better album

[kolby182]

the 2 albums that defined my music tastes and probably my 2 favorites of all time.

[batmannj]

i was never huge into blink, but before american idiot, i always enjoyed green day.

[ihatecayte]

Dookie for sure.
but on this site, blink will win.

[loganmmm]

This poll is done at least twice a year.

[mikeyystyles]

This question is tough because Dookie came out like 7-8 years earlier. Theres a huge generational gap there.

[kolby182]

This question is tough because Dookie came out like 7-8 years earlier. Theres a huge generational gap there.


dookie 1994
enema 1999.

i don't think it's TOO big of a generation gap.

[Alex DiVincenzo]

Enema

[SunnyInPhilly]

I lost all respect for Green Day since American Idiot. It sucks that Blink is gone, but at least the went out on top

[jbaseball44]

Dookie and it isn't close

[Sgt. Pepper's]

Dookie

[allthruwinter]

There'd be no Enema without Dookie. Also, SHE is enough of a reason for Greenday to win that one.

[stayillogical]

How is Dookie not winning this poll?

[jbaseball44]

How is Dookie not winning this poll?
People on this site have a hard on for Blink

[brndnizzle]

I love Blink and I always enjoyed enema of the state, but Dookie is definitely the better album.

[RetardedInLove]

As much as I enjoy Enema, it really should be no contest, Dookie should win.

[Basketcase]

Dookie

hands down

[TallSteve15]

blink all the way

[ACA]

I lost all respect for Green Day since American Idiot. It sucks that Blink is gone, but at least the went out on top

Some bands get better with time -- Green Day is one such band. AI is their best work to date. Blink-182's best album as a whole is probably TOYPAJ but their best songs come from other CDs, I think.

[jbaseball44]

Some bands get better with time -- Green Day is one such band. AI is their best work to date. Blink-182's best album as a whole is probably TOYPAJ but their best songs come from other CDs, I think.
Interesting, I do not hate AI but in large part i think Dookie is their best, most complete album. Most people seem to despise AI and at the same time listen to music that is 100x worse

[BigAl]

I time bomb.

[Poe-tryGirl]

Green Day! Dookie!

[joeag1985]

Dookie without a doubt.

[joeag1985]

Interesting, I do not hate AI but in large part i think Dookie is their best, most complete album. Most people seem to despise AI and at the same time listen to music that is 100x worse

I love American Idiot. Its pretty much a punk rock master piece.. no matter what Johnny Rotten says.. and even after the doublewhiskeycokenoice business.

[sergeantscruffy]

The fact that Enema is winning makes me very sad.

These albums aren't even close.

This is like "Pet Sounds" losing to "Chase This Light".

[of_the_rose]

tough one... but i gotta say dookie, for its time.

[RetardedInLove]

Some bands get better with time -- Green Day is one such band. AI is their best work to date. Blink-182's best album as a whole is probably TOYPAJ but their best songs come from other CDs, I think.

Finally, someone agrees with me about American Idiot!

[Gumbyjag]

it's sad that Blink is winning this poll.

[BJW7191]

dookie was a good album, but there are weak tracks on it... enema is flawless for a pop-punk album

[Hagysaurus Rex]

How is Dookie not winning this poll?

My thoughts exactly, but then again, didn't this site start off as a Blink fansite?

[Hagysaurus Rex]

Some bands get better with time -- Green Day is one such band. AI is their best work to date.

Amen that. Although I like Dookie better and would rather listen to that any day of the week, AI was a much better album. It was a punk rock opera with acts....fucking acts. You really dont see a punk rock album with that kind of scale and large vision a whole lot. I think all of the "I hate Green Day since they sold out with AI" really means "I hate all the mainstream attention AI got."

[blinkme]

i still listen to enema of the state on a weekly basis... dookie, not so much.

[IceAge/HeatWave]

when will people understand that Blink, while good, aren't that great

[tait]

dookie

[tait]

My thoughts exactly, but then again, didn't this site start off as a Blink fansite?
yes

[FUCKDIRTYWIPES]

dookie.

[RiCCioLi]

played out way tooooo much vs. naked guys for 2 years straight

blink! thats basically what those 2 albums were

[hipvee43]

yo u dookies have to realize this site fucking started as a blink-182 site

of course its gonna win.

[phil19]

ive never been a big green day fan so enema ftw

[onemoresong]

dookie ftw!

[justinmfi]

Dookie all the way!!!

[SuNDaYSTaR]

dookie 1994
enema 1999.

i don't think it's TOO big of a generation gap.Enough so that a lot of Dookie fans were graduating before I even started high school.

[White Noise]

I don't really enjoy either, but I would go with Dookie.

[map8705]

dookie was a good album, but there are weak tracks on it... enema is flawless for a pop-punk album

You are correct

[derekmoyer4]

Blink by far

[SJPrice99]

I love blink but there wouldnt BE a blink if it wasnt for Green Day - Dookie, it should be no contest but on this site blink will def win

[sofaraway]

I don't think one can compare these two albums. A better comparison would be Cheshire Cat and Dookie because both albums helped place Blink and Green Day on the map (respectively).

Plus, I think that if Dookie had not come out bands like Blink 182 would not have been formed.

[evry1willisten]

I had a dream the other night that blink put on a surprise reunion show.

...then i woke up and realized how much my life sucks.