Favorite My Chemical Romance Album?

[Piss]

mines The Black Parade

[VIVALAMATT]

The Black Parade is an amazing album, but my personal favorite is Three Cheers.

[Brett3]

I love The Black Parade, but my favorite is Three Cheers For Sweet Revenge.

[darkmartheight]

I think that they get better with each album. I chose The Black Parade.

[phil19]

3 cheers

[yourprivateeye]

"I Brought You My Bullets..." was my soundtrack for 02-03. still a top 20 all-time favorite cd.

[Poe-tryGirl]

"Three Cheers" But all their albums are amazing.

[WhoSaidThat?]

Black Parade. A total no-brainer for me.

[etheritcher]

black parade.
3 cheers is a close second though

[LongDistanceDrunk]

I voted they suck. I like a few of their songs but not any entire albums. Imo one of their worst songs is the goddamn awful Desolation Row cover from Watchmen.

[oddwithoutend]

the black parade

[EmaleeMae]

I voted they suck. I like a few of their songs but not any entire albums. Imo one of their worst songs is the goddamn awful Desolation Row cover from Watchmen.
This.
It was only done well by Bob Dylan.

[PetitChevalier]

The Black Parade is maybe a better album but I prefer Three Cheers XD

[notoaststereo]

three cheers. i still play it every once in a while.

[Helpless]

I loved the overall feel of three cheers so much
Was never really a fan of Black Parade...

[survivngtheera]

3 cheers is the best! more emotion and punk sound to it that really makes them them

[FailedRepublic]

IBYMB/YBMEYL is just purely epic. Wish you had put Life on The Murder Scene and The Black Parade is Dead! because MCR is fucking amazing live

[Undue Noise]

Three Cheers > Bullets > Black Parade imo

[batmannj]

I liked The Black Parade

[LamarVannoy]

I Brought You My Bullets... is definately my all time favourite. Three Cheers is a close second.

[IceAge/HeatWave]

the black parade was fantastic, and very important to me at one point. haven't touched it in 2 years though

[AussieBoy]

3 cheers, parade close 2nd.. 1st album rubbish

[FailedRepublic]

*gasp* Your rubbish! *cry*

[TheZeroKid]

It's usually a power struggle between Three Cheers For Sweet Revenge and The Black Parade for me, but I chose The Black Parade in the end because A) it has 95 plays on my iTunes in it's ENTIRETY since it's release in 2006, and B) I'm a sucker for concept albums.

[Co and Ca]

I Brought You My Bullets, You Brought Me Your Love.

Oh, to be 15 again. I will always have a soft spot for that album. Eventhough I don't listen to it or MCR at all anymore haha. Oh well.

[PopPunkKid]

The Black Parade has the best songs and melodies, hands down. Three Cheers and Bullets may have been "unique", but just because they're unique doesn't always equal the better album (case in point: Panic, Pretty.Odd. >>> Fever, imo).

[FailedRepublic]

It's usually a power struggle between Three Cheers For Sweet Revenge and The Black Parade for me, but I chose The Black Parade in the end because A) it has 95 plays on my iTunes in it's ENTIRETY since it's release in 2006, and B) I'm a sucker for concept albums.

They've all been concept albums.

Bullets: Vampire Hunters (or something) they go and do they're shiz, then the girl dies (Demolition Lovers)
Three Cheers: Continuation of Bullets, the guy trying to save the girl from hell by killing some massive amount of people (Hang 'Em High)
Black Parade: Former Soldier(Nazi?) dies and travels through death making up for what he's done


This might not be completely correct, but this is what I've gathered from them.

The Black Parade has the best songs and melodies, hands down. Three Cheers and Bullets may have been "unique", but just because they're unique doesn't always equal the better album (case in point: Panic, Pretty.Odd. >>> Fever, imo).

You're saying Pretty Odd is better than Fever?!

Tsk tsk tsk

[TheZeroKid]

They've all been concept albums.

Bullets: Vampire Hunters (or something) they go and do they're shiz, then the girl dies (Demolition Lovers)
Three Cheers: Continuation of Bullets, the guy trying to save the girl from hell by killing some massive amount of people (Hang 'Em High)
Black Parade: Former Soldier(Nazi?) dies and travels through death making up for what he's done


This might not be completely correct, but this is what I've gathered from them.

