical]

Before Sunrise/Sunset. Two days and two fully formed characters that equal the greatest romance of the past 30+ years on film.

Question #2. Yes, My wife watches it on her birthday, every year, and anytime it is playing at the local Drafthouse; it is her favorite film. I understand what you are getting at, but I felt removed from that love story as well. However, we knew that Amelie was a bit of a romantic and a little quirky, so it was easier to swallow the love story bit, as we always kind of feel she is strangely perky.

Okay, so here's what I think (and sorry for taking so long but my laptop charger wasn't working). My reason for bringing up Amelie is this: both Amelie and Slumdog are about much more than the love stories. When I brought up romance, I meant Romanticism. I meant the fact that both movies have these great romantic heroes. The story should not be remotely realistic. Jamal believes in destiny and Amelie believes in soulmates. Both movies show us how the title characters conquer obstacles (Jamal, his situation in life, Amelie, her cowardice) to fulfill their dream and get their own happily ever after. If instead, the films were to show us more interactions with Latika or Nino, or more backstory on them, it would only detract from the purpose and fairy tale aspect of the movies. I hope I made sense there.

[Jessooker]

I really want to see it again. This is my favorite.

[stayillogical]

I can't wait to own it on DVD.

[itsmesean0630]

Got back from this not too long ago and wow, what a fantastic movie. 2008 has been a good year for movies.

Love the dance sequence at the end.

[heatherg]

I still have yet to see this buy i need to!!!!!!!!

[a speedo model]

So amazing, loved it. Favorite film of the year.

[pshh]

holy dutch angles

[-Aaron-]

The praise for this film is kinda becoming annoying to me. By no means is it a bad film cause I liked it but Best Picture??? I dont think so. And this is coming from somebody that loves Boyle films.

In the end, its a bonefied Bollywood film.

I'd put this in my top 15 films of the year but I can definitely see this getting a Best Picture nomination. I personally thought the acting was average, screenplay very average, and the cinematography annoying. Mainly due to this...

holy dutch angles

[jusscali]

I may have to see this now. Previously had no real desire too despite all the hype - just doesn't seem like I'd give a shit. Still need to see every single one of the other films but haven't felt compelled.

and as far as humanity is concerned with liking wall - e, then I clearly must be Satan. I mean I saw it twice, and fell asleep twice. I think it was a pretty film and the messages were "cute" but something was missing for me.

[pshh]

I'd put this in my top 15 films of the year but I can definitely see this getting a Best Picture nomination. I personally thought the acting was average, screenplay very average, and the cinematography annoying. Mainly due to this...

if it wasn't for the story i would of driven myself sick of every other fucking scene because of that.

but atleast you feel me there man

[mutualaddiction]

decent movie, I don't know about Best Picture though.

[Smash Adams]

How was Jamal dressed so nicely? He didn't look that poor to me, I know it's kind of nitpicking but everyone was treating him like a hobo or something

[Un'Aria Ancora]

Loved everything about this movie. Best I've seen in a long time.

[atticusfinch]

Great film, definitely Oscar worthy. Just saw it tonight. I personally enjoyed the cinematography, and the screenplay was solid.

[bootsydan]

I thought the cinematography was brilliant. I think that and Ben Button will contend for that oscar this year.

I also thought the writing, the acting and Jamals story were very good. And the direction was outstanding.

There were only two things with this movie that half (and only half) bugged me.

1) It was essentially a love story.
2) Sometimes I felt it was kind of a cheap story trick to have a question on who wants to be a millionaire, then show how he knew the answer. My only defense there is to say that 'Who wants to be a millionaire' happened because of the way his life panned out, and the questions were just lucky. His life didn't pan out because of the show 'Who wants to be a millionaire.'
3) So maybe I can add a third by saying the 'lucky questions' half bugged me. But than that all relates back to point number 1.

Very enjoyable film though. Very good. Hope it wins some oscars.

