March Mayhem Round 1: Over It vs. Yellowcard

[Anton Djamoos]

Who is your favorite band out of these two? Be sure to read the replies for other users' cases for each band.

[chokeychicken]

No Votes

[The Summer Ends]

I like Ocean Avenue more than any song from either band, but I like Over It's catalog more.

[underdawg1119]

Yellowcarddddd

[Alex DiVincenzo]

Yellowcard

[HometownHero]

Over It

[littlebeav]

Firewater was the song that got me past my teenage romance and in a state where I could hold my head up. Sorry, Over It, but that's the bar and Yellowcard is... over it.

[singyoutocoma]

Over It...shame they probably won't take it.

[Undue Noise]

Don't really listen to Over It so Yellowcard by default.

[laxcrs]

tough pick

[notoaststereo]

yellowcard. i know them better.

[SSLYBY]

Over it I got so sick of ocean avenue.

[RIPFenixTX]

probably the hardest one of all...yellowcard have the advantage of being vets.. but over it...great band.. but yellowcard... old stuff is amazing..hmm... ill go against the "underdogs" on this one and give over it the vote

[NateFoundGlory]

I love Yellowcard, I hate to see they aren't doing anything anymore, Paper Walls is great.

[dissident]

yellowcard. i've never heard of over it!

[billyboatkid]

Yellowcard for sure.

Lights and Sounds was ridiculously underrated also. Great album.

[XEmoBoyShandorX]

Yellowcard easy.

[FourStarters]

YC's gonna run away with this one, but this is a really tough call. Everyone should really go listen to Timing Is Everything - fantastic album, solid live band, and extremely nice guys. Over It are seriously underrated, and I think that people here haven't heard of them really just shows that. With the right promotion and a solid label behind them, there's no reason why they shouldn't be huge.

[TalkShowsOnMute]

Yellowcard by far.

[mxpxjf]

Easy pick -> Yellowcard.

[midtown4657]

i don't think i've even heard of Over It.. but i remember like 8th grade/freshman year when all the pop punk kids were talking about the opening band somewhere that had a violin player that did backflips.

[VIVALAMATT]

yellowcard is terrible.

[TMS2787]

Yellowcard.

[phil19]

over it should be winning this.

[punklet2101]

Over It

[kittypants]

who is over it??

[permanentdan]

i love me some yellowcard but i gotta rep my boys in over it for this one.

[Ryzenfall]

Yellowcard. I wake up to them every morning. That violin cuts through any stage of sleep.

[weworemasks]

bullshit. over it is much better. yellowcard has sucked since after underdog ep.

[Olympia]

any band that used to be on springman gets my vote

[atticusfinch]

tough one, but i went with YC.

[Keagan Ilvonen]

Yellowcard

[stuntmaniac]

Yellowcard all the way!

[just.Starla.]

yellowcard. i've never heard of over it!
This.

[trappedintime]

yellowcard! i fuckin' love those guys.

[Troggy]

over it should be winning this.

who is over it??

Phil, there's your reason why right there. Yellowcard is not good at all. Never was. This is pretty disappointing but I understand some people outside of AP.net culture don't know who Over It is.

[246toothpicks]

Over it. They never put out a shitty album. If you've never heard them, at least go listen 1st
http://www.myspace.com/overit

[Badgers08]

Wow, this was tough. I literally had to flip a coin and it came out Over It.

[superichie]

Not really a huge fan of either. But I am more of a Yellowcard fan.

[Cody Nelson]

I love Step Outside Yourself, but Yellowcard is one of my favorite bands, and I gotta represent.

[fishingthe_sky]

Over It's far superior. Too bad they'll lose.

[prefix-core]

Wow. Over It is getting wrecked. But I gave them my vote.

[RonStoppable]

Yellowcard. Never got into Over It, and I listened to Ocean's Avenue all the time in middle school.

[googirl8907]

Over It.

[WFUJerseyJon]

Yellowcard, easily.

[Kaleidoscope]

yeah... not even close.

[TriangularDuck]

I don't know who Over It are.

However, Yellowcard are so terrible, I'd vote for just about anyone over them.

