PDA

View Full Version : March Mayhem Round 1: Lydia vs. Mae


Pages : [1] 2

Anton Djamoos
03/15/09, 08:31 PM
Who is your favorite band out of these two? Be sure to read the replies for other users' cases for each band.

x1onexwo1fx
03/15/09, 08:44 PM
yay for 100th post?

i don't listen to lydia...

cuzimlefthanded
03/15/09, 09:04 PM
thought lydia would blow mae out of the water...weird.

Broclee
03/15/09, 09:06 PM
thought lydia would blow mae out of the water...weird.

It's only been like 7 votes...

jusscali
03/15/09, 09:06 PM
Real tough one for me

zubinmoosa
03/15/09, 09:07 PM
I can't get into Lydia, no matter how hard I try.

Drew Beringer
03/15/09, 09:08 PM
Lydia will destroy this.

zeropunk16
03/15/09, 09:09 PM
Lydia all the way.

unnameworthy
03/15/09, 09:12 PM
After seeing two awful Mae shows and being blown away by Illuminate, I have to go with Lydia.

roju
03/15/09, 09:12 PM
lydia. i haven't been able to get into mae

Iwudstilldie4u
03/15/09, 09:13 PM
Mae has range. I vote them.

irthesteve
03/15/09, 09:16 PM
ewwwww, vote no on Lydia! Most unworthy hype band of AP history fo shizzy.

Destination Beautiful>Destination B-Sides>Everglow>Illuminate>Singularity>This December

and for the record, both of Mae's new songs have been top notch, it's comeback time!

bailmeout13
03/15/09, 09:24 PM
Lydia.

anamericangod
03/15/09, 09:24 PM
Lydia!

taylerx0
03/15/09, 09:27 PM
Lydia by faaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaar.

Keagan Ilvonen
03/15/09, 09:31 PM
Lydia, Mae can't even compare.

bluecrunchy
03/15/09, 09:33 PM
Seriously? Lydia is actually more boring than Mae. Plus, Mae has put out 2 very good albums.

HometownHero
03/15/09, 09:35 PM
I can't get into Lydia, no matter how hard I try.
How is that possible

katieissweet
03/15/09, 09:36 PM
This was the second toughest one for me. I picked Mae even though Lydia will probably win.

OveriseFan
03/15/09, 09:37 PM
Bringing Mae back to a tie.

zubinmoosa
03/15/09, 09:39 PM
How is that possible
I don't know. I've heard so many good things about them, but even Illuminate, couldn't get into it :shrug:

Imperfektion
03/15/09, 09:42 PM
Tough one, but I voted Mae.

bouttogetfancy
03/15/09, 09:45 PM
hopefully lydia pulls through on this one!

juliaisnotcool
03/15/09, 09:47 PM
Even though Illuminate was my 2008 AOTY, I had to vote for Mae for nostalgic reasons. Also, they've put out 2 albums I've loved as opposed to Lydia's one.

And I just realized I have a Lydia avatar, ha.

PunkDrums182
03/15/09, 09:48 PM
Lydia will destroy this.
Seemingly not, but I would have thought so too..

Although I enjoy mae, Lydia made a certain connection with me. Illuminate was one of my AOTY's of 08. Great cd, so beautiful.

irthesteve
03/15/09, 09:49 PM
This one is so close, Go Mae!!! Go Mae!!!

fadedmemories
03/15/09, 09:49 PM
Lydia. Illuminate>everything Mae has done

HometownHero
03/15/09, 09:49 PM
I don't know. I've heard so many good things about them, but even Illuminate, couldn't get into it :shrug:
What about his flawless voice? Lush instrumentation? Amazing live show? Emotion? Mindymmmmmmwhitemmmmm? Amazing lyrics?

fromoc2dc
03/15/09, 09:52 PM
Lydia. No question.

WhoSaidThat?
03/15/09, 09:52 PM
Lydia. They've yet to disappoint me.

zeropunk16
03/15/09, 09:54 PM
Mindymmmmmmwhitemmmmm?

I think it should be a rule that anytime you mention Mindy on this site, you use this phrasing.

Fury15
03/15/09, 09:55 PM
I can't get into Lydia, no matter how hard I try.

lydia. i haven't been able to get into mae

fight

alann
03/15/09, 09:55 PM
Mae.

dani1292
03/15/09, 09:58 PM
Lydia for sure.

Jamos4184
03/15/09, 09:58 PM
This is much closer than i thought it would be. Lydia takes it for me, but only because Mae dropped off so much with Singularity. That album was a HUGE disappointment for me.

WFUJerseyJon
03/15/09, 09:59 PM
Mae, can't get into Lydia.

