Does anyone NOT like Gatsby's American Dream?

[WithoutASoundXO]

I went to go see treos last night in CT and Gatsby played with them. I had listened to Ribbons and Sugar ages ago but never really got into it. I've listened to all the hype about their new stuff and I have to say I was very dissapointed. They were not very impressive and I think that everyone just talks about how great they are because it's the cool thing to do.

[ArTkY_]

No. I love them.

[SonEric84]

I don't really listen to them.

[Manbotisdead]

I dislike them with a passion.
I think they are great musically, but vocally the singer is not my thing. I wish that he'd stop whining and just sing. It doesn't fit the music. No offense to those who love this band. I mean I love high pitched bands (Mars Volta and Coheed) but his voice seems a little out of place.

[Samuel]

i cant stand his voice

[Clarett'sGreyGoose]

I don't really listen to them.
exactly.

[kidinthecorner]

I saw them in concert once with The Spill Canvas. I thought the singer was just... gay, not a great performer like it seems everyone thinks.

[VeloriumCamper]

my brother is seeing GAD/TREOS/The Rocket Summer tomorrow at the Chance.

I like them, nothing special, but good

[YearsGoneBy]

i dont care for them

[SC0926]

i dont like or dislike them. they arent bad, they just arent my thing

[Kid Kilowatt]

Their music would have made Anne Frank give herself up.

[SonEric84]

Their music would have made Anne Frank give herself up.


hahahaahhahaa Ouch.

[pUnkKid174]

honestly, i've heard of them...but i've never listened to them

[mat1419]

never listened to them

[VeloriumCamper]

hahahaahhahaa Ouch.

i second that

[selftitled85]

i dont understand the hype. some of the lyrics are good. but the cd is rather bland and normal in my opinion.

[YearsGoneBy]

Their music would have made Anne Frank give herself up.
hahahah

[workinclasshero]

Shhhh, I'm Listening to Reason
good song, amazing band

[The Silencer]

I cannot get enough of this band, I don't see how everyone all of a sudden jumped on the "I don't like GAD anymore" bandwagon?

and how is the singer's voice high??

[Manbotisdead]

I cannot get enough of this band, I don't see how everyone all of a sudden jumped on the "I don't like GAD anymore" bandwagon?

and how is the singer's voice high??
He hits high notes dipshit that's how.

I never liked this band though.

[Rebs]

Not my favorite, it doesnt make me cringe, but I wouldn't buy the cd.

[TitoThePoolBoy]

i saw them with circa survive and was incredibly let down. the lead singer does these dance moves that almost seem choreographed, and you're like wtf? i was a little embarssed for them really. they were the headliner at the show i went to, and 2/3's of the crowd left during their set. :/



but i <3 scott weber.

[Mercy Medical]

I went to go see treos last night in CT and Gatsby played with them. I had listened to Ribbons and Sugar ages ago but never really got into it. I've listened to all the hype about their new stuff and I have to say I was very dissapointed. They were not very impressive and I think that everyone just talks about how great they are because it's the cool thing to do.
Man, you hit the nail on the head right there. Yup, all the people like them because it's the cool thing to do. That's why I listen to all the music I listen to because it's gets me in with the popular crowd and it helps me get lots of friends.

[kidinthecorner]

i saw them with circa survive and was incredibly let down. the lead singer does these dance moves that almost seem choreographed, and you're like wtf? i was a little embarssed for them really. they were the headliner at the show i went to, and 2/3's of the crowd left during their set. :/



but i <3 scott weber.
Ha.

When I saw them, The Spill Canvas opened, just him alone, then GAD, then .. Madcap? (Whoever sings "Bright Lights, Big City") was the headliner. EVERYBODY left. There were like 4 kids left in the crowd when they finished.

Well, I'm guessing. I left after 4 or 5 songs and there were about 10 people left.

[The Silencer]

He hits high notes dipshit that's how.