[bootsydan]

Before Sunrise/Sunset. Two days and two fully formed characters that equal the greatest romance of the past 30+ years on film.

Linklater is a legend.

holy dutch angles

Haha. I hear this.

[pshh]

Linklater is a legend.

i fuckin hear that man :-)

[Recovery Room]

I thought the cinematography was brilliant. I think that and Ben Button will contend for that oscar this year.

I also thought the writing, the acting and Jamals story were very good. And the direction was outstanding.

There were only two things with this movie that half (and only half) bugged me.

1) It was essentially a love story.
2) Sometimes I felt it was kind of a cheap story trick to have a question on who wants to be a millionaire, then show how he knew the answer. My only defense there is to say that 'Who wants to be a millionaire' happened because of the way his life panned out, and the questions were just lucky. His life didn't pan out because of the show 'Who wants to be a millionaire.'
3) So maybe I can add a third by saying the 'lucky questions' half bugged me. But than that all relates back to point number 1.

Very enjoyable film though. Very good. Hope it wins some oscars.
Haha, I love when people argue/complain about this.

One of the main themes of the film was DESTINY.

[stayillogical]

Yeah, I hate when someone's main complaint of the movie is just that they missed the whole point.

[Smash Adams]

Amitabh Bachchan didn't like it
http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/ET_Cetera/Big_B_slams_Slumdog_Millionaire_on_ blog/articleshow/3979604.cms
because it made India look like a hellhole not because of the portrayal of him

[Recovery Room]

Amitabh Bachchan didn't like it
http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/ET_Cetera/Big_B_slams_Slumdog_Millionaire_on_ blog/articleshow/3979604.cms
because it made India look like a hellhole not because of the portrayal of him
Has he not left Bollywood or something?

[Jessooker]

I'm seeing this again saturday.

[cantnokdahustle]

Haha, I love when people argue/complain about this.

One of the main themes of the film was DESTINY.

So, if you are smart enough to understand a theme, then you must agree with it? That doesn't make any sense.

[GuitarR0cker1]

I need to see this.

[ThePurpleHearts]

I've yet to see the film, but I've wanted to since I heard Dev Patel was playing the main character. Anwar, from Skins! It's just kind of weird to me how big this film has gotten.

[SkyHeldUpByStar]

Amitabh Bachchan didn't like it
http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/ET_Cetera/Big_B_slams_Slumdog_Millionaire_on_ blog/articleshow/3979604.cms
because it made India look like a hellhole not because of the portrayal of him
I read that earlier. I take up issue with his statements that the only reason the movie is popular is because it was filmed by a westerner. I also have a problem with his argument that western culture only awards and recognizes Indian films in the vein of Satyajit Ray while mainstream Bollywood films are snubbed. I understand what he's trying to say but....I mean we do that to our own movies. You don't see Austin Powers getting critically lauded at the Venice or Cannes film festival.

[bootsydan]

Yeah, I hate when someone's main complaint of the movie is just that they missed the whole point.

Haha, I love when people argue/complain about this.

One of the main themes of the film was DESTINY.

See this:

So, if you are smart enough to understand a theme, then you must agree with it? That doesn't make any sense.

[stayillogical]

See this:

You can't criticize a movie for it's intended purpose. Plain and simple. If you don't like it, then it's just not your cup of tea. But you should still be able to say, it was good for what it was. That is my philosophy. To be able to fairly judge a movie and call it good or bad, there has to be some objectivity. If some people in here don't believe in fate, destiny, soulmates, and all of that, then that's personal. It doesn't make Slumdog a bad movie. You don't have to agree with the theme to appreciate the movie and whatever it's conveying. As long as it does what it intends to well.

[boldt_action]

See this:
For a movie whose plot is based of the theme of destiny, you would have to put aside beliefs of 'plausibility', since you, as a viewer, are being told a story of 'destiny'.

