PDA

View Full Version : Poison the Well - Versions


Klatzke
01/16/09, 09:28 PM
Poison The Well - Versions
Release Date: April 2, 2007
Record Label: Ferret Records

It took me forever to get into Versions. It didn't help that I had chosen to pass on buying it altogether at first, seeing as You Come Before You was, for me, a spectacularly boring affair. After initially passing on it, it took almost a full year before I saw a section of it (the first 3 or so songs) on my friend's computer. He never listened to them, simply stating that he "couldn't get into it." After syncing it, (forgive me, RIAA) and listening to the tracks a couple of times, interest was found and before too long I had a copy for myself. Instead of being without this glorious album now, I just kick myself for not looking into it sooner.

Versions is quite possibly one of my favorite albums. As far as heavier music goes, I believe it's clinched the top spot, and I easily regard it as (so far) being the pinnacle of Poison the Well's career. Having heard their previous albums, I basically expected more of the same from them, and was utterly shocked. It didn't have the crushing capacity of their previous albums, and they progressed leaps and bounds on the change they'd started to move towards on You Come Before You. Really, with four years between the albums it's no surprise that they'd taken such a stylistic shift.

The potential for utter brutality is still there, but unlike their past work, the aggression on this album seems more channeled and focused. In many places, vocalist Jeffrey Moreira actually seems to be coming apart at the seams. The haunting melodies that he's delivering aren't the only indication of this, but when he breaks in with his tortured screaming it often sounds like a madman's cries. This is, in no way, a bad thing, and it adds one of the definitive factors for the album. The haunting lines he delivers in songs like "Slow Good Morning," "Nagaina" and "Riverside" are some of the most chilling moments of the album. Because the singing is present in just about every song, it becomes one of the most interesting factors, and provides a harsh differential against the tortured screaming.

The musicianship on this album is where Poison the Well progress the most. They never really played into fads or stereotypes, but they've taken it a step further on this album, bringing in everything from horns to slide guitars. In each track, you're met by a wall of sound, and not the "everything sounds fuzzy" kind of wall. It's more like you hear each instrument for what it is, but when it all comes together you've just met such a crushing, heavy sound that there's really no other way to perceive it. The guitars jump and twist, they incorporate all kinds of effects, and you can hear Chris Hornbrook blasting away at his set in the background. They've managed to create a sound that's somehow both atmospheric and unbelievably heavy at the same time. There are times when I really feel like the sound issuing forth can take me wherever I need be. They can have me perplexed by the screeching, creepy intro to "Composer Meets Corpse" or completely awed by the unbelievably textured melody in "The First Day Of My Second Life." There are moments that almost meet, in my opinion, the stunning arrays that many post-metal groups have come to experiment with recently. They're not ready to wear the post-metal tag by any means, but there are plenty of moments in their stunning escalations and atmospheric vibes that remind me of some of those bands.

The lyrics on this album fit its style perfectly. As I said before, there's a certain quality to Moriera's vocals on this album that make him seem almost like a madman that can't control his thoughts. The lyrics are, oftentimes, seemingly insane. A great example of this is from "Slow Good Morning" where he (seemingly confidently) sings "Sir they say we aren't really here, so don't just try to punish us, you are the one who has lost his mind. We didn't bring the bodies, we didn't throw them on your floor. You are the one who has lost his mind." Another great example can be found in the song "Pleading Post", where Moreira proclaims, "Is it wrong to use depair, For our own personal gain? To fuel the fires in the guts. So happiness wasn't for you - it didn't come with the blood" and later, coming loose he screams, "Use them to get where you need to go. Heard you say if there's a flame, you'll burn every tree that you see. Even the one you carved the lame and the females name into."

This is a definite progression for Poison the Well. Given some freedom (such as the ability to record in Sweden) they've shown they're not out of tricks, and that they'll continue to push out a sound that, while easily identifiable as their own, will always be pushing the envelope. With Versions, Poison the Well created an album that not only captured what made them unique, but through some experimentation and progression, created a whole new sound that completely blew out my idea of what to expect from them.


At the Soundawn; The Bled; Warship; Norma Jean; From Autumn To Ashes' Too Bad You're Beautiful (attn: This isn't labeled "sounds like")

http://www.myspace.com/poisonthewell

EndSerenading
01/26/09, 09:10 AM
good review, ill have to listen to it. I was a fan of the opposite of december way back in the day and honestly havent kept up much with them since. so maybe this is a good time to start

Mediocrity
01/26/09, 09:38 AM
I couldn't disagree more; whilst the opening few tracks and Naive Monarch sound like quintessential Poison the Well the whole thing comes unstuck when they try to broaden their palette. That's with the exception of Nagaina, which is epically astounding, and shows a much better use of dynamics than the rest of the more 'adventurous' material, which is bogged down in relatively juvenile lyrics.