I never liked this band though.
well let's see, I think I would know if the singer hits high notes and/or has a high-sounding voice, seeing how I am a fan of the band and I actually do take the time to listen to them :thumbsup:

[Manbotisdead]

well let's see, I think I would know if the singer hits high notes and/or has a high-sounding voice, seeing how I am a fan of the band and I actually do take the time to listen to them :thumbsup:
I listened to them today, also I fucking take choir so I would know what is high for a male to be singing and what wouldn't be. What he is singing with is called a falsetto, or fake high voice. Its a certain placement of tome and breath support that allows a singer to sing outside there average range.

[Trainsaw]

they're alright, i've got acouple of their songs but never really got into them

[kidinthecorner]

I listened to them today, also I fucking take choir so I would know what is high for a male to be singing and what wouldn't be. What he is singing with is called a falsetto, or fake high voice. Its a certain placement of tome and breath support that allows a singer to sing outside there average range.
Is that all you've learned in choir?

[Manbotisdead]

Is that all you've learned in choir?
No, you learn about support and shit, but i'm not the most musical person around so I can't get into specific notes and whatnot.

[kidinthecorner]

You dont say.

[TitoThePoolBoy]

i was in choir in third grade, and they made us sing the michael jackson free willy song. :embarasse

[Manbotisdead]

You dont say.
Why do you take it, and if so do you know alot more than what I just said? Or were you just asking?

[Help.Me.]

We were supposed to see Gatsby's American Dream with TREOS( Amazing band, and great live show!!) but had to leave early. :cry: I wish we could have stayed. Their music is different something that makes you want to listen more. In my opinion anyways.

[afk999]

i tried to get into them and i thought they were good nothing spectacular like people say though

[The Silencer]

I listened to them today, also I fucking take choir so I would know what is high for a male to be singing and what wouldn't be. What he is singing with is called a falsetto, or fake high voice. Its a certain placement of tome and breath support that allows a singer to sing outside there average range.
wow, I've never heard of that before, do tell me more :help:

[Spooky]

pssh, gatsby's is sweet. Although i haven't seen them live yet, so i can't comment on that.

[panic !!]

I don't like them.

[yeknom]

I went to go see treos last night in CT and Gatsby played with them. I had listened to Ribbons and Sugar ages ago but never really got into it. I've listened to all the hype about their new stuff and I have to say I was very dissapointed. They were not very impressive and I think that everyone just talks about how great they are because it's the cool thing to do.

no.

[Manbotisdead]

wow, I've never heard of that before, do tell me more :help:
Apparently not because you missed it in GAD's music.

[Adeniz19]

i have gaven them a couple fair shots cause of scotts hype and i usually like the bands he recommends but i just cant get into gatsbys

[AreTwoKay]

i dont like or dislike them. they arent bad, they just arent my thing
Yeah I didn't care for them much and was getting soo tired of always seeing them get over hyped and I am finally giving their new cd a chance and I'll admit its good musically but the vocals kill it, just something about his voice gets on my nerves

[HailTheHartBrak]

I love them. Maybe its possible that they are a great band and have a lot of fans who actually like their music. But that would be impossible because everyone who likes a band that you dont like is just doing it because it is the cool thing to do.

[Frank Giaramita]

I went to go see treos last night in CT and Gatsby played with them. I had listened to Ribbons and Sugar ages ago but never really got into it. I've listened to all the hype about their new stuff and I have to say I was very dissapointed. They were not very impressive and I think that everyone just talks about how great they are because it's the cool thing to do.

I agree with your statement 99.9%, except I don't think people like them "because it's the cool thing to do".

[Paul Tao]

I can't get into them.

[IAmCountryMusic]

i dont like them at all but i dont want trouble with weber

[punkpixie]

I wasn't impressed when I heard them. I've tried again since, and I just can't get into it.

[WithoutASoundXO]

Everyone that likes Gatsby is too embarrassed to post that they do so they take away my "scene points."