This seems to follow basic logic. And if you don't believe in the theme of the movie, how could you possibly say it deserves an award? Because without accepting the theme of destiny, the movie falls absolutely flat.

[Recovery Room]

So, if you are smart enough to understand a theme, then you must agree with it? That doesn't make any sense.
See this:
Are you two for real? That isn't what I said and is far from what I was implying.

The point is that you can't complain about the way a film plays out when it does so in harmony with its central theme.

[stayillogical]

Are you two for real? That isn't what I said and is far from what I was implying.

The point is that you can't complain about the way a film plays out when it does so in harmony with its central theme.

I like how you said that perfectly in one sentence. I rant too much.

[fluke182]

Ripping on Slumdog: it's so hot right now.

I love the perennial "little movie that could" backlash. It always comes, every single year.

[cantnokdahustle]

Ripping on Slumdog: it's so hot right now.

I love the perennial "little movie that could" backlash. It always comes, every single year.

The little film that could would be Let the Right one in. Does Slumdog deserve to be nominated this year? Absolutely, but only because there was the very good and the very mediocre this year.

[cantnokdahustle]

You can't criticize a movie for it's intended purpose. Plain and simple. If you don't like it, then it's just not your cup of tea. But you should still be able to say, it was good for what it was. That is my philosophy. To be able to fairly judge a movie and call it good or bad, there has to be some objectivity. If some people in here don't believe in fate, destiny, soulmates, and all of that, then that's personal. It doesn't make Slumdog a bad movie. You don't have to agree with the theme to appreciate the movie and whatever it's conveying. As long as it does what it intends to well.

Wow, I wish I could justify subjectivity by stating that it is subjective.



The point is that you can't complain about the way a film plays out when it does so in harmony with its central theme.

Sure you can; you can attack its silly premise and the director's inability to sufficiently draw you into that world.

[drudo182]

I really enjoyed this film but I don't think it's worthy of a best picture award or anything.

[ForlrnPerplxity]

I really enjoyed this film but I don't think it's worthy of a best picture award or anything.
Same. I really liked it, but I don't understand why it's getting so much award buzz.

[Recovery Room]

Sure you can; you can attack its silly premise and the director's inability to sufficiently draw you into that world.
Just because someone may find the premise "silly" doesn't mean the movie shouldn't stick to the rules within the universe of where the story is told.

How would you suggest destiny be conveyed in a film about a poor nobody on a game show that has the ability to win a fortune? Have him pull the answers out-of-nowhere? Lucky guess every one? That movie would last 30 minutes and not really tell a story or sculpt a theme. Or would you have him get the first question wrong and booted right away?

I just don't get what else someone could or would expect within the context of the theme of this particular film.

[fluke182]

The little film that could would be Let the Right one in. Does Slumdog deserve to be nominated this year? Absolutely, but only because there was the very good and the very mediocre this year.
Well, to be fair, Let the Right One In has no chance for any nominations now that it's been passed for Foreign Film. I love, love, love Let the Right One In. But sadly, it has no chance. It's the little film that's sadly being ignored.

[lazyman]

this movie was awesome

[drudo182]

Same. I really liked it, but I don't understand why it's getting so much award buzz.

Maybe it's because I expected a ton. Award noms sure, but I don't think its best picture quality.

[jbaseball44]

Right now it is looking like this is will be one of the front runners for best picture at the oscars.

[drudo182]

I would bet that it doesn't win best picture.

[cantnokdahustle]

Well, to be fair, Let the Right One In has no chance for any nominations now that it's been passed for Foreign Film. I love, love, love Let the Right One In. But sadly, it has no chance. It's the little film that's sadly being ignored.

Absolutely, but a two and a half month run in American theaters is not something I thought could happen. We saw it again on Wednesday night and the show was still packed.

[stayillogical]

Why was Let The Right One In disqualified for Best Foreign? That was in my top 3 of the year. It deserves some awards.