Dre Okorley
01/26/09, 10:13 AM
Just bring back OOD and we'll be happy.

Klatzke
01/26/09, 10:14 AM
I couldn't disagree more; whilst the opening few tracks and Naive Monarch sound like quintessential Poison the Well the whole thing comes unstuck when they try to broaden their palette. That's with the exception of Nagaina, which is epically astounding, and shows a much better use of dynamics than the rest of the more 'adventurous' material, which is bogged down in relatively juvenile lyrics.
See, i think that when they try to expand it works better. Just my opinion on it though.

Burning Star IV
01/26/09, 10:22 AM
Just bring back OOD and we'll be happy.
Won't happen. Stop trying.

trash zoo
01/26/09, 12:48 PM
Opposite of December is monotonous and boring
this band improves itself with every album, as I like to say

Brett3
01/26/09, 01:31 PM
Amazing album. My favorite Poison The Well album.

miarnold
01/26/09, 03:10 PM
Opposite of December is monotonous and boring
this band improves itself with every album, as I like to say
comments like these don’t surprise me. they come from children who could barely talk when PTW’s OOD was released. and don’t feed me some bullshit argument explaining how some beatles or pink floyd album means as much to kids today as it did 30 or 40 years ago. In 1999, underground metal and hardcore was just as much of a lifestyle as a genre of music. and i can identify more with that genre of music than music that predates it. minor threat is one of my favorite bands; however, not living the moment, side by side with the band leaves me with some disconnection. I was 16 when the opposite of december was released. That album is probably the most quintessential metalcore album ever recorded. put aside your ipod and kick ‘nerdy’ on a beautiful component stereo system. i think youre opinion will change.

Klatzke
01/26/09, 03:38 PM
comments like these don’t surprise me. they come from children who could barely talk when PTW’s OOD was released. and don’t feed me some bullshit argument explaining how some beatles or pink floyd album means as much to kids today as it did 30 or 40 years ago. In 1999, underground metal and hardcore was just as much of a lifestyle as a genre of music. and i can identify more with that genre of music than music that predates it. minor threat is one of my favorite bands; however, not living the moment, side by side with the band leaves me with some disconnection. I was 16 when the opposite of december was released. That album is probably the most quintessential metalcore album ever recorded. put aside your ipod and kick ‘nerdy’ on a beautiful component stereo system. i think youre opinion will change.
Doesn't make this album any less. As well, it kinda adds to the idea that you'd "hate to see them change" and that that's why you'd dislike this album.

YouSmellExcited
01/26/09, 03:41 PM
bring back YCBY & TFTR Poison The Well

Greg.Kushlan
01/26/09, 04:16 PM
I think this is probably my second favorite album From them after YCBY, I like the B-sides they've been releasing lately too.

a morning view
01/26/09, 05:54 PM
YCBY is FAR superior to this album. You need to go back and listen to that record again, because it just might be PTW's best.

Oh, and there's no denying the greatness of OOD. It really is the quintessential metalcore album. All the shitty metalcore bands of today wouldn't exist if PTW hadn't released that album.

Klatzke
01/26/09, 06:37 PM
YCBY is FAR superior to this album. You need to go back and listen to that record again, because it just might be PTW's best.

Oh, and there's no denying the greatness of OOD. It really is the quintessential metalcore album. All the shitty metalcore bands of today wouldn't exist if PTW hadn't released that album.
Heard it quite a few times. I own it. Versions kicks it's ass.

Burning Star IV
01/26/09, 08:42 PM
Everyone just needs to stop bitching about how they don't sound like they used to. Just appreciate the music this bands makes.

