Pick

[circatbs]

Go.

[alann]

Sa

[Machu505]

This is actually difficult for me.

[estrella starr]

bn.

[11:11]

IARB = Deja/YFW
IDOTG < TDAGARIM

So Brand New wins this one for me.

[bailmeout13]

Neither?

[batmannj]

(shakes head)

brand new will win in a landslide. as usual.

[circatbs]

(shakes head)

brand new will win in a landslide. as usual.

they are losing

[ihatecayte]

IARB is sooooooo so good. i love that album.
but that's one album vs. Deja and TDAG.
brand new wins for me.

[batmannj]

they are losing

after 16 votes. brand new does not lose polls on AP, and even against the beatles they put up a fight

[circatbs]

after 16 votes. brand new does not lose polls on AP, and even against the beatles they put up a fight

yeah i saw that...

[LongDistanceDrunk]

they are losing

Not anymore. Brand New wins every poll except the Beatles and God polls

[aircourtneys]

Crap, Those are my 2 favorite bands that was really hard for me

[just.Starla.]

Say Anything

[White Noise]

Bn.

[SuNDaYSTaR]

Brand New. Both are close though.

[FUCKDIRTYWIPES]

brand new. although i love say anything.

[CTMarshall]

Brand New put out one good album (devil and god). Say Anything put out two. That's just my opinion.

[handlikesecret]

Say Anything.

[futilespider]

it seems like everyone really likes brand new around this site. your favorite weapon was amazing...and there were some good songs off the other couple cds, but there is no comparrison between brand new and say anything. Max Bemis is a songwriting genius. i'm not putting down brand new...i just don't think they come close to say anything

[miss sobriety]

Say Anything

[SLoT]

Had to choose. Had to go with Say Anything. Brand New just doesn't do it for me anymore. Maybe when I was right out of high school.

[samsara]

SA dang it!

[Angela23116]

brand new. easy.

[ElevenElm]

i have yet to understand as to why people with ears listen to say anything.

[Poe-tryGirl]

This is tough. I picked Brand New.

[BJW7191]

brand new... i havent heard a say anything song that i enjoy

i dont get their hype

[more heart]

say anything, no contest

[Heart-A-Tact]

Say Anything. I don't understand how any poll involving Brand New being set next to or against any other band on this website is necessary. The outcome is, in most cases, predictable.

[threepunchjim]

IARB = Deja/YFW
IDOTG < TDAGARIM

So Brand New wins this one for me.

This except that in defense beats out devil and God.

[darkmartheight]

actually a close one!

[BigAl]

Max Bemis. Obviously.

[DaniMoo]

I'd say Say Anything. Although I'm a fan of both, this was easy for me. I find myself listening to SA more, and I find Max's lyrics better/more interesting.

[Burn That Shit]

I still don't understand the love affair with Say Anything, or anyone that has a love affair with in defense of the genre considering the second half was complete poop.

[Co and Ca]

Brand New. hands down.

[bluecrunchy]

Say Anything has put out one good album. Brand New has put out three good albums. Easy choice for me.

[billyboatkid]

Bn. never looses.

[adam289]

Brand New.

[murrich]

Brand New should win this battle of mediocrity.

[harryCane]

Brand New. Not even kinda close.

[allthruwinter]

Brand New will always be better than Say Anything. Maybe if Say Anything released a sophomore album that didn't completely suck at life, this would be more debatable.

[SanePsychotic]

Brand New.

[etheritcher]

super tough
i think i like bn a little bit more than sa

[tommy's ghost]

IARB = Deja/YFW
IDOTG < TDAGARIM

So Brand New wins this one for me.

Have you heard SA's demos and EPs? They're great as well.

[Machu505]

Dammit I'm going with Brand New. They've had 2 amazing albums while SA only has IARB.

[hockeyguitar99]

Say Anything easily for me. I love DE and TDAG, but I love IARB and IDOTG also, and thats just more songs that are better overall.

[_><_]

A year ago I would've voted for Say Anything, but i recently got into Brand New. TDAG is amazing. So my vote goes to Brand New.

[xBrandNew]

two of my favorite bands right there, but brand new is just phenomena

[The Stiletto]

Enough with the fucking Brand New poll....
We know thay are great, we know they win every freakin poll on AP.net !!!

[inCinerate.1028]

Say Anything.