PDA

View Full Version : Alesana - On Frail Wings Of Vanity And Wax


npmshah
01/20/09, 06:16 PM
Alesana - On Frail Wings of Vanity and Wax
Record Label: Fearless Records
Release Date: March 20, 2007

Alesana is no doubt one of the scene’s love-hate relationship bands. Even though they draw criticism for being highly generic, they also draw praise for being one of the best cookie-cutter bands in the post-hardcore scene. Both of these comments on the band follow through on their debut On Frail Wings of Vanity and Wax. Though Alesana has since recorded another, much more mediocre album, this disc shows plenty of potential for the band. From slow piano ballads that showcase vulnerability and beauty to the furious, fast-paced rockers that take a page from death metal, this album is as diverse as it is promising.

The disc opens with “Icarus,” a one minute track that showcases the epitome of Alesana’s vocals: its lyrics are mainly spoken over a backdrop of a scream/sing harmonization. The band then takes no time to breathe as they follow up this short, and succinct summary of their band with “Ambrosia,” the album’s first single. This song contains a great, sing-along chorus, amazing screams, and even mixes it up with an interesting guitar line. “Pathetic, Ordinary” is a much catchier pop track that showcases clean vocals above all. The contrast between this and the next track, “Alchemy Sounded Good at the Time,” is amazing. “Alchemy” is one of the album's heavier tracks and introduces a death metal-like growl and a sort of discord that makes the listener queasy and impressed at the same time.

“Daggers Speak Louder than Words” is very generic in the sense of the album as a whole, while “Last Three Letters” opens with some soft singing and a mellow guitar line before launching into a hardened scream. The song transitions between heavy and soft for most of the track, making it a definite highlight of the album. “Apology” is another standout. Though the transition screams from the soft intro to the faster verses is cringe-worthy, everything else in between is amazing. The next three songs, “Tilting The Hourglass,” “This Conversation Is Over,” and “Congratulations I Hate You” have amazing parts interspersed all over the three tracks (the chorus of “Tilting,” and the intros and choruses to “Conversation” and “Congratulations”), but overall are very generic. “Third Temptation of Paris” and “Siren’s Soliloquy” are nothing special, but album closer “Nero’s Decay” features some impressive scream/sing harmony.

If you are lucky enough to have the bonus track to this album, you are probably wondering why “Early Mourning" didn’t make the album proper. This piano ballad is probably the best thing I have ever heard from Alesana, and the lyrics bring tears to the listener’s eyes as the band recounts an experience involving a lost love. The chorus contains amazing harmonies and the highlight of this song is the beautiful screaming that takes place over the crooning of the song’s finale, the only appearance the harsh vocals make during the song’s nearly four-minute duration. Following that is “Apology (Acoustic)”, which is basically a piano-only version of the original song. The screaming is toned-down, and that makes this track better than the original.

This release was a strong debut for Alesana, and only time will tell if they can bounce back from their recent sophomore slump.

Blessthefall, The Devil Wears Prada, underOATH, screamo with very poppy tendencies, Greek Mythology

http://myspace.com/alesana

http://alesanarock.com (http://alesanarock.com/)

Klatzke
01/31/09, 10:01 AM
You need another " after "Early Mourning for one thing... and idk what's with that last sentence.

As for the review itself.. Good job. I don't exactly agree (I think this album is pretty terrible, and they're far from "the best band in the post-hardcore scene") but you did good at getting your point across.

circatbs
01/31/09, 07:38 PM
Awesome review Neeps, I really really like this band/album. I'm a loser haha.

fadedmemories
01/31/09, 11:30 PM
lolololol

denissuxx
02/01/09, 04:25 AM
the lyrics bring tears to the listener’s eyes as the band recounts an experience involving a lost love

I lol'd.

Generally good review, my only advice would be to do less of a track by track. Also, your 'conclusion' is a bit too short for my liking.

SomedayTheFire
02/01/09, 05:06 AM
I used to live off this album when I was like 15 haha
Still like Ambrosia, but I've grown out of Alesana a bit.
Good review Neeps :-)

Kbm600
02/01/09, 07:25 AM
Apology is still my jam.

