Favorite Wonka

[angryandconfusd]

Hopefully everyone has had enough time to see both.

[drudo182]

depp.

[The_Crowing]

Both were great. But I think I might have to go with Depp because he showed the depth of Willy Wonka that wasnt shown before in the original movie, and was true to the book also.

[VeloriumCamper]

wilder..

[TheAcademyROCKS]

wow that is a really close call...i had to go with gene wilder because i grew up with that, not to mention as much as i liked the new version and how depp did get a good heartfelt performance with depth, wilder's singing and his jokes were classics

[TJ Wells]

i dont even think its CLOSE...wilder is 1000x better

[theESCO]

Fuck Gene Wilder.

[littlehope4us]

gene, he has more of that jerk type of thing goin on. like 'oh...no...stop....'

[charly horse]

I like Johnny Depp better, but I like the old movie better than the new one.

[TheAcademyROCKS]

Fuck Gene Wilder.
haha i like the capital letters for each word...it makes you sounds like you actually have a grudge against gene wilder, but you need to put periods after each word like this

Fuck. Gene. Wilder.

[theESCO]

Actually..I was just being grammatically correct. Capitalizing the first word of the sentence, and someones name. But I'm glad I could give ya a laugh, haha.

[TheAcademyROCKS]

haha that gave me another laugh because technically you are right about that, but then again its not a complete sentence so maybe your not right,...shit everything is making me laugh tonight, especially that myspace sold out thing with tom saying goodbye to the emo f.a gs haha

[marrost]

Haha come on. I don't even need to see the new one to know that it's Gene Wilder.

[R7265ab]

The new one is awesome :)

[TMartin442]

i didnt like the new movie... so im going w/ wilder

[WakingTheMisery]

gay for johnny depp.

i went with wilder.

[takingback98]

whenver i see wilder i automaticly think of wonka.

[Chemical Love]

I still havent seen the new one yet :-\

[Indie Bracelet]

I love the old one; I love the new one. I had to go with the back when one though.

[suburbn_thrills]

Gene without a doubt.

[sean omerta]

I think they were both great and work as two standalone movies.
I can't really see them as two versions of the same movie at all.

I abstain from the vote.

[last light]

the new movie was awful.

[sean omerta]

i'm not trying to start a fight or anything but i'm really curious as to why someone would think that?

[last light]

i'm not trying to start a fight or anything but i'm really curious as to why someone would think that?

why it was awful? the way depp acted the part was obnoxious and just odd for the sake of being odd, i found it to be far too long, poorly done, not funny, horrible effects, it was FAR AND AWAY the worst tim burton film ive ever seen. hopefully corpse bride makes up for this.

[sean omerta]

okay, cool. I was honestly just wondering why.
I still enjoyed it.
I think i'll enjoy Corpse Bride, too.


edit: for typo.

[last light]

okay, cool. I was honestly just wondering why.
I still enjoyed it.
I think i'll enjoy Corpse Bridge, too.

its just not really my type of movie i guess...i probably should have said that before, i just found myself bored thats all. glad you enjoyed it, im really looking forward to corpse bride