I Know Exactly What Goes On

[circatbs]

Pick 1.


TAYF ftw

[alann]

Tell All Your Friends

[Machu505]

I love Brand New but Your Favourite Weapon isn't really good. Tell All Your Friends wins this for me.

[11:11]

YFW is my favorite Brand New cd.

[jay_klinkhammer]

Tayf > Yfw

Yfw > Tdagarim

[josiahh]

TAYF > YFW

But, the difference between TBS and BN is that BN has gotten progressively better while TBS' trajectory has been straight down.

[Burn That Shit]

Yfw > Tdagarim

Wrong.

Tell All Your Friends is much better than YFW by the way.

[loganmmm]

YFW is the only Brand New album that I can tolerate....

SHUNNNNN!!

[The Personist]

Tayf > Yfw

Yfw > Tdagarim

False.

TAYF is the better album, but Brand New's other 2 blow it out of the water...and everything else TBS has done.

[LongDistanceDrunk]

False.

TAYF is the better album, but Brand New's other 2 blow it out of the water...and everything else TBS has done.


Hate hate hate hate hate hate

[The Personist]

Hate hate hate hate hate hate

You made me lol with this. I don't even know why.

[LongDistanceDrunk]

You made me lol with this. I don't even know why.

Its a quote from the Playa Hata's Ball on Chappelle show.

[fadedmemories]

TAYF, in my opinion, is still better than anything by BN, I just never got into BN

[circatbs]

TAYF, in my opinion, is still better than anything by BN, I just never got into BN

Me too.

[Machu505]

Why would anyone vote for Your Favourite Weapon? It's so... not good.

[kolby182]

i think brand new might lose this one.

[Burn That Shit]

i think brand new might lose this one.

Indeed. Taking Back Sunday with John Nolan was pretty solid, for the genre anyway.

[fadedmemories]

Good to see that TAYF is winning

[SeanEBoy2686]

Your Favourite Weapon wins this for me without a doubt. Both are great albums, but I'm partial to BN. I'm surprised by results of this poll though... I thought it'd be closer.

[shwaz499]

Tayf>yfw....deja>all

[kolby182]

tbs may have started stronger...but brand new finishes on top with the rest of their albums. I think a good poll would be 70 x's 7 vs. There's No "I" In Team..............which I'm sure there has been one before but I don't feel like going back 6 years to find one.

[element11790]

I'm shocked TBS is in the lead. I voted for them cause I think it's the better album but everyone on this site bows down to Brand New. lol

[TheZeroKid]

:death:

Tell All Your Friends >>>>>>>> Your Favourite Weapon

Deja Entendu >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Tell All Your Friends

[TBSEmoKid]

TAYF, in my opinion, is still better than anything by BN, I just never got into BN

Agreed for the most part.I can listen to Brand New,but they're not one of my favorites.Hahaha,no bias though.

[anamericangod]

I really don't see how anyone could vote for YFW.

[r000000b]

Deja Entendu might stand a chance against Tell All your Friends but Your Favorite Weapon isn't even a solid "every fucking song is perfect" cd. anyone who says otherwise should have their eyes through the scope and their mouth on the barrel of a gun. don't ever poll this way again.

[lauren<3s music]

I really don't see how anyone could vote for YFW.
pretty dumb statement. your favorite weapon is an excellent album and while i prefer tdag and deja more, it was the start of brand new's vision. tell all your friends was good, but semi generic when you look at all the other releases by tbs and around the same time frame.

[Anthony Lutz]

Your Favorite Weapon... Even though it's Brand New's worst.

[himynameisjohn3]

i really like them both, but i've been listening to YFW a lot lately and i haven't heard TAYF in a while.

[adam289]

Tell All Your Friends.

[mxpxjf]

Me too.

Me 3.

[anamericangod]

pretty dumb statement. your favorite weapon is an excellent album and while i prefer tdag and deja more, it was the start of brand new's vision. tell all your friends was good, but semi generic when you look at all the other releases by tbs and around the same time frame.