[phoenixinflames]

Yea, Yellowcard is killing...figured.

[cscwell107]

Over it should win this but sadly they will not.

[brentkid]

I loved Paper Walls.

Yellowcard.

[hailthewarrior]

ocean avenue wins this.

[Ollie McKraut]

Over It kicks a ton of ass and deserves to win.

[TangledUp]

Yellowcard, hands down. Over It is good, but doesn't compare in my mind.

[absolution]

absolutely unbelievable how few people have heard of Over It.

[Impreza WRX]

Over It !!

[tjb4233]

Over It is amazing...but Yellowcard has my vote due to the body of work

[Yellowcard2006]

Yellowcard, no question. Always.

[c_rob2700]

Love Yellowcard so that was an easy vote for me. I've never listened to Over It though

[Poochemist]

I'm not a huge fan of either, but if pressured I'd pick Yellowcard.

[Dubui_209]

Yellowcard No contest.
A lot of blow outs this week

[Bostancic25]

In my opinion, Yellowcard is up there with some of the best pop-punk bands

[SeanEBoy2686]

Yellowcard would beat a lot of bands on these polls for me. Over It would also beat a few, too bad they were pinned against YC.

[zubinmoosa]

I'm a fan of both bands, but went with Yellowcard because of my fascination with Yellowcard a couple years back. I didn't think Over It would be getting wrecked so badly though.

[PenThrive]

First landslide on the list thus far.

I went with Yellowcard because I don't know anything about Over It.

[narca9]

Paper Walls is one of my favorite albums ever. I just can't vote against them.

[live.]

There was a period of about a few months where I liked Over It more, but I've loved Yellowcard for a longer span of time.

[Jim Morgan]

Like both bands, but Yellowcard lead me to Over It. YC.

[lurker411_k9]

I'm not a huge fan of either, but if pressured I'd pick Yellowcard.

This.

[|adr3naLine|]

This was a toughy, I went Yellowcard though just because I listened the hell out of Ocean Avenue when it came out.

[mmgx]

love both bands but i never listen to my yellowcard cds anymore but i do listen to my over it ones. so i have to go with over it.

[Formatfun]

Never liked Yellowcard, never listened to Over It... so the logical choice was vote against Yellowcard.

[more heart]

I never completely got into Over It. Plus, Ocean Avenue is just amazing.

[tm24x]

yellowcard

[ThisIsNotDan]

oof tough for me. YC

[phil19]

Phil, there's your reason why right there. Yellowcard is not good at all. Never was. This is pretty disappointing but I understand some people outside of AP.net culture don't know who Over It is.

yeah i think you're right. I was honestly shocked at how many "who are over it?" posts there's been.

[ryheeles]

Yellowcard's put out a lot more stuff that I'm still really into years after hearing it. Simple as that

[AussieBoy]

yellowcard... its all about the fiddle!

[Yagami]

As much as I enjoyed Paper Walls and a few other Yellowcard songs here and there, they might as well change their name to Yellowcrud when compared to Over It. Fucking underrated band too, and it's a shame they're losing (though it was expected).

[Troggy]

yeah i think you're right. I was honestly shocked at how many "who are over it?" posts there's been.

Me too, really. They have been part of AP.net lore for several years now. They really are getting smashed here though, 4 to 1, that's just bad. I hope some of the kids at least give them a chance now.

[Rest_Easy]

I liked Junction 18 covering over it....

[phil19]

Me too, really. They have been part of AP.net lore for several years now. They really are getting smashed here though, 4 to 1, that's just bad. I hope some of the kids at least give them a chance now.

yeah lets hope now that people have heard of them they'll check them out. we know that they wont be dissapointed

[Dubui_209]

In my opinion, Yellowcard is up there with some of the best pop-punk bands
THIS

[onthefringe]

each of yellowcard's releases had a few good songs.

[Troggy]

What does that even mean? I have heard of them but never actually listened to them before

LOL...they got the Tate promotion, front page exposure, blah blah blah. That's what I mean.

[AlkalineAshes]

yellowcard goin down next round