PDA

View Full Version : Midtown-Favorite CD?

dpetty21
12/10/08, 01:11 PM
I searched and searched and could not find anything posing this question. Anyways which Midtown CD is your favorite?
The Personist
12/10/08, 02:11 PM
Living Well. I love that album, though all three are good. I honestly almost flipped a coin between Living Well and FWYK
dpetty21
12/10/08, 02:48 PM
I chose Save The World. For me it's STWLTG>LVITBR>FWYK
AbeLurkin
12/10/08, 03:27 PM
This is so hard. Save The World has Midtown's best songs. Living Well has the most great songs. FWYK changed the way I thought about an album.
just.Starla.
12/10/08, 05:01 PM
Tough choice, but I'm going to go with Save the World
billyboatkid
12/10/08, 09:56 PM
Living Well is just so Classic I had to go with it.
LongDistanceDrunk
12/11/08, 04:51 AM
Save the World is the only one I like
anamericangod
12/11/08, 05:24 AM
They're all good, but Forget What You Know is a masterpiece.
lew_1987
12/11/08, 06:24 AM
I thought that Forget What You Know would be clear in the lead with this one... but I suppose there are a lot of people that prefer the nostalgia of Living Well...
Paulb-182
12/11/08, 06:26 AM
i havent got forget what you know or have i ever heard it..

have the first two though.
lew_1987
12/11/08, 06:49 AM
i havent got forget what you know or have i ever heard it..

have the first two though.

You need to hear it.
BJW7191
12/11/08, 07:25 AM
forget what you know... soooo good
Anthony Lutz
12/11/08, 08:27 AM
Living Well Is The Best Revenge
CTMarshall
12/11/08, 03:00 PM
I need to get Forget What You Know...but I went with Living Well.
alann
12/11/08, 07:09 PM
Living Well, but this question is way too hard for me
tait
12/12/08, 06:11 PM
it was a hard choice but i went with forget what you know. all three are great in their own way
brndnizzle
12/12/08, 08:31 PM
I went with Save The World...but I think I may have been skewed because I just listened to it like, an hour ago. Tough question all around.
cory-182
12/12/08, 10:56 PM
Wow...I thought Forget What You Know would be far behind the other two.
fadedmemories
12/13/08, 03:58 AM
This is a tough one, but I have to go with Living Well Is The Best Revenge
zerock
12/13/08, 07:41 AM
Fwyk
more heart
12/13/08, 01:41 PM
figured living well is the best revenge would be at the top. it's amazing.
HelpMeSleep
12/14/08, 01:16 AM
forget what you know, no question. one of my all time favorite albums ever.
gonfreaks
12/14/08, 01:42 PM
Forget What You Know.
dpetty21
12/14/08, 06:33 PM
Wow...I thought Forget What You Know would be far behind the other two.

I thought the same thing. I'm surprised how even it is.
yourprivateeye
12/14/08, 08:22 PM
forget what you know, no question. one of my all time favorite albums ever.

my exact thoughts.
RunningFool
12/16/08, 10:45 AM
I chose Save The World. For me it's STWLTG>LVITBR>FWYK

This exactly.
dpetty21
12/16/08, 01:03 PM
This exactly.

Finally...I was beginning to think I was the only one haha.
HelpMeSleep
12/17/08, 02:27 AM
my exact thoughts.
:highfive: you rule.
stayillogical
12/17/08, 07:15 AM
Wow, how is FWYK not winning this?
HelpMeSleep
12/17/08, 12:24 PM
Wow, how is FWYK not winning this?
from my personal opinion, I'd say the same thing, but didn't a lot of people not appreciate it when it came out?
stayillogical
12/17/08, 12:41 PM
from my personal opinion, I'd say the same thing, but didn't a lot of people not appreciate it when it came out?

No idea. I'm late on the Midtown boat (I only knew the song on the Spiderman 2 soundtrack) but had heard lots of great things about FWYK which is how I got into them.
HelpMeSleep
12/17/08, 12:50 PM
No idea. I'm late on the Midtown boat (I only knew the song on the Spiderman 2 soundtrack) but had heard lots of great things about FWYK which is how I got into them.
I was late on that boat too. all I ever had of them for years was their cover of Your Love off of Punk Goes 80s. FWYK was actually the second album I got from them though, I got LWITBR first.
Kid Defender
12/17/08, 06:25 PM
Save the world is losing to that peice of shit forget what you know? Good God what the fuck...
westendriot
12/17/08, 07:34 PM
i love them all but i went with save the world.
yourprivateeye
12/17/08, 08:57 PM
:highfive: you rule.

haha yes! but obviously we both rule equally!
fadedmemories
12/17/08, 10:10 PM
Good to see Living Well is winning
ethanblake
12/18/08, 08:44 AM
good poll
jahh
12/20/08, 02:44 PM
living well.
though save the world is good too.
HelpMeSleep
12/20/08, 02:46 PM
haha yes! but obviously we both rule equally!
whoa, late pass, I just saw this. yes we do!
11:11
12/20/08, 02:47 PM
I've one heard Living Well.
HelpMeSleep
12/20/08, 02:55 PM
I've one heard Living Well.
you're missing out.
11:11
12/20/08, 03:35 PM
you're missing out.
:shrug: I just have a lot of other music to listen to. Never got around to it.
HelpMeSleep
12/20/08, 03:44 PM
:shrug: I just have a lot of other music to listen to. Never got around to it.
Forget What You Know is an amazing album.
yourprivateeye
12/21/08, 05:21 PM
whoa, late pass, I just saw this. yes we do!

you might be the only person I've ever met that actually likes that record. I think it's pure genius. I love the first two equally but FWYK is unlike any record ever. so good.
HelpMeSleep
12/22/08, 03:23 AM
you might be the only person I've ever met that actually likes that record. I think it's pure genius. I love the first two equally but FWYK is unlike any record ever. so good.
really? I agree. it is absolute genius. my favorite album ever, with Letters by Butch Walker as the only major competition.
inCinerate.1028
12/22/08, 08:38 AM
Fwyk
yourprivateeye
12/22/08, 02:16 PM
really? I agree. it is absolute genius. my favorite album ever, with Letters by Butch Walker as the only major competition.

I think it's one of the most underrated records ever. It has its own sound that you can't really compare to anything. They showed that they could write more than catchy pop-punk songs. Too bad it was a flop and now there's no more Midtown, but there is Cobra Starship :-(
midtown4657
12/23/08, 11:35 PM
i had to go with Save The World, Lose The Girl , if just because it was the first one i got way back in 8th grade, and its just one of those defining albums for me. It's really one of those albums that encompasses everything i love and enjoy about music, and i also always liked that i never had to tune down to jam to it like the latter two albums. However, FWYK is a close, close second there for me. both are probably in my top 10 all time.

Living Well is great, but i've never liked "In The Songs" that much, and i'd have to say the same for "Perfect" - it was always too ballad-y for me. The rest of that album i find to be as stellar as the rest of their material, and some of the songs on it are amongst my favorite Midtown songs ever (Find Comfort In Yourself, Get It Together, A Faulty Foundation) but Save the World and FWYK kinda always felt like more complete and cohesive albums to me.



looks like i'll be listening to midtown the rest of the night.