Never Give Up Vs. Transatlanticism

[petethemeat]

Which is a better album?

[fueledbyvictory]

who is never give up by?

[VIVALAMATT]

who is never give up by?

Yeah, I have no idea what album he's referring to, but I'm 100% positive it's not better than Transatlanticism. Not many can beat that album.

[voncorn]

The Postal Service - Give Up?

Both were released in 2003 and involve Ben Gibbard, sooo that's what I think the OP meant to put.

[VIVALAMATT]

The Postal Service - Give Up?

Both were released in 2003 and involve Ben Gibbard, sooo that's what I think the OP meant to put.

Thaaaat makes way more sense.

Still isnt better than Transatlanticism though. That's Gibbard's masterpiece, in my opinion.

[recall reality]

lol. I'm guessing that's what he meant. Should probably change it in his profile too...

Maybe he's just an optimist.

[fueledbyvictory]

The Postal Service - Give Up?

Both were released in 2003 and involve Ben Gibbard, sooo that's what I think the OP meant to put.

Yeah, that's what I thought. I was like checking in iTunes and I couldn't find anything, haha.

[MattRM]

Transatlanticism. Give Up is good, but not that good.

[dpetty21]

Thaaaat makes way more sense.

Still isnt better than Transatlanticism though. That's Gibbard's masterpiece, in my opinion.


Exactly my thoughts. Trans is one of the best albums I've ever heard.

[xNyssa]

I have to be honest and say that I haven't heard Give Up yet (shame, shame), but Trans. is an amazing album so I think I can safely say Transatlanticism ^^

[just.Starla.]

The Postal Service - Give Up?

Both were released in 2003 and involve Ben Gibbard, sooo that's what I think the OP meant to put.
That's what I thought he meant.

I love Trans., but I prefer Give Up.

[IceAge/HeatWave]

trans is awesome. understating.

[ScottFarcas]

trans is better

[Everiggs]

Give Up. Transatlanticism is good, but not that good.

There we go.

[Undue Noise]

Transatlanticism.

[petethemeat]

wow epic fail on my part. yea i meant give up by the postal service.

[billyboatkid]

I haven't heard either. Shame on me.

[SuNDaYSTaR]

Too hard of a choice. Went with Give Up because it's my personal favourite, however both are just incredible.

[theguy77]

hahaha ar eyou kidding

transatlanticism >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

it doesnt matter what's on the other side. hahaha. if death of an interior decorator were removed from the tracklisting and used as a b-side instead, i would consider the album virtually flawless for that style of music. unfortunately they had to ruin the otherwise PERFECT flow and order of that album by sticking a cute quaint little song in between two moody, atmospheric tracks.

[VIVALAMATT]

Give Up is good, but not great.

It doesn't come anywhere close to Transatlanticism in my mind. That album is perfect.

[drewziph]

I haven't heard either. Shame on me.
lol. do it.


Also. Transatlanticism. It makes me laugh that people bother making polls that are going to be so one sided :p

[rickmo]

lol. I'm guessing that's what he meant. Should probably change it in his profile too...

Maybe he's just an optimist.

this

[xBrandNew]

Transatlanticism is one of my favorite albums of all time. I could listen to it for years on end, and will continue to do so. dcfc<3

[KyleMcr]

It's close, but Transatlanticism.

[KyleMcr]

I haven't heard either. Shame on me.

How is this possible?