Tail0130
03/15/09, 10:00 PM
This is the most surprising close vote ever.

newfoundmichael
03/15/09, 10:00 PM
ewwwww, vote no on Lydia! Most unworthy hype band of AP history fo shizzy.

Destination Beautiful>Destination B-Sides>Everglow>Illuminate>Singularity>This December

and for the record, both of Mae's new songs have been top notch, it's comeback time!

Yeah I've never gotten Lydia. I think they are overhyped on this site too.

HometownHero
03/15/09, 10:03 PM
I think it should be a rule that anytime you mention Mindy on this site, you use this phrasing.
Haha it should be a law. After these polls there should be voting for some other rules for the site. That being one of them haha

irthesteve
03/15/09, 10:03 PM
Yeah I've never gotten Lydia. I think they are overhyped on this site too.
All aboard

http://www.jefklak.com/wiki/uploads/Articles/HypeTrain.jpg

TakenByCars
03/15/09, 10:09 PM
this is a though one, but Mae is getting my vote.

ManicanParty49
03/15/09, 10:15 PM
Saw Mae live, and didn't enjoy it. Lydia gets my vote.

what_ever
03/15/09, 10:16 PM
not a big fan of either, but I prefer Lydia

themadsilentist
03/15/09, 10:18 PM
Mae has been amazingly shittastic since Everglow.
Lydia has buckets of potential, and Illuminate.
Lydia wins.

zeropunk16
03/15/09, 10:23 PM
Mae has been amazingly shittastic since Everglow.
Lydia has buckets of potential, and Illuminate.
Lydia wins.

Faye wins.

themadsilentist
03/15/09, 10:25 PM
Faye wins.

Why thank you.

tonyC4L
03/15/09, 10:32 PM
Easily the hardest poll in this round.

aloneatlastnj
03/15/09, 10:34 PM
ewwwww, vote no on Lydia! Most unworthy hype band of AP history fo shizzy.

Destination Beautiful>Destination B-Sides>Everglow>Illuminate>Singularity>This December

and for the record, both of Mae's new songs have been top notch, it's comeback time!

:ok:

atticusfinch
03/15/09, 10:41 PM
IF Mae was still a band with the original members, it would have to be Mae hands down.

Destination: Beautiful>This December, It's One More And I'm Free
The Everglow>This December, It's One More And I'm Free
Illuminate>Singularity
This December, It's One More and I'm Free>Singularity

Illuminate = Destination: Beautiful
Illumiate>The Everglow

It's pretty much split 50/50.

I'm gonna flip a coin.

It was tails, so Mae.

cuzimlefthanded
03/15/09, 10:51 PM
It's only been like 7 votes...

oh fuck haha thanks man i didn't even see that. fail on my part

imagination
03/15/09, 10:53 PM
voted mae, never listened to lydia. should. still voted mae.

drailskid
03/15/09, 10:58 PM
mae. because I believe that The Everglow is the greatest album in history

zeropunk16
03/15/09, 11:02 PM
This is gonna be a barn burner!

http://img89.imageshack.us/img89/3721/jimross4ct.jpg

Spenny
03/15/09, 11:05 PM
Gotta go with Mae.
*gets stoned by Lydia fans*

Coh33d
03/15/09, 11:05 PM
Close race on this one but I went with MAE.

andrewshungry
03/15/09, 11:19 PM
damn i figured lydia would be winning by a landslide

zeropunk16
03/15/09, 11:26 PM
Gotta go with Mae.
*gets stoned by Lydia fans*

Well I'm a Lydia fan, lets get stoned!!

IamTheINDUSTRY
03/15/09, 11:31 PM
Lydia will destroy this.
gosh i really thought so too. cant believe its so close.

Cheesus
03/15/09, 11:35 PM
wow... dead even

kdefrisc
03/15/09, 11:36 PM
oh man this was a really difficult choice....chose lydia though, illuminate has made more of an impression on me than any mae album

Spenny
03/15/09, 11:36 PM
Well I'm a Lydia fan, lets get stoned!!
Good job not understanding what I said.
Being stoned does not always refer to the effect of smoking pot.

Undue Noise
03/15/09, 11:43 PM
Wow really close poll - Lydia all the way.

phil19
03/15/09, 11:44 PM
i think i tied this one up for mae.

onthefringe
03/15/09, 11:45 PM
i like lydia, but the everglow and singularity are great albums. so mae.

shortymyer
03/15/09, 11:45 PM
Just broke the tie haha. Go Lydia!

VIVALAMATT
03/15/09, 11:55 PM
Mae!

fadedmemories
03/15/09, 11:55 PM
This is a close one. Go Lydia Go!

DandonTRJ
03/15/09, 11:57 PM
To be fair, I haven't spent much time with Lydia, but also to be fair, they didn't hook me nearly as quickly as Mae. The Everglow is a fucking masterpiece from start to finish. I don't even care if Elkins' voice isn't that great live. He's an amazing composer.

