Minor threat or Black flag?

[EatItSucka]

Black flag.

[Circa1628]

why don't you just do this in the which band is better/worse thread(s)

They are both solid though, I have listened to more Minor Threat, so I guess I would choose them.

Waits for the lock

[EatItSucka]

why don't you just do this in the which band is better/worse thread(s)

They are both solid though, I have listened to more Minor Threat, so I guess I would choose them.

Waits for the lock
IDK, I think this deserves its own thread.

You can go on forever about these 2 bands.

[Anderson]

I'd go with Minor Threat. I don't know a lot of Black Flag tbh but I love Minor Threat.

[Circa1628]

Out Of Step With The World is a great song

[xJesusFreakx]

Minor Threat.

Straightedge ftw.

[EatItSucka]

Out Of Step With The World is a great song
For sure. I mean, I respect Minor threat and all they have done for music, but their views just aren't the same as mine.

Black flags song spray paint the walls is my favorite from them.

[JimGray]

Minor Threat.

I don't really have a reason, or anything against Black Flag, although Henry Rollins is kind of a tool, but it's just preference I suppose.

[shit stroll]

well, my war is one of my favorite albums, so i'd have to go with black flag.

[Dre Okorley]

Black flag hands down. Are you kidding?

"WE ARE BORN WITH A CHANCE! RISE ABOVE! WE'RE GONNA RISE ABOVE! NOW IM GONNA HAVE MY CHAAANCE". Gold.

[EatItSucka]

Black flag hands down. Are you kidding?

"WE ARE BORN WITH A CHANCE! RISE ABOVE! WE'RE GONNA RISE ABOVE! NOW IM GONNA HAVE MY CHAAANCE". Gold.
"IT FEELS GOOD TO SAY WHAT I WANT, IT FEELS GOOD TO KNOCK THINGS DOWN! IT FEELS GOOD TO SEE THE DISGUST IN THEIR EYES, IT FEELS GOOD IM GONNA GO WILD!"

[kieren legacy]

both are sick. you cant com pare them though because alot of the older black flag is weirder. im gunna say black flag tough because i can

[JimGray]

both are sick. you cant com pare them though because alot of the older black flag is weirder. im gunna say black flag tough because i can

r u spel?

[Circa1628]

com pare? Really?:-|

[Colorblind!]

com pare? Really?:-|

because he can.

[EatItSucka]

r u spel?
Lol, saw that coming.

[PRoman]

black flag!

does anyone like Amebix?

[EatItSucka]

black flag!

does anyone like Amebix?
I'm a fan.

[JimGray]

Never heard.

Link?

[Hey Kevin]

Minor Threat
Black Flag didn't have their shit down
neither of those bands are the best 80s hardcore band though

"Henry Rollins isn't gay, he just does things like poetry and working out."

[Dre Okorley]

Black Flag didn't have their shit down


Whatever that means...

[EatItSucka]

Never heard.

Link?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fzBIJcEPzGg
Kind of like an earlier version of doom.

[Hey Kevin]

Whatever that means...


listen to how many times the dudes fuck up their parts on Damaged
and other than that record their stuff is ok. Family Man is a great spoken word.

[kieren legacy]

r u spel?
what

[TheOtherAndrew]

Black Flag, but barely. Minor Threat is amazing for a band whose entire career can fit on one CD.

[Circa1628]

Black Flag, but barely. Minor Threat is amazing for a band whose entire career can fit on one CD.

well put

[Circa1628]

by the way, Fugazi is better than both bands

[PRoman]

lol fugazi is good but in noway did they do what black flag did for punk

[Jumpoff]

Not a fan of either band. Go figure. Don't hate them just don't find them that amazing at all

[Circa1628]

lol fugazi is good but in noway did they do what black flag did for punk

what bands did for punk is not the question here, it's who is better

[PRoman]

touche but then iguess its all matter of opinion

[TheOtherAndrew]

by the way, Fugazi is better than both bands
Comparing Fugazi to Black Flag is like comparing Yo La Tengo to Dashboard Confessional.

[Circa1628]

touche but then iguess its all matter of opinion

of course of course. I personally like Fugazi more

[Circa1628]

Comparing Fugazi to Black Flag is like comparing Yo La Tengo to Dashboard Confessional.

it's relevant, because of Ian MacKaye

[Jumpoff]

it's relevant, because of Ian MacKaye

Like how comparing racetraitor to fall out boy is relevant?