[jbaseball44]

I would bet that it doesn't win best picture.
I would say it has a decent chance, it's hard to tell right now cause it is so far away from the actual awards ceremony.

[drudo182]

Best part of Slumdog...

http://specials.rediff.com/movies/2008/jun/16slid1.jpg

Beautiful.

[drudo182]

I would say it has a decent chance, it's hard to tell right now cause it is so far away from the actual awards ceremony.

True. I just think Button and Wrestler are better films. Personally, Button ended up being my favorite from 2008 so I'd love that.

[jbaseball44]

True. I just think Button and Wrestler are better films. Personally, Button ended up being my favorite from 2008 so I'd love that.
I'm not sure about Button's chances, it ended up getting some so-so reviews. I think Rourke is a virtual lock for his performance in the wrestler, i can't say yet what i think of its chances for best picture.

[drudo182]

I'm not sure about Button's chances, it ended up getting some so-so reviews. I think Rourke is a virtual lock for his performance in the wrestler, i can't say yet what i think of its chances for best picture.

I think Rourke will win too. I don't see either winning best picture really but again, we don't even have the noms.

[Recovery Room]

Slumdog Millionaire is a much better film overall than Benjamin Button and The Wrestler and I love both.

But I realize everyone has their own opinion and right to it so to each their own.

[drudo182]

Button just got me good. Only beef with that one was I didn't think the story needed to be told from the standpoint that it was (reading the journal). It's my only major problem with it.

[poppa Q]

Why was Let The Right One In disqualified for Best Foreign? That was in my top 3 of the year. It deserves some awards.

Sweden nominated a different film to "represent" its country instead, the Academy only allows one film representation per country.

[cantnokdahustle]

The nomination process for foreign language films is ridiculous. Hence, Apocolypto's nomination, and LTROI's snub by its own country.

[fluke182]

Absolutely, but a two and a half month run in American theaters is not something I thought could happen. We saw it again on Wednesday night and the show was still packed.
Lucky bastard. I live in Alaska, where it still has yet to be even heard of in all likelihood, nor has it made it any where even near a theater. Thank god for torrents. I'd love to see it in theaters.

[bootsydan]

I had to drive an hour to the nearest cinema that was playing it. And when I got there it was completely packet out. I don't think there would've been anymore than 5 empty seats.

On the oscar buzz though. I heard the Americans weren't happy when it won all the awards at the Golden Globes? So maybe that will count against it...

[aminorthreat55]

The nomination process for foreign language films is ridiculous. Hence, Apocolypto's nomination, and LTROI's snub by its own country.
It actually didn't get snubbed; it didn't premiere in Sweden until after the submission date, so it is eligible for next year.

[stayillogical]

Watched this again in theaters. Took my best friend, I love first time reactions to certain parts.

[alann]

I thought that this was going to be a boring Bollywood movie, but it wasn't.
Damn, it was absolutely brilliant.

[Adeniz19]

finally got around to seeing this, and i think it most definitely deserves all the hype it's been getting. Is it my favorite movie from this year? No, I still think I enjoyed TDK and Wall-E much more, but so far this is my favorite to win best picture. Such an emotional roller coaster.

[WakingTheMisery]

I'd like to see this. Its getting such mixed reviews in my circle.

[stayillogical]

The thing that makes this movie my #1 is that it has so much replay value for me. Far more than Wall-E does.

[soundofthebrown]

Excellent movie. I was hesitant to see this movie at first, due to the fact that I grew up around Bollywood films - but this film defies that stereotype and is an excellent story. Very difficult to see some of the things that were shown in the movie - but that adds to its affect.

[Lueda Alia]

The theaters in my city aren't playing this. :-( In fact, the closest one playing it is 2 hours away. I hate it.

[stayillogical]

The theaters in my city aren't playing this. :-( In fact, the closest one playing it is 2 hours away. I hate it.

There are other ways...