That is all.

shoop
01/26/09, 09:03 PM
Anyone else forget about the DVD they're releasing in the future? PTW if anyone, deserves to be able to share their live show on CD/DVD more than all these shit pop bands these days. It'll sell quite well im sure (or at least i hope), and why.. well because they give off one of the most distinct vibes ever... very overpowering. I truly wish they would record/sell each and every single show they ever play/played. I'm confident that i'd buy them until my $ ran out. I really wish they'll figure something out marketing wise because this could very well work for them.. anyone who's seen them live knows what im talking about. And no it wouldnt bore fans into being content with a bootleg over catching them live again. Anyone disagree? This band fucking rules... and while i dont dig the indie-ish shit all too much, i dont see them letting me fully down ever.

trash zoo
01/26/09, 09:28 PM
comments like these don’t surprise me. they come from children who could barely talk when PTW’s OOD was released. and don’t feed me some bullshit argument explaining how some beatles or pink floyd album means as much to kids today as it did 30 or 40 years ago. In 1999, underground metal and hardcore was just as much of a lifestyle as a genre of music. and i can identify more with that genre of music than music that predates it. minor threat is one of my favorite bands; however, not living the moment, side by side with the band leaves me with some disconnection. I was 16 when the opposite of december was released. That album is probably the most quintessential metalcore album ever recorded. put aside your ipod and kick ‘nerdy’ on a beautiful component stereo system. i think youre opinion will change.
I don't have an ipod, the other albums are better but I like Nerdy at least, I could talk pretty well when I was 9, I think several way-better metalcore-ish albums came out in 1999 than OoD, and hey I like Minor Threat too! We share some common taste! We can be best friends now.

EndSerenading
01/27/09, 04:58 AM
Opposite of December is monotonous and boring
this band improves itself with every album, as I like to say
sure by today's standards but not when it came out in 1999 compared to other albums out there.

I can definitely understand other people liking later releases later though, but having heard OOD first, Ive never enjoyed any of their other stuff as much because that album just floored me in 1999, along with hopesfall's "frailty of words," codeseven's "division of labor," thursday's "waiting" and dillinger's "calculating infinity" all released the same year. I remember the 'scene' just blowing up over the next few years - had no idea it would get as big as it is today back then haha.

But Versions is the one album I havent really checked out so Im going to give it a shot.

Klatzke
01/27/09, 05:40 AM
Anyone else forget about the DVD they're releasing in the future? PTW if anyone, deserves to be able to share their live show on CD/DVD more than all these shit pop bands these days. It'll sell quite well im sure (or at least i hope), and why.. well because they give off one of the most distinct vibes ever... very overpowering. I truly wish they would record/sell each and every single show they ever play/played. I'm confident that i'd buy them until my $ ran out. I really wish they'll figure something out marketing wise because this could very well work for them.. anyone who's seen them live knows what im talking about. And no it wouldnt bore fans into being content with a bootleg over catching them live again. Anyone disagree? This band fucking rules... and while i dont dig the indie-ish shit all too much, i dont see them letting me fully down ever.
Indie-ish shit? What album are you listening to?

Dre Okorley
01/27/09, 05:41 AM
sure by today's standards but not when it came out in 1999 compared to other albums out there.

I can definitely understand other people liking later releases later though, but having heard OOD first, Ive never enjoyed any of their other stuff as much because that album just floored me in 1999, along with hopesfall's "frailty of words," codeseven's "division of labor," thursday's "waiting" and dillinger's "calculating infinity" all released the same year. I remember the 'scene' just blowing up over the next few years - had no idea it would get as big as it is today back then haha.


Bingo. I come from the 2000 hardcore kid era, it is, and always will be a classic to me and those of us who had good times with PTW in that time. Fun shit.

But Versions is the one album I havent really checked out so Im going to give it a shot

Yeah. I was mainly just busting balls and being nostalgic. Maybe I'll give it a shot...

Circa1628
01/30/09, 01:10 PM
great review, my favorite songs are "Breathing's For The Birds" and "The Notches That Create Your Headboard"

shoop
01/31/09, 10:47 PM
Indie-ish shit? What album are you listening to?
Obviously i'd be talking about Versions. Which other one of their albums has a good amount of indie-ish prog in it?

Klatzke
02/01/09, 06:44 AM
Obviously i'd be talking about Versions. Which other one of their albums has a good amount of indie-ish prog in it?
Well none of them have any kind of "indie" in them, so...

shoop
02/02/09, 01:11 AM
Well none of them have any kind of "indie" in them, so...
What crack are you smoking.

Klatzke
02/02/09, 04:57 AM
What crack are you smoking.
Lol I just find it funny that as soon as something has any kind of a different sound it's dubbed "indie."

shoop
02/04/09, 04:06 PM
Lol I just find it funny that as soon as something has any kind of a different sound it's dubbed "indie."
I said "indie-ish prog"... so you're saying experimental has no off-branches? hoe plz.