The Personist
03/15/09, 11:57 PM
Holy shit I was the tying vote.

Lydia!

anamericangod
03/16/09, 12:00 AM
Lol @ Mae keeping this so close.

Do you really want to give Slade that gratification?

fadedmemories
03/16/09, 12:09 AM
Holy shit I was the tying vote.

Lydia!
Good one!

Ryzenfall
03/16/09, 12:10 AM
Lipshits. Dead even.

I like both of these bands. Mindy's voice made me vote Lydia.

bouttogetfancy
03/16/09, 12:12 AM
must be the closest poll

irthesteve
03/16/09, 12:21 AM
IF Mae was still a band with the original members, it would have to be Mae hands down.

Destination: Beautiful>This December, It's One More And I'm Free
The Everglow>This December, It's One More And I'm Free
Illuminate>Singularity
This December, It's One More and I'm Free>Singularity

Illuminate = Destination: Beautiful
Illumiate>The Everglow

It's pretty much split 50/50.

I'm gonna flip a coin.

It was tails, so Mae.
weirdest math ever

gemini089
03/16/09, 12:36 AM
tough choice...i saw lydia live and they were amazing, but the everglow is one of my favorites...

fadedmemories
03/16/09, 12:51 AM
must be the closest poll
Indeed.

atticusfinch
03/16/09, 12:51 AM
weirdest math ever

there's probably a reason that I failed math twice in college. hahaha.

notoaststereo
03/16/09, 12:54 AM
mae... but only for destination beautiful and only because ive never listened to lydia.

irthesteve
03/16/09, 12:54 AM
there's probably a reason that I failed math twice in college. hahaha.
whatever works for you... haha

anamericangod
03/16/09, 01:11 AM
Finally got to put my 208 fake accounts to use.

Pawan1993
03/16/09, 03:27 AM
Lydia is brilliant. Mae is good but seems repetitive after a couple of listens.

W/O a Parachute
03/16/09, 03:55 AM
lydia, i can't believe its this close. singularity destroyed all i ever loved about mae

just.Starla.
03/16/09, 05:15 AM
Lydia for sure.

zeropunk16
03/16/09, 05:42 AM
Good job not understanding what I said.
Being stoned does not always refer to the effect of smoking pot.

Good job not understanding sarcasm. Now get me some BC bud.

princesschad
03/16/09, 06:10 AM
How is that crap band Mae even close here?

lucygray
03/16/09, 06:21 AM
Lydia

trappedintime
03/16/09, 06:26 AM
Lydia

batmannj
03/16/09, 06:30 AM
This was the most difficult matchup so far. I went with Mae by a small margin because the new songs have been some of the best I have heard from them, and I think that Destination:Beautiful is slightly better than Illuminate when comparing their best records respectively.

hydraulicheart
03/16/09, 06:43 AM
If this poll had occured four years ago... I still would have picked Lydia.

WFUJerseyJon
03/16/09, 07:05 AM
While Mae has fallen off, The Everglow was just about a perfect album and Destination: Beautiful wasn't far behind. Plus, Lydia is more overrated than Duke.

Alex DiVincenzo
03/16/09, 07:20 AM
Not really familiar with much of Lydia, but I enjoy Mae.

ship of fools
03/16/09, 07:43 AM
The young rookie Lydia up against the seasoned veteran Mae in this all or nothing fight to the death!

citylites
03/16/09, 08:25 AM
Lydia by a landslide

uglystar03
03/16/09, 08:45 AM
Mae's first two lengths are miles better than Lydia's first two lengths. I loved Illuminate, but for me it is not competition to The Everglow.

summachick708
03/16/09, 09:04 AM
mae. because I believe that The Everglow is the greatest album in history
THIS.

BrennanHickson
03/16/09, 09:19 AM
yay for 100th post?

i don't listen to lydia...
You are not welcome here.

Iwasalid
03/16/09, 09:34 AM
I just cant get into Lydia...I am always trying but they just dont do it for me

adam . . . ???
03/16/09, 09:46 AM
wow this is close. c'mon Lydia!

Julia Conny
03/16/09, 10:27 AM
I don't know, I wanna give it to Lydia, but Mae did release Destination: Beautiful.

aprilrainx
03/16/09, 10:32 AM
lydia! <3

stevoemo
03/16/09, 10:38 AM
Being as how this is a tourney, I am gonna have to go with who's better right now, and that's Lydia, hands down.

awakeohsleeper
03/16/09, 10:53 AM
Wow, close.

spunkmastaflex
03/16/09, 10:56 AM
I couldn't get into Illuminate very much, its good but something that i really have to be in the mood for

xSpillFiction
03/16/09, 11:17 AM
I chose Mae, but Lydia gets so much love on this site, so I'm not expecting Mae to win.

