PDA

View Full Version : What would you do if I sang out of tune?

tonyC4L
03/15/09, 10:58 PM
Which version do you think is better?
loganmmm
03/16/09, 03:24 AM
Although I love the Beatles, I prefer Joe Cocker's version.
HopeInLove
03/16/09, 07:53 AM
Beatles get props for writing it, but Joe Cocker really gave that song so much more and really made it his own, and I far prefer his version.
googirl8907
03/16/09, 08:14 AM
Joe Cocker.
SlappedActor
03/16/09, 08:16 AM
I know it's sacrilege to ever vote against the Beatles, but Cocker's version is just so damn good.
notoaststereo
03/16/09, 09:23 AM
although the beatles version is awesome i'd say im more used to and have a bigger connection to the joe cocker version.
eclipsegts1
03/17/09, 11:25 AM
Come on guys, THE WONDER YEARS!
Alex DiVincenzo
03/17/09, 12:17 PM
Love Crocker's verses but prefer The Beatles' chorus... went with the latter.
Jason Tate
03/17/09, 02:46 PM
I sincerely hate anyone that says "Crocker".
Alex DiVincenzo
03/17/09, 06:10 PM
I haven't heard the Cocker version. I'm guessing he takes out the words "get high"

Cocker's version does say "get high," but the way its sang, it's harder to make out. I can't believe you've never heard it! Never watched The Wonder Years? Youtube it. Now.
dpetty21
03/17/09, 06:45 PM
I know what it is but haven't watched it. Most likely its one of those shows thats only good if you grew up with it
Nah I don't think so. I've never met anyone who disliked the Wonder Years. I mean I did grow up with it but I still think you'd enjoy it. I'm trying to buy that show on DVD if/when it comes out.
stonecoldfox
03/18/09, 01:37 PM
haha totally didn't realize the cocker version was from the wonder years....eh, beatles version still blows it out of the water
Everiggs
03/26/09, 08:07 AM
Wonder Years 4lyfe.
actionpat
03/26/09, 03:09 PM
Come on guys, THE WONDER YEARS!

yea!
the beatles' version is great but joe cocker's version has soul.
jgord88
03/27/09, 04:31 PM
Big Wonder Years fan.
fueledbyvictory
03/29/09, 02:46 PM
I sincerely hate anyone that says "Crocker".

We don't hate.
didwhat77times
03/29/09, 07:19 PM
That's a tough choice. The Beatles by default because Joe Cocker's cover couldn't exist without the original.
jbaseball44
03/29/09, 07:26 PM
The Beatles version, easily
lindZ629
03/29/09, 08:34 PM
I think this is one of those rare times when the cover beats out the original, at least for me.