Favorite Brand New Album

[TheZeroKid]

I saw this as an actual topic in the music forum, but we need a place to see the results clearly. AP jizzes in their pants everytime Brand New is mentioned, so I'm turning the tables on themselves. Which one of BN's albums is the best?

[danman]

everyones gonna bash you for making this poll and say 'this has been done 1000 times before'

deja gets my vote

[princesschad]

Devil and God.

[LongDistanceDrunk]

Where is the none of the above option? Not everyone likes them

[jbaseball44]

Tdag

[RamInGoreville]

devil and god.

I want my vinyl.

[writeacliche]

Where is the none of the above option? Not everyone likes them
Then they probably don't have a favorite brand new album and probably shouldn't be in a thread devoted to voting for one.

gtfo

edit: I voted for Deja. YFW and TDAG are both awesome records but Deja has so much replay value because of the great lyrics.

[Machu505]

The Devil and God is by far their best work yet.

[Burn That Shit]

TDAGRIM, Deja is excellent as well though. I got into Brand New off of Deja and when I went back to listen to Your Favorite Weapon I was pretty disappointed.

[MontanaFromNY]

your favorite weapon because that was the album that got me into them and becasue it was the first album i started to listen to religiously

[TheZeroKid]

I voted Deja Entendu because it has the catchiness of YFW with the maturity of TDAGARIM

[CTMarshall]

The Devil and God by a long run.

[hipvee43]

y is deja not winning by soooooooooo much ? this is confusing. my perspective of tdag is that it had some amazing songs and some shit songs, deja as an album will always be there best to date!

[Burn That Shit]

y is deja not winning by soooooooooo much ? this is confusing. my perspective of tdag is that it had some amazing songs and some shit songs, deja as an album will always be there best to date!

There's absolutely nothing on TDAGRIM that I'd say is shit, there's definitely 1 or 2 songs that don't fit the album in general but they're still very good.

[oddwithoutend]

tdagarim>deja entendu>>>your favorite weapon

[Ryzenfall]

The other day i listened to a few songs on each of the Brand New records... still can't get into them.

[sammyboy516]

there's no choice for "overrated - none of thek are all that incredible"

[Burn That Shit]

there's no choice for "overrated - none of thek are all that incredible"

Probably because the poll is asking for your favorite Brand New album, not your opinion of their music in general.

[sammyboy516]

Probably because the poll is asking for your favorite Brand New album, not your opinion of their music in general.


haha, i know. i was just kidding.

[S-Man]

thank god for deja. it's my all time fav. i was expecting everyone to say yfw, that's what all my friends love. guess they're just a bunch of weirdos...

[kolby182]

I'm glad someone did this poll (even though I'm sure it's been done before) i haven't seen it or results from it. TDAG is so fucking good. It probably won't win, but I voted for it.

[batmannj]

devil and god for sure. love that album.

[anamericangod]

Deja by a longshot.

[of_the_rose]

Where is the none of the above option? Not everyone likes them


That's actually not true. EVERYONE likes them. Fact, not fiction.

[Say Nothing]

The Devil and God

[hipvee43]

There's absolutely nothing on TDAGRIM that I'd say is shit, there's definitely 1 or 2 songs that don't fit the album in general but they're still very good.

vinny's songs hahaha

[The Personist]

TDAG. Hands down.

[adam289]

The Devil and God.

[ElevenElm]

i go back and forth between deja and devil and god, but i think my heart lies with deja.

[White Noise]

Wow, a year ago this poll wouldn't even be close. I guess a lot of the Deja fans are seeing the truth.

[rckstr29]

Where is the none of the above option? Not everyone likes them

Are you sure? They're pretty damn likable.

[samsara]

Well duh...

[LongDistanceDrunk]

Are you sure? They're pretty damn likable.


And so is Jesus

[rckstr29]

And so is Jesus

Ya. True that.

[11:11]

YFW>Deja>>>TDAG

That's not to say I don't like TDAG.

[wickedmajestic]

come on.. give your favorite weapon some love

[sdisticsquirrel]

Devil and God IS their best album, but the question asks for favorite... so, for me... it's Deja

[BrokenMirror]

No question. The Devil And God is by far my favourite BN album.

[holybuble]

the devil and god is 8 times better than deja.

[TheZeroKid]

the devil and god is 8 times better than deja.