I am Mick
03/16/09, 11:32 AM
I can't believe how close this is.
I'm all about Lydia

fran.182
03/16/09, 11:32 AM
Mae! "The Everglow" is a perfect record! So much nostalgia every time I listen to that record. It's so beautiful.

While not as good, "Singularity" is also great...

About Lydia, I just hate that overrated band.

irthesteve
03/16/09, 11:37 AM
This one is way close, which is dumb

PenThrive
03/16/09, 11:47 AM
Mae.

Analog Rebellion
03/16/09, 11:51 AM
Whoa, this is closer than I expected.

npmshah
03/16/09, 11:52 AM
mae is good...
lydia is better

Daniel Thompson
03/16/09, 11:56 AM
if Mae hadn't released Singularity, they would have my vote. Too bad. Lydia it is!

cscwell107
03/16/09, 12:04 PM
This was the hardest one for me. I gave it to Lydia after a lot of thought.

HometownHero
03/16/09, 12:32 PM
Whoa, this is closer than I expected.
I hope you chose Lydia to

HometownHero
03/16/09, 12:33 PM
Mae! "The Everglow" is a perfect record! So much nostalgia every time I listen to that record. It's so beautiful.

While not as good, "Singularity" is also great...

About Lydia, I just hate that overrated band.
They are not overrated whatsoever

princesschad
03/16/09, 12:37 PM
This is so close!

lonelysuperstar
03/16/09, 12:50 PM
This was really hard for me but I've liked Mae for longer. Not so much into more recent Mae, but I think The Everglow is nearly perfect. They got my vote based on that album.

drewz5
03/16/09, 12:51 PM
ewwwww, vote no on Lydia! Most unworthy hype band of AP history fo shizzy.

Destination Beautiful>Destination B-Sides>Everglow>Illuminate>Singularity>This December

and for the record, both of Mae's new songs have been top notch, it's comeback time!

i wouldn't say they're too overhyped because i do like illuminate a lot, but that mathematical equation you got going there i agree with, so i will have to vote for mae

Analog Rebellion
03/16/09, 12:52 PM
I hope you chose Lydia to

Duhhh :)

irthesteve
03/16/09, 12:56 PM
Duhhh :)
nooo, bad choice :-(

on a side note, i got Texas at Circuit City's going out of business sale for only $2.20, haha, such a legit deal. But the point of this is that the booklet has pics of only you except one girl, is that Madi from the song? since the picture is next to those lyrics. Either way, the cd is good driving music, well done my friend

sohcampco
03/16/09, 01:01 PM
Mae, I love Lydia, but Mae is something else.
I didn't like "Singularity" as well but nothing could top "Destination: Beautiful" for me

Analog Rebellion
03/16/09, 01:02 PM
nooo, bad choice :-(

on a side note, i got Texas at Circuit City's going out of business sale for only $2.20, haha, such a legit deal. But the point of this is that the booklet has pics of only you except one girl, is that Madi from the song? since the picture is next to those lyrics. Either way, the cd is good driving music, well done my friend
Haha Lydia > Mae.

Haha nice, I didn't even know Circuit City sold my music. Yes, that's Madi.

Thank you :-)

Analog Rebellion
03/16/09, 01:03 PM
Holy crap this one is still close. 2 votes make the difference with almost 1000 votes cast.

PaintMeBlue
03/16/09, 01:04 PM
Lydia, no contest. Mae bores me.

relaxrelapse830
03/16/09, 01:07 PM
This is intense.
I voted for Lydia. I've been playing Illuminate nonstop recently.

irthesteve
03/16/09, 01:07 PM
Haha Lydia > Mae.

Haha nice, I didn't even know Circuit City sold my music. Yes, that's Madi.

Thank you :-)
how can you say Lydia > Mae? maybe my excellent math skills can help you out here:

Destination Beautiful>Destination B-Sides>Everglow>Illuminate>Singularity>This December

true story right there ^

foisol
03/16/09, 01:22 PM
Lydia. I love them.

ijbet59
03/16/09, 01:32 PM
nothing like illuminate.

TalkShowsOnMute
03/16/09, 01:34 PM
I love both, but Illuminate is one of the best, if not the best album I've ever heard and I could listen to it over and over forever. I can't believe it's so close. Before anyone votes in this one, listen to Illuminate one time and tell me it's not better than anything Mae has.

Analog Rebellion
03/16/09, 01:44 PM
how can you say Lydia > Mae? maybe my excellent math skills can help you out here:

Destination Beautiful>Destination B-Sides>Everglow>Illuminate>Singularity>This December

true story right there ^

Haha, I've just never been a fan of Mae. Plus, Lydia are my brosephs from another Joseph?