Tell All Your Friends is generic compared to their other releases? I think you're forgetting that the other releases are shit.

[Tim Lincecum]

most of the songs on YFW are hit or miss. I think the best songs on YFW are better than the best songs on TAYF, but TAYF is better over all because YFW has like 5 throw away songs on it

[more heart]

tell all your friends fo' sho'

[lauren<3s music]

Tell All Your Friends is generic compared to their other releases? I think you're forgetting that the other releases are shit.
imo it's not some earth shattering album. neither was yfw but it is definitely likable

[LongDistanceDrunk]

Deja Entendu might stand a chance against Tell All your Friends but Your Favorite Weapon isn't even a solid "every fucking song is perfect" cd. anyone who says otherwise should have their eyes through the scope and their mouth on the barrel of a gun. don't ever poll this way again.
LOL

[anamericangod]

imo it's not some earth shattering album. neither was yfw but it is definitely likable

Not like it's one of the most defining/influential albums in this entire music scene.

[darkmartheight]

I personally love both albums to death, but if my house was burning down I'd take tell all your friends.

[r000000b]

Not like it's one of the most defining/influential albums in this entire music scene.
you're fighting a brand new fan who won't listen to logic or reason. all they know is this band's albums top all other albums but have no way of explaining why. YFW was actually more generic than TAYF was and the only reason you could even call TAYF generic is because as soon as it came out a million bands spawned trying to copy that same sound and visceral feeling. YFW is coy at best and is not the winner is any way, shape or form

[LongDistanceDrunk]

you're fighting a brand new fan who won't listen to logic or reason. all they know is this band's albums top all other albums but have no way of explaining why. YFW was actually more generic than TAYF was and the only reason you could even call TAYF generic is because as soon as it came out a million bands spawned trying to copy that same sound and visceral feeling. YFW is coy at best and is not the winner is any way, shape or form

That is exactly right dude

[justletgo]

Tell All Your Friends will forever be my favorite record.

[RamInGoreville]

All I know is that:
Everything > Louder Now.

[hf57]

easily tayf

[phil19]

fark me this is a tough choice. i love both albums but i went with yfw because i like brand new more than taking back sunday

[Deadbolt01]

I think tell all your friends has its moments but way too much filler. It's actually quite easily my least favourite TBS record.
Your Favourite weapon I like all the way through, I really like it, so therefore wins hands down.

[Cuddleworthy]

tttyg and tayf would be a better poll. yfw sucks

[ElevenElm]

i don't like either very much, but i've never really liked taking back sunday. therefore, i pick yfw.

[billyboatkid]

I love Brand New to death but TAYF is definitley better..

Still have love for YFW tho.

[IceAge/HeatWave]

brand new can actually lose in something on this website?

[Machu505]

brand new can actually lose in something on this website?

Well YFW isn't a good album in it's own right, and undoubtedly BN's worst. Take This to Your Grave vs. Tell All Your Friends would be much more interesting.

[SuNDaYSTaR]

TAYF > YFW

But, the difference between TBS and BN is that BN has gotten progressively better while TBS' trajectory has been straight down.This.

[Ryzenfall]

Friends before weapons.

[inCinerate.1028]

Tell All Your Friends.

[VIVALAMATT]

I love Brand New but Your Favourite Weapon isn't really good. Tell All Your Friends wins this for me.

bingo.

[hellogorgeous]

I love Brand New but Your Favourite Weapon isn't really good. Tell All Your Friends wins this for me.


i agree, they have a few good songs but every song on tayf is pretty much golden

[Alex DiVincenzo]

I can't believe YFW isn't dominating. I do prefer TAYF though.

[TreyForest]

YFW got my vote but i have and love both records
the best songs for me on yfw (sudden death, logan to gov, 70x7, and soco ) r better then the best on tayf