Thrice vs Brand New ALBUMS

[x1onexwo1fx]

I just had to do it.

[Burn That Shit]

This will be interesting.

[phoenixinflames]

Alchemy Index followed closely by Devil and God, then Vheissu for me.

[cason eat world]

Vheissu. It shouldn't even be a choice.

[x1onexwo1fx]

Vheissu. It shouldn't even be a choice.

Say that again? I couldn't understand you.

[RiCCioLi]

TDAGARIM for sure.

[Oddpac87]

TDAGARIM for sure.
This.

[Yagami]

The Illusion of Safety > Vheissu = The Alchemy Index > Brand New albums

[phil19]

tough call. in the end i went with the album i probably listen to the most - deja entendu

[Bobcat46308]

TDAGARIM for sure.

yeah man

[AussieBoy]

artist in ambulance!

[cason eat world]

Say that again? I couldn't understand you.

Haha my bad. I meant that this shouldn't be a choice. Vheissu easily takes it by a mile.

[billyboatkid]

You should have done three Thrice albums with the three BN albums.

False start. Ten yard penalty.

[x1onexwo1fx]

You should have done three Thrice albums with the three BN albums.

Which three? It's kind of hard considering how some people liked Thrice's progression as a band and some people didn't. I just put them all in there to make it a bit easier on me. And besides, I think it's more interesting this way.

[batmannj]

Vheissu.

I am honestly shocked that Deja is not running away from this poll on here.

[Troggy]

The Illusion of Safety > Vheissu = The Alchemy Index > Brand New albums

I can get along with this. I chose Illusion of Safety.

[WhoSaidThat?]

De

[WhoSaidThat?]

They're all great, though.

[Clark]

Deja Entendu, will, of course, win, but it should be The Devil and God...

[markythrills]

Illusion Of Safety re-defined good music for me.

[Bloodsucker II]

Vheissu.

I am honestly shocked that Deja is not running away from this poll on here.

THIS.

[liveloud4life]

I really don't know how Illusion of Safety has more votes than Artist.

[White Noise]

Vheissu, by far.

[donwagenblast]

1. The Devil and God are Raging Inside of Me
2. Deja Entendu
3. The Alchemy Index

[CloseToShore]

This one was so unfair. Couldn't choose between Vhessiu, Alchemy Index, and TDAGARIM. Went with my fav. band and Alchemy.

[I am Mick]

artist.

I know TDAGARIM will win, even though it's mostly garbage. Whatever.

[wheresadalia]

i just had to go with the one i probably listen to the most- deja entendu

[shwaz499]

Deja.

[Neo Cassady]

Artist

[SeanEBoy2686]

Devil & God... hands down. Followed by Deja, YFW, and The Artist In the Ambulance.

[FUCKDIRTYWIPES]

Deja will clearly win this.

[Burn That Shit]

Didn't know people held Deja to such a high standard, it's definitely not a top 10 album or anything haha.

[AlternaPrincess]

TDAGARIM for sure.

Agreed.

[a morning view]

The Devil and God Are Raging Inside Me

[Everiggs]

Vheissu for sure.

[brokenhats]

artist in the ambulance is perfect beginning to end but i love all these albums

[glassjaw777]

Alchemy Index followed closely by Devil and God, then Vheissu for me.

amen

[Sventhegreat]

Deja ftw

[jbaseball44]

Easily TDAG

[Yellowcard2006]

I chose Deja, I haven't listened to a whole Thrice album.

[zubinmoosa]

Vheissu. It shouldn't even be a choice.
80% of these albums are top notch. There should definitely be a choice. I don't know what you're smoking. I actually couldn't pick.

[TotalCollapse]

Deja for sure.

[more heart]

It's The Artist in the Ambulance for me.

[Hagysaurus Rex]

TDAGARIM for sure.