TheLoyalVox
03/16/09, 01:46 PM
This is way too close.

irthesteve
03/16/09, 02:02 PM
Haha, I've just never been a fan of Mae. Plus, Lydia are my brosephs from another Joseph?
personal connection ftw i guess. But seriously, give another listen to Destination Beautiful sometime soon and see if it at least changes your mind on Mae just a little bit

ericsounds41
03/16/09, 02:12 PM
Wow this one's going to be close.. well right now it is anyway.. I'd say Mae though.. barely.

hailthewarrior
03/16/09, 02:12 PM
Mae by far. Lydia is a shitty hype band with a chick who can't sing live... Destination:Beautiful is a beautiful album.

owiseone35
03/16/09, 02:21 PM
Lydia is only up by 12 o snap. Lydia has the better live show. But I love destination beautiful, it is like the quintessential summer album. I went with lydia though b/c I believe they have more talent and Mae's Singularity was really forgetful.

jnnlopez
03/16/09, 02:28 PM
LOVE Lydia. Mae=ehh. Mae has some good songs though.

zubinmoosa
03/16/09, 02:36 PM
The Everglow was a fantastic effort. That puts Mae on top for me.

Zachals
03/16/09, 02:52 PM
lydia is great and all...but mae is greater

justletgo
03/16/09, 03:08 PM
Wow, this is way closer than I thought it would be.
Even though I think Mae is alright, I love Lydia ... and Mindy.

Rob Hrx
03/16/09, 03:14 PM
Mae. When these guys are on form, they dominate.

mutualaddiction
03/16/09, 03:17 PM
Mae, based solely on the Everglow, which is a masterpiece.

xxhard_to_sayxx
03/16/09, 03:19 PM
Lydia! =)

crimesides
03/16/09, 03:24 PM
I love Everglow too much to vote against Mae on this one. But nice to see that the vote is so close.

ExplodingStereo
03/16/09, 03:26 PM
Tough call here. Lydia is so overhyped, it's unbelievable. Illuminate's a decent record, but not the best record of '08 like everyone on here put on their Top 10 lists. I kind of know Mae and they're also decent, but I went with Lydia because I knew more of their music.

TheHoldSteady
03/16/09, 03:51 PM
Go Lydia!

rendezvous
03/16/09, 04:10 PM
lydia is ok..but mae is fantastic

Shrillex
03/16/09, 04:25 PM
Don't listen to Lydia.

RelientAudio
03/16/09, 04:39 PM
Lydia's a personal fave, so I gave them my vote. But everyone that voted for Mae because of the Everglow...that album was kick ASS. I just feel like their new stuff is lacking. Current status on Mae: disappointed yet hopeful.

samsara
03/16/09, 04:48 PM
meh Lydia

ninthandash
03/16/09, 04:53 PM
saw mae about two weeks ago, and they've definitely improved on their live performance (especially vocally) since I'd seen them last.

All Lydia's songs just hit with a really hard impact, though. After the everglow, all of Mae's songs just lost all of their feeling it seemed like.

The winner is Lydia, in my book.
:D

tinfoil-hearts
03/16/09, 05:06 PM
I'm a big Mae person. Sorry, Lydia.

prkchpsndwchs
03/16/09, 05:39 PM
I'll be pretty upset if mae doesn't win.

Analog Rebellion
03/16/09, 06:48 PM
Mae by far. Lydia is a shitty hype band with a chick who can't sing live... Destination:Beautiful is a beautiful album.
Shitty hype band? I guess you haven't heard the other hype bands that have been floating around lately, or maybe you're just smart enough to ignore them. Regardless, even if you don't like Lydia, I don't know how you could degrade them to a "shitty hype band". They're definitely a talented group of individuals.

Also, Mindy sang their whole set last night without Leighton, and she sounded great. And that compliment is coming from someone that's very critical of live performances.

ElevenElm
03/16/09, 06:51 PM
i really like lydia, but i love mae as well, so i voted for them just because they deserve the vote and i know lydia will win.
yay run on sentences!

bouttogetfancy
03/16/09, 07:00 PM
yay lydia..hour and a half to go!

nicoteen
03/16/09, 08:03 PM
The Everglow alone should win this one for Mae. Such a great album. No offense to Lydia as they are a good band.

fadedmemories
03/16/09, 08:10 PM
Get well soon Leighton.

littlebeav
03/16/09, 08:56 PM
haha, hell yeah. My vote put Lydia up 1. I used to like Mae, but that last CD was shit.

kdefrisc
03/17/09, 01:42 AM
AAAHHHH this poll is so freakin close

anamericangod
03/17/09, 01:52 AM
Shitty hype band? I guess you haven't heard the other hype bands that have been floating around lately, or maybe you're just smart enough to ignore them. Regardless, even if you don't like Lydia, I don't know how you could degrade them to a "shitty hype band". They're definitely a talented group of individuals.