From what I've heard:

Bullets and Three Cheers started out as concept albums involving what you described but the stories were pretty much abandoned. There's still elements of them in certain songs, but the whole unifying concept was scrapped for the most part.

As far as The Black Parade goes, it's about someone who isn't liked by many people dying of cancer and going through the physical, mental, and emotional feelings of death while looking back on his life and who he's loved. In the end, we're led to believe he's accepted death, but one can take the interpretation of the video for Famous Last Words, in which the band, as death personified as the black parade, and their parade float is burning, to mean that The Patient has decided after looking back at his life that he's "not afraid to keep on living", even if it means he'll live alone. He fights the disease and judging from the burning parade imagery in the video, he wins.

...pretty much.

[FailedRepublic]

Ahh yeah I forgot he was called the patient. Good explanation :)

[Alex DiVincenzo]

Bullets > Black Parade > Three Cheers, but they're all pretty good

[Poll]

Bullets, by quite a distance.

[MyNameIsRoss]

I said 'they suck', I've always said that. Plus they've always looked kind of stupid, and I judge books by the cover.

[FailedRepublic]

At least you admit it xD

[lucky#88]

all their albums are kinda hit or miss for me...none are really great all the way through but the black parade is my favorite...for some reason i liked the whole marching band concept it worked for them

[Clark]

You're saying Pretty Odd is better than Fever?!

Tsk tsk tsk
Well, it is. Their first album was really catchy (like herpes), but no more. Pretty. Odd. was actually a solid album.

[FailedRepublic]

Except Fever doesn't leave giant abcesses >;]

[Signatoria]

very difficult to chose, but probably Three Cheers went together very well, wheras Black Parade didn't wuite make it.
THEY BOTH ROCK THOUGH.
Bullets was a bit too...idk unpolished.
I can't wait for the new album~!

[billyboatkid]

I used to like this band a lot.

I was way into Three Cheers. But now I could really care less.

Voted for Three Cheers.

[IceAge/HeatWave]

i'm not sure if i still like this band, but i loved black parade. i just haven't touched it in 2 years.

[just.Starla.]

I Brought You My Bullets followed by Three Cheers.

[Yellowcard2006]

I choose Black Parade.

[ghsNICK!]

Black Parade.

[DriftingNAndOut]

"Early sunsets over monroeville" from Bullets is an awesome song. I like how hes all breathing heavy and his voice is cracking at the end. I had a tough time gettin into the rest of that album though. Voted for Revenge.

[OnaedInSpace]

3 cheers.

[jgord88]

Bullets was by far my favorite by them. I don't even touch the other stuff they have done cause that album is just so good. Not kidding.

[emo-kidd.x]

i love the old original album :] i brought you my bullets you brought me your love xx i love it it's so raw but shows just how much potential they have and you know that they are going to bloom in something so epic with more experiance. an album of hope and dreams which we now know are and can be fulfilled xox

[SuNDaYSTaR]

I believe everyone agrees their first album is far worse than everything else they've released. Went with Three Cheers only because it's when I discovered them.

[Ryzenfall]

I feel like they got hugely better with each release, but I hardly spin MCR.

[pennie]

i love the old original album :] i brought you my bullets you brought me your love xx i love it it's so raw but shows just how much potential they have and you know that they are going to bloom in something so epic with more experiance. an album of hope and dreams which we now know are and can be fulfilled xox


So much is wrong with this profile.

3 cheers,its the only decent thing they have.

[nickthehick2]

3 Cheers of course.

[itsbusinesstime]

As much I like 3 cheers, I Brought you my Bullets is such an amazing album (granted the songs are all pretty long). "Honey, This Mirror Isn't Big Enough for the Two of Us" is by far one of my favorite songs of all time.

I think half the people here are disagreeing with this bc they play a different style of music now. Bullets is just a much more raw sounding MCR, but includes some of the best work.

[The Raine]

Three Cheers.

[ATHEER]

All of them are great but three cheers is the best