[Regards]

I enjoy Minor Threat more, although I haven't honestly listened to much Black Flag

[Circa1628]

Like how comparing racetraitor to fall out boy is relevant?

don't be stupid. I think Fugazi is better than Black Flag, it doesn't matter if the genre is different or not.

I like Mewithoutyou a lot more than Bring Me The Horizon, or does that not count because they are in a different genre?

[EatItSucka]

what bands did for punk is not the question here, it's who is better
If I had to say what band did the most for punk, Id pick Iggy pop. For HXC, id have to say Bad Brains.

[Circa1628]

Bad Brains are so sick

[EatItSucka]

Bad Brains are so sick
Even if you don't like them, you got to respect them.

[Circa1628]

Even if you don't like them, you got to respect them.

how can you not respect doing flips on stage

[kieren legacy]

by the way, Fugazi is better than both bands

fugazi is sooo sick. my dad used to jam with them.

[EatItSucka]

how can you not respect doing flips on stage
Ha ha. I wish I could have seen them back in the day. They had so much energy.

[Circa1628]

fugazi is sooo sick. my dad used to jam with them.

that is sweet

Ha ha. I wish I could have seen them back in the day. They had so much energy.


same

[kieren legacy]

[quote=Circa1628;33428202]that is sweet




yeah and the drummer acctually filled in for a while.

[kieren legacy]

[quote=Hey Kevin;33423692]Minor Threat
Black Flag didn't have their shit down

minor threat didnt either
no 80's hard core did except the dead kennedys who could acctualy play. not that i dont like black flag or minor threat.

[DilesMavis]

I like them both a lot. I love Minor Threat, big fan of Ian... Black Flags Wound Up is one of my favorite songs though.

[kieren legacy]

Black Flag, but barely. Minor Threat is amazing for a band whose entire career can fit on one CD.
minor threat would definatly be better if they wrote more songs

[NEP633]

minor threat. I hate how most kids in hardcore will talk so much shit if black flag isnt your favorite band.

[turncoat93]

Minor Threat!!

[Dre Okorley]

minor threat. I hate how most kids in hardcore will talk so much shit if black flag isnt your favorite band.

:talkingshit:

[SanePsychotic]

Hard to say, but I like Black Flag a tad bit more because there's just more material to get into. Both are awesome bands though.

[EatItSucka]

Minor Threat!!
...You tell me that I make know difference
At least I'm fucking trying!
What the fuck have you done?

Its in my eyes its in my eyes
Its in my eyes its in my eyes
Its in my eyes its in my eyes
Its in my eyes its in my eyes
And it doesn't look that way to me
IN MY EYES
And it doesn't look that way to me.
IN MY EYES

Thanks a lot friends...

[NEP633]

...You tell me that I make know difference
At least I'm fucking trying!
What the fuck have you done?

Its in my eyes its in my eyes
Its in my eyes its in my eyes
Its in my eyes its in my eyes
Its in my eyes its in my eyes
And it doesn't look that way to me
IN MY EYES
And it doesn't look that way to me.
IN MY EYES

Thanks a lot friends...

k.

[Hey Kevin]

[quote=Hey Kevin;33423692]Minor Threat
Black Flag didn't have their shit down

minor threat didnt either
no 80's hard core did except the dead kennedys who could acctualy play. not that i dont like black flag or minor threat.


Bad Brains had their shit down

[Hey Kevin]

best 80s hardcore band
Void

[jster2000]

that is sweet




same

seeing bad brains would be insane
anyway
i am gonna have to go with MT

[kieren legacy]

[quote=kieren legacy;33854882]


Bad Brains had their shit down
true.

[kieren legacy]

...You tell me that I make know difference
At least I'm fucking trying!
What the fuck have you done?

Its in my eyes its in my eyes
Its in my eyes its in my eyes
Its in my eyes its in my eyes
Its in my eyes its in my eyes
And it doesn't look that way to me
IN MY EYES
And it doesn't look that way to me.
IN MY EYES

Thanks a lot friends...
its "no difference" not "know difference"

[raychull]

Minor Threat.

[EatItSucka]

its "no difference" not "know difference"
I dont always write correctly
I always fuck up when I speak
I dont always write correctly
My communication skills are very weak

[kieren legacy]

man your poetry is great. i slurr my speech alot. and sometimes i choke on my saliva

[JF ANTI-FLAG]

I Love Both, But I Listen To More Minor Threat As I Agree With Most Of Their Anti Racist Views

[kieren legacy]

yeah minor threat wrote more political songs were as black flag was more about depresion and drinking.