Why 8? Can you give me 8 reasons why? I'd love to hear them lol. Deja and Devil are pretty close, with Deja having a slight lead with me.

[black hole sun]

tdagarim>deja entendu>>>your favorite weapon

In perfect agreement.

[holybuble]

Why 8? Can you give me 8 reasons why? I'd love to hear them lol. Deja and Devil are pretty close, with Deja having a slight lead with me.

8 is perfect because is composed by two circles one above the other.basically two laps in a common indy race

[cory-182]

I figured Deja would be the most popular, but YFW being so far behind The Devil and God surprises me.

[FUCKDIRTYWIPES]

deja

[Hagysaurus Rex]

Like this hasn't been done ten thousand times....

I love Deja, but the musicianship, songwriting, and technicality in TDAGARIM really impress and speak to me, so it gets my vote hands down.

YFW is a fun pop/punk album I'll spin only when I'm in the mood.

EDIT: wait, what? This poll confuses me. In the title it says "Favorite Brand New Album," but under the first post it says "best Brand New album." There are clearly two answers. Deja is my favorite, and I'll spin it any day, but TDAG is an absurdly much better album (see musicianship, songwriting, etc. above) even if it's not as accessible as Deja.

[Alex DiVincenzo]

YFW > Deja >> TDAGARIM

[jjjkman]

Where is the none of the above option? Not everyone likes them
then don't vote? that would be the logical thing to do, the website doesn't really revolve around your needs

[Heart-A-Tact]

Your Favorite Weapon. I've never been too into these guys, but I do enjoy more than a few songs from that album.

[LongDistanceDrunk]

Then they probably don't have a favorite brand new album and probably shouldn't be in a thread devoted to voting for one.

gtfo

edit: I voted for Deja. YFW and TDAG are both awesome records but Deja has so much replay value because of the great lyrics.



then don't vote? that would be the logical thing to do, the website doesn't really revolve around your needs

Goddamn people I was being sarcastic. I would choose Deja

[Oddpac87]

YFW > Deja >> TDAGARIM
You're mixing up your "less than" and "greater than" signs.

[Illuminate]

Devil and god > deja > yfw


got better each time.

[LongDistanceDrunk]

You're mixing up your "less than" and "greater than" signs.

you have the best avatar ever

[Oddpac87]

you have the best avatar ever
Haha. Thanks. I couldn't resist joining the masses on here with a "why so serious?" avatar leading up to the movie, and c'mon, the Mooninites make everything better.

[Alex DiVincenzo]

You're mixing up your "less than" and "greater than" signs.

You're mixing up "funny" and "stupid"

I knew I'd be in the minority on this one and someone would call me out on it.

[Deadbolt01]

Mine changes from time to time, right now it's deja.

[Anthony Lutz]

Lyrically: Deja
Musically: TDAGARIM

[roflcopter]

i like both devil and god and deja, but i find myself listening to devil and god a lot more.

i could never get into YFW.

[speakhandsforme]

y is deja not winning by soooooooooo much ? this is confusing. my perspective of tdag is that it had some amazing songs and some shit songs, deja as an album will always be there best to date!
There are many premises to make the case that The Devil and God is better than Deja. I personally think TDAGARIM throttles its predecessor by leaps and bounds but that's just me.

[LIbroski]

yfw for the raw, young, long island sound

[yourprivateeye]

TDAGARIM is the grestest record of all-time.

but I also have the astronaut from the cover of Deja tattooed on my leg.

[tommy's ghost]

The Devil and God is absolutely astounding, I love it to death... so it gets my vote.

[billyboatkid]

De

[Shark90576]

I love Deja and Devil and God, but Your Favorite Weapon will always be my favorite.

Raw, pop/punk sound which was so awesome back when it came out. Just brings amazing memories back and is one of the better CD's to listen to in the summer with the windows down and the music blaring.

[Praetor]

If your answer is anything other than TDAG then you have a worthless taste in music.

[Co and Ca]

the devil and god are raging inside me. hells yeah.

[DaveZeroZero]

Your Favorite Weapon.

[Dan CiTi]

I can't see how anyone can take most of this band's music seriously.

[Undue Noise]

TDAGARIM because it's amazing. Deja is a close second.

[I am Mick]

Deja

[VIVALAMATT]

This poll is a joke.

Devil and God is by far their best work. Deja Entendu wasn't even that good.

[hellogorgeous]

deja is my life in album form, but i love the other two as well