You've been This'd

[speakhandsforme]

TDAGARIM > The Artist in the Ambulance > Vheissu > Alchemy Index > Deja > the rest

[theguy77]

devil and god > deja > alchemy index > vheissu >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> all else

[Keagan Ilvonen]

Voted The Devil and God, but it was close.

[Kevward]

VHEISSU. That album is magical. It started Thrice's transformation into different styles. I'll listen to it forever.

But don't get me wrong, I still love Brand New. Devil & God and Deja are some of my all time favorites.

[Nick Le]

Alchemy Index for me.

[Pat Brown]

Tough. It was between the artist in the ambulance and the illusion of safety for me. I went with the latter.

[Ryzenfall]

It's hard to decide between Thrice albums. I went with Vheissu.

[sarahgrc]

VHEISSU. That album is magical. It started Thrice's transformation into different styles. I'll listen to it forever.

But don't get me wrong, I still love Brand New. Devil & God and Deja are some of my all time favorites.
Magical is not a genre.
Experimental is.
:)

[mxpxjf]

Artist in the Ambulance was my first and still favorite Thrice record. Never been a fan of Brand New...

[yufli]

Tough choice for about half a second between Deja Entendu and Vheissu. But I went with Deja Entendu because it's amazing in new ways every time I listen to it.

[xsinkshipsx]

devil and God was a beautifully depressing album....

[fishingthe_sky]

Shit, this was a really hard choice. All of these albums are in the higher echelons of my favorite music.

Vheissu>Deja>Artist=YFW>TDAG=Alchemy>Illusion>Identity.

[xJesusFreakx]

Thrice is my favorite band, but TDAGARIM is a better overall album than anything they've done.

TDAGARIM > The Alchemy Index > The Illusion of Safety = Vheissu > TAITA = Deja Entendu > Your Favorite Weapon > Identity Crisis

[smelltheglove]

"illusion of safety", followed by "deja entendu".

[AussieBoy]

boo the brand new love

[princesschad]

As much as I love everything on this list, especially Vheissu, nothing will ever beat Devil and God.

[VIVALAMATT]

I don't know, it should've been "all of thrice's albums" vs "all of brand new's albums".

I think that Thrice has put out way more quality albums (in my opinion) than Brand New, who really only has 2 that I like. The thing that'll be deceptive here is that many people are torn over what Thrice album they think is best. Nevertheless, I think you'll find that Thrice gets more votes than Brand New does overall.

[VIVALAMATT]

And I went with the Alchemy Indexes, by the way. All 4 were amazing.

[circatbs]

Deja, as it's my favorite BN album and I could never get into Thrice.

[fadedmemories]

Vheissu
Artist
Deja

[x1onexwo1fx]

I don't know, it should've been "all of thrice's albums" vs "all of brand new's albums".

I think that Thrice has put out way more quality albums (in my opinion) than Brand New, who really only has 2 that I like. The thing that'll be deceptive here is that many people are torn over what Thrice album they think is best. Nevertheless, I think you'll find that Thrice gets more votes than Brand New does overall.

Currently:
all the votes for Thrice - 183
votes for JUST Deja Entendu - 175

I do agree that Thrice have a larger quantity of goods, and I myself honestly can't decide which Thrice album I like the best, but I personally think nothing can beat TDAGARIM.

[theguy77]

Shit, this was a really hard choice. All of these albums are in the higher echelons of my favorite music.

Vheissu>Deja>Artist=YFW>TDAG=Alchemy>Illusion>Identity.

hahahahahaha what the fuck

[WasteofPaint31]

Vheissu is easily the best

[jbaseball44]

hahahahahaha what the fuck
my thoughts exactly

[fishingthe_sky]

hahahahahaha what the fuck
Not trying to argue that either is necessarily "better" than TDAG, because I think that TDAG is, for all intents and purposes, a better cd. I just happen to prefer both Artist and YFW over TDAG. I listen to both way more than TDAG, and I have a certain nostalgic attachment to both.

[George-Michael]

Had to be honest and pick Deja, even though I really wanted to vote for Illusion of Safety. Good Poll.