Also, Mindy sang their whole set last night without Leighton, and she sounded great. And that compliment is coming from someone that's very critical of live performances.

Oh my God, I would have loved to have seen that.

Kurt Retenauer
03/17/09, 06:07 AM
lydia

lindZ629
03/17/09, 06:21 AM
How the hell can you guys listen to Lydia? Whoever the vocalist is, he/she needs a new job.

Analog Rebellion
03/17/09, 08:33 AM
Oh my God, I would have loved to have seen that.

Yeah it was great.

Soulcatcher
03/17/09, 10:27 AM
Mae, though lydia is cool too

princesschad
03/17/09, 01:22 PM
How the hell can you guys listen to Lydia? Whoever the vocalist is, he/she needs a new job.

Haha, what?

Analog Rebellion
03/17/09, 02:16 PM
How the hell can you guys listen to Lydia? Whoever the vocalist is, he/she needs a new job.
No.

Analog Rebellion
03/17/09, 02:42 PM
Damn this poll is so close
Seriously. 1 vote right now. Geez.

katieissweet
03/17/09, 02:49 PM
I thought Lydia was going to be dominating this the whole time.

lonelysuperstar
03/17/09, 03:18 PM
Wow it's intense how close this is. I think Illuminate is fantastic, I've been playing it non-stop. However, to me, The Everglow is perfect - there's nothing I'd change about that record.

owiseone35
03/17/09, 03:20 PM
one vote man I wonder how this one is gonna come out...

Analog Rebellion
03/17/09, 03:38 PM
I thought Lydia was going to be dominating this the whole time.
I actually though so too, at first. But considering the fact that Mae is bigger and has been around longer, it makes sense that they're tied with a heavily AP-hyped band. When I say AP-hyped, I mean Lydia has a significantly larger percentage of listeners here than they do out in the normal pool of every day music listeners.

Uh oh, Mae has pulled ahead for the first time.

katieissweet
03/17/09, 03:42 PM
I actually though so too, at first. But considering the fact that Mae is bigger and has been around longer, it makes sense that they're tied with a heavily AP-hyped band. When I say AP-hyped, I mean Lydia has a significantly larger percentage of listeners here than they do out in the normal pool of every day music listeners.

Uh oh, Mae has pulled ahead for the first time.
Yeah I guess it does make sense. I just assumed since Lydia is such an AP-hyped band that everyone would vote for them.


And now it is tied. This is a close one.

xsinkshipsx
03/17/09, 03:43 PM
destination beautiful+ the everglow= better than lydia

Analog Rebellion
03/17/09, 03:45 PM
http://i11.photobucket.com/albums/a172/homerun7dh/Picture2-18.png
Craziness.

hailthewarrior
03/17/09, 03:48 PM
Shitty hype band? I guess you haven't heard the other hype bands that have been floating around lately, or maybe you're just smart enough to ignore them. Regardless, even if you don't like Lydia, I don't know how you could degrade them to a "shitty hype band". They're definitely a talented group of individuals.

Also, Mindy sang their whole set last night without Leighton, and she sounded great. And that compliment is coming from someone that's very critical of live performances.

Haha, yeah, I ignore most things neon. When I saw them open for Waking Ashland a couple years ago, they had no life, the singer was lifeless in voice and action and it was just very blah. I listened to Illuminate once and it did absolutely nothing for me.

Analog Rebellion
03/17/09, 03:55 PM
Haha, yeah, I ignore most things neon. When I saw them open for Waking Ashland a couple years ago, they had no life, the singer was lifeless in voice and action and it was just very blah. I listened to Illuminate once and it did absolutely nothing for me.
That's fine. I still don't agree with classifying them as a shitty hype band.

HammersNStrings
03/17/09, 03:59 PM
I broke it... Lydia FTW.

KyleMcr
03/17/09, 09:38 PM
Lydia

phil19
03/17/09, 09:44 PM
mae's back in the lead!

speakhandsforme
03/17/09, 09:57 PM
Lydia is losing by two....what....

InsmileOutblood
03/17/09, 10:08 PM
Lydia! Now by one.

friskycurtain
03/17/09, 10:12 PM
ZOMG!!! 1 vote seperation

W/O a Parachute
03/17/09, 11:21 PM
this is fucking ridiculous

Lydia: 690
Mae: 691

i really thought lydia was going to dominate this.

billyboatkid
03/18/09, 02:49 AM
Lydia. Damn down by one. Incredible.

fadedmemories
03/18/09, 05:07 AM
Come on Lydia!

lonelysuperstar
03/18/09, 12:36 PM
Just listen to The Everglow and your decision will be made clear.

erma12879
03/18/09, 05:44 PM
Mae.
Sun (acoustic).
End of story.

fadedmemories
03/18/09, 06:17 PM
This poll is so damn close.