Everything else, I could care less.

npmshah
02/01/09, 11:19 AM
Thanks Nicky, Adam, and Jay...
i discovered this band during the summer and it took time to grow on me...
and ive started to grow out of them slightly...
but i still find this album (and a few parts of the newer one) a bit of a guilty pleasure

newfoundmichael
02/01/09, 05:56 PM
Absolutely in no way is this one of the best "cookie-cutter bands" in post-hardcore...these guys blow so hard.

EDIT: That sounded dickhead-ish. The review wasn't too bad though man, I just think this shit gets reviewed enough. haha

FaceLixeMurder
02/01/09, 09:11 PM
they are one of my guilty pleasures but by no means a good band

hockeyguitar99
02/03/09, 02:12 PM
It was well written, but really?

They are nowhere near being the best band in any category.

Handraa
02/03/09, 07:04 PM
Didn't quite agree with the whole The Devil Wears Prada thing in the RIYL, and I don't really think they're the best band in the post hardcore genre.
But other than that, well written.

tjflairr
02/27/09, 12:28 PM
How can you seriously put the vocal rating that high. Absolutely unacceptable.

circatbs
02/27/09, 02:01 PM
How can you seriously put the vocal rating that high. Absolutely unacceptable.
The clean vocals outweigh the screams.

Handraa
02/27/09, 02:12 PM
The clean vocals outweigh the screams.
They both suck.

circatbs
02/27/09, 02:14 PM
They both suck.
I think the clean vocals are good, besides the fact they are a bit nasally. The screams, however, are horrible. They're done completely the wrong way and don't even sound to good.

Broclee
02/27/09, 10:35 PM
Maybe I'm an idiot, but I thought The Third Temptation of Paris was one of the only decent tracks on here...maybe it's just me, but I love the historical context, and the interweaving vocals, and I find the clean vocals more bearable on that track.

Klatzke
02/28/09, 09:22 AM
Maybe I'm an idiot, but I thought The Third Temptation of Paris was one of the only decent tracks on here...maybe it's just me, but I love the historical context, and the interweaving vocals, and I find the clean vocals more bearable on that track.
Definitely the best track from the album.

Klatzke
02/28/09, 09:27 AM
Oh, and nothing can scar you more than hearing this band live.

npmshah
04/13/09, 12:53 PM
Oh, and nothing can scar you more than hearing this band live.
really? i checked vids of this band at bamboozle and they seemed pretty good :shrug:

Klatzke
04/13/09, 01:05 PM
Well do you enjoy being spat on? Or the sound of a grown man barking?

npmshah
04/13/09, 01:20 PM
Well do you enjoy being spat on? Or the sound of a grown man barking?
dont alot of bands spit on people on the crowd? i got spit on by Justin from The Morning Of when he released water he had just drank into everyone in the front...
i dont think i would particularly enjoy the sound of a grown man barking, they cant scream live well?

Klatzke
04/13/09, 01:42 PM
dont alot of bands spit on people on the crowd? i got spit on by Justin from The Morning Of when he released water he had just drank into everyone in the front...
i dont think i would particularly enjoy the sound of a grown man barking, they cant scream live well?
Saying they "don't do it well" is giving them too much credit. And not like spitting water just straight up spitting

npmshah
04/13/09, 02:25 PM
Saying they "don't do it well" is giving them too much credit. And not like spitting water just straight up spitting
ew... i just lost my strong desire to see them live...
if they happen to be opening for a band i like/play a festival in a time slot when no other decent acts are on ill check em out, but other than that not so much...

Klatzke
04/13/09, 02:28 PM
ew... i just lost my strong desire to see them live...
if they happen to be opening for a band i like/play a festival in a time slot when no other decent acts are on ill check em out, but other than that not so much...
I saw five minutes of their set at warped and left after one song

npmshah
04/13/09, 02:30 PM
I saw five minutes of their set at warped and left after one song
haha oh wow... i'm guessing they opened with "This Conversation is Over" though?

Klatzke
04/13/09, 03:50 PM
haha oh wow... i'm guessing they opened with "This Conversation is Over" though?
I don't even know. I heard a whine, girly screaming, and barking.

Dystroxia
01/23/10, 10:13 PM
Didn't quite agree with the whole The Devil Wears Prada thing in the RIYL, and I don't really think they're the best band in the post hardcore genre.
But other than that, well written.
I agree, TDWP is way better, but in the end both bands are good.