Analog Rebellion
03/19/09, 08:18 AM
When I went to bed last night, Mae was up by like 8 votes, now Lydia is ahead again. Stop toying with my life!

ACA
03/19/09, 08:48 AM
I just tied at 723.

zubinmoosa
03/19/09, 08:52 AM
Oh baby

weownthestreets
03/19/09, 04:33 PM
Lydia. Because of their discography.

spunkmastaflex
03/19/09, 04:46 PM
omg, lets go Maeeee

cscwell107
03/19/09, 04:47 PM
Wow I can't believe it is tied.

tommy's ghost
03/19/09, 05:30 PM
Holy shit, I made it a tie. Lydia all ze way.

justletgo
03/19/09, 06:32 PM
Holy shit Lydia down one vote! I never would have thought!

fadedmemories
03/19/09, 11:35 PM
742-741 with Mae leading.

KidInTheHall182
03/20/09, 12:19 AM
I just tied it up, go Lydia!

fadedmemories
03/20/09, 12:43 AM
I just tied it up, go Lydia!
Good job!

MyNameIsRoss
03/20/09, 05:37 AM
Lydia, but not a big fan of either.

Ducks_own
03/20/09, 07:36 AM
It's kind of like Bush and Gore in 2000, but a win-win.

I went with Mae. Even though Singularity was a drop-off from their last two albums, their last two singles already make up for it.

Though after buying and listening to Illuminate, Lydia is also a great band. I can see now why this is so close.

EmaleeMae
03/20/09, 08:03 AM
Lydia will destroy this.
Exactly what I thought..

EmaleeMae
03/20/09, 08:04 AM
Lydia.
Lydia.
Lydia.
Lydia.
Lydia.
Lydia.

EmaleeMae
03/20/09, 08:05 AM
When I went to bed last night, Mae was up by like 8 votes, now Lydia is ahead again. Stop toying with my life!
Haha!

Anton Djamoos
03/20/09, 08:05 AM
This is crazy close.

Broclee
03/20/09, 08:07 AM
This is a freakin' nail biter, lawdy.

zubinmoosa
03/20/09, 09:02 AM
This is crazy close.
Hey Anton, is there a way to make these polls limited to only people with AP accounts? Because it's very easy to spam votes by voting when signed out. Also, many people have recruited fanclubs and/or street teams to mass vote for their bands, when they are not even AP members.

If that is not possible, then closing the polls after 24 hours maybe would stop this, because it wouldn't be enough time for many outside people to get a hold off it. Many of these matchups have taken a turn (for the worse) after 48 hours or so, so I think it might be a good idea for the next round.

Anton Djamoos
03/20/09, 09:14 AM
Hey Anton, is there a way to make these polls limited to only people with AP accounts? Because it's very easy to spam votes by voting when signed out. Also, many people have recruited fanclubs and/or street teams to mass vote for their bands, when they are not even AP members.

If that is not possible, then closing the polls after 24 hours maybe would stop this, because it wouldn't be enough time for many outside people to get a hold off it. Many of these matchups have taken a turn (for the worse) after 48 hours or so, so I think it might be a good idea for the next round.
We'll make it so only registered people can vote from now on.

zubinmoosa
03/20/09, 09:22 AM
We'll make it so only registered people can vote from now on.
Nice.

of_the_rose
03/20/09, 11:14 AM
Lydia.

Montauk1222
03/20/09, 11:17 AM
Lydia, I can never get bored of them

kigginsthisprov
03/20/09, 11:37 AM
I really thought Lydia would be beating Mae by a lot, but there's a competition here.

anamericangod
03/20/09, 11:42 AM
Lydia is pulling away with it now.

left6reenthumb
03/20/09, 01:58 PM
Lydiaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa!!!

and quit your complaining about street teams helping out...that is one of their reasons of existence -_____-

Broclee
03/20/09, 02:02 PM
Lydiaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa!!!

and quit your complaining about street teams helping out...that is one of their reasons of existence -_____-

It's completely fair to have so that only registered members can vote, this is about AP.net's favorite band, not Which Band has a Bigger Street Team or whatever.

imahoodlum
03/20/09, 03:05 PM
Lydia, hands down.

zubinmoosa
03/20/09, 03:10 PM
It's completely fair to have so that only registered members can vote, this is about AP.net's favorite band, not Which Band has a Bigger Street Team or whatever.
agreed

Merkin
03/20/09, 03:48 PM
interesting

Broclee
03/20/09, 04:18 PM
Wtf happened? Last night it was tied it the mid 700's and now Lydfia is winning by 200? I guess some fan club came in and voted like the 30stm poll

Good god, I just noticed that.

Seriously, that's no fun.

I loved this particular one because of how close it was, it actually felt exciting.

Broclee
03/20/09, 05:20 PM
Word. This poll was fucking sweet and I thought it would be cool if this poll was won by just a few votes. Its been neck and neck the whole time and constantly tied but now Lydia has clearly won. At least all the future polls will be members only so things will be fair and none of this mass voting silliness occurs again

Indeed, it really defeats the purpose to have a mass voting of non-members, so I'm glad that'll be coming into play.

Spenny
03/20/09, 07:32 PM
Wtf happened? Last night it was tied it the mid 700's and now Lydfia is winning by 200? I guess some fan club came in and voted like the 30stm poll
Pretty much.
Lydia was winning by barely anything this morning when I looked, but now they've pulled away.

santi__x
03/20/09, 10:52 PM
Lydia! <3

amberofcourse
03/20/09, 11:55 PM
Lydia! No doubt about it.

anamericangod
03/21/09, 02:04 AM
Unbelievable, Mae just got like 400 votes in an hour.

Piss
03/21/09, 02:17 AM
this poll isn't accurate

smiller
03/21/09, 05:35 AM
Definately Mae! Love them! Their newest song is incredible!

Broclee
03/21/09, 07:41 AM
Unbelievable, Mae just got like 400 votes in an hour.

Wow, haha.

daftknight
03/21/09, 09:34 AM
Hahah awesome. Mae FTW!

lexidoodleellis
03/21/09, 09:47 AM
i voted mae.

my favorite cd of all time is The Everglow.

I am not too big on their CD Singularity, though.

As a pianist I find their stuff so beautiful and inspiring.

I actually haven't ever listened to Lydia!

anamericangod
03/21/09, 09:57 AM
i voted mae.

my favorite cd of all time is The Everglow.

I am not too big on their CD Singularity, though.

As a pianist I find their stuff so beautiful and inspiring.

I actually haven't ever listened to Lydia!

Check them out. They're not as poppy as Mae, but they aren't too far removed.

Broclee
03/21/09, 09:57 AM
i voted mae.

my favorite cd of all time is The Everglow.

I am not too big on their CD Singularity, though.

As a pianist I find their stuff so beautiful and inspiring.

I actually haven't ever listened to Lydia!

Check em out, they have some awesome piano parts as well, on top of the rest of their beautiful music.

Analog Rebellion
03/21/09, 10:33 AM
Holy shit. First Lydia's fan club or street team came in, now Mae's fan club or street team came in. Ridiculous.

Soulcatcher
03/21/09, 12:07 PM
mae all the way :)

zeropunk16
03/21/09, 01:13 PM
God damn. The battle for Middle Earth doesn't have shit on this.

ohitisjess
03/21/09, 04:55 PM
Mae, because I love their music so much. It can never get old to me, and I find myself listening to it especially in this nice spring weather that's been happening here lately.

hf57
03/21/09, 05:16 PM
lydia hands down for me

amber3
03/21/09, 06:51 PM
Lydia.

bouttogetfancy
03/21/09, 10:08 PM
gosh darn i wish lydia would win

Ducks_own
03/22/09, 04:25 AM
GAH! I stop looking at this for a day, and a massive comeback occurs... This is seriously messed up.

reneelove89
03/22/09, 08:47 AM
Mae >lydia

Hands Down, Best Band Ever.

imahoodlum
03/22/09, 10:17 AM
People with one or two posts should not be allowed to vote.

Analog Rebellion
03/22/09, 10:53 AM
People with one or two posts should not be allowed to vote.
Agreed. There should be a 50 post minimum.

imahoodlum
03/22/09, 11:08 AM
I was going to say at least 100. Notice how they signed up in March 2009 too.

Analog Rebellion
03/22/09, 12:10 PM
I was going to say at least 100. Notice how they signed up in March 2009 too.
Yea, I can't see them actually limiting it, though. They probably see this as a good opportunity to get new users.

WFUJerseyJon
03/22/09, 02:54 PM
Shocked but thrilled Mae is winning this.

batmannj
03/22/09, 03:18 PM
I am really surprised Mae is most likely going to win this.

taylerx0
03/22/09, 03:19 PM
I am really surprised Mae is most likely going to win this.

Same here... and not in a good way.

batmannj
03/22/09, 03:33 PM
Same here... and not in a good way.
It was tough for me. I went with Mae but it was like splitting hairs.

Broclee
03/22/09, 03:44 PM
Lydia got a lot votes recently, this might come down to the wire.

imahoodlum
03/22/09, 03:52 PM
Holy shit, it's way closer now.

Fin.
03/22/09, 03:58 PM
Two of my five favorite bands, but I've gotta go with Mae.